Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
gibletjane · 18/09/2021 10:37

The young people I know are far more worried about

high rents/buying a house
wage stagnation/increased taxes/less disposable income
never being able to retire as pension won't be enough/state pension age moving out
not having a free at the point of care nhs in the future.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 10:34

I totally agree, but working from home doesn't give a good work-life balance to many people. You have nowhere to really relax as you're constantly at your workplace

I think it depends on the individual. My brother & sil worked 100% remotely pre covid but they often used places where you could go to work (not sure on the name).
But I agree that a choice is the best option, for me hybrid is what works for me.

EllieLondon5 · 18/09/2021 10:26

My husband and I have worked from home since March 2020. Our employers are both offering a very flexible hybrid model - basically do what you like, as long as the work is done, we don’t care.

I think we’ll probably stagger it so that one of us is home and the other in the office. That way there is someone here for the kids. It’s good to have this option.

However, we are still using nursery and wraparound care (kids are 7 and 4). Could not get a thing done otherwise. I do get a bit annoyed when parents of very young kids are using it as a way to avoid childcare - you’re still supposed to be working, not looking after your kids?

Obviously different kettle of fish if your kids are older and more self sufficient.

Gwenhwyfar · 18/09/2021 10:20

@starlilly88

I've been worried about this from the beginning. I will be encouraging my kids not to go into careers where they don't see any colleagues and have to work from their bedrooms for the rest of their lives. It's damaging and isolating for young people to not see anyone from work just because their senior managers want to work from their big houses and gardens. And local cafes won't thrive, most people just eat lunch at home, not spend it locally
I'm worried about people being worried about young people! It's not just young people who need interaction or training to to see others work to be able to learn from them. But yes obviously if you have a small place wfh is much more difficult and the bosses will always be able to choose whether work or office. I've heard of some who forced all their staff to wfh and then went in themselves because obviously there's no Covid risk then.
Gwenhwyfar · 18/09/2021 10:18

"Everyone should be supported to have a good work life balance, not just those with childcare needs. "

I totally agree, but working from home doesn't give a good work-life balance to many people. You have nowhere to really relax as you're constantly at your workplace.

starlilly88 · 18/09/2021 10:09

I've been worried about this from the beginning. I will be encouraging my kids not to go into careers where they don't see any colleagues and have to work from their bedrooms for the rest of their lives. It's damaging and isolating for young people to not see anyone from work just because their senior managers want to work from their big houses and gardens. And local cafes won't thrive, most people just eat lunch at home, not spend it locally

QueenBee70 · 18/09/2021 10:07

@Mamanyt

I think that a balance between office time and WFH would be ideal. There are a good many businesses in the US that have said that once things are "more under control" (will they ever be if people WILL NOT vaccinate?) they plan on a split week.
Yes they will be , my friend is part of a government study and still has natural antibodies against covid after contracting it ten months ago with no symptoms .
gibletjane · 18/09/2021 10:01

Perhaps you also need to improve your reading comprehension, then.

From what I can read, you remote work but don't like it although you haven't said why you can't change your job or explained why it's ok for you but not others.

What I can't comprehend is why remote working equals vile, selfish & without a thought for others & why you would label yourself as such & your posts haven't enlightened me.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 18/09/2021 09:57

in return for a certain lifestyle

Well my lifestyle felt a bit shit before working from home.

then productivity will slip

No there’s ways to manage that. You focus on outcomes and output not how many hours someone sits in an office.

We also need to acknowledge that there are more benefits to working than money for both society and individual.

So far the benefits to me as an individual are much greater wfh. Society will adapt. Like it has many times.

Work is and will always be about industry and productivity. Not blending it for a cushy home life where you can avoid seeing people you don’t like and swapping them for a dog.

A lot of us and our employers have now realised you can have both. Goddess forbid we should be happier. People like you want us to be miserable.

That’s not to say there isn’t a place for wfh. There is course is, especially as it helps ppl like me balance earning money with childcare. But it should definitely be the exception rather than the norm.

Everyone should be supported to have a good work life balance, not just those with childcare needs. Given the climate emergency and this opportunity to reduce travel and improve wellbeing it should be the norm not the exception. At least a hybrid model should be.

I think this has all started because what we saw as an acceptable commute started to get further and further away.

It was never acceptable. Sometimes you don’t fully realise how bad something was until you get out of it.

Find something closer.

Insulting. Not everyone can. You sound like Norman get on your bike Tebbit. He didn’t say it for climate reasons. (He said it because a lot of Tory politicians don’t really give a shit about ordinary people).

