Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lidl parking charge

157 replies

RahRahRa · 17/09/2021 10:21

I do most of my weekly shopping at Lidl and have just received a parking fine for overstaying in the car park by 29 minutes, the time limit is 1 1/2 hours.

Yes I should have paid attention, it is a new branch that we’d never been to before and tbh I just didn’t think about the time limit.

This is such a shame, I love Lidl but have three kids all with varying levels of ASD who slow me down (I don’t take them all with me but often have one or two). I am also a bit of a ditherer and like to take my time choosing.

I will appeal the fine but I don’t fancy my chances of it being revoked. As I can’t risk this happening again, I have no choice but to not shop there anymore. Their prices have gone up anyway and we have closer supermarkets so no real loss to me - Apart from the parking fine!

Lidl say there’s nothing they can do as a third party looks after their car parks but they must be involved in setting the policies so why on Earth do they allow this to happen to loyal customers? 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HelpwithPCNs · 06/11/2021 17:34

Winterweightlossgoal
For some people 90 minutes is not generous. Those for example in wheelchairs who have to unload them from their car and then collapse them on return to their cars can easily lose 10 minutes there before they have started shopping.
Bear in mind too that these parking companies often film your car reg. on the way in and the way out. That does not take into account the time it can take to find a parking spot, especially at busy times. Nor does it take into account the time it can take to leave the car park if there is already a queue trying to get out on to a busy road.
I am sure Lidl will lose more customers who have received PCNs than who cannot wait for five minutes for a parking spot.
Also someone who spends a long time in their store and therefore more likely to spend a lot of money there is more likely to get a ticket but is exactly the kind of customer that Lidl should want to keep coming back. Crazy psychology by Lidl.

fishonabicycle · 06/11/2021 17:12

Probably standing in the queue for the single till for at least 40 minutes if it's anything like the branch near me!

HelpwithPCNs · 06/11/2021 17:09

Lockheart it should matter to Lidl that someone is spending £500 with them. Most supermarkets are now starting to use these leeches like Parking Eye which is a big mistake. They are not there to catch out those that park at Lidl but don't shop there. They are there to squeeze every last penny out of Lidl's shoppers . And they do try very hard.

Lidl and the other companies that use the likes of Parking Eye andVCS etc. etc. will come to regret using them as they cause more trouble and will lose them customers. Lidl employed the robbers and they do have the power to quash a number of PCNs but they failed to allow for the sheer number of times that they would have to cancel since these parking companies are rapacious.

ColorMagicBarbie · 19/09/2021 11:12

Mr Taylor advises never to ignore a Parking Charge Notice because legally, private parking firms can take you to court if you don't pay up.

He said: "Prior to 2015, to ignore them would have been the correct advice.

"But in 2015 in the Beavis v Parking Eye case, judges in the Supreme Court, the highest court in the land, ruled Parking Charge Notices are enforceable and prices charged are just."

As a result, the judgement effectively rewrote the law of penalty charges, meaning parking firms will now be able to take you to court if you don't pay up.

Asda and Lidl supermarket parking fines - an insider's guide to how to beat them

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/asda-lidl-supermarket-parking-fines-17245668.amp

WinterWeightlossGoal · 19/09/2021 11:11

@RahRahRa

Totally agree Djifunrsn

Tbh, even if they do let me off the fine, this has put me off shopping with them. Why would they want to loose customers in this way? It makes no sense 🤷🏻‍♀️

There’s more than enough choice where we live and they’re opening up a new Aldi nearby very soon so I’ll just go there instead.

Surely they will lose more customers by not having anywhere from them to park because someone is overstaying the generous 90 mins free parking?
itsgettingwierd · 19/09/2021 11:10

@Darkchocolateandcoffee

OP I also love food and shop in Lidl AND have an ASD child, but I cannot fathom how you could spend two hours in there with at least one child with ASK.

Honestly how did they not have a meltdown? When I do Lidl with my autistic son I am in and out in about ten minutes as the alternative would be horrific.

I do my foodie dithering in more luxurious food shops on my own!

Well as you well know not everyone with asd is the same.

This thread also shows not every NT person is the same re shopping.

🤷‍♀️

My local Aldi has a time limit. Think it's also 1.5 hrs as in right on edge of town centre. I use disabled bay as ds has a BB. Reminds me that I don't think I've ever seen a sign by the disabled parking. I must remember to look!

ColorMagicBarbie · 19/09/2021 11:05

Don't ignore it. This often used to work but there was a big case a few years back which had seemingly set the precedent. If they can demonstrate that it's likely you knowingly entered into the contractual terms then they can take you to court and many do this nowadays.

Fluffypastelslippers · 19/09/2021 10:53

@TimeForTeaAndG

I didn't say I did, the we I was referring to was my DH and I.

Oh, you said 'up in Scotland we...' so forgive me for assuming we referred to people in Scotland rather then just you and your DH Confused

But more fool you for paying, they are not from the council nor the police. They're a request for payment from a free car park, they've lost zero money by someone overstaying the arbitrary time limit.

If I breach conditions I'm happy to pay. I don't know why the need to name call, it is a choice I make, it's just different to yours, that's all.

Fluffypastelslippers · 19/09/2021 10:48

@SoloISland

am registered as disabled. And that entitles me to a Blue Badge. OK? OK … Means they accept that I am disabled and give me the relevant privileges. We call it registered here in Ireland which does not mean there is a written register.... That is the terminology they use and I am not sure what your issue is? Please google the term? Yes some local authorities do have a disabled register so they can check re parking privileges etc.

Goodness I was only asking Sad

I don't have an issue, i was asking because I wanted to know. So Ireland has a register for disabled people? Thanks. No need to be quite so rude though Confused

Ikeptgoing · 19/09/2021 10:34

@RahRahRa

Then your option is to use the advice groups suggested to argue PCN on a technicality . The fb group literally gives you advice within 24 hours on your post.

Don't go back to Lidl. I regularly take 60- 90 mins (albeit in a large shop) as I'm disabled and cannot get round easily. So it only takes a long queue at tills or a slow toilet stop for me to go over that time.

Luckily only Lidl has made 90mins restriction on path king, Asda Waitrose Co-op Sanisburies all have 3 hours. Aldi's has no parking restrictions (but the aisles are crowded)

RahRahRa · 18/09/2021 21:32

BeautifulBirds as herculesoffline has said I’ve tried contacting Lidl, twice by phone and once by email - but it appears that they literally couldn’t give a monkeys about keeping their loyal customers 😒

OP posts:
Ikeptgoing · 18/09/2021 11:44

Find and ask to join this fb group OP. They will help you go through process

But definitely think it is worth considering whether to email Lidl head quarters and also manager of the supermarket branch with photocopies of the notice and your receipt and say that you have SEN children and are a regular customer, so can they please arrange to have this fine wavered?

Lidl parking charge
herculesoffline · 18/09/2021 08:39

@BeautifulBirds

I worked for a supermarket and the car park was operated by a third party. Customers who had been fined used to come in, prove they had shopped with us and I would email the car park operator to waiver the fine. It's quite straight forward.

Complain to the head office if the store won't help.

This isn't the case for every supermarket, and in any case OP literally says she's tried this..
Ikeptgoing · 18/09/2021 08:38

@BarbaraofSeville

FGS people aren't suggesting that there's a 'register' of disabled people, merely using it as a shorthand for the fact that they qualify for PCP/a blue badge and consequently they are likely to take longer than many people in the supermarket.
Yes they are Hmm Read those PPs comments and the actual comment I quoted. Anyway it won't add much to OPs situation as Whether she has DPB (blue badge) for her Children or whether they are registered disabled, adds little to parking notice/ invoice situation

I doubt anyone would ask for proof of their disability if she wrote a letter to the company.

I think there's been some good advice earlier on this thread about pepipoo and writing to Lidl with photocopy of till receipt explaining also have SEN children. There's also helpful fb group you can ask to join called "Private Parking PCNs- free advice and appeals" who are super helpful

LemonFantaGin · 18/09/2021 07:39

Sent proof you were in store and they will squash it for you.

Eyesofdisarray · 18/09/2021 07:07

These are parking charges NOT fines!!!!!!!!

BarbaraofSeville · 18/09/2021 06:50

FGS people aren't suggesting that there's a 'register' of disabled people, merely using it as a shorthand for the fact that they qualify for PCP/a blue badge and consequently they are likely to take longer than many people in the supermarket.

Ikeptgoing · 18/09/2021 05:30

Oooh a few more PPs are claiming there is no disabled register . Depends on which country .. but

Yes there is. It's a duty for every local authority in England (& pretty sure in Scotland and Wales too unless they repealed the NAA) .
No it isn't voluntary for the LA to maintain a disabled register. It's a duty under National Assistance Act 1948 . It is however voluntary for disabled persons whether they ask to be registered disabled or not.

Ikeptgoing · 18/09/2021 05:20

@Fluffypastelslippers

op are your children registered as disabled? If so, the Blue Badge will cover all parking.

What is meant by 'registered disabled'?

There is no 'disabled register'

HmmHmm YES you can be registered disabled and Local Authorities do indeed maintain register of disabled persons in their area. You have to ask. Legislation is s29 NAA 1948 & CSDPA 1970.

It is separate to the DPB (blue badge) process, which will give automatic eligibility to be registered disabled but you still have to ask.

Pretty sure NAA & CSDPA are not just England but also Scotland and Wales

Anyway, you get sent yellow disability registration card. The list is always far less than number of actual disabled people in the community as people forget to ask to be registered. It has tight criteria for each category (eg fit mental health need to be under a CMHT or psychiatrist, partial or blind registration decisions are made by opthalmologist, etc)
This is just to correct a couple of PPs earlier on the thread and won't really help OPs situation other than she can say her children are registered disabled with ASD if they are (as children it'd be under children's act legislation)

Hont1986 · 18/09/2021 02:48

I think there is a 'register' of blind people? Don't know anything about it other than i know I've seen 'are you registered as blind?' on various forms before.

Another one here who has no idea how OP spent 2 hours in a shop with six aisles. Especially since Lidl famously has very little choice. It's not like she was getting stuck on deciding between 15 varieties of strawberry jam, either you pick their own brand or maybe one other.

Lockheart · 17/09/2021 23:45

[quote PumpkinsGalore]**@SoloISland* You are not registered* as disabled - nobody is.
I also have a blue badge. I receive the highest rate of PIP. That's it. There is no 'register' of disabled people! 🤣[/quote]
Actually it depends on your local authority, some do keep voluntary registers of those who are classified as disabled. Not all, but there are those that do.

There is no national register.

PumpkinsGalore · 17/09/2021 23:15

@SoloISland You are not registered as disabled - nobody is.
I also have a blue badge. I receive the highest rate of PIP. That's it. There is no 'register' of disabled people! 🤣

PumpkinsGalore · 17/09/2021 23:08

How in Santa Claus's Workshop, did you manage to spend 1 min short of TWO HOURS in Lidl?!?!

XenoBitch · 17/09/2021 22:25

YABU.. 2 hours in Lidl?

pelosi · 17/09/2021 22:23

I agree with pp. do you have proof of the kids’ ASD. Appeal bases on that.