Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Nursery dropped 12 month old baby off changing table - can any one help?

182 replies

Yokomoyr · 18/09/2021 12:19

[Name redacted by MNHQ] nursery in Birmingham:

During the first 2 hours of the first day of my then 12 month old son being there - they dropped him off a changing table onto a hard floor.

He had a huge lump on his head and was quite drowsy for a week afterwards, but neither A+E nor GP seemed too concerned.

Now he is struggling with communication and when we tried to get a medical examiner and solicitor to help us get some money out of the nursery to pay for Speech and Language Therapy, we have pretty much been told it cannot be linked and nothing has been done.

I would like someone to at least tell me they will look into this nursery or provide some help in the private SLT (as NHS is taking >6 months to refer through) - is that unreasonable?

Put my most precious person in the care of someone else and in an inexcusable moment when full attention was meant to be on him, there was a serious error which lead to a severe head injury in a 1 year old child.

Must admit I feel quite let down.

OP posts:
Abigail12345654321 · 18/09/2021 17:53

@Droite

MNers are incredibly blasé about "accidents happen". I wonder if the reaction would be the same if the child had fractured her skull and had serious bleeding on the brain? Would you all be telling OP to ignore it because "accidents happen" - especially given that this was a totally avoidable accident?
But that didn’t happen. That’s exactly the point!
SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 18/09/2021 17:47

@Yokomoyr

Thanks to everyone's replies -

I accept that accidents are inevitable, nurseries generally have a 1:3 type policy and if he was at floor level and just fell but the member of staff was elsewhere with another child, I could completely understand...

However, this was a 1:1 care situation with a child at a height off the ground that is not normal. The primary duty of care is to make sure they do not fall, the second is to change the nappy.

if this happened to an adult at work, or in another setting, or to a child that could talk, we could make a case.

Even minor head injuries can be serious:

Scans can demonstrate what appear to be minor head injuries which are actually quite damaging, but intervention is also helpful:

We just want resolution to this situation

@Jemi202 is absolutely correct.

The article about children doesn’t support you at all, OP. Perhaps there was some confusion. First of all, they divided the groups of children with “minor” head injury into those who were kept as inpatient in the hospital overnight or outpatient (not hospitalized). Your son would not qualify as inpatient, as you’ve said no one found it serious (did they keep him in the hospital inpatient? That means they checked him in, put in a pediatric ward, etc, not just that you ended up in an A&E ward for a long period). It THEN says, “ the inpatient but not the outpatient group displayed increased hyperactivity/inattention and conduct disorder between ages 10 to 13, as rated by both mothers and teachers.” But you haven’t mentioned these issues; you’ve mentioned language delay. And is he aged 10? And IMMEDIATELY after that, it says: “No clear effects were evident for various cognitive/academic measures, irrespective of severity of mild injury or age at injury.” So, nothing to do with language delays, learning difficulties, etc. If anything, they’ll use that article as proof to not give you the resolution you want.

The very first sentence of the conclusion is, “Most cases of mild head injury in young children do not produce any adverse effects…” Did you read this, OP, or just the name of the paper?

As for the second article you linked to, it’s about adults and talks about “the length of loss of consciousness” and post-traumatic amnesia. And these are still considered mild head injuries. Yet you think your son had a serious head injury. As you can see from additional comments here, there are posters whose babies had skull fractures, and there was no lasting effect. Solicitors know when they can’t “win” a case.

I am indeed only sorry this has caused you stress. But it may be time to accept that your son’s language delay is as random as many language delays. But the question is, how old is your son? If he’s still VERY young, he may catch up before you even get a SALT referral.

mumwon · 18/09/2021 17:08

op with the best will in the world your lo language difficulty probably has nothing to do with this -just because you found something which suggests a link doesn't prove this.
So lets imagine you try for no win, no fee. While you don't pay the solicitor doesn't mean you won't have major expenses -first, you will need to pay for medical report second probably a barrister -think a about five thousand or more.
but the major thing is that you need enough medical evidence for the solicitor to consider the case & frankly, op, from the information you have provided -you don't. No evidence on the medical notes?
However, you can & should talk to OFSTED

ThisIsNotAMill · 18/09/2021 16:37

Yes Yabu.

Speech problems are so common it's much more likely to be totally unrelated.

However...if you think your son has brain damage due to this injury then take him back to the GP and push for a proper diagnosis of such. Report the nursery to Ofstead or equivalent if you feel they were negligent.

All you're doing is going for compo 🙄

The nursery won't entertain you and its highly unlikely anyone will touch such a legal case with a bargepole, as you've discovered.

Save your time and effort - you won't get any money for this.

santabetterwashhishands · 18/09/2021 16:21

If the hospital were not concerned at the time I would say there's no connection to the accident and his speech delays x
I have a child with speech delay and i was always looking for a reason initially but sometimes there is no answer x

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 18/09/2021 16:18

About to say changing on a unit in nurseries is the norm..never worked in one where there hasn't been a unit. Usually a bar or something in place to prevent rolling off but on the floor.. nope!

