Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I need to get a grip when it comes to my nanny?

412 replies

AdifferentGoat · 18/09/2021 11:55

Am fully ready to be told I am being a gigantic cow but figured I'd ask. So, just to quickly sum it up, I am finally back at work (part-time) but am working from home (long story but essentially I am searching for financial freedom). As many recommended since my husband works day and night and is able to contribute when it comes to child work, I hired a nanny to take care of my child while I work...
It all sounds nice and all. I should be ecstatic. I mean it is the ideal situation. I get to work and know my child is being taken care of... But I cannot STAND her. Something about her just rubs me the wrong way. I have felt this for the past few months but always chalked it up to me being oversensitive.
If I sound deranged, it's because I feel deranged! Let me give a few examples. I recently asked if she could please not change my daughter's diaper in the living room. The look she gave me was like I asked her to clean up the blood from a body I murdered. So then I figured, okay maybe I am being a little anal and kind gave it a rest. However last night I went out for the first time in MONTHS. I asked if she could sit her while I was out (I am of course paying her for the additional hours). My husband is traveling so I figured it would be safest to hire her for the evening vs someone new. So she comes over but didn't annouce her presence. I was playing with my child and shouting random songs (as you do) and nanny suddenly 'appears' (she has her own keys). I yelped as seriously thought a ghost had appeared. That and I was in my underwear assuming I was home alone!! I looked at her and said oh my I didn't know you were here! And she gave me a silent look and said 'Yes. Yes i have been here for a hour'. She seemed off (again) but figured I'd ask if she was okay. She said she was okay. I kind of left it at that and went out.
Anyway to finally get to the end of this convoluted post, am I crazy for assuming this woman has bad energy? The easiest solution is to find someone else but she has such a good relationship with my child and my child has bonded to her. That and I need to work! How do I just fire someone because they have bad vibes?? Maybe I am the issue? If you have read this far. Thank you. I just don't know what to do.

OP posts:
Droite · 19/09/2021 09:26

I don't know why you insist on feeling guilty about this. The woman is moody, she keeps asking for advances on her salary, she owes you money she is making no effort to repay, she cadges gifts, she overshares about her family problems - I can't think of any employer who would actually keep someone who does this. Your baby likes her because he sees her a lot, he really won't be harmed by being in the care of a better nanny. There are nannies out there with whom you will gel much better, and who will therefore be better for your baby.

5zeds · 19/09/2021 09:18

You’re not crazy or unreasonable (and as an aside, you get one life you are ALLOWED to choose what to do with it and DON’T have to justify why something does or doesn’t work for you). It’s like going on holiday or choosing a book or a drink. You choose, not dh or friends or anyone else.

Imagine if the nanny turned up on time, made the baby happy, babysat when you wanted to go out and then wasn’t there. Imagine if she just got paid without issue, and didn’t angle for presents or take your charity donations. Imagine if you didn’t know when she was having a bad day become she was a professional at work and didn’t unload on you. Imagine if she praised you for feeding and dragging yourself up from depression and celebrated your new job with and did everything to help make it work.

Now is this employee anything like that?

Sometimes you have to push hard towards the life you want.

RandomMess · 19/09/2021 09:11

At the end of the day you don't gel so find a new nanny and give notice.

It's so important that you feel relaxed and comfortable with people living in your home and you don't!

AdifferentGoat · 19/09/2021 09:07

So before I get to the all the responses I have received (thank you so much). There is some confusion re why I was surprised she was home. The thing is I had given her the entire day off and I told her to please come home by x hour and to let me know when she would arrive so I could ready myself. She has a boyfriend /partner/someone so I told her to just enjoy her day and come home at x hour so I could meet my friend for dinner. Why I was unsettled was, she hasn't arrived by time I asked her to come home hence I assumed she was running late. However she had been in the house all along. I never lied in my interview with her. I told her weekdays live in and weekends she could do her own thing aside from when we require babysitting but we pay her as a live in and have added more money as she isn't live in during weekends . I told her family time is very important to me but I want a dynamic where her and I are a team and work together.
I'm sorry if I sound frustrated but I am. My husband barely exists in our day to day life. I have no family or anyone to count on. My baby had serious colic and rarely slept. And finally I get this highly recommended nanny and a new job, and I cannot f**king relax as something about this woman rubs me the wrong way. And on same note, I feel ridiculous. Who am I to complain? I needed help and I got it but she makes me so uncomfortable but is it me? Am I the crazy unreasonable person?

