Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take my DC to funeral?

211 replies

UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 10:45

Very sadly, my cousin's husband died recently.

When I was told the date of the funeral I booked the day off from school for my 9yo DD and my eldest (14) is at college and not in that day, anyway. My DM offered me a lift to the funeral and when I said I was bringing the DC she was surprised/mildly shocked.

I may be completely off the mark here but I thought funerals were family get togethers to celebrate the life of our family member. My DC have previously been to my grandparent's funerals. I remember going to a number of funerals as a child. I have always taken them to the church service and wake but not to the crematorium as that tends to be the very sad bit. I was planning to do the same at this funeral.

Will it be frowned upon if I bring them to the funeral? Will others bring their DC, do you think?

OP posts:
BobMortimersPetOwl · 16/09/2021 19:10

Children aren't welcomed at funerals in my family or close circle, unless they were very close to the deceased, as in a sibling or child. I'd probably get the opinion of the chief mourners and go with that.

I can't stand when parents claim their children provided some light review at a funeral. It most certainly isn't the case at any funerals I've been to. Similarly I dislike the notion of it being a learning event. Nobody needs to learn how to behave at a funeral or how to mourn.

UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 19:07

@Shhhhhhhshh

I took my DC 7&2 to my DF funeral. The 2 year old had no idea what was going on but found it interesting and brightened up an otherwise awful occasion.

7 y.o knew what was going on and held my DM hand throughout the service. Yes she found the crying a bit upsetting but she was so proud that she could support her Grandma.

That's lovely.
OP posts:
Antinerak · 16/09/2021 19:07

I think your children are old enough to understand how to behave at a funeral- quiet, respectful, not messing around. I'm Irish so always had kids at funerals but they were used to it and young ones were allowed to play as normal, especially after. Make sure you talk to them about what to expect so they're prepared and allow them to share their emotions on the day

Rainbowsew · 16/09/2021 19:07

Yanbu if they were close and knew each other.

Yabu if they were not close/didn't know them to take a child out of school for the funeral. If my cousin's partner died I would attend but not my dc they don't have a relationship with them, I'd let dh choose as whilst he knows them he isnt close. I'd be going for support and for the sake of the relationship we had as children.

UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 19:06

@Porcupineintherough

With all due respect to some of the posters above, I think treating funerals as an interesting opportunity to normalise death for children to is a bit distasteful. Most people's passing is deeply distressing to someone and their funeral isnt a spectator sport.
I certainly have never treated funerals as 'an interesting opportunity' or 'spectator sport' for my DC. They have been family get togethers to celebrate the life of our family member. The funerals were deeply distressing to me and others as well as being sad for the DC too. I find it strange that you suggest that family members including DC wouldn't be upset about someone in their family dying.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 19:01

@likearoomwithoutaroof

I wouldn't take children to a funeral until they were teens (if they wanted to go) unless it was a direct family member like a grandparent. Even then, I wouldn't take them now (at 5 and 3).

I didn't attend a funeral until I was an adult.

It's interesting my DM said this too - she didn't attend a funeral til she was an adult. Then she said they didn't take us to funerals when we were young - I started reeling off all the funerals I remember. It appears that it was my DF that wanted us to attend. I have nothing but good memories of the funerals - a nice way to say goodbye. At the 1st funeral mine came to they were baby and 5yo. It definitely helped the 5yo understand what was happening when his great-grandfather died.

Consequently, after speaking to my DF he thinks the DC should come! So a split just like this thread has shown. I think I'll speak to one of my second-cousins (cousin's DC) to see if they are taking their DC.

OP posts:
Rummikubfan · 16/09/2021 18:59

@UndertheCedartree to me it’s still random but I come from a different culture and it wouldn’t occur to me to take my children. I have only been to one funeral not from our culture so it’s not something I’m familiar with.

UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 18:52

@honeybeesknees

We have always taken our DC to funerals for close family members. The only one we couldn’t was one which was restricted by the rule of 6 early on in covid times, and one DC in particular has really struggled with that death, and I’m assuming the lack of closure, as they often ask when we will be having their ‘party’. Of course take them out if they are being noisy, but as adults, a lot of us would struggle without the closure of a funeral, so why shouldn’t children.
I agree - this is my thinking too
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 18:51

@Rummikubfan - well it's clearly not random based on the responses on here! I wasn't really close to him either but I would definitely like to celebrate a family member's life as part of the grieving process. Not sure why that wouldn't apply to children too?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 18:47

@MadeOfStarStuff - yes, he was like a great-uncle to them
@Notaroadrunner - if they'd never met him it would be different. But we meet up for family events and Christmas etc every year.

OP posts:
Penistoe · 16/09/2021 17:50

So their first cousin in law once removed? No I wouldn’t take a child in this case, unless it was common in your family- which you wouldn’t be asking this Aibu if that was the case.

bellinisurge · 16/09/2021 17:45

Irish Mum/British Jewish Dad. Brought up in UK. Never went to funerals as a child. But that may have been because we were effectively ostracised by both families (with notable exceptions) because it was a "mixed marriage "

sbhydrogen · 16/09/2021 17:41

I'd been to over a dozen funerals before I'd gone to secondary school. I'm not scarred by it; after all, death is a part of life. You should take them!

Member984815 · 16/09/2021 17:23

It's normal where I am for children to attend

UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 17:22

@Bigfathairyones - yes that was my experience too re: the atmosphere. I agree about making sure the DC wouldn't disturb the service. At my grandparent's funerals my ex- DH was there so he would have taken them out if necessary, although he didn't need to.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 17:19

@StarCat2020 - aww, how sweet. I have to say at my grandparent's funeral when the DC were much younger people seemed to like them being there as they provided a bit of light relief.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 17:17

@cervixuser - yes, that's the way I see it. My cousin has described the church service as a celebration of her husband's life.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/09/2021 17:16

@LIZS - they knew him well - met at all family occasions and would go over sometimes too. I mean we didn't meet up with them all the time but enough for them to know him pretty well.

OP posts:
Ofallthethings · 16/09/2021 15:53

I think if they didn't know him , i.e. only met him once or twice maybe not, but if they knew him they should go. I went to funerals as a child, my Grandad's when I was 7. Me and my sister held my grandma's hands when she walked down the aisle behind the coffin. I think it helped her a bit. We didn't go to the burial, just the service and wake.
When FIL died all grandchildren were there, ranging from 2 years old to early 20's. Children should be allowed to attend these events to say their own goodbyes.

We are all English. There's obviously a range of views within England. When my Aunty died none of her grandchildren were allowed to attend, and I was quite shocked the older ones weren't there (other two between 1 and 2 so that was understandable).

shouldistop · 16/09/2021 15:40

I don't think there's anything wrong with children at a funeral but I wouldn't keep a child off school to attend a cousins, husbands funeral - unless your child knew them very well?

LakieLady · 16/09/2021 15:38

My DP's DGD was 6 when she attended his funeral last year.

She was fine, and behaved impeccably.

HyacinthsHydrangeas · 16/09/2021 15:35

To your question, OP, I think the best course of action if you're really unsure is: Ask someone else who is close to your cousin/familiar with how the funeral is being planned and see what they think. I wouldn't bother your cousin with this, but maybe try to find someone who is more closely involved with the proceedings than you are. There is also the separate issue of "does this rise to the level of taking my child out of school," which is something only you can answer. Your instinct seems to be that yes, it was, so I'd say go with your gut.

I'm American (married to an English man who now lives here in the US) and for me, too, it has been very surprising to learn about some British attitudes toward children at funerals. Not that it's wrongobviously every culture gets to make its own rulesbut very, very different. I have attended funerals from before I am able to remember (so a very young age) and I would never expect anyone to leave a child of any age at home in order to attend a funeral. Of course, I would expect them to take the child out of any proceedings if they became disruptive.

In my circles, childrenespecially little onesare very welcome at funerals because they bring some levity and happiness to an otherwise sad situation. It's also a sign of respect to the family--if my family were invited around to someone's house for a holiday gathering, and I didn't bring my children, I think it would be perceived as a little odd.

Culturally, though, we are as a people liable to turn up at just about anybody's funeral. Did we work together more than five years ago, but we are still friends on social media and I just found out your dad died? OF COURSE I will show up for the wake. Not long ago, our entire office basically closed so we could all drive several hours away to our colleague's father's funeral. Obviously we had never met the deceased, but we knew his son (our coworker), so why would we not go? It's just a way to show the surviving family that there are lots of people in the community thinking of them at a hard time. I literally would not be able to count the number of funerals/death rituals I have attended.

My husband and I are currently engaged in this discussion because we have a funeral to attend in the coming weeks. I assumed our 3 year-old was coming, he assumed our 3 year-old was staying home. So we will see how it plays out!

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 16/09/2021 15:17

For me, it depends on how close the person who died was to the family. When my DGF died, I did not hesitate to bring my newborn and 2-year-old to the funeral. A number of relatives commented that having them there was «beautiful and life affirming», and my mum only got through the service by holding my DD close against her. (She thanked me afterwards for letting her do that… and DD definitely wasn’t scarred by it).

However, for my SIL’s mother’s funeral, I got a babysitter and attended alone with my DH.

BiBabbles · 16/09/2021 15:10

Having dealt with this culture clash, I'd ask the next of kin - so your cousin I'd guess - or if they're not available, someone a bit closer to your cousin on what their thoughts are on your children attending.

The community I grew up in, everyone went including children. I never thought about that. In my spouse's family, there have been some that think spouses coming, especially wives, is unusual. There was a range of opinions on children and even teenagers attending so we learned to ask whoever is closest to the person who died that we could talk to and then after that ask our children if they wanted to attend. I didn't understand the choices sometimes, but I found that worked well for us in helping us understand what was actually thought vs what was my MIL's ideas on how funerals should be (being the family member we spoke with most and had many opinion on that).

Flowers500 · 16/09/2021 15:09

Death is a part of life, stopping children from grieving property doesn’t stop them being impacted by death, it just makes it more confusing. I find the attitude of sweeping death under the carpet deeply strange