ShaneTheThird · 18/09/2021 16:17

It's not very helpful people saying it wasn't an accident. Accidents happen all the time. You weren't there to witness what actually happened. Everyone seems to have made up a scenario where the staff member plonked the one year old on a high table and walked off. Maybe the staff member put the child on the changing table and maybe dropped a wipe or nappy mid change and instinctively bent down to grab it. In that split second the child could have rolled off the table. Therefore that would be an accident not negligence.

All we do know is the child fell off a change table and received a none serious bump on the head that multiple healthcare professionals weren't worried about he was sent straight home without treatment and now a still very young child has some sort of speech delay and a mother demanding money to seek private speech therapy.

insancerre · 18/09/2021 16:14

@Autumngoldleaf
Changing babies and toddlers on a table is par for the course at nurseries
Otherwise the nursery will be sued by the staff for their bad backs
Changing babies on the floor is ok at home with one baby but not in a nursery with multiple changes per day for lots of children

Isthisnom · 18/09/2021 16:05

That’s awful for him and you but accidents do happen. If medical professionals do not think there is any link between his communication difficulties and the head injury I don’t know what more can be done. I’m sure they will have had to fill in the relevant forms etc to comply with their accident policies.

Autumngoldleaf · 18/09/2021 15:56

Wow.. I Cant believe he wasn't changed on the floor! A table which a baby can fall off!

Looubylou · 18/09/2021 15:53

I'm very much an "accidents happen" mentality - but this wasn't an accident if someone made the decision not to have hold of this child after placing him on a table. It's basic safety. I too would be very upset. However, if medical staff say there is no link to current difficulties, it is time to move on and stop blaming nursery for his delayed communication skills. How old is he OP, and what difficulties are there? Would it help, personally, to have counselling regarding the trauma of the incident?

FatCatThinCat · 18/09/2021 15:46

To get anywhere with this you need to prove 3 things:

  1. the nursery were negligent,
  1. your son suffered a brain injury as a result,
  1. your son's development delays are a result of that injury.

You can't prove any of those things so you're wasting your time and energy on it.

prh47bridge · 18/09/2021 15:37

I understand you are upset. However, I'm afraid you aren't going to get anywhere with this. Unless you can find a medical expert who can establish a link between your child's injury and his communication difficulties, you don't have a case for anything from the nursery. I can understand why you think these things are linked but they may be completely unrelated.

Mynameismargot · 18/09/2021 15:31

@dottiedodah

I think people saying that OP is just after money are being unfair .She is worried about her DC ,and concerned that a totally avoidable accident may have caused some sort of long term damage. Obviously needs some sort of specialist legal help.
If she is concerned that there is long term damage then surely what you mean to say is she needs specialist medical help not legal? I'm not sure how a lawyer can investigate/diagnose medical issues?
Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 15:28

Did the child lose consciousness or vomit at all?

Katela18 · 18/09/2021 15:20

OP, I really feel for you here as its horrendous when something like this happens, especially when you have trusted someone else with the care of your child.

However, I do think you need to let this go now. It looks like you have been doing a lot of in depth research into head injuries in babies. There doesn't appear to be anything to link your child's injury with a need for SLT intervention and chances are it isn't linked at all

Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 15:20

@VaccineSticker

Go privately for an MRI
So give a child a general anaesthetic overrides this?
Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 15:19

@x2boys

I know. But I wanted to hear the exact words the dr used

Because that’s Pertinent to the supposed case.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 18/09/2021 15:12

@Thefaceofboe

For the PPs saying the child was left unattended - the OP doesn't say that. DCs can fall from changing tables when adults are beside them. Children wriggle

Honestly, it really isn’t hard to stop a child falling off. I’m very petite and have worked in an under 2 room for the past 8 years and never come came close to allowing a child to fall off, even the wrigglers or kickers! Proper units at a height should have a little barrier to stop children ‘rolling off’ and if they start to kick up a fuss, take them off or put the mat down on the floor. If you aren’t capable of keeping them safe on the unit, you shouldn’t be doing their nappy there.

Obviously the staff thought they could keep the child safe. MN is full of posts from parents whose DCs have fallen from beds, counters, etc. People don't deliberately put DCs at risk. That's the difference between an accident and negligence. No-one thinks they'll be unable to keep a DC safe and then does it anyway. I'm very impressed that in your 8 years of looking after under 2s no child has ever had an accident - a fall; a trip; a bump or bruise. Our nursery had the highest rating and there was still a parent signing the accident book every single week. The PPs who are pretending the nursery staff left the DC unattended are creating a layer of negligence that isn't in the OP.
VaccineSticker · 18/09/2021 15:09

Go privately for an MRI

ThorsLeftNut · 18/09/2021 15:06

How old is he now OP?

Unless he has very good communication and speech before hand (which at 12 month I can’t imagine he did) and then had very little speech or affected communication after the accident, I don’t think there’s any way you can prove it is linked.

That coming from a mother who’s child has had a worse injury injury at nursery. I’ve moved on because nothing can change about it now.

x2boys · 18/09/2021 15:06

@Nocutenamesleft

What did the drs say with regard to his head injury at the time and lasting damage?
According to THE OP there were no concerns
Ellmau · 18/09/2021 15:04

Have you withdrawn him from the nursery?

Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 15:01

Also just noticed the age

What speech problems are they having now?

Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 15:00

What did the drs say with regard to his head injury at the time and lasting damage?