Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are school dinners healthy?

56 replies

HungryHippo11 · 16/09/2021 22:14

What is the general opinion of school dinners? I know they're free but this is what my daughter has had this week:
Sausages and mash
Omelet and diced potatoes (chips)
Pizza and wedges (chips)
Some sort of vegetable pie and roast potatoes
Fish fingers and chips
All come with a portion of veg.

I'm no expert but I'm pretty sure if a mum posted on here that her child had chips 4 times in a week, that wouldn't be considered a healthy diet. And I realise they're on a tight budget and for some kids the alternative is no lunch, so they're providing a service the best they can. But would you be happy with this? I'm thinking I might just send her with packed lunches instead.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whatalovelydaffodil · 14/04/2022 14:58

It all depends on how those lunches have been cooked and the quality of the ingredients.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 14/04/2022 14:55

They’re DREADFUL here.

“What did you have for lunch today?”

“Pizza. I left the mash though.”

“Mash?”

“Yes. Everything has to have potatoes or pasta with it and they didn’t have any chips.”

“Any veg?”

“Sweetcorn.”

“And pudding?”

“Arctic roll.”

So carbs with carbs and carbs followed by carbs then?

Repeat daily.

I’ve taken her off school dinners and I give her actual food now.

whowhatwerewhy · 14/04/2022 14:30

If your unhappy with the free school lunch , send in a packed lunch.

Owwlie · 14/04/2022 14:22

I think the problem is that there’s a real mix between schools, depending on the catering company. I work in a secondary and we’ve had 3 caterers in the time I’ve been there. One was awful but one was really good, unfortunately didn’t get the contract renewed due to the cost. It comes down the funding, schools need to be better funded.

The caterers at DDs school have good healthy options, and a real mix, curries, omelette, vegetable jambalaya, roasts dinners, pasta dishes and a salad bar everyday, but they also offer jacket potatoes and sandwiches because as @Pinotwoman82 says, that meal will be the only one of the day for some children, there needs to be an option they will eat. And pizza and chips is pretty much a guarantee for most kids. Better that they’ve eaten something than starve. It’s the same at home as well, for some parents they can’t afford to waste £5 on a meal their kids won’t eat when it only costs a couple of quid for chicken nuggets and their kids aren’t going hungry.

scandiinuk · 14/04/2022 09:53

This is a topic that is so interesting to me. I'm Swedish, have lived in England for a long time, and have worked in schools. It shocked me to see the standard of food served here. It is not healthy, and the argument that 'they wouldn't eat it otherwise' is not necessarily true - children often eat what other children eat, so school is a great place to create good eating habits. It is very common for Swedish children to happily eat 'strange food' in nursery school - but to be difficult to please at home: they will eat what everyone else eats.

A long time ago I worked in a school kitchen for a short while. I told my then colleagues that chips and crips would never ever be served in Swedish schools - they are not healthy. 'But don't you ever eat potatoes' I was asked. Oh yes - boiled potatoes. Much healthier. Sometimes mash. They looked at me like I had three heads 'children would never eat that'. Well some do!

In Swedish schools, desserts are offered maybe 1-2 times a term (so 3-4 times a year). There is always a salad bar with kidney beans, sweet corn and other vegetables and crisp bread (not soft bread daily). (This is the description of the salad bar in the city of Lund: 'There are at least five different vegetable components, at least three of which must be rich in fibre, at least one pulse and at least one salad vegetable or fruit. The aim is that each child eats 100-125 grams of vegetables or fruit with their school lunch'.) Rarely fried food. Never anything deepfried. School dinners are nutritionally balanced, calculated to meet 1/3 of the daily requirements over a period of time. And yes, school dinners are free for everyone, nobody brings a packed lunch.

