Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another Dog one

107 replies

Softfresh · 16/09/2021 15:04

Took DD to the park today for a picnic lunch and a play after. I have no problem with dogs personally but DD is absolutely terrified of them.

We sat down at the picnic tables and within the space of 5-10 minutes, 3 different groups of people with 8-10 dogs between them decided it was okay to let their dogs pound up to us, off lead and jump and bark all around us. It's okay though because "they're friendly" why do people think this is okay? I don't mind dogs but I still don't want them jumping all over me when I'm eating lunch!

Every time this happened, I told them that DD was afraid of dogs. The first 2 groups were reasonable enough and took the dogs away after a few jumps and barks at us. DD was on edge by this point but I tried my best to calm her down.

Then a mother and daughter approach with yet another 2 dogs, running around our feet, jumping and barking. I explained that DD was scared so asked if she could move the dog. Of course her dog was friendly and wouldn't harm her Angry by this point DD was practically on top of the table trying to get away from them! The woman then decided to tell DD that her dog gets excited when it sees food so she should hide her sandwiches! Wtf! At this point I had enough and told her sternly to move her dog and let us eat our lunch. I've already told her DD doesn't like dogs, she seemed pretty offended by my sharp tone.

Aibu to expect dog owners to keep their animals under control around people eating lunch? Why do these dog lovers think everyone must love their dogs as much as they do? I had to pack up and take DD elsewhere to eat and she spent the rest of the time completely on edge so our lovely afternoon was ruined by selfish rude people Angry Rant over!

OP posts:
Softfresh · 17/09/2021 10:43

The signs regarding dogs on a leash is the norm in play parks and picnic areas where I live. I assumed it was like this everywhere unless it's a dog friendly park where I assume there is signs stating that?

Exaggeration of people allowing their dogs off leads in a park? I don't see what's so obscene about it? The first 2 group's of people happily moved their dogs away when asked, it was the last pair that decided their dogs weren't a problem when it was clearly causing DD distress. It's like this in every park we visit now, even inside the play park area there's always someonethat the rules don't apply to. It's a shame that she has developed such a fear because of a few bad owners. She has had many good encounters with responsible owners and their pets in the past but these have been overshadowed by the bad.

I think what tipped her over the edge was last year seeing a small dog on a lead being mauled by a larger dog off the lead in another park. It was traumatic even for me to witness so no wonder she's jumpy now. We no longer visit that park.

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 17/09/2021 10:33

I hate people who say you should work on your child's fear.

^I don’t understand this at all. My DDs used to be afraid of dogs, but I did all I could to help them get used to them. Why? Because they have cousins and friends who have dogs. (We don’t have a dog ourselves, as I’m a cat owner and my DH is allergic.)

Surely the majority of children have friends or family members with dogs? Would you want them to miss out on parties or play dates because they’re afraid of dogs?

I’m not saying that this lets irresponsible dog owners off the hook.

Mantlemoose · 17/09/2021 10:17

You're not unreasonable at all. I never have dogs on lead around humans as dogs aren't interested. I do have to put them on leads for other irresponsible dog owners who let their dogs run riot as mine don't like other dogs. I do sometimes have issues with kids wanting to cuddle or clap them and that's a pain. Moral of the story is train dogs and kids!

Dillyjones72 · 17/09/2021 10:11

‘ I hate people who say you should work on your child's fear.’

Why? Why on earth would you not given that dogs are a common occurrence that the child will see daily? Is it better just to leave her terrified of all dogs, let her grow up into an adult who’s afraid of dogs, and then pass that fear on to her own kids one day??
It’s one of those ‘life skills’ that adults need to teach their kids - how to be around dogs, how to be wary but not afraid etc.
If I had a kid afraid of the dark I would help them with that fear - I wouldn’t just leave them to it then rant everytime they We’re in a situation where lights are off.

Dillyjones72 · 17/09/2021 10:06

@vivainsomnia I’m with you, I think there’s deffo a measure of exaggeration in the original post. We’re in a neighbourhood with a lot of parks and a lot of dogs and a lot of schools, kids etc and I’ve yet to witness so appalling behaviour en masse from dogs/dog owners…

vivainsomnia · 17/09/2021 09:42

I'm surprised you didn't mention there were signs saying dogs should be on lead in you first posts considering that's the most relevant bit of info. Sorry, call me cynical but I can't help wondering whether that really is the case, especially if that many dogs happened not to be in such a short time.

