Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the fact that non-vaccinated people will now have to isolate from all non-red countries has been hidden in the small print

242 replies

Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 18:49

I’m pretty sure today’s travel announcement means that if you’re not vaccinated then you must self isolate for 10 days and take day 2 and 8 tests (can still test to release) from all countries outside of the red list

This means that non-vaccinated people going to what are currently green countries who thought they wouldn’t have to isolate, now will if they return after 4th October

OP posts:
toocold54 · 17/09/2021 22:01

One very obvious reason is that it gives people a push to go and have the vaccine.

Which is clearly what it’s all about

So why can they do pretty much everything a vaccinated person can in the UK?

The above is very contradictory.

If the government want to push people into getting a vaccination they would create more restrictions within the UK.
They of course do want to push people to an extent but that’s not what the restrictions on travel is about.

housewifeathome · 17/09/2021 22:01

@Lostinacloud

The answer is, because it makes no sense!

Vaccinated or unvaccinated when it comes to travel is irrelevant. Since both populations can catch and spread covid, surely if governments wanted to apply some common sense and actual science, travel would be subject to testing only. Negative test you’re good to go, positive then obviously not and you have to stay at home until better or cleared from the possibility of infecting anyone else.

This absolute vilification of the unvaccinated is horrific, unjustified and we must not buy into it.

Well said 👏🏼 The vilification of the unvaccinated is utterly shocking and unjustified. You'll get slated on here though for this rational comment!! 😬
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 22:00

@Butterflyfluff

I think it's quite reasonable for those who choose to be unvaccinated to be subject to more restrictions. I don't see how that's 'bitter'.

But no one has actually explained why preventing unvaccinated people travelling to countries with lower infections rates than us (who are happy to accept them), by forcing them to isolate upon return, is desirable, other than ‘because they can’

Unvaccinated people are subject to very few restrictions in the UK - why not focus on that rather than travel?

The answer is ‘because it’s too hard’

It’s desirable because it reduces the spread. It’s the same reason you have to have other vaccines to visit certain countries. Again, not a new concept.
Lostinacloud · 17/09/2021 21:59

And of course there’s the total failure to acknowledge natural immunity, which has been proven in many studies now to be extremely robust. Some studies out of Israel even suggest that those with natural immunity have only a 1% chance of becoming reinfected or infecting anybody else.
How many of the unvaccinated are people who have successfully recovered from covid and so would like the opportunity to rely on their own proven immunity? We won’t know because it is ignored but potentially many previously infected but unvaccinated travellers could be less likely to bring covid into the country than a vaccinated person who is yet to get it.
Yet more reason why we must not support the division being created. It is discrimination without any just cause.

toocold54 · 17/09/2021 21:57

Why is it a risk to you (assuming you’re in the UK) letting someone who’s not vaccinated travel to a green country, that has lower case rates than the UK?

If there was a new, rapidly spreading infectious disease in Africa would you think it was fair that lots of people from Africa came to the UK for a holiday knowing that there’s a high chance they’ll bring the disease with them?
So why should green countries who’ve worked hard to get their cases down have to then have a rise in cases and go in to lockdown again.

I actually think our country should have shut the boarders straight away and only let the people who needed to travel travel.
Why repeat the mistakes when it’s not necessary.

alterego2 · 17/09/2021 21:57

@Butterflyfluff

And people who smoke, drink, take drugs, are fat, take up medical resources too
Ok - I'll admit to not reading to the end of the thread but I'm going to respond to this anyway

People who smoke, drink, take drugs or are fat do not infect other people with those qualities.

Fairly sure someone else will have said this but I'm too cross to read on and find out

Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 21:54

Negative test you’re good to go, positive then obviously not and you have to stay at home until better or cleared from the possibility of infecting anyone else.

This

A negative tested unvaccinated person has to be less of a risk than an untested vaccinated person

OP posts:
Lostinacloud · 17/09/2021 21:51

The answer is, because it makes no sense!

Vaccinated or unvaccinated when it comes to travel is irrelevant. Since both populations can catch and spread covid, surely if governments wanted to apply some common sense and actual science, travel would be subject to testing only. Negative test you’re good to go, positive then obviously not and you have to stay at home until better or cleared from the possibility of infecting anyone else.

This absolute vilification of the unvaccinated is horrific, unjustified and we must not buy into it.

minatrina · 17/09/2021 21:51

@Butterflyfluff

One very obvious reason is that it gives people a push to go and have the vaccine.

Which is clearly what it’s all about

... yes?
Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 21:50

Because they’re more susceptible to getting the virus and therefore higher risk.

So why can they do pretty much everything a vaccinated person can in the UK?

OP posts:
Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 21:49

One very obvious reason is that it gives people a push to go and have the vaccine.

Which is clearly what it’s all about

OP posts:
pelosi · 17/09/2021 21:49

@Butterflyfluff

I think it's quite reasonable for those who choose to be unvaccinated to be subject to more restrictions. I don't see how that's 'bitter'.