OP posts:
PerseverancePays · 19/09/2021 08:34

It sounds to me like you have very little experience in hiring and working with people in your home. Your nanny on the other hand saw you coming ! She has massively taken advantage of you and in her own way undermined you.
You have very afternoon to interview new nannies and weekends as well. You can have your baby with you for the interviews as you can see how they interact with her.
Stop referring to your husband, he’s abusing you by saying that all problems are you being ‘dramatic ‘. That is his get out clause to ever accept any responsibility. It’s not normal to work so exclusively that you are never available for family life and he knows it.
Get some therapy and assertiveness classes for yourself, you need better coping mechanisms, the ones you have are not working for you.
You are doing great coming out of your depression and getting a job and knowing what your exit strategy is, well done for that. But you need to get rid of your nanny by lining up a new one first. Don’t worry about your daughter settling in with her, let the nanny get on with it. Keep your office door shut when you are working!
Baby not sleeping; get some advice, training, increase the nannies hours to night time so she gets up and you never know she might have techniques that will settle the baby. If you do increase her hours, deduct her loan, ignore her family’s problems , she’s guilt tripping you.
Honestly you are doing great , living in the States is hard.
Big hugs to you 💐

user1496146479 · 19/09/2021 08:31

@CustardySergeant

"The reason her arriving home was weird is because it wasn't a weekend but a weekday."

But you said she lives there during the week and somewhere else at weekends, so why be surprised she's there on a weekday?

Exactly what I was thinking!
butterpuffed · 19/09/2021 08:29

I cannot voice any concern without being told I am 'dramatic'.

Not sure your husband means that, I think it's said to shut down the conversation.

Blondeshavemorefun · 19/09/2021 08:21

My first reply was that she isn’t A good fit. It happens sometimes in nanny jobs

You find a new nanny. Your child will be fine. She will adjust and like new carer

If it is nights you are struggling with then get a sleep trainer in

Sleep deprivation is one of the worst things for mental state

I do think you would be better with a live out nanny

MeridianB · 19/09/2021 08:21

Sorry if I misseD it but did you get references for this woman? I suspect she is playing you. A loan for four months of salary which she has yet to start repaying properly because there is ‘always something’ plus five advances on salary? Stop all the extra financing now.

Get some legal advice on how to dismiss her fairly (I’d want to pay her off or write off loan to cover notice rather than trust her with my baby during notice period, as she sounds erratic and unpredictable).

Not sure when your probation ends but if it’s more than a month away I wouldn’t wait. Find a stop gap - nursery, nanny share for a short while and then step back and assess what you really need for childcare and use an agency, so they manage any drama.

Excited101 · 19/09/2021 08:16

I didn’t want to read and run, you’ve had some good advice op but I’ll try and write a proper reply later. X

Maireas · 19/09/2021 07:42

Sorry, I've just read the rest of your posts, OP. There's some very good advice on here, but the point is that you're uncomfortable with this woman in your home and it needs to change (wherever you live!)

Maireas · 19/09/2021 07:37

You sound as if you're in the USA - check your employment laws

ShadesOfMagenta · 19/09/2021 07:32

AdifferentGoat - you poor thing- some of the advice on this thread has been very unhelpful.

Stop searching for ways to make yourself feel comfortable with this woman - trust your gut instinct.

Is your workaholic DH a high earner and do you have access to the family income? Have you thought about getting a sleep expert/nanny to help with baby’s sleep routine? If baby sleeps then you will be less exhausted.

Are you getting help for your PND? Do you have good medical care - could you access online therapy?

