Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation

206 replies

Mumguilt12 · 17/09/2021 23:19

After a recent death in the family, Me and DH were chatting about our death and funeral plans etc. Cheery huh!

Anyway, I said the songs I wanted played at my funeral. And I am absolutely clear that if my organs can be donated, they should be. All of them.
If not, I’d like to donate my body to science. I’d like to be cremated.

He thinks organ donation is not nice. “I dont want them to cut me up etc” I am absolutely shocked by his negative feelings towards it.

I said if our kid needed a new heart, would he accept it and he said he would. Now I believe if you are willing to take, you should be willing to give.

He is certain that he finds it all a bit wrong and it’s not nice for the family left behind. I also said that I completely disagreed and I personally would find comfort in knowing my relative had saved a life.

I know it’s silly but a) if I go, I don’t trust him to follow my wishes b) I’m judging him. How can you not want to help a sick person?! I don’t get it.

He comes from a religious family although himself is not really into it (other than a general belief in god). Not sure if that’s part of his thoughts.

It’s really made me look at him in a different light. AIBU?

It’s times like these that I think we are really not compatible. I really value kindness and thinking of others and he… really doesn’t.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hubbystoo · 29/06/2022 16:16

How about forcible donation from someone who’s taken more than one life or terrorists, with no justification e.g. spur of the moment, jealousy, self defence etc.

RedToothBrush · 23/09/2021 08:23

@blubberyboo

The purpose of the opt out is that it makes it easier for families to consent to donation. Someone who hasn’t opted out or told their family they didn’t want to donate most likely didn’t feel strongly that they didn’t want to be a donor

Disagree with this logic. That’s what campaigners for opt out want to believe.

In reality all that would tell me as a family member is that by loved one could never bear thinking about it and would leave me still not knowing what they wanted.
Opt in is much more certain.
A better way would be to have much more common advertising campaigns to get people to opt in by text or email or at least open conversations.

I agree with you blubberyboo. It makes it harder for families to feel they can say no. Its a form of coercion rather than a free choice. Some people will feel they cannot be assertive or will be judged if they so no.

I have a general problem with any health care set up which forces you to feel you cannot say no or makes it more difficult to say no as it undermines the ethics of consent. That includes vaccines and screening.

I find it wholly unethical and wrong.

The assumption is that we are all donors until we object which comodifies our body parts and makes us a potential asset.

I do think it puts anyone who is vulnerable in a particularly difficult position especially if they have no one to advocate for them or they are under state care.

I think it a step too far. Even with all these reassurances.

With all the pressure to donate and the emotional manipulation of the subject I wonder what the next campaign will be. One to remove family consent? I do think it will happen in time regardless if what protests on this thread are because of the increase in demand for donations and the assumption that medical intervention should always be done even if its not necessarily in the interest of the patient.

I am firmly in the, just because you can do something doesn't mean you necessarily should, camp.

I don't object to organ donation on principle. I do object to a creep towards state ownership of the dead and a growing almost ghoulish feeling by some that they have the automatic moral right to other peoples organs and its 'selfish' not to give them up after death. That is a selfish notion in its own right which fails to recognise the emotional / spiritual side of death which is very real (and important to the mental health throughout life) to many.

notthemum · 23/09/2021 06:43

@LowDecemberBackInB12. (Hope I remembered your posting name properly)7
OMG. I have just read your post about the staff playing music and holding your little one's hand.
Please ignore the attitude of the disgusting poster who seems to believe that they were entitled to the amazing gift that her family received.
It must have taken every bit of every bit of strength you had for you to allow this. I know that I could not of let that happen if it was my child.

I am totally in awe of you. You are an incredible woman.
I am so sorry for your loss 💐

RedHelenB · 22/09/2021 14:24

@blubberyboo

The purpose of the opt out is that it makes it easier for families to consent to donation. Someone who hasn’t opted out or told their family they didn’t want to donate most likely didn’t feel strongly that they didn’t want to be a donor

Disagree with this logic. That’s what campaigners for opt out want to believe.

In reality all that would tell me as a family member is that by loved one could never bear thinking about it and would leave me still not knowing what they wanted.
Opt in is much more certain.
A better way would be to have much more common advertising campaigns to get people to opt in by text or email or at least open conversations.

I agree with this.
blubberyboo · 22/09/2021 11:39

The purpose of the opt out is that it makes it easier for families to consent to donation. Someone who hasn’t opted out or told their family they didn’t want to donate most likely didn’t feel strongly that they didn’t want to be a donor

Disagree with this logic. That’s what campaigners for opt out want to believe.

In reality all that would tell me as a family member is that by loved one could never bear thinking about it and would leave me still not knowing what they wanted.
Opt in is much more certain.
A better way would be to have much more common advertising campaigns to get people to opt in by text or email or at least open conversations.

PurpleDaisies · 22/09/2021 10:49

I have registered as an organ donor. I've had a donor card since I was about 18.

That still only tells your family that you were happy to be a donor. It isn’t legally binding. They still need to consent.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 22/09/2021 10:48

(so what I meant was, I've opted in, so am not affected by an assumed opt in)

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 22/09/2021 10:48

@PurpleDaisies

I'm on the register so the opt out system doesn't affect me (but I am not that keen on it - I don't think consent should be assumed).

Sorry, I might be being slow-which register fo you mean?

I have registered as an organ donor. I've had a donor card since I was about 18.
HoppingPavlova · 22/09/2021 10:34

Buttons294749 My spiritual beliefs are that my soul won't leave my body until my heart stops and I am cold. So if they invent a way to harvest after that then that's cool with me, unfortunately as it is I have had to opt out for religious/spirituality needs.

I’m in no way having a go, genuinely curious. I don’t understand what you are saying, could you expand further? Is it that your soul wont leave your body if your organs in general are gone before your heart stops, or are you specifically referring to donating your heart in that your soul could never leave your dead body if your beating heart resides in another body? If it’s organs in general, how does that fit with things that are often taken out during life such as appendix and tonsils? Again, in no way disagreeing with you, would really like to understand what’s behind your beliefs.

PurpleDaisies · 22/09/2021 10:22

The assumption now is that you are willing to be a donor unless you opt out or your family object.

The purpose of the opt out is that it makes it easier for families to consent to donation. Someone who hasn’t opted out or told their family they didn’t want to donate most likely didn’t feel strongly that they didn’t want to be a donor.

RedHelenB · 22/09/2021 09:49

[quote Robgem81]@RedHelenB that is not the assumption at all. Nobody is going to take body parts because you have not opted out. What is the issue with people feeling they are being dictated to. It's ridiculous. Go onto the NHSBT website and educate yourself and then click on the link that takes 2 seconds and opt out.

To make it clear in the rare likelihood you are in a position to donate organs your family will be spoken to first and your end of life wishes established. To make it easy for your family to make that decision have the conversation and register your decision. [/quote]
The assumption now is that you are willing to be a donor unless you opt out or your family object. Previously it was the other way around and I still think it should be. As I said I carried a donor card.

Robgem81 · 22/09/2021 08:22

@RedHelenB that is not the assumption at all. Nobody is going to take body parts because you have not opted out. What is the issue with people feeling they are being dictated to. It's ridiculous. Go onto the NHSBT website and educate yourself and then click on the link that takes 2 seconds and opt out.

To make it clear in the rare likelihood you are in a position to donate organs your family will be spoken to first and your end of life wishes established. To make it easy for your family to make that decision have the conversation and register your decision.

AMALT · 21/09/2021 21:14

@Horst

I’d donate my body to medical science or a cadaver farm but not organ donation to others.

Am I kind or a selfish arsehole hmmm.

Dh doesn’t agree with me donating my body to science or the farm so I guess I’m keeping everything though unless he goes first.

What on earth is your reasoning behind that?
Buttons294749 · 21/09/2021 21:13

My spiritual beliefs are that my soul won't leave my body until my heart stops and I am cold. So if they invent a way to harvest after that then that's cool with me, unfortunately as it is I have had to opt out for religious/spirituality needs.

Horst · 21/09/2021 21:00

I’d donate my body to medical science or a cadaver farm but not organ donation to others.

Am I kind or a selfish arsehole hmmm.

Dh doesn’t agree with me donating my body to science or the farm so I guess I’m keeping everything though unless he goes first.

RedHelenB · 21/09/2021 20:31

I always carried an organ donor card but I don't like the having to opt out now either, why should the assumption be that others can just take body parts unless you specificallysay no? I still think it should be the other way round.

Livelovebehappy · 21/09/2021 20:23

People choose not to donate for all sorts of reasons. I will be donating my organs, but it’s my choice, and I respect other people’s choices to not want to be a doner.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 21/09/2021 19:47

They do say eyes are windows into the soul. Thinking about it, yeah it feels weird to imagine someone else having their parts. Can it be because we see them, unlike other bits, so there is bigger attachment emotionally?
And aww at seeing where you going. I actually like that.

Mantlemoose · 21/09/2021 19:42

@Mumguilt12

I’m pretty sure deep down it’s just squeamish thoughts (80%) and a belief in afterlife (20%)

I guarantee if I go first, he would feel uncomfortable with letting go any or all of my organs. He’s made particular comments about they eyes/cornea donation.

I have agreed to everything being donated but not eyes/corneal because I need to see where I'm going in the afterlife. I fully appreciate its stupid and my physical body won't be going with me but I can't get past it.
TheWernethWife · 21/09/2021 19:35

I'm donating my organs, so is my partner and my adult son.

hangrylady · 21/09/2021 18:16

@Lockheart

So some crackpot like the PP thinks it's Ok to take an organ but wouldn't donate one and that's OK with you is it? I get that it's probably not possible but it's what I'd like to see, with obvious exceptions for those who are unable to donate for actual reasons not some afterlife bollocks. Get off your high horse.

Of course it's ok!

  1. the NHS treats on the basis of need, not on moral judgements. If you need an organ the most, you'll be top of the list, regardless if you're a donor yourself.

  2. organ donation is a donation, it's not compulsory nor should it be expected. It is not a condition of receiving medical treatment, including receiving an organ.

  3. who else do we deny treatment to on the basis that they don't "give" enough? Do we bump the rich to the top of the waiting lists on the basis that they pay more tax than the poor and therefore "give" more to the NHS?

  4. even if you are on the register, the likelihood of your organs being used is tiny. There's nothing to feel particularly virtuous about.

You're right of course but as someone who's Dad is on the kidney transplant waiting list it's a bit of a touchy subject for me, sorry.
Lockheart · 21/09/2021 17:54

So some crackpot like the PP thinks it's Ok to take an organ but wouldn't donate one and that's OK with you is it? I get that it's probably not possible but it's what I'd like to see, with obvious exceptions for those who are unable to donate for actual reasons not some afterlife bollocks. Get off your high horse.

Of course it's ok!

  1. the NHS treats on the basis of need, not on moral judgements. If you need an organ the most, you'll be top of the list, regardless if you're a donor yourself.

  2. organ donation is a donation, it's not compulsory nor should it be expected. It is not a condition of receiving medical treatment, including receiving an organ.

  3. who else do we deny treatment to on the basis that they don't "give" enough? Do we bump the rich to the top of the waiting lists on the basis that they pay more tax than the poor and therefore "give" more to the NHS?

  4. even if you are on the register, the likelihood of your organs being used is tiny. There's nothing to feel particularly virtuous about.

MrsDThomas · 21/09/2021 17:54

Im happy to give mine.DH isn’t and won’t talk about serious stuff.

He hasn’t opted out so if he dies, ive decided they go to someone who needs them.

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 21/09/2021 17:52

So some crackpot like the PP thinks it's Ok to take an organ but wouldn't donate one and that's OK with you is it? I get that it's probably not possible but it's what I'd like to see, with obvious exceptions for those who are unable to donate for actual reasons not some afterlife bollocks. Get off your high horse.

The NHS goes by clinical need, not moral conduct.

They can't present a hypothetical scenario to someone and make a judgement about their medical care based on them providing the acceptable answer.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 21/09/2021 17:50

I agree. It shouldn't be opt out- you get nothing.

Some people opt out of many things, still get them.

Healthcare should be in no way based on tit for tat and whoever would be happy with that should think long and hard about whether they really are these "good and kiiiind" people they claim to be

Swipe left for the next trending thread