Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Nursery dropped 12 month old baby off changing table - can any one help?

182 replies

Yokomoyr · 18/09/2021 12:19

[Name redacted by MNHQ] nursery in Birmingham:

During the first 2 hours of the first day of my then 12 month old son being there - they dropped him off a changing table onto a hard floor.

He had a huge lump on his head and was quite drowsy for a week afterwards, but neither A+E nor GP seemed too concerned.

Now he is struggling with communication and when we tried to get a medical examiner and solicitor to help us get some money out of the nursery to pay for Speech and Language Therapy, we have pretty much been told it cannot be linked and nothing has been done.

I would like someone to at least tell me they will look into this nursery or provide some help in the private SLT (as NHS is taking >6 months to refer through) - is that unreasonable?

Put my most precious person in the care of someone else and in an inexcusable moment when full attention was meant to be on him, there was a serious error which lead to a severe head injury in a 1 year old child.

Must admit I feel quite let down.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whosaidtha · 18/09/2021 20:55

I'm not minimising how you feel but how are you assessing s&l is needed? Most places won't even refer until child is 2. If your child is over 2 then how are you linking it to a year old accident?
I understand how upsetting this must be and hopefully the nursery have implemented some extra training or other safety precautions but I'm not sure you have a claim.

mumwon · 18/09/2021 20:40

@Cryalot2 cross post - a lot of what you say resonates - dd has asd (adult) & getting true & accurate diagnosis was a long pathway where she went through being medicated & treated for something she did not have.

mumwon · 18/09/2021 20:35

as I previously said - go to OFSTED
But it has been noted that because of lockdown many lo have NOT had social & language stimulation that they normally would have so many db/dc are behind in communication - this has been mentioned
So -how old is your lo, does he talk at all? Is his language indistinct? How many words does he have?
Have you had his hearing checked or his vision? Has he had a lot of colds? Were you working from home (& this is NOT a criticism - its about a hurdle that many parents have had) & did he have a fair amount of screen time?
As others have said - first, when he fell did the nursery ring & was he sick or sleepy? I assume you took him to a & e first than gp later?
I do not expect you to answer but just to consider
When you have a child with any difficulty particularly one which must have been there since birth - many (most?) look for reasons & blame - & often blame themselves (autism is a prime example -think mmr) The point is an incident or accident can happen but it doesn't mean that it caused the issue or disability.

Cryalot2 · 18/09/2021 20:11

Op sorry what happened. Obviously you are both upset and shocked.
You say he had a serious head injury but the gp and a&e claim not so. So medicially he didn't have have such.
You say it caused communication problems yet the experts say otherwise.
Communication delay is common especially with boys.
Who looked after him after the incident? How did they find him?
How long since it happened?

And what age is he now.
What does your hv say?
You admit you want compensation for a bump on the head which a&e did not regard as a serious head injury .Did he have to stay in hospital?
Sometimes you just have to accept the situation.
My son was born with a serious condition which could have been fatal and countless drs and hospitals failed to pick up and it was discovered by chance when he was well into his teens. We could have sued for neglect but it never entered our heads.

Motorina · 18/09/2021 20:10

No, what is the point is the way that MNers evade this question. You can have a child fall off a table due to someone's negligence and sustain little or no injury - the fact that there was little injury does not prevent them being negligent, it just means there is nothing you could claim for. Or you could have that child fall off that table as a result of exactly the same negligence and sustain a very serious injury, and I suspect that most of the "accidents happen" brigade might well be encouraging OP to take legal action. And yet the causation is exactly the same. So why the different approach?

Because the entitlement to compensation depends on the degree of harm done.

I think it's likely that the OP (or, more precisely, the child) could get compensation for the injury caused by the fall. That is, for a bump and a few days feeling poorly. How much that would be I have no idea, but I doubt it would be very much.

To get compensation to pay for private SALT the OP would have to convince a court that it was more likely than not that the speech delay was caused by the fall. It's hard to see how that's doable when the medical evidence is that the two were unrelated.

If the child had sustained a very serious injury then there would be a claim for damages proportionate to that injury. But, on the face of it, they haven't. So that claim isn't there.

People are not telling the OP to ignore it or that she should not be distressed. Of course she should - her baby was hurt. They're saying they don't think the claim she wants to pursue has legs.

Abigail12345654321 · 18/09/2021 20:02

@Droite

MNers are incredibly blasé about "accidents happen". I wonder if the reaction would be the same if the child had fractured her skull and had serious bleeding on the brain? Would you all be telling OP to ignore it because "accidents happen" - especially given that this was a totally avoidable accident?

But that didn’t happen. That’s exactly the point!

