Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
YourWinter · 17/09/2021 23:30

I have zero interest in coffee shop culture, I'm the person who takes their own flask and packed lunch. I haven't had to commute on public transport since the early 1980s and if I'd been able to WFH I'd have been absolutely thrilled to not have to use my car (the cost of fuel, worry whether it would start in cold weather, often difficulty finding a parking space). But I work in a supermarket, WFH wasn't an option as we were on the front line throughout. I can't wait to retire next year and be out of the workplace for good.

One of my DDs loved WFH, she doesn't need people around her and works very productively and happily alone in the space she set up as her home office, and is disciplined about getting away from her screen, and getting outside for breaks. The other DD hates it, one day a week it's nice but generally she needs the buzz of interacting with people face to face. No rights or wrongs, but I would be wholly in favour of employers offereing it as a flexible option where possible.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 23:27

NYC doesn't represent the whole of America, I know, but it so often leads the way with trends - including work policy. They recognise the importance to the recovery of getting offices reopened.

www.nytimes.com/2021/09/01/nyregion/new-york-city-workers-office.html

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 23:21

@Tealightsandd

Even intra-city commutes on public transit can be lengthy, and (in the US, at least) often unsafe. Many who live in cities are still happy to not have to do them anymore.

This is the UK though. And also, when this happens, many more people aren't as privileged as to be able to relocate from a city (and if everyone did, the suburbs and villages would be as full as cities).

If we're talking about America, it's leading the way with the return to the office. They've acknowledged the need - for the sake of the national economy, and wider society in general.

If someone lives alone, there's usually no real problem with doing it from a studio.

Lots of couples have to live in studios. And how depressing will that be. Stuck all day every day in one room - to sleep and to work.

If they share with others, yes, space may be an issue. If the company makes WFH optional, they're free to go to the office and work there if they'd rather

But, use it or lose it. If lots of people WFH, companies will close offices (and start outsourcing the work abroad for cheaper labour).

I'm talking about America because I'm currently based there. Most areas have removed the legal restrictions on returning to the office, but many employers still allow people to work remotely if they want, with the expectation of making that permanent. Mine is one of them.

I lived in a studio for several years. I did plenty of work from home in that time (well before covid), and never found it depressing. Lockdowns are long over, and there's nothing stopping anyone from spending some or all of the workday (or their free time) somewhere other than their apartment.

My job isn't going to be outsourced. If someone believes (probably wrongly) that working from the office will make their job less likely to be outsourced, they can go right ahead and work from the office if they want. But I'm not going to just for that.

gypsy22 · 17/09/2021 23:19

Work from home 5 days a Week .. not healthy for anybody - you are talking as an employee but for the businesses or reds to be effective
Get the balance right though and it’s very constructive for both employee and employer .

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 23:18

@Hekatestorch

You mentioned your area as a way to refute my point. You basically said only old people take public transport in your area, as if that's in any way relevant to to the general situation on a national level. I wasn't the only one who thought that was a totally self absorbed comment that entirely missed the point, either.

If I was replying to any point you made it would have directed it at you.

And you think other people make it all about them?

I didn't say it was the same in all areas. I simply pointed out that public transport isn't impacted by wfh on some areas. Mine Included. Odd yoh find it so bothersome that not every area is like others

You arent the only one? And what? I am not the only one that thinks the remote worker calling people who want to wfh, selfish, is very very odd.

You just don't seem to be able to grasp, on any level, that you're not the centre of the universe. Yes, maybe the point about public transport doesn't apply to your area (and I'd still doubt that - perhaps people less privileged than you DO need to rely on it because they have no choice?) but so what? Who cares? I and other posters have said that it has been impacted where we are. I'm in London, which contains nearly 1/6 of the population of the entire UK. Public transport being scaled back is a massive deal here, even if it doesn't personally affectme.

I don't think it centres around me. I simply don't agree with you. The only person who expects people to arrange their lives so their own is benefitted is you. I am not the one trying to attach morality to people's working patterns, because it might make my eurostar tickets more expensive.

