Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Nursery dropped 12 month old baby off changing table - can any one help?

182 replies

Yokomoyr · 18/09/2021 12:19

[Name redacted by MNHQ] nursery in Birmingham:

During the first 2 hours of the first day of my then 12 month old son being there - they dropped him off a changing table onto a hard floor.

He had a huge lump on his head and was quite drowsy for a week afterwards, but neither A+E nor GP seemed too concerned.

Now he is struggling with communication and when we tried to get a medical examiner and solicitor to help us get some money out of the nursery to pay for Speech and Language Therapy, we have pretty much been told it cannot be linked and nothing has been done.

I would like someone to at least tell me they will look into this nursery or provide some help in the private SLT (as NHS is taking >6 months to refer through) - is that unreasonable?

Put my most precious person in the care of someone else and in an inexcusable moment when full attention was meant to be on him, there was a serious error which lead to a severe head injury in a 1 year old child.

Must admit I feel quite let down.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 18/09/2021 14:16

I am sorry this has happened can I recommend you take him to a cranial osteo who specialises in babies

gingergran · 18/09/2021 14:13

In the first instance you need to raise a formal complaint with the nursery and if you aren’t satisfied with their response you should contact ofsted. If they, ofsted, feel there are grounds for investigation they will look into the matter further especially if they consider the nursery has been negligent in any way.

From my professional experience I think it will be extremely difficult to claim against the nursery without the support of medical professionals and/or ofsted because there needs to be proof of a link between the incident and the subsequent language delay. Most issues with language and communication are not apparent until the child is in their second year so this could just be considered coincidental.

MLMbotsno · 18/09/2021 14:09

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

You would first need to prove that he fell due to their negligence and that the fall caused him damage.
Indeed. You are assuming that the fall caused the speech delay - many children have speech delay.

@Yokomoyr you haven't said how old he is now. The answers will be different depending on age.

SumthingWitty · 18/09/2021 14:04

I see I cross posted with you OP.

Sorry I am slow at writing and typing.

IHaveNoOneToTalkTo · 18/09/2021 14:04

How old is your child, OP?

SumthingWitty · 18/09/2021 14:00

I’m sorry this happened to you and your son OP.

But I disagree with many other posters. I’m sorry if this worries anyone, but head injuries are sometimes wrongly downplayed by hospitals and medical professionals and it is only more recently that concussions are taken seriously in sports etc.

Even if taken seriously, not all damage is visible on standard CT or MRIs, but may be on fMRI etc. Some damage is to the chemical functioning of the brain, not simply physical damage from bleeding or inflammation. This is all verifiable from many medical sources which are free to access and googleable.

It is not certain thankfully, but it is plausible that a child could sustain injury that has some kind of effect.

We are learning more about concussion and brain injury all the time. For example tests are being developed that aim to reliably detect concussion by analysing proteins released into the blood after injury. I’m sure there are others too. If successful and reliable, this will be a valuable diagnostic tool giving new information to doctors/ paramedics and will tell us more about the frequency of concussion that may be invisible to the eye, or some scans. www.ucsf.edu/news/2019/08/415206/simple-blood-test-unmasks-concussions-absent-ct-scans

None of this makes it easier to know exactly if or how your son has been affected Yokomoyr. I think try other solicitors, especially the larger ones. Also I really recommend contacting Headway the head injury charity for advice if you haven’t already. They are supportive and knowledgeable.

I suspect other solicitors and doctors may tell you to keep notes but wait until he is older and to see if any of his difficulties persist compared to children of his age. I know this may not help you now, but perhaps speaking to the Headway charity might be some support at least Flowers

HalzTangz · 18/09/2021 14:00

Was this accident in the last week or two, or was it a year or so ago (not clear from your post)

If it's recent then how can you state SAL, surely the child is to young to even jump to that conclusion.

Some children progress at different rates, my friends child stayed mute until he started reception year (now he doesn't shut up).

Would you sue yourself if your child bumped his head in your care (it's easily done and accidents do happen), I doubt the nursery diliberately dropped him.

