Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation

206 replies

Mumguilt12 · 17/09/2021 23:19

After a recent death in the family, Me and DH were chatting about our death and funeral plans etc. Cheery huh!

Anyway, I said the songs I wanted played at my funeral. And I am absolutely clear that if my organs can be donated, they should be. All of them.
If not, I’d like to donate my body to science. I’d like to be cremated.

He thinks organ donation is not nice. “I dont want them to cut me up etc” I am absolutely shocked by his negative feelings towards it.

I said if our kid needed a new heart, would he accept it and he said he would. Now I believe if you are willing to take, you should be willing to give.

He is certain that he finds it all a bit wrong and it’s not nice for the family left behind. I also said that I completely disagreed and I personally would find comfort in knowing my relative had saved a life.

I know it’s silly but a) if I go, I don’t trust him to follow my wishes b) I’m judging him. How can you not want to help a sick person?! I don’t get it.

He comes from a religious family although himself is not really into it (other than a general belief in god). Not sure if that’s part of his thoughts.

It’s really made me look at him in a different light. AIBU?

It’s times like these that I think we are really not compatible. I really value kindness and thinking of others and he… really doesn’t.

OP posts:
AlCalavicci · 19/09/2021 14:09

I haven't rtft yet but @Floralnomad here is the donation page , and yes you can opt to donate certain parts or everything
www.organdonation.nhs.uk/register-your-decision/donate/?

I regesterd to donate a couple of years ago , it was than and still is the right thing for me to do . I will be honest I dont see why anyone would not donate but it is their choice and nobody should disrespect that.

Nat6999 · 19/09/2021 14:08

ZoeCM That isn't the reason I would refuse a donated organ, my cousin & friend both had transplants, my cousin had a kidney & liver & spent the rest of his life being terrified of infections due to the anti rejection drugs, a common cold would put him in hospital, thankfully he passed away before Covid was ever heard of. My friend had a kidney transplant 5 years after suffering renal failure, the kidney lasted 6 months before it failed & made her so sick she begged to have it removed. Getting a transplant isn't the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, it's another set of constant hospital appointments, drugs to be taken & things to be avoided.

LittleEsme · 19/09/2021 13:42

I'm pro-donation and in the instance where that doesn't arise, I'm also considering donating my body to medical science. My own daughter benefited in Med school from this and the person they worked on was treated with ultimate respect and care. My daughter found it a really humbling experience.

That said, my family are not convinced that they could go through with making that decision, and I also respect that.

Living and loving is hard. Adding the judgement and criticism of others into the mix makes it so much harder.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 19/09/2021 13:31

It’s a very emotive subject though and I feel you have to respect other family members opinions

I’m pro donation, I’ve been involved professionally in organ retrieval and seen the emotional pressure that some of the medics involved suffer with when calling in recipients

I will in the next decade need a double corneal transplant myself, however I have high functioning autistic DC

DD in particular feels very distraught at the idea of me donating my body parts, she has quite complex mental health conditions including PTSD and I don’t feel that I can add to her trauma by donating when she will already have grief to process and so have reluctantly agreed I won’t be a donor

However I don’t feel that I can accept new corneas if I am unwilling to hypothetically donate to others, it is a situation that I ponder on regularly but my child’s mental health comes first

LittleEsme · 19/09/2021 13:31

@EmmaJR1

My dad had a kidney transplant at 18, a 2nd kidney transplant at 24 and a heart transplant at 40. He was told the heart would last 6 years. He died 5 weeks ago at 64.

In my opinion, people who are squeamish about organ donation are just self involved. Your family do not see your empty carcass. You're sewn up and dressed nicely before you are burned or buried.

Obvious I'm a bit sensitive about it but I LITERALLY wouldn't be here if everyone felt the same as your OH and my dad wouldn't not have had those 4 very fulfilling decades either.
I think his view is very selfish.

As sensitive as a fucking mallet.

Honest to God, how can you not read these people's
experiences with a shred of empathy for others. Your experience and emotions that go along with that trauma are unique to YOU.

How can you, or anyone else on this thread, stand in judgement of other's trauma, is utterly beyond me.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 19/09/2021 13:23

In my opinion, people who are squeamish about organ donation are just self involved. Your family do not see your empty carcass

My son was NOT an empty carcass. He was still my son.

Since when do we dehumanise our loved ones who have died?

It isn't self involved at all. I have left the choice to my children. The circumstances in which someone has to die to be able to donate their organs are usually shocking for the families, you can't blame someone for seeing their living, breathing loved one (albeit attached to machines that are keeping them alive) laid there and not accepting that they are dead.

I think the people who use words like 'carcass' are making people squeamish around the subject actually.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, organ donation is selfless and its a gift, but its not selfish to make the choice not to, in the way that it's not selfish to leave everything in your will to your loved ones rather than to charity, your loved ones are the ones who have to carry on and live with their choices, and donation isn't an easy decision.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 13:21

I wiuld also like to add that that was said because people keep using "against organ donation" rather than "don't want to donate"

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 13:19

@RedToothBrushi have later corrected it into most
This was the whole bit
^Not wanting to donate your own doesn not mean peroan is against organ donation. Just against their own organ donation.
I cannot imagine anyone arguing against organ donation in general.^
I am actually on the side of people having a choice

ftw163532 · 19/09/2021 13:16

I've talked to people who are so traumatised by receiving an organ and knowing someone else died to keep them alive that they are not able to live.

It is not as simplistic or black and white as the posters with no actual experience of this being real are making out.

People can and do decline transplant surgery, just as people can and do decline other life saving interventions such as chemotherapy, CPR, transfusion, other surgeries, etc.

EmmaJR1 · 19/09/2021 13:14

My dad had a kidney transplant at 18, a 2nd kidney transplant at 24 and a heart transplant at 40. He was told the heart would last 6 years. He died 5 weeks ago at 64.

In my opinion, people who are squeamish about organ donation are just self involved. Your family do not see your empty carcass. You're sewn up and dressed nicely before you are burned or buried.

Obvious I'm a bit sensitive about it but I LITERALLY wouldn't be here if everyone felt the same as your OH and my dad wouldn't not have had those 4 very fulfilling decades either.
I think his view is very selfish.

RedToothBrush · 19/09/2021 13:12

@Whitefire

I cannot imagine anyone arguing against organ donation in general.

Of course people do, to think that the concept of organ donation does not raise moral and religious issues for people is incredibly naive.

I think people who can't imagine someone having different views because they are so confident their view is right are arrogant, narrow minded and rather insular.

They should speak to more people from different backgrounds. And consider why saying those views might simply be taboo, and people may be unwilling to be honest in their view - precisely because they will get jumped on by those with the 'morally superior' view. As demostrated in this thread by several posters.

ftw163532 · 19/09/2021 13:07

Why would I possibly want to receive an organ from someone who was coerced or forced? That's morally the same as taking organs from prisoners or people murdered to order. It is barbaric to advocate for such a thing.

However organ donation kinda seems like a no brainer to me. After all, you don’t even know you’ve done it… because you are already dead. And you might just help a person in need, and their family. And your family might get comfort too.

By that logic, once someone is dead why do we care about respecting their body? Why do we care when someone is dismembered or subjected to vile acts after death? Why do families care when their loved one's remains cannot be located or retrieved or identified?

By your logic, all of that is inconsequential because they're dead so no longer afforded humanity.

Of course it matters. Your lack of empathy is disturbing from someone claiming to be so very concerned about kindness.

ThinWomansBrain · 19/09/2021 13:02

I can understand you being surprised if it's the first time that the topic has come up and you'd just assume that he'd have a rational thought process and have similar opinions to yours.
Given that you don't, but it's only just arisen - it doesn't seem the most obvious 'how can we possibly stay together, totally incompatible" thing.
Why not just accept that you have differing opinions, and respect each others wishes - and agree that you will do so when one of you dies - without that, he could over ride your wishes if you die first.

And think about the age you should talk to your child about this - early / mid-teens? they equally have the right to male their own decision.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 12:51

I think people have to look at it realistically. There are about 6k people waiting for transplant.
500-600k people die a year. About 3.5k transplants happen a year. I think it's close to 30 million people on the register.
So about half. Going with that and adding some conservativness to it, out of that 500k people who die annually, 150k+ are most likely ropelted in.

Not being registered donor is not as bad as some are making out. Chance of the organs being usable is miniscule as is a chance of needed a transplant.

Balonzette · 19/09/2021 12:50

I don't want to be a donor. It's weird that this is one of those things that you need to justify to people.

Vickim03 · 19/09/2021 12:37

My sister donated her organs. It gives me comfort she’s helped save others. You have to die on life support to be able to donate so it’s a slim chance anyway.

ZoeCM · 19/09/2021 12:16

A) there doesn't need to be a logical reason and B) people get defensive because of the "rais[ing] an eyebrow" attitude from others.

If someone would accept an organ but wouldn't donate one, there isn't really any way around it: that person is a hypocrite. I've tried to think of a way to sugar-coat that, but I can't.

blubberyboo · 19/09/2021 11:46

I think something that is never vocalised in these sorts of debates ( apart from covid vaccinations of course) is that many people have a fear of government and those in positions of power and in this case of medical professionals.

We all put our trust in them at that point of sickness and death when it comes down to it there is the fear that when faced with a life to save or to let the life go in order to use organs for half a dozen other people ( for financial reasons or to meet targets) the medical person might choose the latter.
Or in a world where money matters organs could become lucrative items.

It’s horrible to say but honestly I think that’s where a lot of reluctance comes from. Mistrust of those in power and fear of organ harvesting.

Having a system of opt in means that at that life or death moment the surgeon or whoever has no idea as to whether they can use those organs for another and therefore must only focus on the life in front of them.

I’m not saying it’s right or a well founded fear but I think that’s where it comes from and just isn’t articulated well

MagnoliaXYZ · 19/09/2021 11:35

In all likelihood, I would accept an organ if I needed one. I would be reluctant to accept a blood transfusion unless it was essential (eg could I have IV iron instead, could surgery be deferred to allow it time to work and my Hb to improve? What would happen if I said no (a family member had a transfusion during chemo because the Hb needed to be 100, their Hb was 99)? Would a transfusion reduce risk or merely improve symptoms?).

I'm not keen on the idea of donating, though. I know my family would find it traumatic knowing that my organs (and I know they would be useless to me at that point) were being removed. I haven't opted out. I don't like the idea of opt-out and I actually believe that there needs to be a legal challenge to this as there is no other medical procedure where opt-out is acceptable. I might be a little more inclined to donate if I could set some conditions to it (for instance, I looked after a patient who was on the transplant list for a kidney. The patient had received a kidney from a relative but hadn't taken the anti-rejection medication so the transplant failed. I wouldn't want someone like that to receive my organs or those of my family if I was the one being asked). It's nothing to do with religion or being squeamish, but concern over the trauma my family would go through and my family, whom I know and love, take priority over the needs of someone I have never met.

I'm not an unkind person, though. I have donated many, many units of blood, have spent countless hours over many years volunteering for a charity and I have worked many unpaid hours of overtime in the NHS.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 11:17

This goes back to my point above about people getting defensive, organ donation should be because that is what the person wishes to happen and their survivors are accepting of it too, not because of what is little more than bullying and belittling like has been shown on this thread.

Amen to that

Whitefire · 19/09/2021 11:16

Once you're dead you're dead. You don't need those tissues anymore why condemn someone else to more misery because of a misplaced belief in a book that's never been proven to be true.

It is not my responsibility or that of my family to ensure someone else's happiness after my death. It is neither for you to declare that this is, in your words, due to misplaced belief.

This goes back to my point above about people getting defensive, organ donation should be because that is what the person wishes to happen and their survivors are accepting of it too, not because of what is little more than bullying and belittling like has been shown on this thread.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 19/09/2021 11:15

@Whitefire

I cannot imagine anyone arguing against organ donation in general.

Of course people do, to think that the concept of organ donation does not raise moral and religious issues for people is incredibly naive.

Yes, but that is usually for their own organs, not "no one should be giving organs". Ok I generalised there in true mn fashion. Let me rephrase. I cannot imagine many people arguing against organ donation in general.
Whitefire · 19/09/2021 11:07

I cannot imagine anyone arguing against organ donation in general.

Of course people do, to think that the concept of organ donation does not raise moral and religious issues for people is incredibly naive.

Whitefire · 19/09/2021 11:04

But a little bit of me does raise an eyebrow at people willing to accept a donation but not willing to even consider donating themselves with no logical reason as to why. People get very defensive.

A) there doesn't need to be a logical reason and B) people get defensive because of the "rais[ing] an eyebrow" attitude from others.

LittleEsme · 19/09/2021 10:55

@LateDecemberBackInLowB12
Thanks

What youve written makes perfect sense.. To be honest, and I say this as gently as I possibly can to anyone reading, you'd have to be utterly fucking heartless (or hard of thinking) to respond to Late's post with a "yes, but..."

Thanks