Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
ididitsocanyou · 18/09/2021 08:32

Re ‘no one wants to work anymore’ - and if they ever did.

Many people are industrious and want to work. If there is a national air of positivity around the concept of work then it becomes about more than earning wage. It becomes a matter of pride.

Compare the bowler hat man in the underground in the 60s with the wfh IT consultant of today. One ‘earned’ his right through his fortitude to wear the uniform and in return he garnered respect. He earned his life’s privileges through his work and dedication.

In comparison, we probably wouldn’t be able to identify the IT consultant. They could be in scruffy jeans, in the pub in the middle of the day. Or asleep. So where is the work ethic message for the next generation? If workers are not visible then nobody will want to become one. There is no sense of belonging or pride in ‘joining the workforce’.

This is going to end up one way I think. It will lead to a less productive, lower skilled but more entitled generation. Until we all get back to the understanding that work is hard and requires some fortitude and sacrifice in return for a certain lifestyle then productivity will slip. We also need to acknowledge that there are more benefits to working than money for both society and individual.

Work is and will always be about industry and productivity. Not blending it for a cushy home life where you can avoid seeing people you don’t like and swapping them for a dog. That’s not to say there isn’t a place for wfh. There is course is, especially as it helps ppl like me balance earning money with childcare. But it should definitely be the exception rather than the norm.

I think this has all started because what we saw as an acceptable commute started to get further and further away. People should find more local jobs. If you travel more than an hour per day to it from work then you shouldn’t have applied for that job in the first place. It isn’t within your vicinity. Find something closer.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 08:05

Wfh or a hybrid model doesn't just benefit the privilege.
Its been better for some who are disabled stay in the workforce, parents, those who have chronic conditions.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 07:59

You're going on as if I want to work remotely myself but I don't want anyone else to when my ENTIRE POINT is that I don't want to either!!!!

So you don't like it so therefore it's a bad thing. Why don't you get a non remote job then?

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 07:51

Someone said the argument re public transport is "silly" because "services exist to meet demand" and if that demand is reduced then it is quite right that services be reduced. There are many people who can't work from home - nurses, carers, shop workers, cleaners, hotel workers, etc, etc, etc - and those people need reliable and regular public transport. There are also people who may not be working but who want to get to the shops, the cinema, etc. etc. If they don't have access to good public transport, that, in turn, affects the viability of those businesses.

But there are plenty of people who drive to work & drive to the shops & the cinema hence why the model shifted from high street to places like Bluewater where lots drive to eat, shop & the cinema. High streets have been dying for years due to people shopping in out of town big complexes & online shopping but I didn't see anyone worried about public transport usage then. 2020 saw car ownership increase to a record number.
Surely someone who drives to work & parks in a car park instead of using the available public transport is just as responsible for the decline of the service as a remote worker?

Humblpi · 18/09/2021 07:50

Still love wfh and think the economy will adapt - we used to have community delivery services and shops and saw a return to that in lockdown. I find a hybrid system the worst of all worlds - i'm set up for work at home, if i go into the office i take my laptop and get a hot desk, so i dont gave my second screen and am less productive anyway. Boss wants people back in for 'cameraderie' but wfh us a dealbreaker for me now and i know they are struggling to recruit across the board so the ball's in my court.

Personally, i think we need and entirely new model when it comes to public transport. Train fares are fucking ridiculous for absolutely shit service.

Namenic · 18/09/2021 07:48

I guess it’s a battle between employers and employees. Hopefully there will be churn so that employees are matched with employers with similar working preferences. Having diverse facilities and flexibility sounds like it will make for greater inclusiveness and diversity within a team.

YouTubeAddict · 18/09/2021 07:44

I’m restarting WFH in just over a week after a 6 month hiatus. I literally can’t wait. My frontline NHS job was so stressful and I hated it (plus I was bullied for my disability) Just looking forward to being able to work at my own pace. Forward thinking businesses will survive. Unfortunately it’s a dog eat dog world and if public transport services aren’t required or are required less then it’s can’t purely be blamed on people who WFH.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 07:41

In London there has been a huge drive to get people to cycle to work over the last decade. That impacts public transport usage too.

Eleganz · 18/09/2021 07:38

@Dongdingdong

Those are pretty much the people who are still going regularly the rest of us are going in hybrid working under duress. And it won’t continue in our office I know that for a fact as people are just point blank refusing to go in.

@frazzledasarock So let me get this straight - your employer has been eminently reasonable by asking people to adopt a hybrid model (by which I assume you mean a mix of going into the office and WFH) and you genuinely think they will be forced to revert to people working fully from home? I think you’re going to be disappointed.

Entirely depends on how many people it is and what they do. Replacing skilled people us an utter pain in the arse.
Dongdingdong · 18/09/2021 04:41

Those are pretty much the people who are still going regularly the rest of us are going in hybrid working under duress. And it won’t continue in our office I know that for a fact as people are just point blank refusing to go in.

@frazzledasarock So let me get this straight - your employer has been eminently reasonable by asking people to adopt a hybrid model (by which I assume you mean a mix of going into the office and WFH) and you genuinely think they will be forced to revert to people working fully from home? I think you’re going to be disappointed.

Dongdingdong · 18/09/2021 04:18

Perhaps it is what you need and want, however I have noticed bills increased so actually wfh should be compensated for that.

Why should WFHers be compensated for higher bills when they’re saving a packet on transport costs?

halloweenie13 · 18/09/2021 03:49

Perhaps it is what you need and want, however I have noticed bills increased so actually wfh should be compensated for that. Also, not , everyone want's to return to the office , I work a minimum 20-30 hour week whilst finishing off masters and attempting to see friends and family in spare time. WFH allows me to successfully do this without impact on my work whereas social anxiety significantly impacts my work in an office environment

Hekatestorch · 18/09/2021 03:30

@Rozziie so you are looking for another in office Job?

Its you who is missing the point so spectacularly. You are throwing wild statements around about how selfish it is to want to wfh and you work full remotely and intend to keep doing it, to make your own life better.

@Tealightsandd the bus is free at the point of use. You knew exactly what I meant. It has to be so people can get to the hospital because public transport is so poor.

Also if people used public transport to get around and see family and friends at weekends, they still will at weekends. The people who will not be 'jumping in their cars instead' would have driven anyway.

For the most part, they don't have a car and then take public transport at weekends.

Mamanyt · 18/09/2021 01:18

I think that a balance between office time and WFH would be ideal. There are a good many businesses in the US that have said that once things are "more under control" (will they ever be if people WILL NOT vaccinate?) they plan on a split week.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 18/09/2021 01:18

No one wants to work anymore!

But how many people have ever worked because they enjoy it? I'm not saying no one has - there are people who love their jobs - but, particularly in the sectors that would formerly have been office-based and are now WFH, are there really so many people who would be working if they didn't have to?

NotMyCat · 18/09/2021 01:10

If you're ringing a call centre, the chances are it's not because they're WFH that affects the wait times
We are SO heavily monitored. For anyone that hasn't done it -
I log on at 8am exactly. Not 30 seconds past as that counts as late. Then I am available to take calls. Log off for my break (click break) at 10am and take 15 mins (to the second), same for lunch. The only time I am not available is if I click personal which is if I need the toilet or something and more than 5 mins personal would be "are you ok" type thing
After a call it automatically puts me back available with a 5 second break between calls
Everything is visible, my screen is recorded, my phone line is recorded and my manager can see exactly what status I am in (personal etc)

I take about 200 calls a day and we are getting battered, it's just busy 🤷🏽‍♀️ and there is actually only me WFH but people complain it's taking 5-10 mins to get through. It's not because of WFH as every other staff member is in!

ellyeth · 18/09/2021 00:52

I agree with you OP.

Someone said the argument re public transport is "silly" because "services exist to meet demand" and if that demand is reduced then it is quite right that services be reduced. There are many people who can't work from home - nurses, carers, shop workers, cleaners, hotel workers, etc, etc, etc - and those people need reliable and regular public transport. There are also people who may not be working but who want to get to the shops, the cinema, etc. etc. If they don't have access to good public transport, that, in turn, affects the viability of those businesses. For those who argue there is too much consumerism anyway, to some extent I agree, but that is the current economic model we have and, in my opinion, it can't be changed overnight without causing severe social and economic repercussions.

I think most people go along with the idea of some flexibility as to days spent working from home and going in to work. But I believe that working exclusively from home may have started to lose its appeal for both employee and employer. As has been mentioned, many people are finding it difficult to have their home and office in the same place for a number of reasons.

I found commuting to work tiring and stressful and I believe having perhaps one or two days working from home would have relieved some of that stress. However, working permanently from home would, I think, be very isolating and might, in the long run, affect people's confidence, skills and knowledge levels, ability to communicate easily and work as a team when necessary.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 18/09/2021 00:50

But you have more housework because you're home all the time. I don't get that at all.

You don't create much mess spending a day on your laptop, and you can do bits and pieces in your lunch hour which helps. Also, I wouldn't personally leave the washing machine going while I was out of the house at work, for safety reasons, but WFH I can pop a wash on first thing in the morning with no fears.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 00:36

Now it’s the other way around. It’s fashionable to prioritise mental well-being over work because we’re in a massive slump. It’s hard to get a promotion in your slippers!

Uk productivity has declined since the 08 crisis.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 00:32

No one wants to work anymore!

🤔

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 00:07

Also it won't help the environment. Many jobs can't be done from home, and people WFH will still want to travel - for leisure, to go shopping, get to medical appointments, visit friends and family.

They won't be able to do that (in an environmentally friendly way) if public transport is run down (more than it already is) because of the double whammy of massive loss of ticketing revenue and the tightened public finances, due to the national economy losing billions of office based industry income.

So instead people will get in their cars to travel around.

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 00:03

It can only be a good thing that people are allowed to prioritise life over work rather than work over life.

Not good if it's the privileged only. Those with the luxury of a home environment suitable for WFH. Fuck the rest, eh?

Times change and how things get done change.

Not always for the best.

We're on a marathon sprint towards turning into a Brazil or India. Friends from both those countries hate how it is there - the terrible inequality. Drastic extremes of rich and poor. A wealthy minority living very well indeed - and an increasingly desperate destitute majority, with no or limited access to essential public services.

Sad that so many welcome this.

Ewan83 · 17/09/2021 23:51

I do think that wfh or more remotely is the future. If we really want to get real about being greener and helping the environment then surely commuting will need to become more limited. I know people talk about younger starters struggling with no seniors in the office but in 50 years time do we all expect we’ll still be 9-5? It can only be a good thing that people are allowed to prioritise life over work rather than work over life. Times change and how things get done change. Everyone young or old has to move with those changes esp now we have the tech to make it possible.

ididitsocanyou · 17/09/2021 23:41

I think it’s early days for many of you to be honest. I’m not dissing the fact that WFH is great for so many reasons, but those reasons are beneficial on a largely personal basis, not a professional basis.

Clearly, it is still a novelty for many. Two years is no time to judge the success of this experiment. You might want to wait until you’ve been at home for fifteen years or so and you’ve got older and your kids don’t even think you ‘really’ work, not in like a proper job like their friends’ parents do. You might need to see a few recessions through to see who’s most disposable when budgets are cut. Yes, your family life may be stronger. Some aspects of your health may improve. Your house may be prettier. But I will bet that your career would have suffered. You would have plateaued at some point. If you are still wfh and are earning what you are now or more in fifteen years time, I’d be surprised.

The reasons for this are clearly visible, when you evaluate the perceived benefits of wfh. If you are someone who is prioritising the leisure gains rather than the work gains then that speaks volumes about your perception of work.

The four day week in my mind is a terrible idea. Flexible hours across the board further condemn our work ethic to death.

No one wants to work anymore!

In the boom times when the economy is up and there is money to be made, people will squeeze every hour out of their day to work. People get high on it. Work becomes fashionable. Those who work, who are seen to work, have power. Now it’s the other way around. It’s fashionable to prioritise mental well-being over work because we’re in a massive slump. It’s hard to get a promotion in your slippers!

Nothing wrong in prioritising home life over work life, I’ve g doing it myself and don’t regret it, but you need to have your eyes wide open. It gets tedious. When I went freelance to wfh, I thought I’d have it all but I didn’t I really gave up my career. It just happens so slowly you hardly notice.

If you’re a youngish couple and you’re both wfh and don’t intend to go back in, I’d worry. You will end up poorer with fewer opportunities and a reduced network. You will be comfortable, but forgotten. I’m talking long term. For now, yes it’s a nice change. But we are better together. What I’d give to sit in an office with a team and delegate and make progress! Be part of something bigger than little old me. Talk to a colleague for moral support when things go wrong. It’s soooo important.

We need to be careful what we wish for I guess whichever side of the fence you sit on. Me, I know I’d get bored of the commute in a week Grin.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 23:33

I lived in a studio for several years. I did plenty of work from home in that time (well before covid), and never found it depressing.

There's always outliers. And of course, things that are a temporary novelty when we're young become very different when permanent long-term.

It's widely recognised by medical experts that it is not physically or mentally healthy to be confined to one room all day, everyday, night and day. People will become depressed and insular and will suffer increased social anxiety. And heaven help the couples stuck in a studio all day and night together!