I'm also a bit dubious that the dogs were that close to you jumping and barking as that's very unusual behaviour. Coming close to smell the food, yes. Ju.ling and barking, no, unless you started shooing them away aggressively.

In any case, if it is really true that the area is clearly stated as dogs on lead, the dog owners were totally in the wrong.

And the number of dogs who are treated like children, and then act accordingly
Honestly, what business it is of yours to judge?

I don't agree with the way some mum dress their babies to look like older children, or pierce their ears when very little, but that's none of my business and it's up to them how they treat their baby. If some people want to treat their dog like kids, who are you to consider this wrong?

PineappleWilson · 17/09/2021 09:29

The answer to "but he's friendly" is "I'm not - get him away from me now" with a Paddington stare. My DD is jumpy around dogs because she's 3, and many of them are chest height in comparison to her. It's like you being introduced to an excitable Shetland pony. She needs space to get used to the thing coming towards her because we don't have dogs so she's not used to them. "Being friendly" doesn't cut it.

MrsRobbieHart · 17/09/2021 09:28

@charlestonchaplin

Feed them. Feed them unidentifiable food from plain bags, like freezer bags, so the owners have no idea what you’re feeding their dog. The more responsible ones will quickly call their dogs away. Expecting people to be decent and inconvenience themselves a smidgeon for your benefit is a waste of time. If you don’t fight fire with fire, you will always be the victim, having to endure patronising lectures from selfish dog owners about overcoming fear.
This.

And announce loudly “oh I have special food for off lead dogs” and refuse to tell the owner what it is. Grin

I love dogs, I am a dog owner. Have zero patience for out of control dogs.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 17/09/2021 09:24

And by the way extendable leads are really dangerous, you can trip people up. Short leads or canicross style, please.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 17/09/2021 09:23

@PixieLaLa

I think your energy would be better spent helping DD over come her fear of dogs. It’s not practical to expect that all dogs she meets are going to be on leads/not run up to her (especially in a park!)

DD will be picking up on your emotion too if your feeling tense/nervous/annoyed when you see dogs off leads approaching so I would try not to react at all or in a positive way.

But it should be. Dog owners should have their dogs on short leads unless they have 100% recall. Why is it ok to let your dogs run up to other people? Keep hold of them.

Lockdown has resulted in squillions of new dog owners, I doubt that anyone will be able to avoid them well quite. Even in offices Angry

Dillyjones72 · 17/09/2021 09:15

The reality is parks, beaches, woods etc are shared spaces and you’re DD isn’t going to be able to avoid dogs, so you need to work with her to get over her fear. And I say that as a parent who has a kid who was terrified of dogs after a big, muddy out of control
Dog jumped all over us in the park one day while it’s useless owner stood there like a lemon. She used to get hysterical at the sight of a dog anywhere near her, which quite frankly was completely impractical.

It took time, and a lot of patience, but not only is she no longer afraid of dogs but is happy to see them for the most part.

Mediumred · 17/09/2021 00:30

Oh, this is awful. I have a youngish puppy and I won’t let her off the leash as I fear this situation and I want to be a responsible dog owner. I am working with the puppy on a long lead, I suppose the time will come when I will risk her off lead but if a situation like this happened then I would be so apologetic and she would be back on the long lead until I felt I could try again. I don’t think you or your daughter should have to moderate your behaviour, it’s up to dog owners to train their dogs.

JassyRadlett · 17/09/2021 00:21

The thing with having a kid who’s scared of dogs is that you do a lot of careful, patient work to help them to overcome their fear and then some twat of a dog owner lets their darling rush up to your kid, jump up at them and bark, trilling ineffectually that ‘they’re friendly really!’. And so you’re back to square fucking one while sanctimonious twits tell you that you really should help your kid overcome their fear. Rinse, lather repeat. He’s ok with them now but it would have been faster and easier without chocolate teapot dog owners with a worse sense of boundaries than their dogs have.

I grew up around dogs and love them, so it’s been particularly annoying to have a child scared of them; the fact he was scared of them in the first place was because of being barked at and jumped on. Tbh when you’re three feet tall, being scared of something that can jump higher than you are tall, can knock you flat, barks in your face and has sharp teeth is incredibly rational.

Littlescottiedog · 17/09/2021 00:10

@Skyla2005

Accidents can happen. I was over the park with my dog and he ran round the corner out of sight before I knew it he was upon a family eating fish and chips as a picnic on the grass and he ate lots of their food They were very understanding about it
😲 I hope you offered to pay for their food!

A dog came to me on a narrow woodland path the other day. It had a fluorescent green collar with the word FRIENDLY on it in black. Sorry, but a) that doesn't give you the right to allow your dog to approach strangers and jump up and b) it's still an animal with the ability to hurt a human in certain situations.

DroopyClematis · 17/09/2021 00:02

My daughter was knocked over and mauled by a German shepherd , trying to be 'friendly' when she was 3.
She became terrified of dogs.
We decided to work on this as we knew , full well, that she couldn't hide away from dogs as there were so many around.

23 years later , she is besotted with dogs and has a wonderful affinity with them.
We now own a large breed ourselves.

Lockdown has resulted in squillions of new dog owners, I doubt that anyone will be able to avoid them.

My solution to you would be to talk about dogs and their behaviour to your child .
In the meantime too, continue to have your picnics and the next time a dog comes over, say ' I hope you don't mind if we give your dog chocolate or salted herrings ( or other dangerous foods for dogs) then watch how quickly the owners remove their pampered pooches.

Meatshake · 16/09/2021 23:59

Just tell the owner that the dog has grabbed and eaten a bag of chocolate raisins so they might need to get it checked out at the vet 🤣🤣 that'll get rid of them sharpish!

shrodingersbiscuit · 16/09/2021 23:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

Softfresh · 16/09/2021 23:43

@Dillyjones72 So because you haven't personally experienced something it can't be true? Other posters have expressed similar experiences in this thread so this sort of behaviour seems to be the norm these days with all the untrained lockdown dogs.

I dont see how 3 separate groups of people out walking dogs in a park is like a cartoon fairy story? It was you with the dog wasn't it? Grin

OP posts:
Softfresh · 16/09/2021 23:32

@Blueeilidh The best part was when she told DD to hide her sandwiches because food makes her dog excited. The absolute cf!

OP posts:
Pinkchocolate · 16/09/2021 23:32

I’m a dog owner and I agree, dogs should only be off lead in areas that are safe for them and people. I was petrified of dogs growing up. When I got to about ten my parents took me to see a puppy and I fell in love with him, we took him home and seeing him grow up made me eventually comfortable around dogs.

Dillyjones72 · 16/09/2021 23:29

That’s some bad luck you’ve had with dogs. I’ve never experienced anything close to what you w described… dozens of out of control dogs with owners who don’t give a damn.
Jumping up, barking, trying to grab your food… from a table, almost like dogs in a cartoon or a fairy story…

Blueeilidh · 16/09/2021 23:22

As a dog owner I would absolutely not let my dog approach people at a picnic bench

onlychildhamster · 16/09/2021 23:19

I never used to be afraid of dogs and actually was quite fond of them. But then I moved to the UK and started living in zone 3 where every second person has a dog. Was waiting in my communal garden the other day for a delivery and someone's dog jumped onto me. Was quite a large dog too. Said owner was gallivanting around our communal garden, not keeping an eye on his dog.

My DH is a director of our residents company and I know that people's pets are precious to them and so I would never object to people's request to have dogs in our development (we must be one of the few purpose built flat blocks around which allow dogs including in second floor apartments). Plus I don't want even more Londoners to be pushed out of London just because they need a private garden for their dog. But at times like this, I wish our block wasn't so pet friendly!

It's not just about children being fearful of dogs, I don't understand why it's ok for dogs to jump onto strangers going about their business. If children were jumping onto random adults and licking them, the parents would be horrified. But for dog owners, it's kinda like - aww bless him, he likes you.

Softfresh · 16/09/2021 23:07

@Doveyouknow I completely agree. Irresponsible dog owners give your child the fear in the first place then tell you to "train" your child to be less afraid. I don't blame DD for being afraid when her interactions with dogs have been unpleasant.

How about they just keep their dog away from other people's personal space? You don't have to like dogs or be comfortable with dogs if you don't want to be regardless of how "friendly" they are. Just because you love them doesn't mean everyone else has to.

I like dogs but I only tend to visit outdoor spaces with leash restrictions because I don't particularly want to interact with other people's dogs. Not even these places are safe anymore.

OP posts:
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 16/09/2021 23:03

The ‘accidents will happen’ comment above. That’s not a bloody ‘accident’! You let the dog off it’s lead and let it run out of sight! Own your mistakes, please!

Swipe left for the next trending thread