Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
ididitsocanyou · 18/09/2021 13:20

I don’t know why people get so triggered by a bit of logic. If you don’t like commuting, either move or get a job closer to home. If we all did that then there would be more jobs on our doorsteps (as people from outside the area are not filling them) and house prices would reflect local wages. It’s what people used to do. The only alternative is to commute or wfh. The latter is not in my opinion the answer it’s being made out to be.
I am the perfect example of a wfh person and why you may want to consider your options I left a career 16 years ago and have tread water ever since. I have to fork out myself for training that I would have got for free had I stayed in the office, from just watching and learning from my peers. I used to be sociable before isolation made me socially anxious. I can’t mentally unload on anyone as I am completely alone and deal with the bad days alone and never get to laugh or share or run my ideas past anyone. I am paranoid that I am missing out on new techniques and better ways to do things because I am not connected to a broader team or workforce.

It has its uses yes but wfh is not the answer to our modern day problems. As other people say, a bit of both is probably best.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 12:58

The vast majority of companies are looking at a hybrid model as that is what suits their business. Most young people also favour the hybrid option.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 12:53

Yes, most people on this thread are utterly incapable of seeing anything outside of their own life and interests. That's the entire point.

Do you really not see the irony in this statement?

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 12:51

Other people are selfish because you don't want to take responsibility for creating a daily routine for yourself?

Exactly, it's not about public transport or other strawman it's about that posters own needs & wants & wanting others to change to what suits them whilst simultaneously calling others selfish! It's astounding!

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 12:48

It's already been mentioned by me and others that a lot of people find it very difficult to go out and exercise for the sake of it. Many, many people depend on having 'somewhere to go' and a regular routine, for their mental health and wellbeing.

And as mentioned by others on this thread many don't need to have "somewhere to go" & remote working is better for their mental health & wellbeing.

But I guess fuck them, eh? It doesn't impact you

🤔

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 12:45

Because you posted it as a response to what I said about public transport, as if campaigning for the right for disabled people to WFH means none of them need public transport!!!??

No I posted it as a response to why some people like increased remote working. How is that irrelevant?!

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 12:44

@BreadPita

I'm not sure how many times I need to say I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT MYSELF!

My bad. I guess I assumed you were talking about yourself because plenty of people (myself and lots of people in this thread included) have seen a positive mental health impact from working from home.
I assumed you put the experience of people who liked not having the choice to WFH over people who like having the choice because you were part of the former cohort.
It doesn't really make sense otherwise. Offices haven't disappeared, there's just more acceptance of home working. Some people in my office are back 5 times a week. I haven't been to the office for almost 2 years and I genuinely despised it. Why is that not a good thing?

Yes, most people on this thread are utterly incapable of seeing anything outside of their own life and interests. That's the entire point.

Offices HAVE disappeared. A lot of my friends' offices have closed for good, or are down to about a quarter of the space they used to have. That takes away all the opportunities for properly getting to know all your colleagues, having any kind of 'buzz' in the office, young people getting to learn from all of their senior colleagues.

I'm sure it is a good thing for some people to WFH, but I don't think it's good for society in general. Young people were already spending far too much time home alone, staring at screens, etc. and now the little incentive they had to get out and about has gone. It will have impacts on public service provision, as noted by another poster. People from poorer backgrounds who don't have decent space to work in will be disproportionately affected compared to those with large houses and gardens. People from disadvantaged backgrounds will now not be mixing with people from other backgrounds at work, learning from them and being inspired to aspire to more.

Before the pandemic, lots of industries already had a genuine choice. I was always able to work at least one day a week from home if I wanted, even two. Why didn't the people who claim WFH is essential for their mental health get one of those jobs? Why do they now expect people who didn't sign up for a life of working from their bedroom to be OK with it?

BreadPita · 18/09/2021 12:30

I'm not sure how many times I need to say I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT MYSELF!

My bad. I guess I assumed you were talking about yourself because plenty of people (myself and lots of people in this thread included) have seen a positive mental health impact from working from home.
I assumed you put the experience of people who liked not having the choice to WFH over people who like having the choice because you were part of the former cohort.
It doesn't really make sense otherwise. Offices haven't disappeared, there's just more acceptance of home working. Some people in my office are back 5 times a week. I haven't been to the office for almost 2 years and I genuinely despised it. Why is that not a good thing?

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 12:20

@BreadPita

It's already been mentioned by me and others that a lot of people find it very difficult to go out and exercise for the sake of it. Many, many people depend on having 'somewhere to go' and a regular routine, for their mental health and wellbeing.

There isn't anything mandated by going to the office that you couldn't add to your routine yourself (apart from physically interacting specifically with your co-workers).
Other people are selfish because you don't want to take responsibility for creating a daily routine for yourself? Hmm

I'm not sure how many times I need to say I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT MYSELF!

How do you not understand that a lot of people really need the routine and social interaction of going to work? People already struggling with confidence, depression, etc. now have absolutely no reason to ever leave the house. Do you think that's a good thing?

BreadPita · 18/09/2021 12:13

It's already been mentioned by me and others that a lot of people find it very difficult to go out and exercise for the sake of it. Many, many people depend on having 'somewhere to go' and a regular routine, for their mental health and wellbeing.

