Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there must be something wrong with me that I can't seem to meet somebody?

140 replies

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 11:59

I'm a young (late 20s) healthy and fit woman. I have many hobbies, don't want to say too much as could be outing I suppose (long time reader first time poster) but they are very active. I guess I can say I'm running a marathon in a couple of weeks and it's not my first, I have a high powered job making more than twice the UK median salary and I own a flat in Zone 2 London (mortgaged) and a car. I actively volunteer and am part of several other organisation/group type things.

All my family is overseas so I am very independent, but I have a fabulous group of friends. If they are busy, I travel alone with my pet or go somewhere abroad to run a race myself but travel in groups with them (prepandemic) so am hardly sitting around waiting for a man.

But I've also put a lot of effort into trying to meet someone. I've asked to be set up, and gone the few times friends have set me up on dates. I've been on the apps for years with horrible, awful results. I even tried speed dating recently (also bloody awful). I don't just mean that I felt the men weren't good-looking enough for me or something shallow like under 6ft tall, I mean they were unable to make a conversation for even 4 minutes, barely spoke English so we just couldn't communicate, vastly age inappropriate despite the event parameters, extraordinarily unfit (so incompatible lifestyles), etc. I even asked out a colleague (would be inappropriate except he said he's leaving the job now) who is the only person who I've met in person and found attractive and know to be employed etc but although he said an enthusiastic yes at first when I tried to get a specific time/day out of him he's backed off. I don't get it.

Obviously, many people have had bad experiences online, but most of mine have been exceptionally bad. I mean, racial abuse and an actual sexual assault. So I have given up that. My last ex of about a year was a setup from a friend and what you'd all call a cocklodger, and an emotionally abusive one at that. He abruptly dumped me in a very abusive way on the day the rumours of the lockdown started (he called his mum to get him while I was out of the flat!).

I don't think I deserved any of that! I'm a very caring person in addition to being very 'together'. My only 'drawback' is that I have depression, but it is well managed. I see a private consultant (at high cost) and take my medication and do exercise, eat well, sleep regularly, etc and it doesn't really inhibit anything. Obviously, I sound negative right now, but I'm not a particularly negative person. I'm considered a pretty funny (somewhat dry) person.

I really don't know what else I'm meant to do at this point. I am happy to spend time by myself, but I am getting lonely now. I do a lot of things, as I said, work and volunteering and hobbies, but since the pandemic my social life hasn't returned to normal. I am reaching out to friends but the coupled up ones have retreated into their couples and are only spending time with each other or travelling together, and I'm excluded. We don't go to the theatre anymore. Even my running club doesn't meet regularly anymore. I used to be out almost 5 nights a week, out more often than not, now I'm often home alone on a given night and I recently did a domestic weeklong holiday (I know, this isn't a 'staycation') and I ended up going myself because I couldn't get a friend to come. Later I found out online that the very day I left this UK beauty spot, a group of my slightly older and coupled up friends went to the exact same place. They knew I was going there alone and not by choice and didn't even tell me. I would have loved to go with them, or even just meet that day as I left and they came for dinner or something, but no. I was so hurt.

Sorry this is so long. I just feel like honestly, when I open up to people about this in real life they tell me I have so much going for me. I objectively have a great job and am a high achiever, I am fairly attractive and fit, I am 'successful' and interesting, I'm independent and not looking for someone to take care of me and have no kids and don't need anyone's money or anything. I just want someone to go away with me for the weekend, go out for dinner after work, maybe even cheer me on at the finish line and hold my jacket. Is that really unattainable?

Is there something I'm not trying that I should be?

I know it's long, I don't want to drip feed.

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 17:44

@RandomLondoner thank you for your response.

The main issue with my busyness in the past has actually been that I’ve felt guilty when stepping out the door to go for a running club thing because I knew my boyfriend or the guy I was seeing at the time was going to just sit around at home (and not, god forbid, make a start on dinner or anything useful). Literally he would just be sitting on my sofa playing on his phone the whole time. So I felt I had to get back, couldn’t linger at the pub after, I’d invite him to meet me there but he said he didn’t want to although he was welcome and other people’s partners did.

I just want to know they have their own stuff going on - their own passion and hobby. I am actually really not looking for another marathon runner, I don’t really want to run together, I am happy for you to go play golf Saturday mornings while I run and then we go out together in the evening (or stay in).

Yeah, I think it comes down to needing to meet more and better men!

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 17:39

@MatildaIThink ok so I am Jewish, and I am also an atheist. I have found compared to America fewer people here are familiar with or have met Jewish people and this is not understood. I have also encountered more blatant antisemitism here and I would prefer to avoid that so I put it on my profile for that reason. I am culturally Jewish, spiritually agnostic I would say. This is common for us but not necessarily other religions. By that I mean I attend synagogue and observe holidays but not every edict, like I don’t eat pork but I do eat cheeseburgers, and I worked today on the holiest day of the year (and skipped breakfast but didn’t fast) and went to services last night but won’t tonight. It seems totally arbitrary, because it is. I do what I want because it makes me happy. Much of my volunteering is associated with the religious organisation, but it is not compelled by religion, it is just a community thing for me. When I moved to this country alone I knew nobody and it was a way to instantly have some people around to welcome me. I do not need to date a Jewish man and especially as I don’t want children it’s not important and my family couldn’t care less (and I wouldn’t care if they did). In some ways it would be more complicated to date someone Jewish, because the varied levels of faith and observance would make us less likely to be compatible. But by not mentioning it upfront I’ve ended up on dates with someone who’s said something blatantly racist and felt uncomfortable, as much as it sucks to get messages about how “sexy and exotic” Jewish girls are (I’m from the suburbs…) I’d rather have it online than in person where I can’t block and report them. If they are a bigot or are going to mind that at least 2x a month I’m going to light some candles or something they should self select out. Does that make sense?

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 16/09/2021 17:36

I'm a man, but not a potential candidate, for several reasons that all reflect on my availability and eligibility, rather than yours. I just wanted to to give another vote that there's nothing wrong with you.

I think you need to find a way to meet more and better men, but I don't know the answer to how you do that.

I agree with DrSbaitso's point that many of the things you are rightfully proud of don't necessarily matter much to a man looking for a partner. Having said that, they are part of a picture of an intelligent high-functioning person, who is attractive for that reason, so they're not completely irrelevant. If you were writing a comprehensive advert for yourself, I wouldn't leave them out.

The fact that you have such a full life is a bit exhausting to contemplate. It's not clear if your busyness would be a positive or negative factor. It would be negative if it made a lot of demands on my time and energy, but it could mean you are so busy with your own things that you are very low maintenance. Overall, it wouldn't be put me off wanting to find out if thinks could work, so I don't think you need to hide or downplay this.

Usually the problem with someone in your situation is that they have very high expectations, or are very demanding, but you don't seem like that at all.

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 17:33

@CreepingDeath depressingly, bad news on both counts! My bad ex was introduced to me by a friend. But she only barely knew him. They met at an Extinction Rebellion protest. While I’m pro-planet not burning down this isn’t really my thing so I wasn’t there. She randomly texted me that she wanted to set me up with someone. I asked if she just met him on the street and she said no, it was at the protest. I said “So it was on the street, then.” Unfortunately he was both very attractive and charming and had just finished his MA so I thought she might be into something. And he did take me in a formal dinner date which went really well. Unfortunately, it went south fairly fast. I guess she didn’t know him that well. Unfortunately I haven’t been set up again although I keep asking, everyone insists they don’t have any single friends.

I also had a short fling with someone in my running club. This was a mistake. He too was very attractive though not my usual type, a little bit younger but in a profession I admire (a civic duty not well paid but good for society type one). I had no idea he was chatting me up for weeks - I thought we were becoming friends. One day he basically said exactly that to me, “I’ve been chatting you up for weeks.” I said it wasn’t a good idea, it’s a small closely-knit group, it would ruin the whole group dynamic, etcetera. He basically wore me down insisting it wouldn’t be awkward, he really really liked me, he wanted something real with me. But he got in my knickers and then abruptly dumped me. And it was horribly awkward. It had been a “secret” but I got very ill (I actually think he gave me glandular fever…) and the whole group came over to my flat to drop off a care package, and they couldn’t find my address. He was the one who said “Oh, it’s over there.” So everyone cottoned on. It was after he had dumped me. I found out a while later. I was embarrassed and hurt and angry with him because I hadn’t thought it was a good idea in the first place but he had been relentless. I was pretty cold to him for awhile so he stayed away and went to a different chapter and years later he has a girlfriend I think I’ve never met her, he’s not a friend and we barely speak but at least it’s not as awkward for me. I would never do this again though.

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 16/09/2021 17:27

@Ratatwat

I actually have never used Tinder Smile I have tried OkCupid (worst) and Hinge and Bumble. Hinge, very little activity, Bumble, hundreds of matches a week if not thousands but almost none replied to me within the window (I tried everything from just “hi” to referencing their profile to gifs to a joke, it made no difference). I am willing to try! I’ve always naturally steered clear of the hottest guys, inherently suspicious of them, like how poisonous snakes are brightly coloured I guess Grin.

Maybe I just needed to hear that I should keep trying. I did honestly get very worn down by the “I’ve always wanted to fuck a [minority religion] girl” messages and the “what else do you ride?” but I could try doing it for no more than 20 minutes an evening while I make dinner or something? (And drink)

When you say minority religion, is that a big thing to you, the religion? Is it on your profile? I am just wondering if some men might self limit as they think that someone of X religion would only want to date someone else of the same religion, where as most people these days aren't religious.
CreepingDeath · 16/09/2021 17:22

I think you sound lovely OP. Depressingly, I think it's true that many men are intimidated by a woman who has her shit together - at your age many of them won't be as accomplished and may not want to feel inferior.

How did you meet your last boyfriend? Do you have any male friends you could ask honestly for feedback. I hesitate to say that even because it's not like you are really doing anything 'wrong' as such, you just haven't met any good matches for you. Or you could ask male friends if they know anyone you would be interested in, that way they would come with a recommendation Grin.

Also, I do think culturally there is a bit of a difference, my impression of the US was dating was more formal (going steady vs. not) whereas in the UK I think it's much more relaxed (drunken fumble in the pub), but I could be wrong.

If you are a runner, are there any men there that interest you, at least you would have a shared interest. Quite honestly, not wanting kids means the time pressure is off, which is great.

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 17:12

And just to add @junebirthdaygirl thank you - I do have counselling thanks for the wise reminder, I’m in a running club but our meetings and attendance have dropped off and I was thinking about another one.

I have a horse riding club too which seems to be 100% female Grin and suspect horse riding events will be about the same except for the reluctant husbands who are driving the lorries and taking photos. Never hurts to continue doing more of these which I am always looking for as I love them. Next competition the week before the marathon, here’s hoping I don’t fall off, that would be shite.

I’ll have a think about any other activities I might be able to join when I can free up some of the training time in a couple of weeks.

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 17:08

I actually have never used Tinder Smile I have tried OkCupid (worst) and Hinge and Bumble. Hinge, very little activity, Bumble, hundreds of matches a week if not thousands but almost none replied to me within the window (I tried everything from just “hi” to referencing their profile to gifs to a joke, it made no difference). I am willing to try! I’ve always naturally steered clear of the hottest guys, inherently suspicious of them, like how poisonous snakes are brightly coloured I guess Grin.

Maybe I just needed to hear that I should keep trying. I did honestly get very worn down by the “I’ve always wanted to fuck a [minority religion] girl” messages and the “what else do you ride?” but I could try doing it for no more than 20 minutes an evening while I make dinner or something? (And drink)

OP posts:
Shelddd · 16/09/2021 17:01

Only messaging the hottest guys on online dating apps is a challenging way to go about it though. The hottest 2-5% of guys are dating and sleeping with the top 20-25% of females on apps on the regular, they aren't getting off the apps and they aren't into monogamy.

If you're trying to filter guys, you're better off trying to find guys who are new to the app and online dating in general. The worst person you can go on a date with is a guy who is a serial online dater. You can spot them because their profiles are quite polished, their messages are quite engaging.

It's almost better to find the dull guy with the average profile pic (but where you can still tell he is good looking in real life but maybe didn't select the best photo or selected a boring photo).

Any guy with a profile that's really engaging is a serial online dater, their profile is so good because they've refined it from years of online dating.

Gorl · 16/09/2021 16:59

You honestly sound great. I would date you!

I think a large part of the problem is honestly that 90% of men are shite, and you have high standards. Which of course isn’t actually a problem at all! I think it just means you will take a little longer to find someone who is suitable and compatible.

I know that’s really frustrating, but I think if you just hang in there your lobster will come.

MatildaIThink · 16/09/2021 16:55

[quote Ratatwat]@MatildaIThink you are absolutely right that I have been told by friends as we walked away from a bar etc “He was flirting with you!” And I had no idea, assumed he was out of my league, it never crossed my mind. This isn’t happening now, as in the situation in which this could potentially happen is not arising. I’m not going out enough to encounter people/people aren’t approaching where this might be a question.[/quote]
Tinder it is then! Pick a few pics of yourself that you really love, write a short, concise accurate profile, eg. interests, that you are looking for dates hopefully leading to a relationship, height (short men will often self filter). Swipe right on all the men you who come up that you like this evening, do the same tomorrow, message the matches and ask the hottest one for a coffee on Saturday and the second hottest one for a coffee on Sunday, if either declines then pick another.

junebirthdaygirl · 16/09/2021 16:53

You sound great and what l always say is
Remember you only need to meet ONE guy as long as he is the right one!:
Could you join horse riders on a holiday solely for that as be your type?
Or take up trekking at weekends with a club as you are in good shape and be well able for it
Or go on a skiing holidays for singles
These all mean meeting outdoor types which is what you need .
Could you get involved with a fundraiser things around running or horse riding to meet new people?
Also l think counselling is always worthwhile as it makes you more confident and helps you come across at your best...when l say you l mean all of us.
Remember the pandemic slowed everything down so things will hopefully start being more exciting again so be more opportunities.
Sometimes forgetting all about meeting someone and just having fun causes things to happen.

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 16:49

@MatildaIThink you are absolutely right that I have been told by friends as we walked away from a bar etc “He was flirting with you!” And I had no idea, assumed he was out of my league, it never crossed my mind. This isn’t happening now, as in the situation in which this could potentially happen is not arising. I’m not going out enough to encounter people/people aren’t approaching where this might be a question.

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 16:47

@LaetitiaASD I don’t think I have a very specific physical type, honestly. The men I have dated have been of varied height, hair and eye colour, body type and ethnicity and religion.

@Freeloadingtosser sorry, I don’t know how to answer your questions fully without it being too much?

I’ve spoken to a couple of male friends of over 15 years about this, one very recently for a long time. One I suspect has had romantic interest previously but now lives in another country with a partner so it feels like safe territory. He says all he can think of is that men find me intimidating. And that thank god he doesn’t have to use the apps as he is dating someone he met at university. He also spoke to me about his relationship issues in that conversation. It was over FaceTime.

It’s entirely possible I’m not filtering well. I am open to advice on how to do this. I have chosen not to use the apps anymore a few weeks ago as they ground me down so much and have been going to speed dating events. At those, naturally the only filter is the age the organisers set. So I can’t predict at all beyond that who comes. If the consensus is I need to give the apps another try (which have worked best?) I will take filtering advice. I’ve obviously tried age, what they are looking for, employment status and education level and lack of children and non smokers and as I have a dog they can’t hate dogs either, seems like a lot of filtering already. The additional filtering could happen on messaging, but in my experience I have spent a long time messaging with people who then flake, I think they don’t think of people as real when they’re just photos on an app. But I am open to advice on this. Chat more, longer? Withhold my mobile number?

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 16/09/2021 16:44

I know people who have a lot of success on Tinder, but you will have to go through a lot of frogs as well The worst was one a friend went on, the man said on his profile he was 32, 5ft 11in and athletic an the pictures he supplied looked like that, in reality he was 40+, 5ft 6in, and 4 stone overweight, or the man with halitosis so bad he could smell it 6ft away, or the man who spent the entire date talking about his love of Jesus, but she also met some lovely men as well and ended up married to one of them.

The other thing might be that you are missing the men who are interested in real life. You sound a bit like my brother in a way, he is successful career wise (earns well into six figures), fit and healthy (he will do a 20k+ walk or jog on a Saturday morning for fun and a 50k bike ride on a Sunday morning "because he got bored), he has a six pack, good teeth etc. all my friends think he is hot (but they are married now). He is a lovely guy, great with kids (almost a second father to my two), very intelligent etc. but he also lacks self esteem when it comes to dating, he will chat with someone and she could be hugely hitting on him and he just does not see it, ending up with a kind of "she was nice to talk to" situation, but missing so many opportunities because he seems to miss the blindingly obvious when it comes to attractive women. So what I am wondering is are you missing it when the attractive guy is hitting on you, are you subconsciously dismissing it because you think he won't really be interested?

How about you create a new Tinder profile (use a fresh one if you have an old one). Swipe right on all the decent men who come up in range, message the ones who match and do the usual first few messages, then ask them if they want to go for a coffee, and go for a coffee with the ones you accept.

Shelddd · 16/09/2021 16:44

In general if you are meeting/dating enough people and just no one comes up that is compatible it means your expectations don't line up with what you have on offer.

But that's not necessarily a bad thing, you might still get what you want if you keep playing the numbers. I honestly feel like I married waay up, it took me 10 years of dating to find someone it actually worked with, probably went on dates with hundreds of people (I guess not that unusual in the online dating world)... I can honestly say this was my only successful relationship.

You really only need to make it work one time as long as you are able to recognize that one is working and not let it go.

Shelddd · 16/09/2021 16:39

Did you have these problems with dating pre pandemic?

Some things do stand out in what you've said so far but honestly none of that matters if you have only really felt this way in last 18 months. This is such an unusual time I don't think I would make any changes based off how you feel about how anything has been for last 18 months.

Were you happy with your life and how things were going dating wise pre pandemic?

RaskolnikovsGarret · 16/09/2021 16:37

You sound wonderful. I think I may leave my husband and date you instead. Smile

I really hope things turn out ok for you. You deserve it. Flowers

LaetitiaASD · 16/09/2021 16:30

Based on your posts the only thing that stands out is "I even asked out a colleague who is the only person who I've met in person and found attractive and know to be employed etc " You might not have ridiculous expectations, but perhaps you have a physical type that's fairly specific, and then you combine that with entirely reasonable requirements like "no lazy unemployed arseholes" and you end up with a pretty small potential dating pool.

Freeloadingtosser · 16/09/2021 16:28

Crossed with your last responses

Freeloadingtosser · 16/09/2021 16:26

Your response was more of this really:

it's just...so much information can feel a bit overloading and intense. A bit floodgatey

Have you asked any close male friends for their honest, unvarnished, opinions? These would need to be close enough friends to be completely candid, but with whom there is no romantic interest at all?

Both my and Dr S's responses were caveated by saying 'I am sure you don't list your positive attributes in conversation, however the only impression we have of you is in your posts and this is how you come across'. You have responded with an even longer list of positive attributes and ways in which you feel you handled situations well.

Not trying to detract from these as you have clearly achieved a lot but it does feel like a bit of a campaign to demonstrate there is nothing you could do differently, rather than a reflection. And there may be some element of this in real life too, trying a bit too hard to sell yourself as a complete product.

Where do you think you might be able to improve things? Could this be at the filtering stage if some men were barely able to hold a conversation?

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 16:25

@Siepie oh thank you for the good clarifying question. I would be happy to go on a date to find out, my issue is that I’m not meeting them or being asked out by them in the first place, hence requiring the engineered situations like apps or events and being excited by the idea of the soon to be ex colleague.

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 16:23

Well, yeah. I have opened the floodgates here. But I am trying to give the full picture, answer and preempt all questions. What I have tried, what I have experienced, and what I am like. If it turned out I had a drug habit and £30,000 of credit card debt you’d probably say “Well, there’s your problem!” But none of that here Smile.

On balance if it helps I am slightly more serious and also more reserved, and sometimes people ask me if I’m ok when I actually am but just deep in thought and I’m surprised they’re asking. I always correct my face, smile and say yes and change the subject if that happens.

But I tend to take more time to open up and share about myself, so particularly on a first date (and speed dating!) all you’ll get is I’m American (accent) and I’ve lived here a few years now, yes I think I like it here, I work in [office job]. That’s all! Not too intense, I promise. Maybe one of my hobbies or pets gets a mention but not much more. Light chat about my day and current events and pop culture if it’s a full drinks date.

Oh and for those who put stock in this sort of thing my personality type is ISTJ (I think it’s bollocks!) and I’m a Leo.

I guess I’m more feeling like it’s just me who is struggling so much recently but a few of the comments upthread have confirmed it’s partially an age thing and partially a pandemic thing and a neighbour friend I was texting today said she thinks London is a lonely place and is feeling how I am and asked me to go out for drinks with her so I will chin up and go. After work and a run Wink.

OP posts:
Siepie · 16/09/2021 16:20

One small thing that stood out to me is this:

the only person who I've met in person and found attractive and know to be employed etc

I’m just wondering whether you’re writing people off too quickly. If you met an attractive stranger, you wouldn’t know if he was employed, if he ran marathons, or anything else. Would you decide not to date due to these unknowns, or would you try a couple of dates to find out?

DrSbaitso · 16/09/2021 16:07

Rereading my previous post, I may have expressed myself badly. It's hard to explain what I mean.

There is just such a lot being given. Again, I realise you're trying to give us a full picture so maybe I am judging it wrong. I'm just saying, from where I'm standing, I'm impressed by your achievements and think they're brilliant, and I'm sure you look great (curls are beautiful). It's just...so much information can feel a bit overloading and intense. A bit floodgatey. I guess that's the best way I can think of to put it. Again, I'm going solely on what's here because that's all I've got.

Also, and I may get flamed for this but in my experience it's true....men don't really care about accomplishment in their partners in the way women do. I don't think it's always that they are intimidated by it or actively dislike it. It can be, of course, but you don't want that kind of guy anyway. I just mean that in my experience, it just isn't something that's especially important to men when seeking partners, in the way it often seems to be for women. Of course a shared interest can be a plus, but things like salaries or sporting achievements just don't seem to be something men filter for the way women do.

If you really want honest feedback, you might do better to ask a forum full of men...