Theworldishard · 18/09/2021 14:00

@Mynameismargot

Would you say this so blasé if it was your son? The ops child is a BABY. He should be safe at nursery and he wasn't. That sort of accident should.not happen. Tripping and falling outside yes, but not where a staff member should be with that child every moment they're on the changing table. Shame on you for dismissing this mum..shame on you.

I think most people would be upset at the time but it is obviously months later(at least) and all medical checks showed it was a bump to the head and nothing else. At this point I would not be linking speech and language difficulties(which are extremely common in children, most people I know have had a kid go to SALT at some point myself included) with a bump to the head months ago.

I would say if you are struggling for money to pay for SALT then getting an evening/weekend job would probably be more fruitful than pursuing this. I wouldn't be blase about speech difficulties, like I said one of mine had them but I would and did be a parent and get them treatment not fixate on one of probably many bumps to the head that my child got.

You're all focusing on the OP wanting money allegedly but in her original post she is concerned about what has happened to her child.
aliensprig · 18/09/2021 14:00

OP you still haven't told us how old your child is and how his communication is affected. I suggest you heed the medical experts advice re his head injury and get yourself some therapy, as you clearly need to talk this through with someone.

Mynameismargot · 18/09/2021 13:57

Would you say this so blasé if it was your son?
The ops child is a BABY. He should be safe at nursery and he wasn't. That sort of accident should.not happen. Tripping and falling outside yes, but not where a staff member should be with that child every moment they're on the changing table.
Shame on you for dismissing this mum..shame on you.

I think most people would be upset at the time but it is obviously months later(at least) and all medical checks showed it was a bump to the head and nothing else. At this point I would not be linking speech and language difficulties(which are extremely common in children, most people I know have had a kid go to SALT at some point myself included) with a bump to the head months ago.

I would say if you are struggling for money to pay for SALT then getting an evening/weekend job would probably be more fruitful than pursuing this. I wouldn't be blase about speech difficulties, like I said one of mine had them but I would and did be a parent and get them treatment not fixate on one of probably many bumps to the head that my child got.

Iusedtobeatroll · 18/09/2021 13:56

OP.

If the NHS deems your soon to need SaLT then they will foot the bill. Many young children have communication difficulties. At the age of 2 my oldest could say 4 words. Said oldest daughter is now in secondary school and arguing with me about taking out the bins.

My youngest had had many, many head bumps in their time. The one where they tripped, whacked their head on the door threshold and gave themselves 2 black eyes springs to mind. Or the one where they jumped off the school climbing frame and faceplanted the floor because they thought they could fly is another memorable one.

Although the nursery should have been watching him better, correlation doesn't equal causation. A child hitting their head hard enough to cause a traumatic brain injury wouldn't just have communication-based SaLT issues. It would be usual to see other traumatic brain injury related effects e.g. problems with walking, memory, swallowing, behaviour, cognition.

ChequerBoard · 18/09/2021 13:56

@Droite

But now you are just out for £££s, and that's not going to help anyone except your bank balance.

How is it going to help OP's bank balance given her intention to use it for therapy which her child needs? In practice, if damages were awarded they would be awarded to the child anyway and any use of the money would be overseen independently.

People who complain about compensation culture never seen to educate themselves on how the system works.

A payout that's supposed to cover therapy costs would be filling the hole in OP's bank balance that funding that treatment would have cost her so it absolutely would Impact her bank balance. I fully expect that the compo culture OP would be looking to be awarded for her 'pain and suffering' too.

This is a non starter as there is zero medical evidence anyway.

Theworldishard · 18/09/2021 13:56

@VladmirsPoutine

You are massively overreacting.

If this were your baby I'm sure you wouldn't be so blasé about it.

Yeah parents on Mumsnet moan about everything normally. Ridiculous comments. I saw a post where a mum wanted to complain because the teacher had said the weekend was the best part of the week. A baby falls off a changing table from height...oh it's nothing Confused Confused
ditalini · 18/09/2021 13:55

Good grief! Noone is disputing that this event happened Hmm

Presumably the op went through the reporting and complaints procedure at the time (this is clearly not a recent event).

But the op hopes to be able to claim for private SALT from the nursery based on the fall being a cause of her child's speech problems.

The point of the post is not reporting to OFSTED, or accident books, or ensuring that this doesn't happen to another child - that will have been dealt with previously (if not then OP was presumably happy with how the nursery dealt with it at the time).

The point is getting cash to pay for treatment and for THAT they need a medical opinion that supports their hypothesis. Which they don't have.

The Head Injury charity mentioned by a pp sounds like a good next step if op wants to ensure all avenues are pursued.

Theworldishard · 18/09/2021 13:54

What is wrong with posters on here?
Stating it was a bump to the head, a minor injury etc is ridiculous.
THE CHILD FELL ONTO A HARD SURFACE FROM HEIGHT.
The OP has every right to want this investigated. The nursery is liable and should be reported as their nursery is not safe.
Would you be happy to go and pick your child up to be told they'd fallen from height onto a hard floor?
No, so stop being ridiculous and actually answer the post as you would normally.

Idontbelieveit14 · 18/09/2021 13:54

As someone who works with children I’m struggling to see how this happened if the child was being properly supervised.

justasking111 · 18/09/2021 13:53

Baby is 18 months you are concerned 6 months waiting list for referral. Buy some books do the exercises they suggest and wait for a referral appointment. My DB didn't speak untill he was three. My neighbor child just started speaking at 4.

crazyguineapiglady · 18/09/2021 13:52

Accidents happen, but this does sound negligent.

Did you report the nursery to Ofsted?

Rosesareyellow · 18/09/2021 13:52

YABVU. Speech and language difficulties are very common - as are bumps on the head in young children. There is absolutely no way it can be reasonably linked to what happened at nursery.

Comedycook · 18/09/2021 13:51

I am not your DD’s doctor- presumably there was an indication for the scan in your daughters case. 98% of MRI scans in children with speech delay will show absolutely nothing and most of the other 2% will be of uncertain significance.
From OP there would be no indication to do one whatsoever and I maintain it would actually be negligent to do it.

I'm just giving my own experience...I have no idea about whether the ops DC would need one or not. And actually my dds showed absolutely nothing significant

Theworldishard · 18/09/2021 13:51

@Tinkles78

I'm sorry your son had a bump to his head, it's never nice no matter how it happens. But if multiple doctors have checked him over and can't find any reason for concern then you will get absolutely nowhere with suing for damages.

Is your son 12 months old? Kinda hard to assess speech and language regression at that age, they're only just starting to speak!

If you aren't happy with the nursery then you should move him elsewhere, but really I think you have to accept that accidents can happen in all settings, but babies really are pretty resilient!

A 'bump to his head'? He FELL OFF A CHANGING TABLE
VladmirsPoutine · 18/09/2021 13:50

You are massively overreacting.

If this were your baby I'm sure you wouldn't be so blasé about it.

Sirzy · 18/09/2021 13:49

I’m not dismissing her concerns. But she is doing nobody any good going around in circles. It’s not blasé to say that multiple medical professionals have confirmed that thankfully as scary as it was this wasn’t a serious head injury.

Feeding her fear isn’t going to do anything to help.

Theworldishard · 18/09/2021 13:49

@Thefaceofboe

For the PPs saying the child was left unattended - the OP doesn't say that. DCs can fall from changing tables when adults are beside them. Children wriggle

Honestly, it really isn’t hard to stop a child falling off. I’m very petite and have worked in an under 2 room for the past 8 years and never come came close to allowing a child to fall off, even the wrigglers or kickers! Proper units at a height should have a little barrier to stop children ‘rolling off’ and if they start to kick up a fuss, take them off or put the mat down on the floor. If you aren’t capable of keeping them safe on the unit, you shouldn’t be doing their nappy there.

This
GrandDuchessRomanov · 18/09/2021 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.