No, what is the point is the way that MNers evade this question. You can have a child fall off a table due to someone's negligence and sustain little or no injury - the fact that there was little injury does not prevent them being negligent, it just means there is nothing you could claim for. Or you could have that child fall off that table as a result of exactly the same negligence and sustain a very serious injury, and I suspect that most of the "accidents happen" brigade might well be encouraging OP to take legal action. And yet the causation is exactly the same. So why the different approach?

We see this on MN in so many different contexts. I remember a thread where a child got knocked down crossing the road on a pedestrian crossing, sustaining something like a fracture. There were quite a few responses essentially saying a fracture is trivial, accidents happen, don't be greedy. Yet when asked whether their response would be the same if it was their child who had been knocked down and they had ended up severely disabled - which could very easily have been the outcome - they all went very quiet.

You claim for damages when damage is done.

In this case there is no evidence damage was done.

If the child had a fractured skull or intracranial bleed then of course the parents could claim damages.

What on earth is your point? You seem to be waffling.

VladmirsPoutine · 18/09/2021 19:33

@Droite I do think there is a lot of internet keyboard warriorism about it. All the 'Get over it' style responses. No-one would take that position in real life - especially when it concerns such a young child. Same as the threads in which posters tell OPs to go no contact with various family members for all manner of batshit reasons.

Droite · 18/09/2021 19:13

MNers are incredibly blasé about "accidents happen". I wonder if the reaction would be the same if the child had fractured her skull and had serious bleeding on the brain? Would you all be telling OP to ignore it because "accidents happen" - especially given that this was a totally avoidable accident?

But that didn’t happen. That’s exactly the point!

No, what is the point is the way that MNers evade this question. You can have a child fall off a table due to someone's negligence and sustain little or no injury - the fact that there was little injury does not prevent them being negligent, it just means there is nothing you could claim for. Or you could have that child fall off that table as a result of exactly the same negligence and sustain a very serious injury, and I suspect that most of the "accidents happen" brigade might well be encouraging OP to take legal action. And yet the causation is exactly the same. So why the different approach?

We see this on MN in so many different contexts. I remember a thread where a child got knocked down crossing the road on a pedestrian crossing, sustaining something like a fracture. There were quite a few responses essentially saying a fracture is trivial, accidents happen, don't be greedy. Yet when asked whether their response would be the same if it was their child who had been knocked down and they had ended up severely disabled - which could very easily have been the outcome - they all went very quiet.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/09/2021 19:10

Hi OP
I would be mad as well and it's understandable to want something from them.

However you are talking about major head injuries and then in the next sentence saying that both a GP and A and E don't seem too concerned.

If you were going to get any money for treatment you would have to prove under UK law-

That there had been negligence (though duty of care is much higher for young children so you could probably prove this since the result was falling).

That your son was injured

That the injuries were a direct result of the negligence

That any ongoing difficulties or side effects are a result of the injury.

That these ongoing side effects will cause ongoing pain or suffering or financial consequence.

Have you actually got any doctor to say that his speech difficulties could in any way be connected to the fall?

itsgettingwierd · 18/09/2021 19:09

My understanding is to prove the incident led to the resulting SAL delay you have to prove both points.

A) the nursery was negligent.
B) the injury caused damage to the brain resulting in the Sal and delay.

You've been told that B just isn't so.

What about the negligence investigation? We're the nursery found at fault?

I'm not keen on where there's blame there is a claim but where negligence has resulted in proven financial loss (Eg loss of wages etc) then it's a totally different scenario.

If you have medical documentation proving he was ill for a week with his head injury and you lost wages and nursery fees you didn't use there is a proven link if there is proven negligence.

Personally though as awful as it sounds that it happened it doesn't sound like there was serious and long lasting injury and any claim exists.

I think it's very easy to get so embroiled in an argument and belief you're right it's hard to step back and accept your reaction was emotional.

And to prove they were negligent you'd have to prove they didn't follow their own risk assessments when using the changing table.

Threearm · 18/09/2021 19:04

Your best resolution for your sake is to move on. It was a horrible accident but you have no case. You can drove yourself potty pursuing something you have no case over or you can move on, vow to never return to that nursery and continue being a good parent without the stress of pursuing a zero winnable situation.

He is so young there is zero to suggest a link.

Shescratchedmyface · 18/09/2021 19:02

I'm not sure how many one year olds need SALT. Your poor son is he okay?
You have been told by medical professionals that the two issues aren't linked. Why are you seeking compensation? Human error and very traumatic but too much compensation culture is going to ruin the 🌎.

Ozanj · 18/09/2021 18:57

I work in a nursery and while accidents can and do happen, I have yet to see or experience a toddler fall off a changing table in any nursery I have ever worked for. The tables should be set up so everything that is needed for each child is accessible on a specific table & if you’re taking in 2 toddlers, one needs to be on the floor while the other is on top of the table. Definitely get them to investigate this further.

Mamamamasaurus · 18/09/2021 18:48

Your OP says it all to me: "to help us get some money out of the nursery to pay for Speech and Language Therapy"

Somethingsnappy · 18/09/2021 18:35

How old is your son now?

Peanutsandchilli · 18/09/2021 18:34

There are two issues here that need to be dealt with separately.

Firstly, that the nursery has been negligent in allowing a child to fall off a changing table. This absolutely warrants a complaint and an investigation into how this happened. The nursery needs to take full responsibility for this, however, a medical professional had determined that the child was ok at the time, and so the nursery have no case to answer with regards to any medical issues that have occurred more recently. It'll be more of a case of ensuring that their procedures for nappy changing are sound, and that the risk of any similar accident is mitigated.

Secondly, that the child is, for whatever reason, speech delayed, and that needs input from professional speech and language practitioners. Many children are similarly challenged, and it's more than likely the case that this would have occurred without the head bump. You need to focus on getting the correct support for your child, as you have no evidence to win any sort of case against the nursery.

Do the best for your son, instead of putting all your energy into trying to apportion blame.

Susannahmoody · 18/09/2021 18:33

How has his communication changed?

strawberryswirl3 · 18/09/2021 18:32

Omg I'm sorry I can't give practical advice but please ignore the 'accidents happen' comments. I've worked in nurseries and the only way a baby could be dropped from a changing table is pure negligence. Yes it only takes a split second of looking away but that's why you DON'T. It's standard for every nursery I've worked in to gather nappy, cream etc on the table/within reach so that you don't have to take your eyes of the child for any reason. And if they're particularly wriggly or difficult you have another practitioner help or change them on a changing mat on the floor. I'm so sorry this happened to you, it's really not on at all.

jacks11 · 18/09/2021 18:31

OP

Firstly, you really have not determined whether this event is the cause of your child’s problems. It is really easy to see why you might jump to that conclusion, but as yet this is your supposition, not a proven fact. Nobody will pay you damages etc on the basis that you think this is the cause. There are many, many causes for speech delay or developmental delay- it is somewhat more likely that there is an alternative cause. Either way, you’d need to prove that on balance of likelihood it was the fall that caused his probability. To be severe enough to cause this, I would expect there to be other findings on examination or investigation (such as imaging of the brain).

I know it’s easier to think this was caused by somebody else’s negligence, rather than being one of those things/inherited etc. You saw a&e and GP- neither found anything concerning enough to investigate further, by the sounds of things. Of course, both of those doctors may have missed something more serious. But it’s also highly likely they were not worried as there was nothing to find. It is therefore, a bit of a leap to assume that your child sustained a head injury severe enough to cause neurodevelopmental problems.

You need to seek proper medical opinion and have some proof that your child sustained a serious head injury which caused this before you have a hope of getting compensation.

I’d also say, it could be doing your child a disservice to label his issue as a brain injury if it is actually something else.

Blueuggboots · 18/09/2021 18:27

You have absolutely no proof that him banging his head has anything to do with his lack of speech development.

EmeraldShamrock · 18/09/2021 18:21

I'm sorry your DS was injured.
At 12 months he is probably in shock and it has had an impact on his communication.
My DS has whacked his head many times self-injuries they're fairly tough.

Gorl · 18/09/2021 18:17

I’m so sorry this happened, it must be very upsetting.

I think in all honesty the nursery is unlikely to contribute to SALT on the basis of this incident - there’s no clear link between his fall and any issues with his speech.

You have the option of pursuing a negligence claim. I would, however, caution that if medical professionals have already examined your son and indicated that they weren’t concerned you will have a real uphill battle in convincing a court that your son’s fall caused him any long term issues. You’ll need an independent medical report to confirm that there is a link, and any medical professional will be highly influenced by records from the HCPs who examined your son at the time of the accident.

I would try not to focus too much on the fall. It was an awful, stressful thing, but take comfort from the fact that doctors examined him at the time and weren’t concerned.

Many children have speech and language delays which have no obvious cause and which resolve themselves in time and / or with SALT. I would focus on getting your son the support he needs with that and try to leave the fall in the past.

Anothermothernamegame · 18/09/2021 18:06

He didn't have a 'severe head injury'

RickJames · 18/09/2021 18:04

Oh OP, I just want to commiserate with you. You must be so upset. I really hope your DS is okay.

When my DS was this age he rolled off the sofa onto a tiled floor, I was with him, it just happened so fast. He cried a lot and then vomited. I rushed him to the child hospital (fortunately just around the corner from my house) and spent 48 hours in there whilst they assessed him for head injuries. He was actually fine but its the worst feeling.

Please take it easy and see what happens xxx

Nocutenamesleft · 18/09/2021 17:54

@SudokuWillNotSaveYou

You’re right. Any TBI involves loss of consciousness of a certain Glasgow score. Even the mildest ones

OP hasn’t said her child lost consciousness yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread