Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation

206 replies

Mumguilt12 · 17/09/2021 23:19

After a recent death in the family, Me and DH were chatting about our death and funeral plans etc. Cheery huh!

Anyway, I said the songs I wanted played at my funeral. And I am absolutely clear that if my organs can be donated, they should be. All of them.
If not, I’d like to donate my body to science. I’d like to be cremated.

He thinks organ donation is not nice. “I dont want them to cut me up etc” I am absolutely shocked by his negative feelings towards it.

I said if our kid needed a new heart, would he accept it and he said he would. Now I believe if you are willing to take, you should be willing to give.

He is certain that he finds it all a bit wrong and it’s not nice for the family left behind. I also said that I completely disagreed and I personally would find comfort in knowing my relative had saved a life.

I know it’s silly but a) if I go, I don’t trust him to follow my wishes b) I’m judging him. How can you not want to help a sick person?! I don’t get it.

He comes from a religious family although himself is not really into it (other than a general belief in god). Not sure if that’s part of his thoughts.

It’s really made me look at him in a different light. AIBU?

It’s times like these that I think we are really not compatible. I really value kindness and thinking of others and he… really doesn’t.

OP posts:
hangrylady · 21/09/2021 17:48

@Lockheart

I think that if you opt out of organ donation then you should also have to opt out of receiving an organ. Seems fair enough to me.

How often must this facile and childish opinion be trotted out before people realise that's not how our NHS works and how dangerous it is?

So some crackpot like the PP thinks it's Ok to take an organ but wouldn't donate one and that's OK with you is it? I get that it's probably not possible but it's what I'd like to see, with obvious exceptions for those who are unable to donate for actual reasons not some afterlife bollocks. Get off your high horse.
Lockheart · 21/09/2021 17:42

I think that if you opt out of organ donation then you should also have to opt out of receiving an organ. Seems fair enough to me.

How often must this facile and childish opinion be trotted out before people realise that's not how our NHS works and how dangerous it is?

hangrylady · 21/09/2021 17:39

@HarrietsChariot

No way would I want my organs harvested when I die. We don't know what happens after death or whether being hacked to pieces will harm us in the afterlife. There's a substantial school of unsubstiated thought that shows that cremation is bad enough, because it destroys the body too quickly and violently.

Obviously I'll happily accept a donor organ if I ever need one. It's not a contradictory thought process, the idea that I'll accept one but not give one, no more than saying I'll accept medical advice from a doctor but don't give out medical advice myself.

I think that if you opt out of organ donation then you should also have to opt out of receiving an organ. Seems fair enough to me.
abcdeg · 21/09/2021 12:20

@HarrietsChariot

No way would I want my organs harvested when I die. We don't know what happens after death or whether being hacked to pieces will harm us in the afterlife. There's a substantial school of unsubstiated thought that shows that cremation is bad enough, because it destroys the body too quickly and violently.

Obviously I'll happily accept a donor organ if I ever need one. It's not a contradictory thought process, the idea that I'll accept one but not give one, no more than saying I'll accept medical advice from a doctor but don't give out medical advice myself.

Fair enough but your a analogy is terrible. It's more like accepting free clothes when your completely down and out, but not wanting to donate your own old clothes.

Because you're not qualified to give out medical advice, but anyone is capable of donating an organ.

HoppingPavlova · 21/09/2021 11:19

Should have added, I’m more than happy to be cremated. Personally, I would just want it to be after 3 days post death. What others believe or think is equally as valid though obviously.

HoppingPavlova · 21/09/2021 11:16

We don't know what happens after death or whether being hacked to pieces will harm us in the afterlife.

When organs are harvested the donor is treated with the utmost care and respect, they are not ‘hacked to pieces’. Probably even more so than the average surgery as everyone in the room appreciates the enormity of the decisions behind this and has the utmost respect.

I do and don’t disagree with your other point regarding cremation. Personally I believe the spirit (or whatever it is) ‘hangs around’ for roughly three days. It’s so hard to explain, but after a few days bodies change and I’m not talking about the natural decomposition process, it’s something else. It takes a while for the essence/spirit (whatever) to leave then the body is definitely a shell. Personally, I don’t believe that missing organs makes any difference at all to that mysterious element I struggle to describe. The afterlife though, if it exists, I have no idea. I think on the basis that if there is a good place/bad place and if you are not in ‘the good place’ because you gave your organs to enable someone’s life to continue then the decision maker must be quite a cunt and maybe ‘the bad place’ may be the better fit?

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 21/09/2021 09:05

@HarrietsChariot

No way would I want my organs harvested when I die. We don't know what happens after death or whether being hacked to pieces will harm us in the afterlife. There's a substantial school of unsubstiated thought that shows that cremation is bad enough, because it destroys the body too quickly and violently.

Obviously I'll happily accept a donor organ if I ever need one. It's not a contradictory thought process, the idea that I'll accept one but not give one, no more than saying I'll accept medical advice from a doctor but don't give out medical advice myself.

"Hacked to pieces"

"Quickly and violently"

Are you for real? Have you read the whole thread, people sharing their stories of donating their loved ones organs, and also cremation?

Have an opinion, by all means, but if you think that language is OK on such a sensitive subject you have more to worry about in the 'afterlife' than organ donation 😡

HarrietsChariot · 21/09/2021 08:48

No way would I want my organs harvested when I die. We don't know what happens after death or whether being hacked to pieces will harm us in the afterlife. There's a substantial school of unsubstiated thought that shows that cremation is bad enough, because it destroys the body too quickly and violently.

Obviously I'll happily accept a donor organ if I ever need one. It's not a contradictory thought process, the idea that I'll accept one but not give one, no more than saying I'll accept medical advice from a doctor but don't give out medical advice myself.

Gladioli23 · 21/09/2021 08:32

I find organ donation a very difficult subject. The thought of donating my organs or those of a relative makes me want to be sick. I find it horrifying and the fact that it helps other people doesn't change the visceral feeling I have about it.

But I also recognise that neither I nor any relative can use their body after death. My feelings are emotional, not logical, and I know after I die I won't know what's happening. For this reason I have opted in - to donate every organ. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't make me feel ill to think about. I totally understand why people would opt out and I cannot judge anyone who does. I think not being able to override your feelings that one's body parts should stay their own doesn't make anyone a bad person - there are whole horror stories written about people built from others body parts, so it's clearly not an unusual thing for it to make people feel queasy.

It's fantastic that donated organs can save lives. I'm pleased for anyone who can support the programme and feel unconflicted about it. I'm delighted for anyone who benefits from it. But let's not denigrate those who don't feel they can, and minimise the gift that others have made by doing so.

Robgem81 · 21/09/2021 08:03

@RedToothBrush you are still free to make the choice to not be an organ donor. Go on line and opt out. It's easy and takes 30 seconds. Otherwise tell your family you don't ever want to be an organ donor.

Robgem81 · 21/09/2021 08:01

@CourgetteGlutTony you are not being dictated to by the government. The law changed because there are not enough organs for the people that need them and this gives people the opportunity to discuss their wishes with their families. It is a very rare and unique position to be in if you are considered a potential organ donor. As a specialist nurse in this area all families are given organ donation as an end of life choice and their wishes are respected regardless of what the person has opted to do. At the end of the day if somebody has registered to become an organ donor or has not opted out all we want to achieve is the end of life wish that person wanted. It is not a given that you will have your organs taken if you have not opted out. It's a gift like no other and saves and changes lives. But if it's not something you wish to do that is also ok. It's respected. It's nothing to do with the government.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 20/09/2021 11:42

I'm not callous. I just don't believe everything we love about a person stays in the body. I'm sorry if my expression was insensitive to your experience.

Your 'expression' was disgusting.

Why do you think that your feelings and beliefs are more important than others feelings and beliefs?

That's all I'm getting from your posts.

No wonder people don't want to when someone who's whole existence is down to organ donation sees the bodies of peoples children as mere spare parts for others.

The dehumanising is a real problem, and your attitude is doing more harm than good imo.

Even though my son was technically dead, when they took him to the theatre they still played music that I asked for, and they allowed a person on the team to hold his little hand and talk to my boy because they understood that my needs were also important in that situation. For me that extended as far as some, probably silly, requests, for others they may need to be there for their child's last breath. Its us that have to live with the aftermath forever.

I am pro donation, but I am also pro putting the family of the person who just lost their life first in this situation.

blubberyboo · 20/09/2021 11:04

I am so so grateful for the heart and 2 kidneys my dad received. I get extremely emotional discussing it with people

And therefore to be grateful for that gift you can be a donor yourself. Not expect everyone else to pay your fathers gift forward. It stops being a gift if forced or coerced.
And there’s nothing wrong with OPs husband being selfish. He owns his organs and he can do what he likes with them

MordredsOrrery · 19/09/2021 18:52

The op stated her husband said he would take a transplant but didn't believe in his organs being donated. So I think he's selfish.

She said he'd accept on behalf of their son, not himself. When their son is an adult it'll be for him to decide about accepting or giving organs.

As it is her DP is not being selfish as, presumably, OP would also want their son to receive a donor organ if needed. In this case her DP is being the 'selfless' one for hypothetically consenting on behalf of another that which he does not wish for himself.

Heyheyitsanotherday · 19/09/2021 18:21

For those upset by the opt out law that came into place in England last year, please watch the driving force behind it “ max and Keira’s law”. He was one little boy petitioning for it. To be a donor you have to die in a specific way (In an icu either having treatment withdrawn, or be pronounced dead by neorological criteria in an icu ). And families are always the one to make the decisions if you donate or not (providing you are medically suitable). They are involved in complex conversations and donation only goes a head with their consent (they can over ride your wishes either way). So talking about what you want with your loved ones is super important.

Tyrantosaurus · 19/09/2021 18:17

@LateDecemberBackInLowB12

I absolutely do see it as a gift, the most generous gift that anyone could ever receive, I just think people like ops husband who like to take without giving see arseholes.

And his excuses are empty and selfish especially if op thinks he might not follow her wishes.

He hasn't taken without giving.

It certainly doesn't sound like you see it as a gift either after referring to people who donate organs, like my son, or the people who died and helped your dad live as empty carcasses. I'm actually horrified that someone who was effected by such a gift could be so callous.

I don't think you need to be piled on @EmmaJR1 because it's understandable why you feel so strongly about this, but your initial post was quite harshly worded. In regards to carcasses and saying burned rather than cremated.

It's very emotive, but there's no point getting worked up about whether people opt in or out. Chances are, their organs wouldn't be able to be transplanted even if they were on the register. Thousands of organs are wasted everyday regardless of donor status.

The best you can do is be grateful for your dad's donors, be a donor yourself and hope that the kindness of those donating organs inspires others to do the same

EmmaJR1 · 19/09/2021 18:03

@LateDecemberBackInLowB12

I'm not callous. I just don't believe everything we love about a person stays in the body. I'm sorry if my expression was insensitive to your experience.

The op stated her husband said he would take a transplant but didn't believe in his organs being donated. So I think he's selfish.

I am so so grateful for the heart and 2 kidneys my dad received. I get extremely emotional discussing it with people.

Especially if there is someone who flat out refuses to consider it to the extent their partner worries their last wishes won't be followed.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 19/09/2021 17:32

I absolutely do see it as a gift, the most generous gift that anyone could ever receive, I just think people like ops husband who like to take without giving see arseholes.

And his excuses are empty and selfish especially if op thinks he might not follow her wishes.

He hasn't taken without giving.

It certainly doesn't sound like you see it as a gift either after referring to people who donate organs, like my son, or the people who died and helped your dad live as empty carcasses. I'm actually horrified that someone who was effected by such a gift could be so callous.

PurpleDaisies · 19/09/2021 17:11

I'm on the register so the opt out system doesn't affect me (but I am not that keen on it - I don't think consent should be assumed).

Sorry, I might be being slow-which register fo you mean?

XenoBitch · 19/09/2021 17:08

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

I'm on the register so the opt out system doesn't affect me (but I am not that keen on it - I don't think consent should be assumed).

However, I do think that if you opt in that should be that, and family should not be able to override it (and ditto if you opt out). My body, my choice, nobody else's.

If someone has opted out, then it would be awful of their family to overridde that, and consent to donation. But then I do understand why the medical team will let the family override patients wishes to donate. They wont have the chance to sit with their loved one as they pass when life support is withdrawn. They wont be there for their final breath and heart beat. They are living a nightmare at that time, and it is very difficult to think straight. All the more reason it is important to discuss these things before it is too late.
lockdownmadnessdotcom · 19/09/2021 16:51

I'm on the register so the opt out system doesn't affect me (but I am not that keen on it - I don't think consent should be assumed).

However, I do think that if you opt in that should be that, and family should not be able to override it (and ditto if you opt out). My body, my choice, nobody else's.

EmmaJR1 · 19/09/2021 16:33

[quote blubberyboo]@EmmaJR1

I would say that the only person being self involved is you.
You can’t see beyond the fact that your father received a gift which led to your existence but somewhere along the line you have lost sight of the fact that it was a gift.
You don’t see the loss and sacrifice that someone else gave to make him that gift. Now you think it should be something that should be taken and that is shown in your offhand and insensitive remarks.
Many people cannot bear the thought that their loved ones body is damaged.[/quote]
I absolutely do see it as a gift, the most generous gift that anyone could ever receive, I just think people like ops husband who like to take without giving see arseholes.

And his excuses are empty and selfish especially if op thinks he might not follow her wishes.

yomommasmomma · 19/09/2021 14:26

@Babdoc

My DH died at 36. We donated his heart, kidneys and corneas. His heart saved a 21 year old who was dying of a congenital heart malformation. I still grieve DH thirty years later, but there is a small crumb of comfort that we followed his wishes and helped another family to avoid the pain that we suffered. I am a Christian, and don’t see any conflict of interest between religion and organ donation. Christ gave his whole body for our salvation- how can it be wrong for us to offer parts of ours?
Quoting so more people get to read this post, which is one of the most wonderful I have ever read on mn. Babcock you are amazing
blubberyboo · 19/09/2021 14:21

@EmmaJR1

I would say that the only person being self involved is you.
You can’t see beyond the fact that your father received a gift which led to your existence but somewhere along the line you have lost sight of the fact that it was a gift.
You don’t see the loss and sacrifice that someone else gave to make him that gift. Now you think it should be something that should be taken and that is shown in your offhand and insensitive remarks.
Many people cannot bear the thought that their loved ones body is damaged.

XenoBitch · 19/09/2021 14:16

[quote ZoeCM]**@Xenobitch, @XDownwiththissortofthingX and @Nat6999: are you honestly saying that if you got told your only chance of survival was an organ transplant, you'd tell your families that you're turning it down? If you have children, would you really tell them that you're choosing to leave them without a mother? If it were a member of my family I'd beg them to take the organ; I think most people would.

I've never known anyone who died (or whose loved one died) because they turned down an organ transplant on principle, yet just about every time this discussion comes up, several people insist they'd do just that. Are there any statistics on how common it is?[/quote]
Yes. It is still my choice to turn down any sort of medical procedure.