Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation

206 replies

Mumguilt12 · 17/09/2021 23:19

After a recent death in the family, Me and DH were chatting about our death and funeral plans etc. Cheery huh!

Anyway, I said the songs I wanted played at my funeral. And I am absolutely clear that if my organs can be donated, they should be. All of them.
If not, I’d like to donate my body to science. I’d like to be cremated.

He thinks organ donation is not nice. “I dont want them to cut me up etc” I am absolutely shocked by his negative feelings towards it.

I said if our kid needed a new heart, would he accept it and he said he would. Now I believe if you are willing to take, you should be willing to give.

He is certain that he finds it all a bit wrong and it’s not nice for the family left behind. I also said that I completely disagreed and I personally would find comfort in knowing my relative had saved a life.

I know it’s silly but a) if I go, I don’t trust him to follow my wishes b) I’m judging him. How can you not want to help a sick person?! I don’t get it.

He comes from a religious family although himself is not really into it (other than a general belief in god). Not sure if that’s part of his thoughts.

It’s really made me look at him in a different light. AIBU?

It’s times like these that I think we are really not compatible. I really value kindness and thinking of others and he… really doesn’t.

OP posts:
ZoeCM · 19/09/2021 10:27

@LateDecemberBackInLowB12, you don't sound selfish at all.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 19/09/2021 10:19

However organ donation kinda seems like a no brainer to me. After all, you don’t even know you’ve done it… because you are already dead. And you might just help a person in need, and their family. And your family might get comfort too.

I'll be honest here.

I have had 2 of my dc die. I was able to donate my sons organs, I wasn't able to donate my daughters.

To me, after their deaths I felt the same. When they got cremated I didn't feel 'better' about his death than hers.

People kind of expect you to be happy that people are out there and alive because of my sons heart or lungs. I know I'm supposed to find it comforting. I don't at all, given the choice, again, I know it sounds selfish, I would have my little boy back every single time.

I watch videos of men walking women down the aisle when he has her fathers heart, or teddy bears with recordings of someone's child's heartbeat after donation, and I couldn't think of anything worse than to meet the people who my sons organs were donated to. I have a vague description of who got what, and one person, some years later, did want to contact me but I declined.

Don't get me wrong, if I had to choose to donate organs again, I probably would. But its wrong to think that it's particularly comforting to all families afterwards. The process itself was pretty traumatic for me also. The team were lovely, and they fulfilled my daft requests, but it was hard going.

My kids know that I would donate my organs, however I have left the choice up to them entirely, because they are the ones who will have to live with the choice and the process afterwards.

ZoeCM · 19/09/2021 10:18

@Xenobitch, @XDownwiththissortofthingX and @Nat6999: are you honestly saying that if you got told your only chance of survival was an organ transplant, you'd tell your families that you're turning it down? If you have children, would you really tell them that you're choosing to leave them without a mother? If it were a member of my family I'd beg them to take the organ; I think most people would.

I've never known anyone who died (or whose loved one died) because they turned down an organ transplant on principle, yet just about every time this discussion comes up, several people insist they'd do just that. Are there any statistics on how common it is?

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 09:59

Not wanting to donate your own doesn not mean peroan is against organ donation. Just against their own organ donation.
I cannot imagine anyone arguing against organ donation in general.

we will agree to disagree in this case.
Yeah, that's the way forward.

We don't need to understand why someone is uncomfortable with it. As long as they are not telling others not to do it, but keep it to their own body.

Mumguilt12 · 19/09/2021 09:54

I didn’t expect mumsnet to be split quite so much. There seems to be people that are very pro organ donation usually because they have direct experience.

And people that are “my body, my rules. How dare you suggest otherwise”

Of course if it came to it I would not go against my husbands wishes. But a little bit of me does raise an eyebrow at people willing to accept a donation but not willing to even consider donating themselves with no logical reason as to why. People get very defensive.

And I’m entitled to my opinion, just as others are entitled to theirs. It’s not a major deal and ive Realised that DH is kind in other ways and we will agree to disagree in this case.

However organ donation kinda seems like a no brainer to me. After all, you don’t even know you’ve done it… because you are already dead. And you might just help a person in need, and their family. And your family might get comfort too.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 19/09/2021 09:42

@Mumguilt12

People wouldnt help push a car when they see a man struggling? It was literally right in front of us and blocking a side road completely.

He didn’t have strength to push it up hill. When my DH helped the man was so extremely grateful.

It was in daylight in the middle of town if that makes a difference.

Cars break down, you call breakdown services you don’t need to push it home uphill. In the middle of most towns you wouldn’t be able to stop without causing further obstruction yourself.

Regarding organ donation, he has a different view to you, he is entitled to that. I find your sanctimonious attitude far more off putting than his view. He should respect your views if that day should come of course but there is no reason to believe he would not. If he had said he won’t respect your wishes, then you would have something to complain about, but he hasn’t, he has just expressed his own.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 09:39

@Mumguilt12 it doesn't matter. It's not unkind not to atop. Ghere are millions of reasons not to stop no matter what situation and most don't make person unkind.
Howwver, it is bit different since you knew the woman and the man personally. I would stop for someone I know

hangrylady · 19/09/2021 09:38

@Makinglists

We lost Ds1 earlier this year and he became a donor and 5 people are alive because of him. Totally respect his feelings but for the grieving left behind it gives us hope that he lives on.
I'm so very sorry for your loss. You have done a wonderful thing. My Dad is currently on the kidney transplant list and it's because of people like you that he has a chance to survive, Thank you Flowers
Crayfishforyou · 19/09/2021 09:35

@Notimeforaname

Well when you die and if you're embalmed, they obliterate your organs with a trocar anyway. So bit of a waste to not give them ...on the off chance they are suitable of course
I never thought about it like this before, but it is so true!

I’m a believer in donating, I won’t need anything after I die.

Mumguilt12 · 19/09/2021 09:31

And the man having a fit, he had known epilepsy. The woman was his mother and she needed help moving him as she wasn’t strong enough to get him out the car. He was half in and out the door in quite a dangerous position. She had already called an ambulance but needed strength to help move a fully grown adult to a safer position. Shortly after a bloke stopped and she helped move him. I’m quite short and not strong and I’m not sure I would have been as helpful as the man that stopped.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 09:28

No, I wouldn’t stop. I might for a lone woman.

Mumguilt12 · 19/09/2021 09:26

People wouldnt help push a car when they see a man struggling? It was literally right in front of us and blocking a side road completely.

He didn’t have strength to push it up hill. When my DH helped the man was so extremely grateful.

It was in daylight in the middle of town if that makes a difference.

OP posts:
Mumguilt12 · 19/09/2021 09:22

Yeah I do tend to let emotions get better of me and he is much calmer and measured in his approach to things.

Going back to organ donation, I think if anything happened to me, my other family members and friends would help him make the decision anyway. They know what I would like too.

I posted on mumsnet because the initial “no way” from him shocked me a bit. I know it’s a theoretical question that probably won’t come true anyway.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 09:21

Sorry that last sentence was a mess.

You’ve got quite a low bar for what counts as unkindness. I would say pretty much nobody would be kind according to you.

PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 09:20

By “kindness”, I can give a few more examples. So once we were driving past a car that had pulled over. There was a lady standing over a man that was having a fit partially hanging out the passenger seat. We both saw it. Only I demanded we stopped so I could help. I’m pretty sure he would have just driven on.

Do you or your Dh have particular training in this area?

I recently made him go and help someone’s car that had broken down in front of us. It involved pushing it up a slope. I don’t think he would have done unless I suggested.

Neither would most people.

You’ve got low a high bar for what counts as unkindness.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 09:13

He isn't unkind. Just logical. Lady 99% called an ambulance already (also just to add from info gathered on MN, if he was by himself, he should totally not go anywhere near a woman because the could scare her more, you know as a man🤷🏻), i wouldn't stop to push someone's car unless they were obvious danger to them or others...
I did opt in before automatic opt in for organ donation tho.

It's called being human. We are not perfect and no, we don't all need to keep doing "kidness" to strangers to be considered acceptable.

LoislovesStewie · 19/09/2021 09:10

My family know that I want any bits of me to be used after my death for the good of another person. My DH and kids all feel the same way. My mother died of kidney failure and if I can stop another child having to go through what I went through (having my mother die when I was a child) then I am all for donation. My organs are no good to me after death, so I don't get what the issue is.

Mumguilt12 · 19/09/2021 09:08

We have spoken about it a bit more and I do respect his decision. I really hope he respects mine too.

By “kindness”, I can give a few more examples. So once we were driving past a car that had pulled over. There was a lady standing over a man that was having a fit partially hanging out the passenger seat. We both saw it. Only I demanded we stopped so I could help. I’m pretty sure he would have just driven on. I recently made him go and help someone’s car that had broken down in front of us. It involved pushing it up a slope. I don’t think he would have done unless I suggested.

However, he is kind in other ways. He’s extremely kind to friends and is a long-standing volunteer at a charity.

I guess I’m just a bit more willing to assist a complete stranger!

OP posts:
Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 08:57

Yes, that’s true but that’s not the position the op is in.
She is, just as that "kind" one.

Yy to the rest

PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 08:53

The second part of your post goes the other way around as well. Seeing as some people are so "kind" in here, if I was the spouse who did not want to donate, I would be pretty worried the kindness doesn't apply to my body and decisions...

Yes, that’s true but that’s not the position the op is in.

Kindness comes in a lot of forms anyway. It’s probably not kind to your grieving spouse to try to force them to endure your organs being donated (or not) if they’re not ok with that. Because of the nature of the organ donation process, you can make your wishes known but ultimately you still have to trust they’ll be on board with what you wanted.

I don’t have a strong opinion. I’d like to donate my organs but realistically, for that to happen it’s likely to be in pretty devastating, shocking circumstances for my family and I wouldn’t judge anyone who couldn't consent. I’d be dead so it’s not as if it would really still matter to me.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 19/09/2021 08:50

I'm confused. The law has changed recently hasn't it?? I though everyone was now opted in to donating any body tissue on their death unless specifically opting out.

Once your dead your dead. You don't need those tissues anymore why Condemn someone else to more misery because of a misplaced belief in a book that's never been proven to be true.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 19/09/2021 08:41

Organ donation is one of those things where the stance a person takes can have nothing to do with kindness, logic, normal moral code etc etc, for some it is but for some it's more of a visceral inexplicable thing in terms of whether they would want it or not.
I am very ambivalent about it. I'm not sure where it comes from. I think about it from time to time, like when this thread ops up and never get past that I am not sure if I would ever take or give an organ. I have eventually settled on 'I won't know until I'm in that situation' and left it at that. After much soul searching. I am usually very phiulanthropic and logical. I have no idea why this issue is so out of character.

So, I personally think you need to not see his pov as symptomatic of some kind of character flaw, file it under human anomoly and move on.

The only sentence you said that I thought was worth digging into and asking yourself questions about was your last one - the he's kind and I'm not and I value kindness (gist).

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 08:39

@PurpleDaisies

I’m not sure people have understood that you still don’t get the final say either by opting in or opting out. It’s still your next of kin’s choice and that won’t be overridden.

If your spouse is against organ donation, you’ve got more to worry about regarding whether they would allow your organs to be donated in the event that you died first.

You don't need to be against organ donation not to want to donate yours. You can just simply not want to do that with your body.

There should be respect on both sides and next of kins should respect the dead's wishes whichever way they were.

The second part of your post goes the other way around as well. Zeeing as some people are so "kind" in here, if I was the spouse who did not want to donate, I would be pretty worrid the kidness doesn't apply to my bpdy and decisions...

Tbh, if next of kin can just override it, what's the point of asking people anyway.

Whitefire · 19/09/2021 08:35

As more medical advances have been made, so has people's sense of entitlement. However this is now not just over specific treatments, but also feeling entitled over other people's bodies. No one has a right over others in this situation.

PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 08:32

I’m not sure people have understood that you still don’t get the final say either by opting in or opting out. It’s still your next of kin’s choice and that won’t be overridden.

If your spouse is against organ donation, you’ve got more to worry about regarding whether they would allow your organs to be donated in the event that you died first.