I have worked hybrid for years, I don't then judge other people for wanting to do the same. You have the benefit of remote working, you don't want others to have it because it may impact you

That's your only issue. If you really thought not using public transport, not buying daily coffees and lunch out and not working in an office was a selfish act YOU wouldn't be working remotely. You would be booking and paying for eurostar tickets to keep it in use. As that's what you suggested others did.

And no one said it was about 1 person. But where people don't use the public transport for commuting, them going back to work will not protect public transport. Because they didn't use it before and won't after. The same people are using it as were pre pandemic. So 'save our buses' isn't relevant to alot of people when it comes to the decision about wfh or not. It's relevant to many. But to many wfh or in the office will not impact it.

But oddly, you think anyone talking about an area with a different experience to yours, must be just selfish and only talking about themselves rather than talking about their area. But you can talk about your area and you are altruistic. But not actually doing what you think other must do.

Its just everyone else who needs to change their behaviour, to suit you. You can work remotely, but others can. That's the definition of selfishness.

@Hekatestorch I'm actually starting to think you're on a wind-up now.

You're going on as if I want to work remotely myself but I don't want anyone else to when my ENTIRE POINT is that I don't want to either!!!! My entire point is that I also don't think it's good in general, it's not good for young people, it's not good for disadvantaged people, it's not good for people with no space at home, etc. But now many industries have gone to WFH as default, so that anyone who does want to go back mostly office-based work, can't! So why on earth are you acting as if I want to work from home but don't want other people to do it?

It's like you grasp at literally anything except for the actual point. It's truly incredible.

gypsy22 · 17/09/2021 23:17

Really …?

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 23:15

@Tealightsandd

just don't think it's reasonable to expect others to resume otherwise-unnecessary commutes just for that reason.

So where does that end? Is it reasonable to expect other people to pay tax - to fund public services, including some they might not themselves use (eg. state education, mental health services, libraries, public parks, etc)? In a civilised modern society, we all generally have to do some things we'd rather not for the good of society. We're currently doing a biggie. People are being told they have to risk death or disability (from Covid) - for the good of society.

Wrt public transport specifically. Either the job is full-time WFH - in which case it can be outsourced cheaper abroad, or the employee still needs to occasionally go in and/or do site visits. In which case many will need a well functioning public transport system.

It's reasonable to expect people to pay the taxes decided upon by their democratically-elected leaders. If those leaders decide that public transit funding should remain the same or increase, then everyone should pay as required. That's very different from requiring people to use it, which - while bad - is still better than requiring everyone to resume commuting because some of them will use it. Doing that isn't necessary to maintain funding or operational capacity, and really serves no purpose.

Not every job can be outsourced abroad, even if it's 100% remote. Mine couldn't, at least not in the way you're thinking. My employer has specifically forbidden people from moving abroad while working remotely due to licensure issues. But regardless, if a job can be done 100% remotely, ordering people to return to the office for no job-related reason doesn't change that fact. If it can be outsourced, then it can still be outsourced once they go back.

If site visits are truly occasional, they don't require public transit. At most, they require either renting a car or hiring a taxi a few days every month. Public transit wasn't free to begin with, so most people would still come out ahead. If it's more than that, the costs of commuting would need to be factored into the salary package, which is what typically happens anyway.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 23:09

Even intra-city commutes on public transit can be lengthy, and (in the US, at least) often unsafe. Many who live in cities are still happy to not have to do them anymore.

This is the UK though. And also, when this happens, many more people aren't as privileged as to be able to relocate from a city (and if everyone did, the suburbs and villages would be as full as cities).

If we're talking about America, it's leading the way with the return to the office. They've acknowledged the need - for the sake of the national economy, and wider society in general.

If someone lives alone, there's usually no real problem with doing it from a studio.

Lots of couples have to live in studios. And how depressing will that be. Stuck all day every day in one room - to sleep and to work.

If they share with others, yes, space may be an issue. If the company makes WFH optional, they're free to go to the office and work there if they'd rather

But, use it or lose it. If lots of people WFH, companies will close offices (and start outsourcing the work abroad for cheaper labour).

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 23:00

buses to the 2 local hospitals are dedicated, free services.

They're not free. They're funded by tax income. Which the office based industries contribute billions towards.

I answered your question several posts back. I was working one or two days from home long before the pandemic. Like I said, that's a good balance (when possible, obviously depending on the job, as many can't be done from home at all).

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 22:57

@Tealightsandd

And the area near my home is much nicer and safer for exercising - peaceful tree-lined residential streets instead of an urban center with frighteningly bad drivers and frequent crime.

Yep. WFH is limited to those privileged enough to live in comfortable home environments suitable for home working.

Many people have to live in urban centres, with noisy traffic and high levels of crime. Often in cramped and/or shared housing. So going forwards the inequality gap will widen further. Office based roles will be only for those with the luxury of a WFH appropriate home.

I used to be one of them, and I'm glad I'm not anymore. But if they're stuck exercising in an urban center either way, they're still no worse off for WFH. Plus at least now they're free to work up a sweat over their lunch breaks if they're so inclined. Even intra-city commutes on public transit can be lengthy, and (in the US, at least) often unsafe. Many who live in cities are still happy to not have to do them anymore.

A detached house on a tree-lined street is hardly a requirement for working from home. If someone lives alone, there's usually no real problem with doing it from a studio. If they share with others, yes, space may be an issue. If the company makes WFH optional, they're free to go to the office and work there if they'd rather. I do believe that if an employer makes WFH mandatory and therefore doesn't provide an office, the cost savings to the employer from not paying rent on the office should be passed on to the employee who now has to pay for additional living space. I think that's what will happen once the market adjusts.

frazzledasarock · 17/09/2021 22:55

Nope not the company I work for, they absolutely cannot outsource our jobs to different countries.

And the only reason we have the jobs we do is because we’re all qualified and have years of experience.

Our company regularly has big companies poaching staff, people will just negotiate their preferred remuneration and go. It’s not actually easy to replace experienced staff by training up new under qualified people.

Hiring new people at the level of those who leave would be an expensive and lengthy process.

I’ve seen how difficult it’s been for recent vacancies to be filled. So they’ve had to restructure with varying success.

Nobody is irreplaceable, but depending on the person and role it can be very inconvenient and expensive.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:55

Full-time WFH will encourage and enable social anxiety. It will affect more people and more severely. It will creep up on many. As we've seen from the lockdowns, many people struggled to cope with returning to regular social interaction. Full-time WFH will make a very insular - and unequal - society.

Jayne35 · 17/09/2021 22:52

DH’s office have never had enough parking, overcrowded office etc. WFH is better for them and they should keep it IMO. They won’t though, they’ll insist everyone goes back then moan about the parking!

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:52

just don't think it's reasonable to expect others to resume otherwise-unnecessary commutes just for that reason.

So where does that end? Is it reasonable to expect other people to pay tax - to fund public services, including some they might not themselves use (eg. state education, mental health services, libraries, public parks, etc)? In a civilised modern society, we all generally have to do some things we'd rather not for the good of society. We're currently doing a biggie. People are being told they have to risk death or disability (from Covid) - for the good of society.

Wrt public transport specifically. Either the job is full-time WFH - in which case it can be outsourced cheaper abroad, or the employee still needs to occasionally go in and/or do site visits. In which case many will need a well functioning public transport system.

winnieanddaisy · 17/09/2021 22:50

I can't understand how you are still waiting for your driving license 3 months later . In May I applied for my new license online and received it within a week. Did you do it by post? If so your application may have got lost and DVLA have not received it.
I would suggest that you have a look at your bank account to see if the payment has gone out and if it hasn't then apply again online . If the payment has gone out , try phoning again, if you don't get through then write to them telling them you didn't receive it.
There are other ways of communicating with DVLA , maybe send them an email. Good luck .

BreadPita · 17/09/2021 22:44

@Tealightsandd

can cook nutritionally decent, tasty and relatively cheap lunches at lunchtime

I started doing that years ago - taking it to work with me, when I want a packed lunch (sometime it's nice to enjoy a cafe/sandwich shop meal or a lunch out with colleagues).

That's great, but it didn't make sense for me to either spend time cooking an extra meal after dinner or waking up early to cook in the morning. Now, cone lunchtime, I have access to my kitchen and fridge, so these concerns do not exist. Pret's ham and cheese baguettes aren't special. These chains exists because of office workers who are trying to buy back the time they spend commuting and at the office.
Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:44

And the area near my home is much nicer and safer for exercising - peaceful tree-lined residential streets instead of an urban center with frighteningly bad drivers and frequent crime.

Yep. WFH is limited to those privileged enough to live in comfortable home environments suitable for home working.

Many people have to live in urban centres, with noisy traffic and high levels of crime. Often in cramped and/or shared housing. So going forwards the inequality gap will widen further. Office based roles will be only for those with the luxury of a WFH appropriate home.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 22:40

@Tealightsandd

Plenty of teens and young adults grew up just fine in areas with no public transit whatsoever.

It's one of the first things brought up (time and time again) whenever there's a thread on here from someone looking to move more rural from a city.

People fall all over themselves to talk of how shit and limiting it was to grow up without good public transport - how it hindered their ability to be independent the heavy burden on parents to taxi their children everywhere, how difficult it is to get a job (loads can't be done from home).

We need more and improved public transport, not less.

That's something that can be discussed and democratically decided when public transit funding is reexamined. If enough people agree with you, that will be prioritised. I'm not opposed to preserving or expanding public transit so long as sufficient demand is there. I just don't think it's reasonable to expect others to resume otherwise-unnecessary commutes just for that reason.
Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:39

There are loads of jobs available in our sector now with WFH options, so our employer will face a big staff turnover if they force the issue.

There's also high unemployment levels - and a growing amount of underemployment (people having to take part-time and/or lower level jobs due to limited opportunities). It wouldn't be too difficult to train up/retrain/recruit from the large pool of talent out there. And like pp have pointed out, if it's full-time WFH, then yes, not all but many jobs can be outsourced cheaper abroad.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 22:37

Housework always done? But you have more housework because you're home all the time. I don't get that at all.

I suppose it's true that being in my spare bedroom for 50% more time makes it 50% dirtier. But to my mind, that doesn't translate into a need to vacuum it 50% more often.

Yes, you can put the washing machine on while you work, but you also have to make every meal at home and tidy up after yourself.

I can get meals delivered to my home just as I often did at the office. But I also often brought packed lunches to the office, so I (or my husband) still had to make them and wash the tupperware. I don't think there's much difference here, honestly. But I'm perfectly happy to eat simple foods like sandwiches and cereal. I suppose someone whose preferred meals involved more extensive prep might feel differently if they could no longer order them from restaurants.

Why can't you go on a walk on your lunch break from the office?
I could, I suppose, but not a run - I'd be sweaty and disgusting when I came back. Biking isn't practical, either, unless I bought a bike to keep at the office and wheeled it through the hall and into the elevator every day. Not sure that would fly with management, plus if I tried to do it in an urban center, I'd surely get hit by a car eventually. And the area near my home is much nicer and safer for exercising - peaceful tree-lined residential streets instead of an urban center with frighteningly bad drivers and frequent crime.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 22:31

@Tealightsandd

I mentioned my area, to make a point that wfh hasn't impacted public transport in every area.

Wonderful. For the insular. So people will be mostly confined to the area they currently live in? A pity for anyone who needs or wants to travel further afield. For work, or to a specialist hospital, to see friends, visit family who live elsewhere.

And public transport is only doing ok in any area right now because of the government bailouts. Which costs a lot of money to do. Something unsustainable if a permanent loss of the billions from office based industries.

And how is that impacted by people here returning to the office.

People don't travel long distances here on public transport, because its shit.

Werher they are at home or in an office they aren't using it. So sending the. Back yo office isn't a benefit to the public transport in their area. Again, buses to the 2 local hospitals are dedicated, free services. They don't also transport people to their office. Again, these buses are out on because people can't get to the hospital reliably, on public transport. So again, not a service impacted by wfh.

Seriously, are you suggesting people in Cumbria (as an example) must use public transport, even if its crap so that people in Newcastly can keep a service that's not being used on?

Again, because you refuse to answer, are you also a remote worker? Or an office worker? Or are you not working? I assume you use public transport and pay for it everyday? Just incase someone 200 miles away doesn't want to pose the number 53?

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:30

can cook nutritionally decent, tasty and relatively cheap lunches at lunchtime

I started doing that years ago - taking it to work with me, when I want a packed lunch (sometime it's nice to enjoy a cafe/sandwich shop meal or a lunch out with colleagues).

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 22:27

Plenty of teens and young adults grew up just fine in areas with no public transit whatsoever.

It's one of the first things brought up (time and time again) whenever there's a thread on here from someone looking to move more rural from a city.

People fall all over themselves to talk of how shit and limiting it was to grow up without good public transport - how it hindered their ability to be independent the heavy burden on parents to taxi their children everywhere, how difficult it is to get a job (loads can't be done from home).

We need more and improved public transport, not less.

Aggy35 · 17/09/2021 22:26

@ididitsocanyou

I find it interesting that all the perceived benefits of wfh are not actually work related. I.e “I love wfh because I can tidy the house.”

That’s not wfh! That’s tidying the house!

All the negatives are work related: lack of collaboration, productivity, accountability etc.

“I love wfh I get to walk in the park.”

Well you’re not bloody working then are you??

Spending a lot of time commuting ,spending money commuting ,spending less time with family etc...those are negatives not work related. My work means I deal with people in different countries and actually have very little to do with my colleagues besides gossiping.I used to sit at my desk and still have video calls etc.Not everybody is the same ,but people should accept that there are many who enjoy wfh and are not mentally affected by it.
Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 22:26

You mentioned your area as a way to refute my point. You basically said only old people take public transport in your area, as if that's in any way relevant to to the general situation on a national level. I wasn't the only one who thought that was a totally self absorbed comment that entirely missed the point, either.

If I was replying to any point you made it would have directed it at you.

And you think other people make it all about them?

I didn't say it was the same in all areas. I simply pointed out that public transport isn't impacted by wfh on some areas. Mine Included. Odd yoh find it so bothersome that not every area is like others

You arent the only one? And what? I am not the only one that thinks the remote worker calling people who want to wfh, selfish, is very very odd.

You just don't seem to be able to grasp, on any level, that you're not the centre of the universe. Yes, maybe the point about public transport doesn't apply to your area (and I'd still doubt that - perhaps people less privileged than you DO need to rely on it because they have no choice?) but so what? Who cares? I and other posters have said that it has been impacted where we are. I'm in London, which contains nearly 1/6 of the population of the entire UK. Public transport being scaled back is a massive deal here, even if it doesn't personally affectme.

I don't think it centres around me. I simply don't agree with you. The only person who expects people to arrange their lives so their own is benefitted is you. I am not the one trying to attach morality to people's working patterns, because it might make my eurostar tickets more expensive.

I have worked hybrid for years, I don't then judge other people for wanting to do the same. You have the benefit of remote working, you don't want others to have it because it may impact you

That's your only issue. If you really thought not using public transport, not buying daily coffees and lunch out and not working in an office was a selfish act YOU wouldn't be working remotely. You would be booking and paying for eurostar tickets to keep it in use. As that's what you suggested others did.

And no one said it was about 1 person. But where people don't use the public transport for commuting, them going back to work will not protect public transport. Because they didn't use it before and won't after. The same people are using it as were pre pandemic. So 'save our buses' isn't relevant to alot of people when it comes to the decision about wfh or not. It's relevant to many. But to many wfh or in the office will not impact it.

But oddly, you think anyone talking about an area with a different experience to yours, must be just selfish and only talking about themselves rather than talking about their area. But you can talk about your area and you are altruistic. But not actually doing what you think other must do.

Its just everyone else who needs to change their behaviour, to suit you. You can work remotely, but others can. That's the definition of selfishness.

Swipe left for the next trending thread