This is a recent list of the most popular school dinners served in the city of Malmo in south Sweden, a very multicultural city with 350 000 inhabitants:

  1. Broccoli soup (veggie) [particularly interesting to see this one at the top given that a previous poster in this thread said that children would never eat that].
  2. Pastasauce with tomatoes and herbs (veggie)
  3. Filet of fish with vegetables and herbs
  4. Italian macaroni gratin (veggie)
  5. Lasagne, vegetables, cheese (veggie)
  6. Breaded fish with potatoes (boiled!) and cold sauce
  7. Spagetti with chicken mince or soy mince sauce (veggie and meat)
  8. Tacos with chicken mince or soy mince (veggie and meat
  9. Pasta gratin with salmon

www.magasinmaltid.se/vegetarisk-skrall-i-malmos-skolor/

Yes, there are mince dishes on the top list - but not only. And 7 of the 9 dishes are veggie or pescetarian.

Bad health due to poor choices is a massive issue. I wish schools would start serving healthy food and not blame 'they don't want it', and that parents would support schools in this. But given Jamie Oliver's failure to show people how important this is, it won't happen in a long time at least. It is sad that so many children get a bad start.

I do think it is a bit better than it used to be though, but many schools seem to still treat vegetables as 'extras', so not included in the (almost inevitable) mince dish - much easier to avoid then. I web searched a random school and listing one option as 'sandwiches' does not really give me confidence that that would be a balanced meal. Chips at least once a week. Green cabbage - I'd happily eat it, but the way vegetables just seem to be boiled/steamed and added here does not make them appealing. Dessert every day. It could have been worse, but it's not a great menu.
www.victory.southwark.sch.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/VPS-Aut-2021-Menu.pdf

Today's food in Malmo's schools is fish in creamy mustard sauce and boiled potatoes or pea mince with boiled potatoes and carrot tzatziki. Yesterday's food was potato and leek soup, soft wholemeal no-additives-or-E-numbers bread with spreads.

Highfivemum · 13/04/2022 23:08

Better than my DC sch that stopped sch dinners and ripped out the kitchen. They now get a sandwich that is brought in from a larger school. Appalling

Dizzyhedgehog · 13/04/2022 21:55

We're on holiday at the moment but for DS the first week back looks like this for meals:

Monday: Chicken schnitzel with dark sauce, served with organic peas and spaetzle OR Raviolini casserole with zucchini in béchamel sauce,
served with salad with vinegar-oil dressing
Dessert - Rice pudding with cinnamon and sugar

Tuesday:
Potato soup with salmon and dill, served with organic wholemeal bread and carrots
OR Potato soup with wholemeal bread OR
Vegetarian kebab with pita bread, soy gyros, coleslaw, tomatoes and tzaziki
Dessert- Fruit

Wednesday:
Hungarian goulash (beef) with organic spelt rice, served with cucumbers OR
Potato-broccoli casserole with green spelt, served with chive dip (100% organic)
Dessert - Marble cake

Thursday: Vegetarian sunflower seed hash with penne and grated cheese, served with salad and yogurt dressing OR
Apple crumble with vanilla sauce
Dessert - Fruit

Friday: A chicken thigh with barbecue sauce, served with potato wedges and peppers OR Vegetable meatball (carrot, celery, leek) with wild garlic sauce,
served with organic wholemeal rice and tomato salad in vinegar-oil dressing
Dessert - Cherry yoghurt

I find it a bit odd at times and quite dessert-heavy but they try to give the children a range of foods. It gets freshly cooked on site as well.

Pinotwoman82 · 13/04/2022 21:06

The problem is I guess you need to serve children the type of meals they actually want to eat, my DC’s school trialled a new menu and one of the things was broccoli soup, I mean I wouldn’t eat that let alone a child! That didn’t last long, also I guess you need to think about the kids that actually that might be the only meal they get that day, and if you think of all the energy they need for playing and learning a carrot stick isn’t really going to cut it

Owwlie · 13/04/2022 20:45

DDs school menu is really healthy. They only offer chips on a Friday, roast potatoes with the roast on a Wednesday, rice or garlic bread other days. Salad bar and veg options everyday.

They also do really good themed days for anything going on, Easter, Chinese New Year, world book day, they have a special themed menu. It’s really good, they had it open to sample on parents evening. So much better than I remember school dinners being!

TonkaTruckduck · 13/04/2022 20:34

Its tricky. They have pennies to provide a lunch and dessert.
To lots of children potatoes are familiar and will get eaten, where maybe cous cous, bulgar wheat etc isn't
I wouldn't be delighted with the menu but if it was free and all kids were having it and it saved me making packed lunch I'd probably live with it and balance out with healthier options outwith school dinners.

Herani · 13/04/2022 20:06

It’s complete carb-heavy stodge. I volunteered at My daughter’s local school when she was in state juniors and I almost vomited the ‘salt and vinegar’ fish back up. Really nasty tasting brown fishy cheap stuff. And they cooked on site for most meals.
Still don’t understand why a stodgy pudding is needed after lunch. Fruit is adequate if something sweet is needed.
I’m sure some schools get it right, but it reminded me of how aeroplane food or microwave meals might be described in a tasty, healthy way, but never live up to it in how they look or taste.

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/04/2022 19:18

Oven chips / wedges / pre-prepared roast potatoes are generally pretty low in fat. I think McCain oven chips have about 4g of fat per 100g.

How many people eat a sandwich for lunch virtually every day? Bread isn’t any more nutritious than potatoes.

Beautifulmonster87 · 13/04/2022 19:13

@TooManyUnits

I'm genuinely aghast that anyone thinks a roast potato is the same thing as a chip, just a different shape Shock
Why? They’re both cooked in the oven and full of fat!
TooManyUnits · 13/04/2022 19:09

I'm genuinely aghast that anyone thinks a roast potato is the same thing as a chip, just a different shape Shock

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 13/04/2022 19:07

My son is in reception and I’m so disappointed with his lunches, crap, crap and more crap.
Last week he said he was still hungry so they gave him 3 puddings.

DogsAndGin · 13/04/2022 19:06

No they’re vile. The lowest quality crap imaginable. I am a teacher and I am aghast at the quality of the ‘food.’ Look up the law on this - I know for a fact my school doesn’t even come close to meeting it’s legal requirements. Summary of the law attached

Are school dinners healthy?
Saucery · 13/04/2022 18:59

Old thread, bumped by a spammer.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/04/2022 18:45

EmeraldRaine

She hasnt had chips 4 times in a week though. She's had them once, and chips once a week isn't going to hurt her. confused this
It was not once. The diced potatoes were also like chips and roast potatoes and wedges are similar too.

So it is all heavy on carbohydrate and saturated fat.

Seashor · 13/04/2022 18:30

The school lunches in my school are absolutely incredible. We have Hunters chicken, roasts, fish and chips, home made rice pudding with fresh strawberry coulis, Eaton mess with strawberries and fresh cream, pizza baguettes, fresh peppers, cucumber, tomatoes, fresh fruit salad and yoghurts, home made shortbread and carrot cake.
It’s absolutely marvellous! I’m a huge fan.

ButTheyAintSeenUsTogether · 13/04/2022 18:25

School meals are generally crap. Very little nutrition, small and I dread to think the quality of the meat or where it’s from. And the smell...how did they make food smell so bad? My son was almost sick once when describing what his friend was served. I wouldn’t let my kids eat them, not that they would anyway. Definitely send packed lunch.

damnthisvirusandmarriage · 13/04/2022 18:18

I think the school menu is diabolical. It’s unhealthy and made with exceptionally poor quality ingredients such as meat that is full of fat and gristle.

The sandwiches are frozen then defrosted for lunch time.

I agree with lots of versions of chips too. It’s super carb heavy.

I have literally nothing good to say about school meals provided by Newydd School Meals.

moita · 13/04/2022 17:45

My son has three school dinners and two packed lunches a week. He was getting constipated with the school dinners!

At least with packed lunches he has lots of fruit and veggies but I am lucky I can afford to do this and the school allows it

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 13/04/2022 17:43

I’d say they are as healthy as possible given the budget for providing them. We make the kids eat salad at home to ensure they’ve seen a vitamin at some point.

LunchFixers · 13/04/2022 17:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Ace56 · 16/09/2021 23:37

I used to work in several schools and no, they’re not healthy on the whole. Plus even if they sound healthy on paper, the children don’t eat the healthy bits! There’s no one standing over them going ‘eat some more of your veg, go on, one more carrot’ so lots of kids end up eating mainly the carbs and that’s it. Lots of them also hardly eat anything at all - there is a hell of a lot of food waste in schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread