Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation

206 replies

Mumguilt12 · 17/09/2021 23:19

After a recent death in the family, Me and DH were chatting about our death and funeral plans etc. Cheery huh!

Anyway, I said the songs I wanted played at my funeral. And I am absolutely clear that if my organs can be donated, they should be. All of them.
If not, I’d like to donate my body to science. I’d like to be cremated.

He thinks organ donation is not nice. “I dont want them to cut me up etc” I am absolutely shocked by his negative feelings towards it.

I said if our kid needed a new heart, would he accept it and he said he would. Now I believe if you are willing to take, you should be willing to give.

He is certain that he finds it all a bit wrong and it’s not nice for the family left behind. I also said that I completely disagreed and I personally would find comfort in knowing my relative had saved a life.

I know it’s silly but a) if I go, I don’t trust him to follow my wishes b) I’m judging him. How can you not want to help a sick person?! I don’t get it.

He comes from a religious family although himself is not really into it (other than a general belief in god). Not sure if that’s part of his thoughts.

It’s really made me look at him in a different light. AIBU?

It’s times like these that I think we are really not compatible. I really value kindness and thinking of others and he… really doesn’t.

OP posts:
Justyouwaitandseeagain · 18/09/2021 01:14

Not quite. Your family will still be consulted. But as I said above, they are asked to consider what you would have wanted. This is to confirm that your registered decision is still accurate and that they are not aware of any change of heart. People are told about the role of the family so they can make sure they share their donation decision. When family know what a relative wants to happen, the vast majority will support that decision. Those who don’t usually have a very genuine reason why they don’t / feel they can’t. If you are concerned your family won’t support your decision, then the best thing to do is appoint a nominated representative who you know will do so. This could be a professional eg a lawyer you have briefed/instructed or a close friend or relative who you trust over and above your family. I hope this helps.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 01:07

@Justyouwaitandseeagain

Xenobitch Flowers

In terms of your question about opting out and the role of your family, my advice would be to register your decision and clearly inform your relatives that this is what you want to happen.

When families are approached under the new system, the nurses’ aim will be to support the family to work out what their relative would have wanted. If you have registered a decision - whether to opt in or opt, they still check that your family are not aware of any later change of mind/heart or a more up to date decision. If you would prefer your family not to be consulted, you can choose to appoint a nominated representative who you trust to uphold your decision and they will be approached instead (you can do this via the NHS organ donation website).

Yes, I did register my decision.. and the letter I had confirming that implied that it would still be up to my relatives anyway. Kind of renders any sort of opt in/out pointless.
Floralnomad · 18/09/2021 00:54

I do agree that if you would accept an organ you should also be willing to donate but I don’t think it’s a reflection on whether someone is kind and selfless generally .

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 18/09/2021 00:54

Xenobitch Flowers

In terms of your question about opting out and the role of your family, my advice would be to register your decision and clearly inform your relatives that this is what you want to happen.

When families are approached under the new system, the nurses’ aim will be to support the family to work out what their relative would have wanted. If you have registered a decision - whether to opt in or opt, they still check that your family are not aware of any later change of mind/heart or a more up to date decision. If you would prefer your family not to be consulted, you can choose to appoint a nominated representative who you trust to uphold your decision and they will be approached instead (you can do this via the NHS organ donation website).

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 18/09/2021 00:43

The shaming on this thread is awful.

I donated my sons organs many years ago now.

It was a gift, a gift that I chose to give. Had it been expected, or if people had called me selfish and started on about other families and using emotional blackmail I may not have been able to donate them.

It shouldn't be expected. It's not selfish not to put your family through the process, which is bloody hard IMHO.

Its selfless to donate, it isn't selfish not to.