But no one has actually explained why preventing unvaccinated people travelling to countries with lower infections rates than us (who are happy to accept them), by forcing them to isolate upon return, is desirable, other than ‘because they can’

Unvaccinated people are subject to very few restrictions in the UK - why not focus on that rather than travel?

The answer is ‘because it’s too hard’

Because they’re more susceptible to getting the virus and therefore higher risk.
minatrina · 17/09/2021 21:48

But no one has actually explained why preventing unvaccinated people travelling to countries with lower infections rates than us (who are happy to accept them), by forcing them to isolate upon return, is desirable, other than ‘because they can’

One very obvious reason is that it gives people a push to go and have the vaccine.

pelosi · 17/09/2021 21:48

@Butterflyfluff

It’s possible those countries letting unvaxxed in are doing that based on the majority of brits being vaccinated. So again, the vaccinated bearing the load for the unvaccinated.

I’m not up to speed with all green countries but I’m pretty sure most will only accept unvaccinated visitors with a negative test so no one is ‘bearing the load’ of anyone

I think the bottom line here is that Covid has made people very bitter

Some undoubtedly justifiably, but probably not the majority

But UK is not letting in people even if they test negatively but are from a country where majority are not vaccinated.

And other countries are doing the same. So yes, the vaccinated are bearing the load for the unvaccinated.

Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 21:45

I think it's quite reasonable for those who choose to be unvaccinated to be subject to more restrictions. I don't see how that's 'bitter'.

But no one has actually explained why preventing unvaccinated people travelling to countries with lower infections rates than us (who are happy to accept them), by forcing them to isolate upon return, is desirable, other than ‘because they can’

Unvaccinated people are subject to very few restrictions in the UK - why not focus on that rather than travel?

The answer is ‘because it’s too hard’

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 17/09/2021 21:40

'Bitter' is a very overused word on here. I think it's quite reasonable for those who choose to be unvaccinated to be subject to more restrictions. I don't see how that's 'bitter'.

mim321 · 17/09/2021 21:39

@BatShitBitchChops

What happens about the 12-17 Yr olds that have had one dose compared to other countries that have given their young people 2 doses? Will ours be classed as not fully vaccinated?
I discovered recently that lots of my son's friends have had their second doses ahead of time i.e. well before 3 months before their 18th birthday. Having phoned one of our local pharmacies, they confirmed they'll do second vaccinations for any 16 and 17 year olds if they have Pfizer vaccines open that day.

Appreciate the second dose delay is due to the heightened myocarditis risk but the option to get two vaccinations seems to be there for under 18s. I think we'll use that route as it makes our European holiday much more straightforward in December. In all honesty, the travel freedoms were the main driver for the kids' vaccinations as I suspect they've both had covid.

Windyone · 17/09/2021 21:38

@CorianderAndCream yes but surely @Marmunia75 has the answers?

Total respect to @MNHQ who have to deal with all the post deletion requests………

minatrina · 17/09/2021 21:38

I think the bottom line here is that Covid has made people very bitter

Eh. I think it's made selfish people more selfish and thick people more thick.

Butterflyfluff · 17/09/2021 21:37

It’s possible those countries letting unvaxxed in are doing that based on the majority of brits being vaccinated. So again, the vaccinated bearing the load for the unvaccinated.

I’m not up to speed with all green countries but I’m pretty sure most will only accept unvaccinated visitors with a negative test so no one is ‘bearing the load’ of anyone

I think the bottom line here is that Covid has made people very bitter

Some undoubtedly justifiably, but probably not the majority

OP posts:
CorianderAndCream · 17/09/2021 21:36

[quote Windyone]@Marmunia75 I’ve been vaccinated. Is it poison? Should I be worried?
Why are people being told to get vaccinated if its poison? Can you give me more information? I’m really worried now :([/quote]
I hope this is sarcasm 😂

ilovesooty · 17/09/2021 21:36

Well those unvaccinated by choice obviously can stand next to the vaccinated in supermarkets.

However in situations such as travel, it's possible to put different restrictions in place, and I think that's fine.

CorianderAndCream · 17/09/2021 21:35

@Marmunia75

Well, it's not a vaccine? It hasn't stopped people from getting it. If anything it's a bloody magnet attracting disease.

FFS lose some weight, run 5k a day and you'll be fine.

Tell that to the children and people under 30 who have died. I'm sure they run around a lot. Still died.
pianolessons1 · 17/09/2021 21:35

and it's not just the risk of the country, more the airport/plane

pianolessons1 · 17/09/2021 21:35

@Butterflyfluff

Some people really aren’t getting this.

Green countries generally have much lower infection rates than the UK does.

People who chose not to be vaccinated are milling around with all of us in the UK right now.

Where is the harm in them being able to travel to a country with less infection than us?

I think some people on here are so consumed with thinking that everyone should have the vaccine, that they’ve lost the ability to think about this rationally and weigh up what the additional risk actually is.

The point is that every time a restriction like this comes along, a few more people get vaccinated. It's a lever to make people do the right thing.
Swipe left for the next trending thread