Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider taking my children out of school an hour early once a week so that they can go to a swimming lesson?

137 replies

PineNutsAreOverpriced · 18/09/2021 10:30

Just that really. Year 4 twins and a year 6. Weren’t strong swimmers before lockdown and still aren’t now - although they can mostly stay afloat there is still a lot of doggy paddling going on especially from the younger ones.

Previous swimming teacher has moved away. All local teachers and swimming schools are full up after school for lessons and have waiting lists for “sometime in 2022”

But I could get them into a lesson at 2.30pm during the week, on a day I am not working. I can get them there if I pick up at 2.15pm (school finishes at 3pm)

I think I probably would be unreasonable but am considering this.

School does not provide swimming lessons for the year 4s - there was a week course (one session a day) for my year 6 at the beginning of the year but that will be it for the year.

I’m not sure how the head will react if I ask.

Also, we do take them swimming as a family but can’t seem to get them to take it seriously the way they did with lessons. One has dyspraxia and tends to hang off me in the pool, which doesn’t help the situation.

OP posts:
bonbonours · 18/09/2021 13:49

@Bananarama21

bonbonours Can she swim more than 25 metres and on her back aswell? There's a massive drive with Swim England about myths around stopping lessons if they can swim 25 metres it is encouraged they complete lessons up to stage 7 to be a confident and competent in swimming further than 25 metres in more than one stroke.
My experience of swimming lessons is not at all that they focus on water safety but rather that they are obsessed with 'correct' technique and you must do front crawl with your face in the water. I'm not interested in her learning butterfly or having correct technique - you only really need that if you plan to swim competitively.

As far as I'm concerned, my daughter can tread water, keep herself afloat, and swim strongly enough to enjoy a pool and the sea safely with her friends and family.

She would struggle to swim 100 metres without stopping but I would love to hear of a situation where being able to swim that far would save your life. In the extremely unlikely event of falling into water you need to know how to float and tread water, or swim to the edge (definitely closer than 100 m if you fell off it!). In fact the RNLI specifically say if you fall in water DON'T swim, float on your back.

What I have taught her is about sea safety (as we live near the coast) which is much more relevant and valuable so she knows about the dangers of tides, currents, groynes, inflatables etc, and tends to stay within her depth in the sea.

HosannainExcelSheets · 18/09/2021 13:40

Absolutely do it. My DC left school early all through primary to do a competitive sport class that they were selected for and conflicted with school time. The head was absolutely fine with it.

Gazelda · 18/09/2021 13:37

While you're on the waiting lists, could you put the twins in after school care once a week while you take the older one and teach them yourself?

And check out intensive courses.
Ask on FB for recommendations.

Quisto · 18/09/2021 13:31

I did this with my yr 5 child 11 years ago when the swimming centre changed his lesson time and I had to catch a bus to get there. You can only ask, my son's school were very accommodating, but he was very academically capable.

BoomChicka · 18/09/2021 13:25

My dd never had lessons as there was a ridiculous waiting list. Her dad took her at weekends, but she actually mastered swimming in hotel pools on holiday, a week in a resort with a lifeguard might work out cheaper than swimming lessons x 3 Grin

BiBabbles · 18/09/2021 13:20

Bananarama21 That's interesting to read, thanks for sharing. I'd noticed my local pool seems to be really struggle to reopen for more than lane swimming, very few lessons and the family/casual swims that we were using to teach ours are only in the middle of weekdays so not much use for school kids. It makes more sense if they're struggling for staff.

I don't know many pools that allow people to swim in normal clothes (the minimum includes experience swimming in clothes), or is that something that would come up in normal lessons?

Pumperthepumper · 18/09/2021 13:16

I’d definitely ask the question, if you think you could make it work it sounds a great idea. Speak to the head and see what they say.

notthemum · 18/09/2021 13:14

@baileys6904
Sorry ? You were a single parent to a 20 month old for years in a deprived area ? 🍷

TankFlyBoss · 18/09/2021 13:12

@Autumncoming she wouldn't be fined.

Wtf86 · 18/09/2021 13:12

I think ask OP! If it helps my kids are at a private prep and they have an hour of swimming a week in their daily timetable!

Mammyloveswine · 18/09/2021 13:11

This would be unacceptable...first of all they will be missing a LOT of education over the year..secondly it is really bloody disruptive when kids are picked up early!

And you also sign a home school agreement to ensure your child attends during their school hours, so you would be breaking that.