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 09:53

You do realise that disabled people often need to go to things like hospital appointments? To visit family? And many would prefer to actually go out to work? Do you think 'disabled people' are some monolithic group?

Why is the above relevant to what I posted? Again why do you think Unison are campaigning for increased remote working rights?

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 09:51

This is what you have to contend with. It's a hopeless battle. The two tier society is already here - you saw it during covid. The middle classes comfortably working from home, baking bread on the aga and drinking gin in the garden while poor people had to go out and expose themselves to covid for their minimum wage jobs. And these people want to keep that going because guess what...they're alright, Jack!

Again this is way too simplistic & completely ignores the fact the vast majority of people had the " I'm alright, Jack" attitude pre pandemic in terms of how their life choices had a knock on effect on others. You mentioned flying upthread but you are aware that UK & US flight impacts others in poorer countries in terms of climate change so there's that old "I'm alright, Jack" attitude. Eating a frigging avocado is bad for others. I'm just unsure why remote working triggers this weird moral stance but all the other things we do doesn't. If you don't like remote working then fine but you can't take the moral high ground.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 09:47

@gibletjane

We shouldn't run half empty trains just because disabled people might need them.

Err why do you think Unison is calling on the government to give disabled people a new right to work from home if they w ish and for employers to face penalties if they don’t comply?

You do realise that disabled people often need to go to things like hospital appointments? To visit family? And many would prefer to actually go out to work? Do you think 'disabled people' are some monolithic group?
Rozziie · 18/09/2021 09:45

[quote gibletjane]**@Rozziie* I'm not sure why you're labelling @Hekatestorch* posts as incoherent as you really aren't making a lot of sense yourself. [/quote]
Perhaps you also need to improve your reading comprehension, then.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 09:43

We shouldn't run half empty trains just because disabled people might need them.

Err why do you think Unison is calling on the government to give disabled people a new right to work from home if they w ish and for employers to face penalties if they don’t comply?

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 09:42

@Dongdingdong

Perhaps it is what you need and want, however I have noticed bills increased so actually wfh should be compensated for that.

Why should WFHers be compensated for higher bills when they’re saving a packet on transport costs?

Maybe they're not? A lot of people bought a home near work specifically so they didn't need to do a long commute. Why should they have to pay higher bills because their employer decided to make them WFH?
Rozziie · 18/09/2021 09:38

@Tealightsandd

It can only be a good thing that people are allowed to prioritise life over work rather than work over life.

Not good if it's the privileged only. Those with the luxury of a home environment suitable for WFH. Fuck the rest, eh?

Times change and how things get done change.

Not always for the best.

We're on a marathon sprint towards turning into a Brazil or India. Friends from both those countries hate how it is there - the terrible inequality. Drastic extremes of rich and poor. A wealthy minority living very well indeed - and an increasingly desperate destitute majority, with no or limited access to essential public services.

Sad that so many welcome this.

I agree.

But are you surprised? You've seen the vile, selfish way people think from posts on this thread.

Who cares if public transport gets slashed? Only old people use it.

We shouldn't run half empty trains just because disabled people might need them.

Anyone who doesn't want to work in a damaging way they didn't sign up for should change career.

I don't care if young people aren't getting support in the workplace - not my problem.

This is what you have to contend with. It's a hopeless battle. The two tier society is already here - you saw it during covid. The middle classes comfortably working from home, baking bread on the aga and drinking gin in the garden while poor people had to go out and expose themselves to covid for their minimum wage jobs. And these people want to keep that going because guess what...they're alright, Jack!

For now.

QueenBee70 · 18/09/2021 09:38

I agree . After my neighbour caused a fire I am having a nightmare getting the insurance sorted out as they are working from home .

I think both socially and practically there needs to be a better balance as it’s damaging for people’s physical and mental health , plus like you say we risk losing local services . I think it has highlighted a need for flexibility but a total blanket work from home policy is not good .

I don’t actually understand why anyone is still working from home anyway , I work in a school and have down throughout all the lockdowns and there are hundreds of us all in the building every day . We need to get back to normality for the sake of our children to avoid making this unhealthy balance a precedent for their future.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 09:32

@Rozziie I'm not sure why you're labelling @Hekatestorch posts as incoherent as you really aren't making a lot of sense yourself.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 09:28

[quote Hekatestorch]@Rozziie so you are looking for another in office Job?

Its you who is missing the point so spectacularly. You are throwing wild statements around about how selfish it is to want to wfh and you work full remotely and intend to keep doing it, to make your own life better.

@Tealightsandd the bus is free at the point of use. You knew exactly what I meant. It has to be so people can get to the hospital because public transport is so poor.

Also if people used public transport to get around and see family and friends at weekends, they still will at weekends. The people who will not be 'jumping in their cars instead' would have driven anyway.

For the most part, they don't have a car and then take public transport at weekends.[/quote]
OMG I'm actually laughing hysterically now. If what you got from my posts is that I want to keep WFH to make my life better, there's no talking to you, is there? Just keep living on your own little planet, twisting people's words into something not resembling anything they originally said and arguing against points nobody actually made.

Mollymoostoo · 18/09/2021 08:53

My DP has started drinking at 4.30pm daily when he didn't usually get home till after 6.30pm. the savings in petrol have been used up as he now gambles every night. He has put on weight, rarely goes out and we argue all the time
I have been in and out of the office over the past year only really WFH in the 2 strict lockdowns. I have lost weight, gone back to uni and have a social life.
The isolation of enforced WFH is shocking on a person's MH. I agree with having a choice but some companies see this as a way of reducing their costs and passing them on to their staff.
I can't even clean my home as he is still working after I get back. I just want him out the home and facing his boss so he is more accountable for his behaviour.

LadyWithLapdog · 18/09/2021 08:51

That’s sarcasm, by the way. @ididitsocanyou is so out of touch I thought it prudent to point it out. Your bowler hat man vs scruffy IT is a work of genius. That’s also sarcasm.

LadyWithLapdog · 18/09/2021 08:48

“It isn’t within your vicinity. Find something closer.” Thanks for the advice. Millions are getting a lightbulb moment.

Polkadotties · 18/09/2021 08:43

@ididitsocanyou

Re ‘no one wants to work anymore’ - and if they ever did.

Many people are industrious and want to work. If there is a national air of positivity around the concept of work then it becomes about more than earning wage. It becomes a matter of pride.

Compare the bowler hat man in the underground in the 60s with the wfh IT consultant of today. One ‘earned’ his right through his fortitude to wear the uniform and in return he garnered respect. He earned his life’s privileges through his work and dedication.

In comparison, we probably wouldn’t be able to identify the IT consultant. They could be in scruffy jeans, in the pub in the middle of the day. Or asleep. So where is the work ethic message for the next generation? If workers are not visible then nobody will want to become one. There is no sense of belonging or pride in ‘joining the workforce’.

This is going to end up one way I think. It will lead to a less productive, lower skilled but more entitled generation. Until we all get back to the understanding that work is hard and requires some fortitude and sacrifice in return for a certain lifestyle then productivity will slip. We also need to acknowledge that there are more benefits to working than money for both society and individual.

Work is and will always be about industry and productivity. Not blending it for a cushy home life where you can avoid seeing people you don’t like and swapping them for a dog. That’s not to say there isn’t a place for wfh. There is course is, especially as it helps ppl like me balance earning money with childcare. But it should definitely be the exception rather than the norm.

I think this has all started because what we saw as an acceptable commute started to get further and further away. People should find more local jobs. If you travel more than an hour per day to it from work then you shouldn’t have applied for that job in the first place. It isn’t within your vicinity. Find something closer.

This whole post is utter nonsense
gibletjane · 18/09/2021 08:39

Until we all get back to the understanding that work is hard and requires some fortitude and sacrifice in return for a certain lifestyle then productivity will slip. We also need to acknowledge that there are more benefits to working than money for both society and individual.

I'm not sure why remote working impacts fortitude & sacrifice. Why do you think UK productivity was so low pre pandemic?

There is course is, especially as it helps ppl like me balance earning money with childcare. But it should definitely be the exception rather than the norm.

Why should your situation be the exception though?

notthemum · 18/09/2021 08:37

I have been in quite poor health over the last eighteen months or so. However my GPs have been great. I have much more chance of a phone appointment. One of them actually phones me every 2/3 weeks to check on me and they arranged for nurses to come to the house when I needed them. I have been seen at different health authorities when they have had a space and it has been good.
However I have received and continue to receive messages from telephone company who have hiked up my bill by £14. Per month and it is impossible to speak to them. They have also been charging for a different phone that I had prior to this one and I cannot speak to anyone about it.
I have also received loads of letters from the water board demanding cash for previous address. When I finally managed to speak to a person, they were obviously WFH. There were small children in the backgrond who kept screaming and crying, the operative could not hear or understand me properly and they were extremely rude.

DVLA although incredibly slow have been far easier to speak to and much more helpful.
People at the councìl have become even worse at answering their phones and even less help than usual. Finally of course is the DWP. In normal times they are pretty much useless but they are now worse.
So all in all I have found it to have improved things in some ways and made them considerbly worse in others.