Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another Dog one

107 replies

Softfresh · 16/09/2021 15:04

Took DD to the park today for a picnic lunch and a play after. I have no problem with dogs personally but DD is absolutely terrified of them.

We sat down at the picnic tables and within the space of 5-10 minutes, 3 different groups of people with 8-10 dogs between them decided it was okay to let their dogs pound up to us, off lead and jump and bark all around us. It's okay though because "they're friendly" why do people think this is okay? I don't mind dogs but I still don't want them jumping all over me when I'm eating lunch!

Every time this happened, I told them that DD was afraid of dogs. The first 2 groups were reasonable enough and took the dogs away after a few jumps and barks at us. DD was on edge by this point but I tried my best to calm her down.

Then a mother and daughter approach with yet another 2 dogs, running around our feet, jumping and barking. I explained that DD was scared so asked if she could move the dog. Of course her dog was friendly and wouldn't harm her Angry by this point DD was practically on top of the table trying to get away from them! The woman then decided to tell DD that her dog gets excited when it sees food so she should hide her sandwiches! Wtf! At this point I had enough and told her sternly to move her dog and let us eat our lunch. I've already told her DD doesn't like dogs, she seemed pretty offended by my sharp tone.

Aibu to expect dog owners to keep their animals under control around people eating lunch? Why do these dog lovers think everyone must love their dogs as much as they do? I had to pack up and take DD elsewhere to eat and she spent the rest of the time completely on edge so our lovely afternoon was ruined by selfish rude people Angry Rant over!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pigsDOfly · 18/09/2021 20:36

Because the vast majority of people are not scared and don't mind dogs going to them.

Really, how do you know that, have you researched it?

I'm not at all scared of dogs, I have one of my own but I very much dislike it when dogs run up to me and start jumping around me or my dog.

In fact it happened this afternoon when I was out walking my dog.

Out of control, off the lead puppy. It wasn't aggressive, it was young and playful but the owner couldn't get it to recall, and l didn't want its muddy paws all over me.

Laiste · 18/09/2021 16:57

None of our family is afraid of dogs - but how bloody annoying is it when owners have no re call of their dogs IN PLACES WHERE THEY SHOULDN'T BE OFF THE BLOODY LEAD IN THE FIRST PLACE.

On holiday this year (UK) we had at least one wet sandy dog run straight across our blankets, shake and head towards the food bags every damn day.

''Oooh Fluffy, no! Oh Fluffy! Fluffy! Fluffy! No Fluffy! Oh come back Fluffy! Oh sorry, sorry!''

Fluffy is doing what it fucking likes as usual i presume, and all the posturing and shouting from meters away is having no effect.

Fluffy finally leaves and yes we're pissed off but we're trying not to make a big deal of it.

That is not any kind of recall! Also that is not ''people not minding'' your dog, it's people not wanting a confrontation and hoping you and your dog will just fuck off asap.

JassyRadlett · 18/09/2021 16:06

A dog running up to people is hardly out of control.

If it doesn’t return when you call it, it’s not under control.

So either you’re not bothering to try to control it, because you can’t be arsed and think other people should be happy to have your dog bouncing around them (possibly setting back their attempts to help their child to get over their fear, possibly not welcoming your dog, possibly thrilled to have your dog running up), which makes you a bit arrogant.

Or you can’t control it, which is technically against the law. You wouldn’t be prosecuted for it, but the letter of the law is pretty clear.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 18/09/2021 14:13

That means it should not be allowed to run up to people,

A dog running up to people is hardly out of control.

JassyRadlett · 18/09/2021 13:48

Because the vast majority of people are not scare and don't mind dogs going to them.

That is a pisspoor excuse for letting your dog run up to random strangers - ‘most of them don’t mind’.

Softfresh · 18/09/2021 12:46

@aquashiv What's your point? You haven't and I have, have you even read my replies?

My daughter is afraid of dogs because of irresponsible dog owners and bad experiences with dogs. Not only on this day but multiple times in the past. Where did I mention I had anxiety? I have mentioned multiple times that I like dogs, I just don't like them annoying me when I'm eating lunch. I also don't want them jumping around my clearly nervous DD regardless of how friendly they are, this will only exasperate her fear not help her deal with it.

If we wanted to interact with animals, we would visit a petting zoo or somewhere that doesn't have leash restrictions. It's a shame that all the irresponsible owners give all the good owners a bad name. Next time It happens I'm going to start licking and jumping all over the owner, see how they bloody like it.

OP posts:
PumpkinsGalore · 18/09/2021 12:35

@Softfresh Sounds like you need to get your daughter some therapy! Regardless of whether you should 'have' to, you obviously enjoy going places where there happens to also be many dogs. Therefore it would be beneficial to her, for you to help her with her fear.

aquashiv · 18/09/2021 12:01

I've never had that many dogs come up to me even with a whistle and a treat.
Think your daughter might be picking up on your anxiety.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 18/09/2021 09:38

My DD (now 19) was terrified of dogs .
We couldn't find out why for ages . She was sent flying by an over excited boxer in the snow when she was nearly 2yo but she didn't remember that .

Eventually , she had a fear of their breath and spit .
So people saying "Oh he's friendly he'll lick you to death...." Not helping Wink
Nor was "Oh get her a puppy"

Her brother is a DogMagnet , he was power leaned and wrapped by 4 greyhounds in the park and bloody loved it .

It was a long slog , mainly avoiding parks , going places we knew were quieter , ignoring dogs if they were near .
99% dog owners were great and read our body language so drew their dogs away .
Then she went to friends' houses with dogs and found out they weren't demons.
She doesn't like dogs but a healthy avoidance works for her .

Devastatedyetagain · 18/09/2021 08:51

It is actually a legal requirement to keep your dog under control at all times. That means it should not be allowed to run up to people, try to steal food or jump all over them. Why do people think it is their right to inflict their badly behaved dog on everyone else? It is simple, if you cannot control your dog when it is loose, keep it on a lead. We see this time and time again and it will get worse during lambing season.

I don't hate dogs, just irresponsible owner s.

ModerateOven · 18/09/2021 08:43

Just tell the owner that the dog has grabbed and eaten a bag of chocolate raisins so they might need to get it checked out at the vet

That's inspired. I might use that on a local who brings her dog with her to lunch in the pub garden. Telling her I'm allergic to dogs hasn't worked in her keeping it away from me. Maybe that might.

ModerateOven · 18/09/2021 08:30

I stupidly assumed that the owners would be able to read the signs that stated dogs must be kept on a lead

One of our local beaches is designated as a dog free zone, with several notices at regular intervals. There are always off lead dogs on there. What can you do? The owners do what they like, sod the rest of us.

Peaplant20 · 18/09/2021 08:29

@PixieLaLa

lockdownmadnessdotcom

PixieLaLa
I think your energy would be better spent helping DD over come her fear of dogs. It’s not practical to expect that all dogs she meets are going to be on leads/not run up to her (especially in a park!)

But it should be. Dog owners should have their dogs on short leads unless they have 100% recall. Why is it ok to let your dogs run up to other people? Keep hold of them.

“100% recall” Oh give over, could say the same about other people’s kids running up to other people/dogs, equally not ok but MN loves a dog bashing thread 🙄

Agreed! Little kids love running up to our dogs. I usually have to warn parents that spaniel has been swimming and covered in mud. If little kids always run up to dogs it’s difficult for dogs to learn it’s not ok to go over.

I agree with another PP - basically it’s not practical to expect dogs to always be on the lead unless they have 100% recall. It SHOULD be the case but in reality it isn’t and I don’t think that is going to change.

ModerateOven · 18/09/2021 08:20

I wouldn't have to teach her to be less afraid if dog owners hadn't allowed them to jump her in the first place

This. I grew up with a family dog and only became afraid of them after my elder brother was bitten twice by random dogs for no apparent reason, and then I was bitten by a neighbour's dog who charged through their open gate as I walked by with my mother. Not being afraid was my default position until actual experience taught me that was was not a good default position.

vivainsomnia · 18/09/2021 07:44

Why is it ok to let your dogs run up to other people? Keep hold of them
Because the vast majority of people are not scare and don't mind dogs going to them.

MN is full of people scared of dogs or dislike them for some odd reason but it doesn't reflect on the reality. I have one friend scared of dogs due to being bitten as a kid. She's an outdoor person and yet can only report to maybe one in a couple of years incident when she felt uncomfortable with a dog getting to close to her.

Most dogs will approach and do nothing. The youngest ones might jump and indeed, this shouldn't happen and owners should tackle this so it doesn't happen, but in most cases, dogs are not badly behave then kids.

My real pet hate and that gives me the rage is dog shit everywhere. There is no excuse whatsoever for living shit on paths or anywhere people might walk. It's pure selfishness and lazziness.

PixieLaLa · 17/09/2021 17:09

lockdownmadnessdotcom

PixieLaLa
I think your energy would be better spent helping DD over come her fear of dogs. It’s not practical to expect that all dogs she meets are going to be on leads/not run up to her (especially in a park!)

But it should be. Dog owners should have their dogs on short leads unless they have 100% recall. Why is it ok to let your dogs run up to other people? Keep hold of them.

“100% recall” Oh give over, could say the same about other people’s kids running up to other people/dogs, equally not ok but MN loves a dog bashing thread 🙄

PixieLaLa · 17/09/2021 16:58

lockdownmadnessdotcom

PixieLaLa
I think your energy would be better spent helping DD over come her fear of dogs. It’s not practical to expect that all dogs she meets are going to be on leads/not run up to her (especially in a park!)

But it should be. Dog owners should have their dogs on short leads unless they have 100% recall. Why is it ok to let your dogs run up to other people? Keep hold of them.

“100% recall” Oh give over, could say the same about other people’s kids running up to other people/dogs, equally not ok but MN loves a dog bashing thread 🙄

Peaplant20 · 17/09/2021 16:20

I don’t think you’re unreasonable but I agree with PPs that it would be worth trying to work on the fear of dogs with your daughter as they are going to be impossible to avoid all of her life. Do you know someone with a small, calm dog that could come over and do it in a controlled way? I also agree with PP that if you go somewhere dogs are allowed off lead then unfortunately this is going to be unavoidable and perhaps go somewhere dogs have to be on lead or somewhere unlikely they will be off lead! I’ve seen children’s parks where there are specific picnic areas fenced in that dogs aren’t allowed in maybe see if there is one near you? Or there’s a park near me that has picnic tables towards the road side of the park so it would be unlikely dogs would be off lead there.

vivainsomnia · 17/09/2021 15:28

In my town, most parks have areas where dogs e to be on the lead and others where they don't. The latter have play areas and picnic tables too.

It is really bad luck that within 10mns, you had three groups with dogs off lead in an area where dogs are expected to be, and that happened to be poorly trained.

That or you live in an area where rules don't mean anything.

Softfresh · 17/09/2021 12:36

@DontWiltMySpinachPlease Welcome to the Internet. You will be hard pushed to find a thread that hasn't been done to death. If it bothers you so much you know what to do. Wink

I do believe that most of these irresponsible dog owners are genuinely blind to the issues they cause so if reading one of these dog threads can help open the eyes of at least one of them, it's worth it.

I don't see why using the park more than someone gives them free reign to do whatever they want with their animals? We should all be respectful of other users and their personal space. I wonder what the reaction would be if DD was running feral around other people trying to steal their food and jump all over them because she "only wants to play"

OP posts:
IntermittentParps · 17/09/2021 12:17

@Dillyjones72

‘The signs regarding dogs on a leash is the norm in play parks and picnic areas where I live.’

Never come across this ever. Dogs on leads signs around here tend to be out in the fields where there’s livestock. None of the parks in our city ask that dogs be leashed.
Not in my home town either. Although we do have ‘dog beaches’ during the summer restricting dogs to certain areas between May-Sept.
the thing is with parks - dog owners use the parks EVERY single day regardless of weather, 2/3 times a day. So have just as much right to access, and exercise for their dogs, as people who picnic or use the parks mainly in the summer and better weather.

Why do you think it matters that you've never come across dogs on leads signs? Confused They exist where the OP is, so people should pay attention to them.

the thing is with parks - dog owners use the parks EVERY single day regardless of weather, 2/3 times a day. So have just as much right to access, and exercise for their dogs, as people who picnic or use the parks mainly in the summer and better weather.
Not sure why you emphasise the weather so much (is there a moral high ground in going outside regardless of weather that I don't know about?). And the OP isn't saying people don't have the right to access the park and exercise their dogs, just that there are clear areas where off-lead is OK and where it isn't, which people should follow.
Cop on to yourself, eh.

Dillyjones72 · 17/09/2021 11:30

‘The signs regarding dogs on a leash is the norm in play parks and picnic areas where I live.’

Never come across this ever. Dogs on leads signs around here tend to be out in the fields where there’s livestock. None of the parks in our city ask that dogs be leashed.
Not in my home town either. Although we do have ‘dog beaches’ during the summer restricting dogs to certain areas between May-Sept.
the thing is with parks - dog owners use the parks EVERY single day regardless of weather, 2/3 times a day. So have just as much right to access, and exercise for their dogs, as people who picnic or use the parks mainly in the summer and better weather.

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 17/09/2021 11:09

Has this not been done to death? Do you really need help to figure out if people not controlling their dogs are unreasonable?? Seriously!

FGS, no responsible dog owner should let their dog approach strangers, let alone jump up at them or ignore your requests to ask them to stop simply because "they're friendly" but you know that.

What a pointless thread.

Softfresh · 17/09/2021 10:59

@Moonface123 I like dogs, they don't bother me, as does DH. I like a to give them a pat if the owner allows it. It's the actions of dogs that has caused this. Of course we do our best to reassure her but incidents like this seem to be happening more and more recently. Every time it happens we are back to square 1.

OP posts:
Moonface123 · 17/09/2021 10:54

Is she feeding off your anxiety ?
If you try and remain calm that may help her.
I am lucky that my dog wants to avoid people and other dogs, she just has her nose to the ground, but when it comes to food she is greedy.