Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
BreadPita · 17/09/2021 22:23

Yes, people's circumstances will vary.
How has it been good for your health?

I haven't had cold or flu in over 2 years. It was rare to go 6 months without one when I was in the office. Fitness-wise, I'm probably not the norm but it's been great for me. I go to the gym as normal (slightly cheaper because I used to pay extra to use a branch closer to my office on work days). Sitting all day is generally pretty horrible for mobility, so I used to go to the toilet cubicle and (try to) stretch. Not easy in a confined space and I can imagine some people had questions about the frequency of my toilet visits.
Now I just stretch in my living room every once in a while with plenty of space and free from ridicule.
I can cook nutritionally decent, tasty and relatively cheap lunches at lunchtime, rather than visit Pret and it's ilk or picking up a Tesco meal deal.
Bar the effects of the lockdown closure of gyms, I'm probably healthier than I have been in recent memory.

speakout · 17/09/2021 22:23

That in itself is why WFH is not a good idea long term and should be a huge warning sign to us all.

I don't understand that at all.
What is wrong with benefits being leisure related?
I love working from home because I have time to do other stuff- I have important things in my life apart from work.
I have worked from home for a long time and not sure I would ever consider a workplace job again.

frazzledasarock · 17/09/2021 22:23

I love WFH as I can get my head down and get the work done, then sort out the piles and piles of crap in my inbox which I normally need to leave for when I get a chance.

I love that people cannot stop at my desk to have a half hour discussion about ‘stuff’ which has nothing to do with work.

I love that I can get up in the morning log on and sort through my (work) emails whilst the kettle boils, and then dive right into work as soon as I’ve got breakfast out of the way.

I’m more productive at work.

Altho people do ring to chat but they usually tag that on to the end of work calls.

I’m pretty sure most people in favour of WFH have a balance of work and personal related reasons for preferring WFH.

Pre pandemic we spent half our lives commuting on shit over crowded trains and tubes (baking slowly to death during summer on the central line is one thing I will never miss nor wish to return to). Barely saw our kids, spent weekends frantically preparing for the week.

I prefer the calmer pace of WFH. No worries about the trains, getting to every meeting calm and on time not having to clock watch at the end of the day because I can’t miss my train otherwise the next will be ridiculously late, not turning up at the train station to find a massive crowd gathered because the station is shut because omg it rained, in England in October fancy that! 🙄

Yeah and at lunch time I can throw dinner together, so when I finish for the day dinner is ready. I can use my own nice clean bathroom, I don’t have to worry when I am having the period from hell I have everything to hand at home.

People who want to go in to work can continue to do so, but why on earth is there anger at those of us who are happier WFH?
During the pandemic when the lockdowns eased our offices allowed anyone who wanted, to go in. Those are pretty much the people who are still going regularly the rest of us are going in hybrid working under duress. And it won’t continue in our office I know that for a fact as people are just point blank refusing to go in. There are loads of jobs available in our sector now with WFH options, so our employer will face a big staff turnover if they force the issue. Altho I doubt they will.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:22

I mentioned my area, to make a point that wfh hasn't impacted public transport in every area.

Wonderful. For the insular. So people will be mostly confined to the area they currently live in? A pity for anyone who needs or wants to travel further afield. For work, or to a specialist hospital, to see friends, visit family who live elsewhere.

And public transport is only doing ok in any area right now because of the government bailouts. Which costs a lot of money to do. Something unsustainable if a permanent loss of the billions from office based industries.

Birthday552 · 17/09/2021 22:21

Now entirely focused I meant!

Birthday552 · 17/09/2021 22:20

I have always does flexible working and could WFH if needed to pre pandemic . I don’t enjoy it at all now. I actually just really miss people and the separation from home life.

I find it less productive too in many ways and find our business is suffering from the lack of communication. People are not focused entirely on their own tasks and collaborative working is diminishing.

I also miss my colleagues and you just can’t communicate in the same way online. The nuances are missed as is the general day to day stuff you pick up from being around your colleagues.

I’m glad not everyone loves working from home. I was beginning to think I am the only one who isn’t a fan!

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 22:19

Well it's better for the environment. We need to maintain - in fact, improve - our public transport system.

Running near-empty trains and buses isn't better for the environment. Public transit is better for the environment than everyone driving themselves everywhere. It's not better for the environment than everyone just staying home, which is the alternative here.

Also, a civilised society ensures there is provision (including ability to get out and about - social interaction, shopping, hospital appointments, etc) for those too disabled to drive or too poor to afford to run a car.