With regards to Nanny being there at the weekends- tell her clearly that staying here at the weekend is not an option and if possible put this in writing. Then when she leaves for the weekend keep a key in the inside of the house so she can’t get in and/or have a second lock fitted that she doesn’t have a key for so she CANNOT get in at the weekend.

Do you have colleagues who are working Mums? Might any of them be interested in a nanny share (if they have a Nanny then it cuts their costs if their Nanny looks after your baby at the same time)?

How are others coping with closing Nurseries? Are there any childminders near you (“in home day care”) might be the term in the US? With less kids there is less chance of closure etc.

Are you certain that local regulations mean it is hard to fire someone who has not been in your employment for long?

Do you have some friends even if they don’t have kids that you could chat to about this all on Zoom? What about former colleagues?

Good luck.

BookFiend4Life · 19/09/2021 07:25

Also you may not be aware that in the US the probationary period for office type jobs is generally just a formality because of the at-will employment laws. If you do decent work (you seem very conscientious) I'm sure you'll move into the regular position with no trouble.

saywhatwhatnow · 19/09/2021 07:21

Also if I came home to my live in position to find my employer in her underwear shouting random songs and the employer then yelped and seemed really shocked to find me in the house I wouldn’t know how to either. People behave awkwardly in awkward situations

As a nanny this kind of thing is a surprisingly regular occurrence, seeing employers in their PJs/underwear/swimwear/topless is par for the course, especially when you live in. You just have to laugh it off.

If she's not right then find a new nanny, life is too short to feel uncomfortable in your own home. If you want to try and make it work then I would suggest changing the position to live out and only for the hours you need (with overtime agreed in advance). Quick handover at either end of the day and then you stay out of their hair. Be clear if you want certain things done a certain way, she's not a mind reader.

I do however get the impression the feeling is fairly mutual, and sometimes nanny/parent relationships just don't work out and that is ok.

BookFiend4Life · 19/09/2021 07:11

Your baby will be just fine, you're not psycho, you should only have people working in your home that you trust and like. You can do it!

AdifferentGoat · 19/09/2021 07:09

@BookFiend4Life

Also your baby will adjust really quickly, but you have to try your best to focus on work when the nanny is there and let them handle the babycare. It is really tough to work for someone who is WFH and comes out everytime the baby cries. I know you are nervous but your baby will be ok! I took care of three quite young babies for different families (starting at 2 weeks, 3 mos and 6 mos) and they all cried for mom at first but very quickly settled into a happy routine.
You are absolutely right. I don't want to be a micromanaging mum. It is why I try my hardest to work outside the home as to give her space however with zoom calls and what not, it is hard. I think if I trusted her I wouldn't worry but I don't. I don't have an exact reason as to why I don't trust her aside from moody and money issues. That coupled with me already doubting my judgement makes for a bad mix. I guess I just want encouragement re it is okay to dismiss someone and my baby will bond with someone else and I won't lose my job in the interim. Also my baby has bonded so much with her. Maybe I am the psycho who is ripping a connection away from my baby simply because this woman makes me so uneasy.
OP posts:
Eilatan2018 · 19/09/2021 06:55

@AdifferentGoat

She is a live-in nanny. Due to covid, I was worried re having someone enter and exit. Cases are quite awful where I live. Also she requested live-in and I was more than happy as she interviewed so well. That and if you have seen my previous posts, I desperately am seeking financial freedom. Was going through serious postpartum depression and have absolutely no family around. The good news is my baby adores her. Our live in arrangement is one in which she stays at ours during the work week and elsewhere during the weekend. I had told her from start I might need her for the occasional weekend evening to babysit my baby and she said totally fine (we of course pay her for these hours). The problem is... She gets so upset or 'vacant' in the eyes when I ask her to do something differently. Further she seems to have all these family problems and issues with her boyfriend and some days we get the 'amazing nanny' and other days, the shadow of darkness. How on earth do I address this? I have never had in-house help.
You may be being sensitive but you are paying her to look after your child so you need to have someone you’re happy with especially if she lives with you! You’ll find someone else.
BookFiend4Life · 19/09/2021 06:49

Also your baby will adjust really quickly, but you have to try your best to focus on work when the nanny is there and let them handle the babycare. It is really tough to work for someone who is WFH and comes out everytime the baby cries. I know you are nervous but your baby will be ok! I took care of three quite young babies for different families (starting at 2 weeks, 3 mos and 6 mos) and they all cried for mom at first but very quickly settled into a happy routine.

BookFiend4Life · 19/09/2021 06:45

I think you can get it done in three weekends! Use care.com (I was a nanny on care and it worked great for me), line up a bunch of interviews one right after another for Saturday 1 and 2, on Saturday 3 line up your favorites to come play with your baby and go with whoever you like the best. Great attitude is a must.

AdifferentGoat · 19/09/2021 06:40

@BookFiend4Life

I would: write off the money as gone tell her firmly that weekends are family time and she can't stay, "going forward we can't have you here at weekends, I'm sorry I wasn't clearer about that before, thank you for understanding" start interviewing new nannies for a full time/live out position on her day off your husband's opinion doesn't matter because he isn't around, stop trying to get his input or help on anything to do with the firing or hiring, if he calls you dramatic you can just say "it's not working out, I'm looking for someone new"

Don't wait for your probationary period to end, just get her out of the house on the weekends and start interviewing. All states in the US are "at-will" employment which means you can fire her for any reason at any time.

You can do this but you have to just stop doubting yourself and get it done, you will feel much better when the dark cloud/angry shadow is gone. There are a million chirpy 20 year olds that would love to be your nanny.

Thank you so for this advice. I feel trapped because I only just landed this job and firing her and finding a new person will mean I need to dedicate hours to getting my child used to new nanny. Again, this is my fear. I worry how I will have the mental space to focus on both my job and finding a new person. I also am recovering from severe depression so everything seems harder. This is why I am glad I posted as am seeing maybe things aren't as bad as I think they are and it is okay to dismiss her once I find someone new and I am not beholden to her? I also need to accept that my husband simply isn't around to help re decision making. Thank you for the encouragement.
OP posts:
Grellbunt · 19/09/2021 06:21

How did you find the nanny? Do you have a strategy for finding a new one? Stop worrying about the past and focus on that.

Research how much notice etc the existing nanny needs to be given.

Write off loans in your head

  • any repayment will be a bonus now. Don't keep her on expecting repayment to magically happen.

Start searching for new nanny lady

Grellbunt · 19/09/2021 06:17

Of course it makes sense - you are a nice person and you want to help people. But right now you need to come first because that is how you will help yourself and your daughter to build a life as assertive, confident individuals. This is one of those "Put on your own oxygen mask before helping others" moments. Put yourself first for a while. You deserve it and it is necessary.

BookFiend4Life · 19/09/2021 06:15

I would:
write off the money as gone
tell her firmly that weekends are family time and she can't stay, "going forward we can't have you here at weekends, I'm sorry I wasn't clearer about that before, thank you for understanding"
start interviewing new nannies for a full time/live out position on her day off
your husband's opinion doesn't matter because he isn't around, stop trying to get his input or help on anything to do with the firing or hiring, if he calls you dramatic you can just say "it's not working out, I'm looking for someone new"

Don't wait for your probationary period to end, just get her out of the house on the weekends and start interviewing. All states in the US are "at-will" employment which means you can fire her for any reason at any time.

You can do this but you have to just stop doubting yourself and get it done, you will feel much better when the dark cloud/angry shadow is gone. There are a million chirpy 20 year olds that would love to be your nanny.

AdifferentGoat · 19/09/2021 06:15

@MyOtherProfile

For me the biggest problem here is your relationship with DH over what's going on with the nanny. I'd be pushing relationship counseling first.
Yes. True. I do have a DH problem but there isn't much I can do about it right now. I fell in love with him for reasons I barely see anymore. Since we had our baby, all the values I assumed he had have vanished. I cannot voice any concern without being told I am 'dramatic'.
OP posts: