Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there must be something wrong with me that I can't seem to meet somebody?

140 replies

Ratatwat · 16/09/2021 11:59

I'm a young (late 20s) healthy and fit woman. I have many hobbies, don't want to say too much as could be outing I suppose (long time reader first time poster) but they are very active. I guess I can say I'm running a marathon in a couple of weeks and it's not my first, I have a high powered job making more than twice the UK median salary and I own a flat in Zone 2 London (mortgaged) and a car. I actively volunteer and am part of several other organisation/group type things.

All my family is overseas so I am very independent, but I have a fabulous group of friends. If they are busy, I travel alone with my pet or go somewhere abroad to run a race myself but travel in groups with them (prepandemic) so am hardly sitting around waiting for a man.

But I've also put a lot of effort into trying to meet someone. I've asked to be set up, and gone the few times friends have set me up on dates. I've been on the apps for years with horrible, awful results. I even tried speed dating recently (also bloody awful). I don't just mean that I felt the men weren't good-looking enough for me or something shallow like under 6ft tall, I mean they were unable to make a conversation for even 4 minutes, barely spoke English so we just couldn't communicate, vastly age inappropriate despite the event parameters, extraordinarily unfit (so incompatible lifestyles), etc. I even asked out a colleague (would be inappropriate except he said he's leaving the job now) who is the only person who I've met in person and found attractive and know to be employed etc but although he said an enthusiastic yes at first when I tried to get a specific time/day out of him he's backed off. I don't get it.

Obviously, many people have had bad experiences online, but most of mine have been exceptionally bad. I mean, racial abuse and an actual sexual assault. So I have given up that. My last ex of about a year was a setup from a friend and what you'd all call a cocklodger, and an emotionally abusive one at that. He abruptly dumped me in a very abusive way on the day the rumours of the lockdown started (he called his mum to get him while I was out of the flat!).

I don't think I deserved any of that! I'm a very caring person in addition to being very 'together'. My only 'drawback' is that I have depression, but it is well managed. I see a private consultant (at high cost) and take my medication and do exercise, eat well, sleep regularly, etc and it doesn't really inhibit anything. Obviously, I sound negative right now, but I'm not a particularly negative person. I'm considered a pretty funny (somewhat dry) person.

I really don't know what else I'm meant to do at this point. I am happy to spend time by myself, but I am getting lonely now. I do a lot of things, as I said, work and volunteering and hobbies, but since the pandemic my social life hasn't returned to normal. I am reaching out to friends but the coupled up ones have retreated into their couples and are only spending time with each other or travelling together, and I'm excluded. We don't go to the theatre anymore. Even my running club doesn't meet regularly anymore. I used to be out almost 5 nights a week, out more often than not, now I'm often home alone on a given night and I recently did a domestic weeklong holiday (I know, this isn't a 'staycation') and I ended up going myself because I couldn't get a friend to come. Later I found out online that the very day I left this UK beauty spot, a group of my slightly older and coupled up friends went to the exact same place. They knew I was going there alone and not by choice and didn't even tell me. I would have loved to go with them, or even just meet that day as I left and they came for dinner or something, but no. I was so hurt.

Sorry this is so long. I just feel like honestly, when I open up to people about this in real life they tell me I have so much going for me. I objectively have a great job and am a high achiever, I am fairly attractive and fit, I am 'successful' and interesting, I'm independent and not looking for someone to take care of me and have no kids and don't need anyone's money or anything. I just want someone to go away with me for the weekend, go out for dinner after work, maybe even cheer me on at the finish line and hold my jacket. Is that really unattainable?

Is there something I'm not trying that I should be?

I know it's long, I don't want to drip feed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ratatwat · 21/09/2021 10:50

@BookFiend4Life I haven't given it a serious go. At the risk of giving too much information about my thoughts yet again, I was a little intimidated by all the questions about the various permutations of how observant/faithful/etc you can be. I remember there being questions to answer and display (like on Bumble etc for height, age, etc) for how strictly you keep Kosher, what denomination you are, synagogue attendance, etc...the chances of finding someone compatible on even 3/infinity of those seemed extremely unlikely and I would find it very hard to get along with someone stricter than I am on most things. But...I could have another look.

OP posts:
BookFiend4Life · 20/09/2021 23:34

OP apologies if you've answered this already, have you tried JDate or similar? I've heard people on there are generally more interested in relationships than some of the other apps and many people who use it aren't necessarily strongly religious just desirous of a partner with similar cultural experiences and values.

Ratatwat · 20/09/2021 22:54

Yeah @BertramLacey you are probably right, I was a little put off by him when he turned up, but I did make a real concerted effort to hide it and be friendly and polite anyway. I guess it was an option to say actually let's not even go for coffee the minute I saw him but it didn't seem like a nice thing to do. I intended to keep it short and politely inform him immediately after that I didn't want to meet again.

I never spend a moment thinking about IQ except to tell people it's actually a nonsensical (and racist) construct, it was just raised by another poster. I've never told anyone mine and I'm not flashing a Mensa card at anyone either (this is also a flip remark, I have not enquired about joining), don't worry, it does amuse me a little that my parents wanted there to be something wrong with me but the response was 'no she's smart and angry at you for being bad parents' more or less.

I guess I'd rather keep the idiot filter than the alternative. But maybe next time I should cut off the date actually, why should I go through with it making polite conversation when I didn't want to be there either?

OP posts:
BertramLacey · 20/09/2021 19:00

OP I think part of what's going on is you have an excellent filter for idiots and so are automatically rejecting a lot of men. I think puffa jacket man picked up on the rejection at some level - and you can send signals in a few seconds, it doesn't even take minutes. This is a good thing. Despite many people's contention that the world is full of amazing single men and there is someone for everyone, it isn't, and basic demographics would indicate otherwise.

Sadly, I know my IQ because when I was a young teenager my parents got me tested

Don't get too hung up on this. IQ isn't a single definite quantity, or it is, but that doesn't prove what people think. IQ = mental age/ actual age x 100. This relies on there being some kind of average intelligence for each age that is definable and measurable. It's also all well and good when you're 12 and testing as if you're 14, but breaks down if you're 40 and testing as if you're 80. Even if you take IQ as being something definite, it will have changed since you were young.

It was one of my bugbears when watching Scorpion that they would refer to someone as a 168 or a 174. Geniuses should know about the construction of IQ tests, their cultural variability and the ways that scores can be changed with coaching. Apparently that lot didn't.

Ratatwat · 20/09/2021 18:39

Well, a couple of updates, if you find me too verbose you can skip them: I downloaded a dating app Friday, chatted briefly with some not great photos but probably ok guys, asked them for coffee the next morning as advised. One said yes, we both had to leave at noon, I suggested a neighbourhood halfway between us. Went horribly...he turned up late and wearing a puffa coat in the heat and sun, I said shall we walk to the park and grab a coffee en route, less than 2 minutes later at a traffic light he abruptly told me he was leaving. Basically suddenly said "I think you want me to go, I'm going to go," I was quite shocked so I said "I guess if you want to??" and he said "Yeah, I'm going to go," and so I just kept walking on to the park with my dog! That threw me a little bit. He seemed really insecure, had a lot of messages about how he couldn't believe I was talking to him as I'm so pretty blah blah blah I just said thanks you look nice too. No idea what it was about but pretty confident it wasn't anything I did, there wasn't any time!

I enquired at 2 members clubs in London, dog-friendly. Both have replied, one has already scheduled an interview with me.

I directly asked my soon to be ex work colleague if he still wanted a drink, he said yes, I said well ok good and suddenly he said it's just that he HAS A GIRLFRIEND and needs to 'respect the relationship'. The one he's never mentioned until now, not when I asked who he was going away with, not when I first asked him for drinks and he said 'dead keen let's get it booked', not when he suggested I come to his place. That shit is intentional. Fuck off.

I attended the last speed dating event I had booked Saturday (a free ticket for not having matched with anyone - my choice - previously) despite the rough morning date and had several interested, one insisted on getting my number before I left not using the website system. He seems ok. I'll give it a shot, but he's being very difficult about scheduling even factoring in that I'm not that available. I don't find him overly attractive but I know people grow on me for sure, I thought he was a little pushy and is bombarding me with texts yet can't manage either of the two options I've given to meet this week so I don't know. Evidently though at least nothing about my appearance at the event, nails, teeth, conversation or demeanour was that bad.

OP posts:
Ratatwat · 17/09/2021 15:23

@WeCanBeHeronsJustForOneDay To be honest, I didn't really date in the states. I had a high school boyfriend, unserious. I moved to the UK right after graduating uni, I didn't really date in uni (very studious - many extracurriculars as well as some work, and just not a priority). I have now lived here 6+ years and don't think I'm really generally culturally a misfit. Sadly, I know my IQ because when I was a young teenager my parents got me tested for everything to find out if there was something wrong with me because I was so type A, highly strung, never had any fun really. I have never told anyone I even know my IQ, let alone what it is, rather embarrassing that my parents were so upset by my weirdness, it is just depression and anxiety and they probably didn't help by being awful most of the time and having a protracted many year long acrimonious divorce and physically and emotionally abusing me and my sisters, though I got the worst of it. It is not a mystery to me that I moved overseas from them. We have a fine relationship now with distance. I don't believe I'm better than anyone, I believe I am on the whole much more neurotic than most and less able to have fun, less confident, less relaxed, and I don't think I ever come across as rude (I'm often told I'm very polite) I don't have that natural warmth and charm radiating from me that less anxious people do. I'm also aware my academic/work success is a direct result of anxiety; it can lead to a lot of hard work and preparation.

@jay55 Yes I'm really up for that in theory, just need to carve out the time, and pick something, but would like to, anyway. I wanted to take a painting class awhile ago.

@SufferingSailors Thank you. Sorry, long answer with potentially unnecessary detail coming: it is a quirk of my particular synagogue that the membership skews particularly LGBTQ and there really just aren't any straight men my age. There aren't a whole lot of members my age, especially paying ones who regularly attend, this is part of my job to fix in my unpaid volunteer capacity. If anyone there knew anyone they could even theoretically set me up with, they would fall over themselves to do it. People try! A woman wistfully tried to set me up with her son even though he's already dating someone...she isn't Jewish. Haha, but sad, let him be. I would be open to this if it happened, it's just the overengineered JDate/JW3 thing I don't think works for me because if there is a man my age, he is likely to want to marry and have children immediately, alternatively we will have irreconcilable differences about many aspects of observance, etc.

@friendlyflicka thank you so much, that is very kind.

OP posts:
friendlyflicka · 17/09/2021 14:50

I think you sound absolutely superb. Don't change. And don't blame yourself and keep going.

SufferingSailors · 17/09/2021 13:38

If you occasionally attend synagogue would you be able to get set up discreetly with someone? I know you said you'd almost rather not date someone Jewish but it does seem to be a part of your life so it might be worth exploring.

DH is Jewish but culturally Jewish like you but unfortunately we're not in London (and a bit older!) or I'd see if he knew anyone.

I think you sound lovely. I had a friend in a similar position who really despaired of meeting anyone and she did in her mid 30s so I think of her and hope it works out for you.

I guess if kids aren't an issue then at least you don't have the panic of settling and maybe this makes you a bit more fussy? Not that's it's bad to be particular about a life partner but I bet many women do settle because of the biological clock.

jay55 · 17/09/2021 13:17

In my late twenties, before I gave up dating and men in general, I met some lovely chaps through a language class.
It was in central London, the class had people from a bunch of countries and probably half were there to meet people(not in a creepy fucker way) as much as learn the language.

I know you're busy with work and your existing hobbies and 'take an evening class' is an old fashion cliche but it is a way of meeting new people without the pressure of a date.

WeCanBeHeronsJustForOneDay · 17/09/2021 13:17

How long have you lived over here? How did you find dating in the US? I wonder if Americans come across as more direct? That’s probably a massive generalisation/stereotype.

I am reserved/hard to get to know so I completely relate to that aspect. People often have a very different opinion of me once they get to know me.

I had a friend who was gorgeous and got hit on all the time. She was very intelligent but could be very superior and clearly thought she was more intelligent than me and others (she was but you don’t exactly make friends by doing that!) and would tell us her IQ. I’m not saying you would do that! But maybe you can come off as being seen as thinking yourself superior?

FirewomanSam · 17/09/2021 12:17

I also say take any dating ‘advice’ you’re given with a large pinch of salt. People will put a lot of emphasis on which apps are best, and how you should behave on them (leave X days before messaging, let him make the first move, wait X long before meeting up etc etc) but in my experience none of that really matters once you meet the right person.

I met my husband on the crappiest free dating platform but his message stood out immediately and we hit it off right away. We messaged whenever we wanted to, and we were only ever happy to hear from each other because we liked each other! People will disagree, but personally I think if a guy likes a woman he likes her and wants to hear from her, he doesn’t think ‘well I might have liked her but she texted me after one day instead of two’.

Ratatwat · 17/09/2021 12:09

@CrumbsThatsQuick well, since you asked.

  • I can be difficult to get to know: this is definitely true, my social anxiety manifests as being reserved/quiet/serious or even a little cold sometimes. Need to be aware of this if in a situation that could be conducive to meeting new people.
  • My current hobbies are not facilitating meeting potential partners: If I want to meet people in person, I need to try different places/activities to do so, that will have a better gender balance.
  • I need to be willing to try online dating again, but with a better strategy for filtering and chatting. Maintaining standards and safeguarding for myself, but openness to potential matches I had ruled out. Screening via more chatting. I also need to consider a more serious, paid only dating site.
  • I need to stop indulging my overly self-critical tendencies related to my looks and be open to the possibility that someone may in fact be hitting on me and it's possible that my attraction or interest may be reciprocated.
  • Although it's a good thing that I'm independent and successful, I need to be sure that when I'm discussing any of my achievements it's not coming across as a hostile, 'I don't need you' kind of thing. I don't think it really is, but I do think some men are prone to being intimidated by certain things like being out-earned by women and although I'd never tell them how much I earn, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to do the maths on my lifestyle and put themselves in a higher or lower bracket. But if a man is insecure about this, they're just not the one for me, I don't need to bend over backwards to protect their ego.
OP posts:
CrumbsThatsQuick · 17/09/2021 11:58

Which bits do resonate with you OP, from what has been said? That might help steer people more in the right direction. Give us your bullet pointed list, rated in order of how much the advice applies and the associated action plan.

(Just teasing about that last bit. Wink )

Ratatwat · 17/09/2021 11:54

Thanks @TreeSmuggler and @FirewomanSam.

I do sometimes wish I had those pretty long fingernails lots of women have but then again I read an article once that basically said they all have poo under them, so perhaps not.

No tears here, just a bit of a hangover.

OP posts:
stealthninjamum · 17/09/2021 11:52

Op it’s hard isn’t it? I was terrible at dating because I hadn’t been single for twenty years and I just didn’t know what to do. I followed some advice and like you tried to get men to meet up quite soon but suspect I put a few men off by being pushy and inviting them for a coffee. Now I realise I might’ve looked desperate. Lots of dating ‘experts’ say that the man should do the work but I definitely wasn’t going to wait around. Having said that my now partner (of 2 1/2 years) wanted a phone call date on the day we matched and a pub date a week later so he definitely did pursue me.

Anyway good luck, I’m 20 years older than you so can patronisingly say you’re still young and you have many years to find someone, especially if you don’t have the desire for kids making the situation more stressful.

Ratatwat · 17/09/2021 11:41

Look @CreepingDeath, it was a forum post question, not a court summons. If you don't want to read it, or try to understand, and find it exhausting, then feel free to click the 'x' on the top right of your browser tab. Usually I read these because I am interested, and do want to understand, and if I get bored or annoyed I just close the window. I am doing okay, I intentionally set out to do some self-analysis and seek some input from strangers but from some who would give thoughtful, interested input based on actually reading the information supplied. I'm able to take on board what I know applies, comfortable telling you what I know doesn't, and I know that I know myself and you don't know me.

@stealthninjamum I am good at light, flirty chat. If I'm really keen on someone, I run my messages past a friend before I send them. Feedback from my friend on Monday: "You have great chat. I have lost all flirting capabilities. If I lose [partner] I'm screwed." I just typically don't like to waste much time chatting with people on apps, I prefer to just meet up, but I'm hearing that I should spend more time chatting with them. I also hear you about filtering on qualifications, though I am MA educated, I usually filter to undergrad, but can try not doing that. I agree that if they have an interesting background and career it hardly matters what their quals are.

Racism is playing a part. And antisemitism has been an issue, and culturally my religion does play a part in my life, so although I may get more matches if I don't put it in, they wouldn't likely be good ones.

OP posts:
FirewomanSam · 17/09/2021 11:34

TreeSmuggler Amen!

OP you have nerves of steel posting a thread like this here and you’ve handled all the comments remarkably well. I’ve been reduced to tears here by far less!

There’s nothing wrong with you and you don’t need to change anything about yourself or your personality to find a man. You’re just a young woman navigating the realities of dating and it’s rough out there. Yes it’s a numbers game but remember you only need to find one, in the end. Quality not quantity! If and when you eventually meet someone who is the right fit for you and accepts you as you are, you’ll look back and laugh at all these suggestions that you need more/less hobbies, less money, less confidence and nicer fingernails in order to find a man.

Any man who only wants you if you make yourself quieter, shyer, more boring and less financially independent is not a man you want to be with anyway.

I speak as someone who spent my entire 20s with a man who constantly told me I was too this, too that, that I was lucky he wanted to be with me because I was so annoying/boring/stuck up that no one else would. And now I’m married to a wonderful man I met in my 30s who loves me exactly as I am and who has never wanted me to change a single thing about me. You deserve that too, and nothing less.

DrSbaitso · 17/09/2021 11:30

Honestly, it seems like you're looking for the most uncharitable possible reading of anything I say now.

I'm sure it does seem that way to you.

You asked us a question. I've given you an honest answer.

TreeSmuggler · 17/09/2021 11:21

I think you sound great. The only problem is that there are not enough great, or even just normalish men out there. So many men are just blantently horrible, plus more of them than women don't want to be in relationships. So that doesn't leave many. If you had half the attributes you have and were a man, you would have been snapped up years ago.

Forget most of the replies here. No matter what you say people are going to find fault. Your posts are reasonably upbeat - you aren't expressing yourself, aren't showing emotion. If you'd come on here with a sad post - why would a man want to date a sad sack like you, you should be upbeat. Have hobbies - you have too many hobbies! Don't have hobbies - that's boring, get some hobbies, plus you'll meet a man there. Have a good career - you're up yourself! Don't - why would anyone want a lazy person with no career. Etc etc etc until the end of time.

CreepingDeath · 17/09/2021 11:19

I am attempting to fully consider the questions raised as potential criticisms, as none of you know me, you need context, this can take up some words, and you may indeed be off base.

C'mon OP, we are a bunch of strangers of course we don't know you, will never know you - we can only go on what you are writing here. Even if you wrote 10 pages of in-depth detail, we still wouldn't know you. It's not in our interest to read into everything perfectly and understand you completely, why would we?

You are expecting too much from a thread on a public message board. People are trying to come up with helpful reasons, ideas etc. but of course they're imperfect, they are just suggestions.

You are very invested in us all getting the 'right' understanding of you, it's kind of exhausting to read. This constant over analysis is not doing you any good.

stealthninjamum · 17/09/2021 11:19

Op it’s hard to see what you’re really like because you’re answering our questions but the detail does make you seem intense.

I wonder if I’m the early stages of chat you give too much detail or if you are able to be light and flirty. FWIW I tried online dating after being married for 20 years and realised I had terrible written / text skills and what I thought was a great self deprecating sense of humour didn’t come across well to men.

Also I think you said you filter on qualifications, I initially did this because I have a masters, but the guy I ended up with is a fairly successful guy who didn’t go to university and worked his way up from several manual jobs to a career in finance who reads and his background gives him many interesting stories far more so than my Cambridge MA educated ex husband. Lookswise my partners photos didn’t do him justice either, I think a lot of people don’t photograph well so it’s good to give a man who looks average in a photo a chance.

I would agree though that generally men who do online dating are probably not great and it really is a numbers game. I know from the dating threads here (which you should join for support from other brilliant women in a similar position) that men often swipe on every woman and then filter on the ones they like so will be having monosyllabic conversations if you’re not their preferred one. I was looking at men in their 40s / 50s and unfortunately by that age many have let themselves go and have no interests other than pub / Netflix. My partner is bright but not as into art galleries or literature as I would like but I have female friends for that.

I also wonder if racism plays a part, I have heard that certain ethnic groups find it harder to meet people which is disgusting but unavoidable. Also with religion I think many people would avoid someone who puts it in their profile as they would assume it’s a big part of their life. Having said that I completely understand why you would want to filter out bigots if you have had bad experiences where you haven’t mentioned your religion.

Ratatwat · 17/09/2021 10:52

@DrSbaitso Honestly, it seems like you're looking for the most uncharitable possible reading of anything I say now.

I am attempting to fully consider the questions raised as potential criticisms, as none of you know me, you need context, this can take up some words, and you may indeed be off base. Some of you are, some of you aren't, I've acknowledged things that felt right and given my full consideration of everything. I've mentioned I've had a lot of therapy several times as several of you keep suggesting I try it.

told us that you're clearly "not repulsive", which not a single poster has suggested you are
yes, I know, it was a lighthearted and self-deprecating joke about how melodramatic I know I must sound and acknowledging how low my self-esteem has been.

As for whether my therapy is 'working', ha! Ha! What a question.

I do hate for you to feel steamrollered and I really don't even know where to begin with questions like those so I think maybe I'll disengage from them.

I think it's a breakthrough.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 17/09/2021 10:37

A PP mentioned being "steamrollered" and that's honestly how I'm feeling too.

You've asked a question that seems to invite constructive criticism but every time you get it, there's a wall of text about why that's not it. You complained about people accusing you of "writing too much", which is a bit of an oversimplification, and told us that you're clearly "not repulsive", which not a single poster has suggested you are. Quite the opposite. Then the complaints that we haven't acknowledged all your time in therapy. Were we supposed to? Is it working, if you still need it?

Should you "change"? Well, depends on what you mean by that. Stop doing the things you love or never talk about them? Of course not. Consider whether perhaps your social interaction skills might benefit from some honing? Maybe. You have a roomful of women here telling you you're awesome and it's terrible that a handful of us are answering the question about what might perhaps be off-putting, but you don't date women.

I do agree with a PP that you might be using your achievements, as admirable as they are, as a bit of a mask and I wonder if your therapy is addressing this.

Your interactions with men, and others, shouldn't be geared around how you can, say, use your salary to help them while scribbling out the prices or whatever. There needs to be a personal connection, how you make each other feel. What do you think, what do you feel...who are you?

CrumbsThatsQuick · 17/09/2021 10:24

"I often wish I were 15% less intelligent because of all the constant over analysing of possible worst case scenarios."

OP, you are right, I did not read this as a joke.

I think people talking about charm, timing, chemistry, going with the flow, lightening up etc. are giving the most helpful advice. Drop the project. Enjoy your life. If it is meant to be, it will be.

CreepingDeath · 17/09/2021 10:19

As I have mentioned many times, although many posters have skipper over this, I have been in 15 years of therapy.

My apologies, but you do write long walls of text that can be hard to get through, along with a lot of unnecessary detail.

I think you are trying to figure this out too much; your intelligence and your resourcefulness are working against you here. I'm sorry that dating hasn't resulted in a relationship you want, but often it's just dumb luck rather than anything else.

The fact that it's something we can't really control is part of the charm, sometimes it just happens and that's wonderful. But for those of us who haven't found long lasting love, it can be hard to come to terms with (I am long term single but fine with it), especially for people who are very accomplished in other areas of life. They perceive it as a failure, when in fact it's just bad timing, or whatever.