And there should be. If scaled-back public transit is inadequate for those things, the funds freed up from scaling it back can be used to meet those needs in a more targeted way.

Not to mention good public transport offers independence to teenagers and young adults.

Plenty of teens and young adults grew up just fine in areas with no public transit whatsoever. I'm one of them. I rode my bike a lot, and it was good for me. I think telling adults to rearrange their lives so that teenagers can feel more independent is a bit of a stretch.

ididitsocanyou · 17/09/2021 22:18

@speakout yeah I know. I was only jesting. Even so, nobody ever says “the best thing about wfh is that I can spend the hour I was commuting working” do they? Or “the best thing about wfh is that I don’t have to wait in the printer queue”. It’s never work related us my point, it’s always leisure related. That in itself is why WFH is not a good idea long term and should be a huge warning sign to us all.

BoredZelda · 17/09/2021 22:15

if a job can be done at home in the UK it can be done at home in another, cheaper location.

Not so. We have a staff member who is situated overseas. He can do some parts of the job from there, but there are times where we need to do site visits. He can’t do those. I can work from home, do those site visits, without going anywhere near my office.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 22:11

@Gwenhwyfar

"Speak for yourself. It's been great for mine."

Yes, people's circumstances will vary.
How has it been good for your health? I can see some people who used to drive to work using that time to exercise, but in general it's better to be active as a normal part of your day so walking, taking public transport to work or parking a bit further away are more sustainable ways of making sure you're active. Also, most people are much more active at the office, with the walk to the kitchen, printer or toilet being much more than at home. I can't believe many people live in a house where the kitchen and toilet are further away from them than in the office.

As for mental health, yes I suppose a minority of people are happy to interact with their family only or see friends every day, but most people will have more interactions if they go out to work. Talking to people through a screen only is really not the same.

The driving thing is true for me, plus the fact that no one can hear or smell me makes me more willing to exercise during lunch and other incidental breaks that sometimes come up during the day. Amusingly, I do live in a house where the kitchen is farther from my home office than it was in my employer's office, and down a flight of stairs to boot!

As far as mental health goes, I feel like I get more than enough interaction with most of my colleagues virtually. We can chitchat a bit during work calls, and that's plenty for me. I'm fortunate that my husband and I both enjoy each other's company, plus the flexibility makes it easier to keep in touch with other relatives and friends of my choosing. So I think that need is getting met pretty well. I'm much happier overall.

speakout · 17/09/2021 22:10

ididitsocanyou

I think a massive benefit of WFH is no commute and he resultant time created.
Many people have a commute of an hour each way or maybe even more.
Even with a modest 45 minute commute WFH gives you an extra 7.5 hours in a week- almost an extra working day to use as your own time.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 22:10

[quote Hekatestorch]@Rozziie yes a toddler. That has more sense than you.

I mentioned my area, to make a point that wfh hasn't impacted public transport in every area. So the 'you have to go back to work to support public transport' is just irrelevant. Making people return to an office here won't impact the public transport.

Again, YOU need to stop working remotely and start travelling into an office everyday. Because anything else is just making it about YOU. You aren't think over everyone else.

Practice what you preach.

Again, the hypocrisy is amazing. You can can talk about how transport will be impacted in YOUR area. But anyone talking about and alternative view is making it 'all about MMMEEEE!'

Just bizarre.Hmm[/quote]
You mentioned your area as a way to refute my point. You basically said only old people take public transport in your area, as if that's in any way relevant to to the general situation on a national level. I wasn't the only one who thought that was a totally self absorbed comment that entirely missed the point, either.

You just don't seem to be able to grasp, on any level, that you're not the centre of the universe. Yes, maybe the point about public transport doesn't apply to your area (and I'd still doubt that - perhaps people less privileged than you DO need to rely on it because they have no choice?) but so what? Who cares? I and other posters have said that it has been impacted where we are. I'm in London, which contains nearly 1/6 of the population of the entire UK. Public transport being scaled back is a massive deal here, even if it doesn't personally affect me.

It's not a matter of one individual needing to go to the office every day to keep public transport in their area running - it's a general point that if people don't use things, they won't be there. And a lot of people will be much, much worse off for it. But you don't seem to be able to grasp anything that isn't all about you.

ididitsocanyou · 17/09/2021 22:04

I find it interesting that all the perceived benefits of wfh are not actually work related. I.e “I love wfh because I can tidy the house.”

That’s not wfh! That’s tidying the house!

All the negatives are work related: lack of collaboration, productivity, accountability etc.

“I love wfh I get to walk in the park.”

Well you’re not bloody working then are you??

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 21:59

guess what I'm missing is, why is this a huge problem? Many people never used public transit to begin with

Well it's better for the environment. We need to maintain - in fact, improve - our public transport system.

Also, a civilised society ensures there is provision (including ability to get out and about - social interaction, shopping, hospital appointments, etc) for those too disabled to drive or too poor to afford to run a car.

Not to mention good public transport offers independence to teenagers and young adults.

Use it or lose it.

I'd like to be in office 3 days a week

That's a good balance. I was doing that years before the pandemic. One or two days a week at home is a good option for those who want it (with extra flexibility for the disabled and carers). Full-time WFH for the majority, however, is detrimental to individuals, society, and the national economy (taxes will have to go up high to fund public services, without the office based industry contribution).

Aggy35 · 17/09/2021 21:58

I Dont spend hour and in the morning and in the evening commuting so more time at home to tidy up etc.When I make lunch I can put washing machine on etc..plus simply don't wear as many clothes.
In the office there are always meetings galore,people talking to you and you spend your lunch break often at desk .I don't want to walk in the city.I have greenery right next to my house and can enjoy fresh air not car fumes and noise

ididitsocanyou · 17/09/2021 21:56

Have wfh for 16 years and it’s had a negative affect on me in many ways as I am less connected and confident with people. You also have less opportunity to learn from others. In the end I think it is not a good thing. But the upside is convenience. I got to stay home with my children and there are fewer politics to deal with. I have time. But I also get demotivated. Plus you are not seen so you don’t get people elevating you and you miss out on countless opportunities because you are not exposed to life. I am glad as wfh suited me but my career has suffered. I wonder how far I could have got if I had been seen and present and met people with influence. In the end the people who work from home will erode away I’m afraid. 80 percent of success is, after all, just showing up.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 21:52

@Aggy35

Love wfh and so does my partner.Housework always done ,going for walks on lunch breaks.Not eating lunch at the desk and doing silly overtime quite often simply to avoid the rush hour.Couldnt be happier
Housework always done? But you have more housework because you're home all the time. I don't get that at all. Yes, you can put the washing machine on while you work, but you also have to make every meal at home and tidy up after yourself. Why can't you go on a walk on your lunch break from the office?
Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 21:50

@calvados

Even fashion has been affected by wfh…. Items of clothing that were seasonal staples have been dropped for leisure, lounge, active and outdoor wear. I rarely see heels being worn or skirts,… nor men in suits. Personally I lament this. People are sleep walking into elasticated waist bands while wfh… I liked distinct fashion trends
Getting fat as well.
Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 21:49

"I think it's a bit perverse to say that WFH is a bad thing because a lack of commuting is affecting public transport and food outlets. Surely these should be remodelled to reflect different demands. "

They're not being remodelled though are they. The lunch cafes and shops that exist in town and city centres aren't moving to residential areas because there isn't enough of a concentration of workers there.

Aggy35 · 17/09/2021 21:48

Love wfh and so does my partner.Housework always done ,going for walks on lunch breaks.Not eating lunch at the desk and doing silly overtime quite often simply to avoid the rush hour.Couldnt be happier

calvados · 17/09/2021 21:47

Even fashion has been affected by wfh…. Items of clothing that were seasonal staples have been dropped for leisure, lounge, active and outdoor wear. I rarely see heels being worn or skirts,… nor men in suits. Personally I lament this. People are sleep walking into elasticated waist bands while wfh… I liked distinct fashion trends

Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 21:45

"Many people never used public transit to begin with"

Have you got stats for that?? The big concentrations of people are in cities and in cities people do use public transport.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 21:42

"Speak for yourself. It's been great for mine."

Yes, people's circumstances will vary.
How has it been good for your health? I can see some people who used to drive to work using that time to exercise, but in general it's better to be active as a normal part of your day so walking, taking public transport to work or parking a bit further away are more sustainable ways of making sure you're active. Also, most people are much more active at the office, with the walk to the kitchen, printer or toilet being much more than at home. I can't believe many people live in a house where the kitchen and toilet are further away from them than in the office.

As for mental health, yes I suppose a minority of people are happy to interact with their family only or see friends every day, but most people will have more interactions if they go out to work. Talking to people through a screen only is really not the same.

calvados · 17/09/2021 21:42

Spot on!

TiddleTaddleTat · 17/09/2021 21:41

Jelly!