We need to think of our families and what's best for them, as we do with wills, we don't call people selfish for letting our families have our belongings and not leaving it all to charity. Our bodies are the same,whatever makes our families happier and more comfortable is paramount.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 00:42

@Justyouwaitandseeagain

Xenobitch - It is not called organ harvesting anymore, it’s is called organ retrieval. Your account does not match with my experience. Donation only goes ahead when death has already been confirmed. There is no reason why you would be trying to ‘save’ an already deceased patient. The donation and retrieval teams are also purposefully separate to the medical teams who have looked after that patient. Everyone I know working in organ donation and transplantation has the utmost respect and gratitude for the gift those donors and their families give. I am sorry it sounds as if you have had a difficult/stressful experience. Sad
Maybe the trust I worked in then. They called it 'harvesting', although that was 7 years ago for me now so it may have changed. I know the patient is technically dead but it is still hard to see a warm body on the table and not feel like it is wrong some how. Not rational, I know. The theatre I was in did not deal with organ retrieval that often tbh. Like you said, the upmost respect is given in each stage.
Justyouwaitandseeagain · 18/09/2021 00:35

Xenobitch - It is not called organ harvesting anymore, it’s is called organ retrieval. Your account does not match with my experience. Donation only goes ahead when death has already been confirmed. There is no reason why you would be trying to ‘save’ an already deceased patient. The donation and retrieval teams are also purposefully separate to the medical teams who have looked after that patient. Everyone I know working in organ donation and transplantation has the utmost respect and gratitude for the gift those donors and their families give. I am sorry it sounds as if you have had a difficult/stressful experience. Sad

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 18/09/2021 00:30

@XenoBitch To the very best of my knowledge your wishes would be upheld as you have opted out- I.e. you are in the system as not wishing to donate therefore in the event of your death your next of kin wouldn't be approached, if you were referred on by ward staff then a quick search of the register would show you had opted out and it would go no further. However it is always worth telling your family/ next of kin your wishes too and emphasising that they respect them.

To reassure yourself and make sure that your wishes are respected it's always best to ask the experts (I'm not directly involved in consenting) so you can email or call NHSBT to clarify the position of opt out. Here's the relevant page of the website for opt out. The phone number should be easily accessible from there.
www.organdonation.nhs.uk/helping-you-to-decide/about-organ-donation/get-the-facts/

You don't have to justify your decision to anyone on here. It's not selfish to determine what you do with your body. It's the very definition of autonomy. I'd hate to work and live in a society where people's donation wishes were not respected. I'm on the donation register- except for my eyes because I'm too squeamish for that. I know exactly how important eye donation is but they're my eyes, my decision and that's that. 🤷🏼‍♀️ It's not selfish to exercise your bodily autonomy.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 00:27

@poolsidefashion

No, but I was there for "organ harvesting" as it is called. Lights low, and no one talked. There is something that goes against everything in your soul when you have someone on the operating table that you are letting die, and not trying to save.
I have my beliefs about things.. and I do not want to live on in anyway shape or form, be that in spirit or a kidney. Please respect that.

Summerfun54321 · 18/09/2021 00:25

Life and death is complicated and emotional and if someone doesn’t like the thought of their body being taken apart and given to a stranger then I get that. It’s really a personal choice OP, it’s far too deep a topic to call someone selfish over.

poolsidefashion · 18/09/2021 00:19

@Annoyedanddissapointed

Not as weird as you think.
well that’s me told Grin
poolsidefashion · 18/09/2021 00:18

[quote XenoBitch]@poolsidefashion even though I gave fuck knows how many hours of service to the NHS. Yeah, I am selfish.[/quote]
you work for the NHS? your choice is even more bizarre in that case! did you never come across patients who died needlessly? presumably not

Annoyedanddissapointed · 18/09/2021 00:18

Not as weird as you think.

poolsidefashion · 18/09/2021 00:17

[quote Annoyedanddissapointed]@poolsidefashion did you just make a profile to be a cunt to someone? You have no right to talk to someone like that over a decision about their body. Whether that's while they are alive or dead.[/quote]
no I name change regularly but how weird of you to search me Confused

Mumguilt12 · 18/09/2021 00:15

Well xeno you’ve made me realise that my DH is “kind” in other ways. Thinking about it, our kindness and methods to help others is quite different.

OP posts:
CourgetteGlutTony · 18/09/2021 00:12

your and @XenoBitch attitude to organ donation is embarrassingly childish. it annoyed you that the government put something in place to save more lives and your response to that annoyance is to do everything you can to prevent lives being saved. It’s like the dog in the manger. Utterly spiteful and selfish

Nonsense. I’m more than happy to donate all of my organs. All I ask is that somebody asks my DH for the gift of my organs and it isn’t presumed that they can be taken

Annoyedanddissapointed · 18/09/2021 00:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 00:11

@Mumguilt12

Xeno are you ok? Serious question. Do reach out to someone if you need to talk. X
Thanks. Just a little fed up with the "selfish" narrative that seems to get peddled with most things nowadays. More so from people who call me selfish when they have apply that to the teeny 1% chance of organ donation from me when they have no idea what else the rest of my life is like.
HollaHolla · 18/09/2021 00:10

Anyone can have any bits of me which might be useful. I’ve consented to organ donation since I was 17 (Scotland.) I won’t be using them, and as I want to be cremated, they’d burn anyway. 🤷🏻‍♀️
I am genuinely interested in why people opt out - especially when they’d be willing to accept a transplant.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 00:09

@poolsidefashion even though I gave fuck knows how many hours of service to the NHS. Yeah, I am selfish.

Mumguilt12 · 18/09/2021 00:08

Xeno are you ok? Serious question. Do reach out to someone if you need to talk. X

OP posts:
poolsidefashion · 18/09/2021 00:06

[quote XenoBitch]@poolsidefashion what makes you think you can put that on me... "People will die if I don't donate!" when chances are , even if I was an organ donor, it wont happen. Most people who offer to donate organs never actually do. TBH, my death is likely to be at the bottom of a car park in a big mush. No good to anyone. And I do not want to live on in anyone else as any organ at all. That is my belief.[/quote]
I’m not ‘putting it on you’, you made the choice so you’re putting it on yourself. and your choice is selfish.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2021 00:02

@poolsidefashion what makes you think you can put that on me... "People will die if I don't donate!" when chances are , even if I was an organ donor, it wont happen. Most people who offer to donate organs never actually do. TBH, my death is likely to be at the bottom of a car park in a big mush. No good to anyone. And I do not want to live on in anyone else as any organ at all. That is my belief.

XenoBitch · 17/09/2021 23:59

@Teaandcakeordeath83

I work in donation. Just to reassure anyone reading this thread- the opt out system doesn't mean that we will swoop in and take your organs and tissues if you haven't opted out at the time of your death. It just means that if you haven't opted out that we are able to have a conversation with potential donor families about donation- it's about widening the conversation pool and increasing donations that way rather than just taking! If the family does not consent- even for those who have registered their wish for their organs and tissues to be donated- then we simply do not proceed with donation.

Bare in mind that for organ donation to happen you have to have been on life support and declared brain dead- very, very few people have the right circumstances for beating heart organ donation. For tissue donation it's different and you can donate tissues within 6-72 hours of death depending on how your body has been stored. It's truly a gift and my colleagues and myself all treat it as such. The impact a donor and their family has on recipients is incredible.

Op. If you truly want to be an organ/ tissue donor then you really need to make sure that your partner understands that and will respect your wishes. I've seen numerous cases where family have been unable or unwilling to give consent to honour their loved ones wishes, it's understandable as grief affects us all differently. Typically we see more females consenting for their loved ones to be donors than males consenting. I genuinely think it's because we tend to be a bit more pragmatic.

I opted out... if my next of kin say they still want my organs donated, will that happen regardless of my wishes?
poolsidefashion · 17/09/2021 23:57

[quote XenoBitch]@poolsidefashion

What is your big problem with some people opting out of organ donation? I said I am, and that I wont be accepting organs either. So what is the issue?[/quote]
as mentioned in my first post, my problem is that people could die because you’d rather your organs rot. children, mothers, friends, sons, teachers, nurses; who knows who’ll be unlucky enough to need an organ but there isn’t one available. hope that’s clear enough