My local pool does weekend lessons.. or just teach them yourself. My dad taught me and we are teaching our own boys when we go swimming.

womaninatightspot · 18/09/2021 13:09

@PineNutsAreOverpriced

Thanks *@teleskopregel* Grin

@Woeismethischristmas - I could ask the school, they are generally really good and were really supportive of all families during lockdown and still are.

I don’t want them to miss anything important near the end of the day though. They are all academically able and well ahead expectation wise, if that makes a difference

@ChrissyPlummer - I think those time slots are usually for younger ones, mine used to go when in pre-school, although the home Ed kids could also go anytime I suppose

Thinking about it there was another child who used to scoot off nearly two hours early for swimming therapy/ lessons. She'd have a 1-1 then her siblings a twin and older brother would have a 2-1 lesson directly after. Perhaps if you approach it as mostly beneficial for the child with dyspraxia.

Generally teachers are quite good about ensuring kids don't miss a lot. Different if they are being asked to provide work for those on holiday.

PawsNotClaws · 18/09/2021 13:08

If your DC are missing the same hour every week, chances are that they will also be missing the same scheduled lesson/activity each time too, eg art, music, science, interventions.

My secondary school DC misses 20min slots of classes for music lessons, but those are done on a rolling rota basis so that students don't miss the same class each week. Students are also expected to take responsibility for catching up on anything they've missed. it's highly unlikely that a Yr 4 or a Yr 6 child would be able to do that without input from a teacher.

Bananarama21 · 18/09/2021 13:06

bonbonours www.swimming.org/learntoswim/know-child-competent-swimmer/

Bunnycat101 · 18/09/2021 13:02

I think you can legitimately ask the school how they’re planning on ensuring the national curriculum standards for swimming are met. I don’t think it is legitimate to leave early for a beginners swimming class when you should be able to find holiday courses etc.

Bananarama21 · 18/09/2021 13:01

bonbonours Can she swim more than 25 metres and on her back aswell? There's a massive drive with Swim England about myths around stopping lessons if they can swim 25 metres it is encouraged they complete lessons up to stage 7 to be a confident and competent in swimming further than 25 metres in more than one stroke.

TankFlyBoss · 18/09/2021 13:01

Hi @PineNutsAreOverpriced

I'm an education welfare officer and find this a really interesting debate whenever it comes up at work, which it does, in many different schools and for various circumstances.

I would ask the Head. This situation is basically down to their discretion but a decent head should at least talk to you about it.

Ultimately the school cannot stop you collecting your children whenever you want so the answer is technically that you CAN take them out by early collecting, however this certainly does not mean that you SHOULD. I would never advise that you just do this without the agreement of the school unless you truly believed it was absolutely worth the damage it will do to your relationship with the school AND the disruption to the children.

Flexi schooling may be one option to reach an agreement on this and the school should be willing to consider a properly considered proposal from you. It depends a little on what the children's timetable is that afternoon, and how they feel any early collection and flexi schooling will impact this.

There is also the question of whether they register is taken in the afternoon straight after lunch or at the end of the afternoon session just before home time as the school would have to mark them absent which will cause other problems.

I can see your argument that swimming is a life skill, on the national curriculum and won't be provided by school. Maybe there may be some scope to attend the lessons until a basic standard of swimming is achieved as this is ultimately a life saving skill.

I would absolutely discuss it with your head and see how they respond.

Hesma · 18/09/2021 12:53

For a one off maybe but every week, really????

Talktalkchat · 18/09/2021 12:51

I never learnt to swim at school

toomuchlaundry · 18/09/2021 12:49

Has your Y6 DC had their school swimming lessons?

esloquehay · 18/09/2021 12:46

I think you are being unreasonable and entitled to even be considering it. 😯
Wait 'til lessons come up/you get to the top of the waiting list, like everyone else has to. 💚

Clymene · 18/09/2021 12:45

Have a look and see if you can find an intensive course over half term. That was much more effective for my children than weekly sessions.

Cam77 · 18/09/2021 12:45

Not saying she necessarily should by the way, just challenging the assumption that every hour spent in school is “precious”. Learning can happen anywhere.

IAAP · 18/09/2021 12:45

Can you imagine ? one child off Mondays 9-11 to play tennis another for Spanish, another for swimming, one for yoga etc of course let them all attend school just when they want as it’s just basically free childcare right?

Cam77 · 18/09/2021 12:44

YABU. They need to be in school; that’s far more important
Why? Home educated kids seem to do really well, and they’re in school zero days a week for zero hours.