Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refused to rehome a dog ...aibu to think it's a ridiculous decision?

316 replies

brettsndsal · 17/09/2021 10:52

We are a massive dog family.
Over the years we have had a lurcher,a border collie and a poodle all lived a happy long life.
They are part of the family and spoilt rotten.
Birthday ,Christmas presents,taken to the park daily and walks etc etc
We love them like a child basically.
Our last dog Lucy passed away aged 16 six weeks ago.
She was a rescue dog and had a bad start to life.
Anyway I've applied to rehome a dog through two rehoming places.
Both Declined us because we don't have a garden.

We have never had a Garden but that hasn't affected the dog in anyway.
We love opposite a huge park and 5 mins away from the beach.
They've refused to even do a home check because it's not suitable home for a dog.

We applied for a Jack Russell and another poodle.
Even if we had a garden I wouldn't let the dog out alone.

I'm really upset and I don't understand how a garden makes any difference.
They have lots of dogs in at the minute crying out for a new life.
We couldn't love them anymore if we tried

Aibu to think it's a bit shit?

OP posts:
Anordinarymum · 17/09/2021 12:44

liveforsummer

No I have not checked. I am retired and have a massive garden, don't live near a main road, and don't know what else they would check, but I am sure I will find out

LowlandLucky · 17/09/2021 12:43

The charities are very short sighted by refusing you but i am not surprised. Our local animal shelter puts the phone down on any one calling from the local R.A.F camp. I lived on that camp for years and not one family abandoned a pet.

Spidey66 · 17/09/2021 12:43

We e fed up buying a puppy.

We don't have kids,husband retired, live i n a ground floor flat but have a back yard. On paper we were perfect.....

We'd had dogs as kids but not as adults and every dog we asked about 'no,you don't have enough experience ' but how are supposed to get experience without a dog? We were registered with 3 or 4 rescues and all said the same thing, not enough experience.

People say 'adopt don't shop' but it's easier said than done.

PuppyMonkey · 17/09/2021 12:42

@cheesychip

If you've no garden where will the dog go to the toilet?
We have a massive garden but like PPs, my fussy golden retriever wouldn’t dream of doing a wee or poo in it. Oh no, he demands to be taken out on a walk to perform such indignities.Grin
Mymapuddlington · 17/09/2021 12:40

I think it depends on the dog, the potential owner, loads of other factors but hate that they disregard people without knowing what they can offer. I can’t rescue a dog because my son has autism Sad

PandorasMailbox · 17/09/2021 12:40

So many dogs' homes have ridiculous criteria now.

After my sister's beloved 15 year old rescue dog passed away, she wanted to give another dog a good home. Not one of the local shelters would let her take a dog as she had a 6 year old child. Absolutely ridiculous. She ended up getting an abandoned dog from abroad. She's a fabulous little dog, but my sister's still bloody angry that she couldn't give a local dog a home.

Polkadotties · 17/09/2021 12:39

We are getting a dog next year. Won’t even bother looking at rescues as we work full time mainly home based but do have to go in the office (plenty of money to pay for day care), own a cat and some rabbits.

Nanny0gg · 17/09/2021 12:35

@Lavender24

Please don't buy a puppy...
So, just not have another dog?

And so ones got to buy puppies that have been born

WitchBaby · 17/09/2021 12:35

I wasn’t looking for a kitten that used a wheelchair

That made me snort out loud 😂

Thatnameistaken · 17/09/2021 12:33

Have you tried Far place animal rescue and Hope animal rescue? They're in your area and may have a more pragmatic approach to rehoming.

Gatekeeper · 17/09/2021 12:32

my brother in law got his dog from Stray Aid op and he doesn't have a garden

WitchBaby · 17/09/2021 12:32

It's absolutely crazy and infuriating. They'd rather the poor dogs stay in a cage in a rescue than in a flat with access to the beach and park?

We had the same with a cat rescue a few years ago. Tried to adopt an old cat that no one else wanted. Ok, we'll have her I thought. Ooooh no - got turned down because we had a cat flap!!! Yes, we had a cat flap. 'Oh no she may get out at night' they said.
'No, I keep all my cats in at night and lock the cat flap' I said.
But they wouldn't budge 😡

Mangozesty · 17/09/2021 12:32

@brettsndsal Sorry if you've said but whereabouts are you? There is a rehoming centre in my area that's pretty sensible snd might not be so strict.

hiredandsqueak · 17/09/2021 12:31

We rehomed through a small local rescue who took into account individual circumstances. Ours was advertised as suitable to be homed with children or cats but not another dog. She's been an absolute delight. They rehome nationwide but are based in Rotherham www.jlptrustanimalrescue.org.uk/ and support is ongoing should you need it.

Gatekeeper · 17/09/2021 12:30

@brettsndsalis it Stray Aid you've tried ?

Jokat · 17/09/2021 12:30

I haven't had time to read the whole thread (on break at work), so someone else may have made the same suggestion. Look into rescues abroad, like Romania, Spain etc. They are often very well organised places that make the process very uncomplicated, and often have less strict conditions. We went with a Romanian rescue as I was determined to rescue but we have children, so weren't considered by any British resxues we tried.

Coffeepot72 · 17/09/2021 12:30

Many years ago I was declined for adopting a kitten because I gave a mobile phone number, which made me look ‘transient’, which I’m not, it was simply the best number to get me on.

A friend was also turned down by the same organisation, because her husband was in the forces. He had no plans to take the kitten to Afghanistan though.

I was finally accepted by the RSPCA, who did a home visit and recommended I got a ramp leading to/from the back door, which surprised me as I wasn’t looking for a kitten that used a wheelchair, but they explained it was ‘quite a long drop’ for a small animal. I’m guessing this person had never owned a cat.

LiamGallagherIsHot · 17/09/2021 12:29

Rescues are just trying to ensure that the rehoming is a success. Believe me, if you’d seen something of the things I have, you wouldn’t think the rules were too strict.

Not all places insist on a garden. Have you tried Bluecross? They look at each case individually and you won’t necessarily need a garden. Please don’t buy a puppy.

Hoppinggreen · 17/09/2021 12:27

You do sound like a lovely home for a dog OP and I agree that common sense should prevail in the majority of cases.
However, I have done homechecks for both dog and cat charities and some people who think they are an “ideal” home really arent.
The thing I really used to consider was will we get this animal back because it will all go wrong?
Despite what some people think animal charities (with a few exceptions) don’t want to keep the animals for any long than is necessary and they really want the adoption to work for everyone.
Due to experience it is often possible to see how an adoption can go wrong and the things highlighted are often based on incidents that HAVE happened
Having said that I do think that as long as everyone knows how to mitigate potential problems then it’s no reason for a blanket NO

WellLarDeDar · 17/09/2021 12:26

Has similar issues when DH and I lived in a flat many years ago and wanted a dog. Eventually Dogs Trust gave us a chance and we took home a gorgeous GSD boy. That was 9 years ago now, not sure if they've changed their policies. I agree it's ridiculous. There are people with gardens who mistreat dogs and people in flats who give them the best lives ever. It certainly doesn't help the rehoming rates vetoing most of the population. Some dogs will need a private garden but others will cope fine having daily walks in the park. Poor digs are wasting away in kennels when they could be living in loving homes :(

Lovemusic33 · 17/09/2021 12:26

Yes, some of their rules are crazy, most won’t homes that have kids under 5, I don’t really understand this one either, someone who has a baby/toddler is more likely to be home more to look after and train a dog? I know not all dogs can be homes with kids but some can (puppies can). The garden rule is a bit crazy too, I understand that some breeds may not be great to live in a house without a garden but there are many breeds that do fine without one as long as walked twice a day, breeds like greyhounds are pretty good for people without gardens, they happily sleep on the sofa most the day but enjoy a walk.

OP, hopefully you can find a rescue that doesn’t have the garden rule, I’m sure there are some. Getting a puppy in a flat would be much harder than getting a older dog.

MrsPaddyGrant · 17/09/2021 12:25

I volunteered at Dogs Trust and not all dogs needed a garden - it depended on the dog. They might if they were nervous and needed a safe private place to play.

Dont give up keep trying with the various dog rescues - i do appreciate it can be frustrating but they are all doing their best to find the right home for the dogs.

Eilatan2018 · 17/09/2021 12:22

Check fb.. we have an animal lovers page local to our area and people sometimes need to rehome their dogs so wouldn't be an issue with no garden etc. I agree it's so unfair! We have a toy poodle and a 100ft garden but she's so tiny she barely uses it!

HopeForTheBestExpectTheWorst · 17/09/2021 12:18

Yes it's ridiculous. We adopted from abroad (but we're not in the uk anyway) at a time when we were living in a flat and had a dog and a 7yo child. We had a home visit, lots of questions, felt that they really did assess the situation properly.
Ddog2 came along and slotted right into family life.

Loads and loads of dogs the world over live in flats. You take them outside for walks, it's not exactly hard.

After we moved to a house (still no garden, but we're out in the countryside), we wanted to adopt a cat. Didn't meet any of the criteria, apparently. So we bought two kittens, who are now supremely happy, satisfied cats that get on marvellously with the dog and the kids, and love exploring the surrounding fields.

It does make me wonder who exactly they want these animals to go to.

Doris86 · 17/09/2021 12:17

Probably in the massive park right opposite her house which the OP mentioned?