There isn't anything mandated by going to the office that you couldn't add to your routine yourself (apart from physically interacting specifically with your co-workers).
Other people are selfish because you don't want to take responsibility for creating a daily routine for yourself? Hmm

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 11:56

@gibletjane

I know another who is a student and was totting up a grand total of 200 steps a day while wfh in just his bedroom with other family members in all the other rooms. I checked and it really was 200 and not 2k steps.

I had days like this as a student where I barely moved from the bed!

I don't think it's the norm to not move from the bed/room though is it? Even during the height of lockdown my local park was rammed with people exercising pre, post work & around lunchtime.
I walk to work through a park & a few yrs ago I would be uncomfortable in certain parts as I wouldn't see a soul. Even at 6am it's busy now.

It's already been mentioned by me and others that a lot of people find it very difficult to go out and exercise for the sake of it. Many, many people depend on having 'somewhere to go' and a regular routine, for their mental health and wellbeing.

But fuck them, eh? It doesn't impact you.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 11:53

@gibletjane

Perhaps you also need to improve your reading comprehension, then.

From what I can read, you remote work but don't like it although you haven't said why you can't change your job or explained why it's ok for you but not others.

What I can't comprehend is why remote working equals vile, selfish & without a thought for others & why you would label yourself as such & your posts haven't enlightened me.

I've explained my position time and time again, and the reasons why I hold it. If your reading comprehension is too poor to understand, that's not my fault.
Rozziie · 18/09/2021 11:52

@gibletjane

You do realise that disabled people often need to go to things like hospital appointments? To visit family? And many would prefer to actually go out to work? Do you think 'disabled people' are some monolithic group?

Why is the above relevant to what I posted? Again why do you think Unison are campaigning for increased remote working rights?

Because you posted it as a response to what I said about public transport, as if campaigning for the right for disabled people to WFH means none of them need public transport!!!??

Why even mention it? It's completely irrelevant.

likearoomwithoutaroof · 18/09/2021 11:47

A hybrid is working for us. I'm a sahm with two small (5 and 3) children and DH works full time. Pre-covid he worked in an office 1.5 hours away from home. He'd leave at 7am and be home at 7pm, missing pretty much everything with the children Monday-Friday.

He worked from home full time from March 2020 until two weeks ago. He's had invaluable time with the children, been here for baths and bedtimes and has been able to do the school run when he wants to or is able to around work (his work hours are flexible and he wants to do this, it's not be being lazy and wanting him to do 'my' jobs). We're also fortunate enough to have a study, so he has an office at home so it's not like he's working from the living room etc.

However, him being at home full time hasn't been all great. We've been under each other's feet. The summer holidays were very tricky, having the children at home full time, hosting play dates etc, with him trying to work wasn't always great. So over the summer he started doing a few days a week in the office. He works Mon-Thurs now, just longer days. So we've decided he goes into the office 2 days and week and WFH 2 days. We'd found that having him home full time meant he was not seeing anyone but me for days at a time and some weeks he'd barely leave the house. We had nothing to talk about in the evenings, and as nice as it was having some company I found that he was getting over involved when I didn't need him to when I was trying to get on with stuff at home that I'd always done without him perfectly fine which drove me mad. I also really need some downtime alone, it's just how I am. Which always worked before, and now he works in the office the days our youngest is at preschool so I have two days a week to myself to get on without him trying to get involved!

It's a win win for us. We save on two days fuel, wear and tear on the car etc, he's able to be more involved in school where work allows, he stops work to be involved at bedtime each evening (which is good also because it stops him working crazy hours which he would easily do without the 'stop' time). He gets to do homework with the eldest before bed, which he loves. He also gets two days in the office to work without any interruption, the chance to catch up with colleagues in person, have his face seen (which lets face it, whatever the wrongs or rights of it is important).

I have no doubt that at some point in the future he'll be back in the office full time but at the moment and for the foreseeable future his employer is completely happy for people to do whatever works best for them as long as the work is done. So we're sticking with 50/50 for as long as possible. He works on an enclosed site in the middle of nowhere and always took a packed lunch anyway so he wasn't contributing to coffee shops etc regardless. I don't think places like Pret and Costa having a monopoly is a good thing anyway. Hopefully some of them will close and we'll have more local businesses back - our local high street is full of big chain cafes, hairdressers, charity shops and bookies but we've got not one clothes or shoe shop. There are so many empty units. It's a shame.

BreadPita · 18/09/2021 11:42

Someone said the argument re public transport is "silly" because "services exist to meet demand" and if that demand is reduced then it is quite right that services be reduced. There are many people who can't work from home - nurses, carers, shop workers, cleaners, hotel workers, etc, etc, etc - and those people need reliable and regular public transport.

I said this. You made a large list of people who will still make use of public transport. This means revenue will still be there and the service will still be there.
To give you a more concrete illustration, part of my commute used to involve getting the central line at Bank. A train would come every minute but it was still common to have to let 3 or 4 trains pass before I could get on.
If you got rid of all the office workers due to WFH, you could probably reduce that to one every 5 minutes (for example) and still not have those overcrowding issues. Noone is left stranded by an extra 4 minute wait. The current frequency exists to (inadequately) meet current demand.

DarlingFell · 18/09/2021 11:40

YABU

WFH is AMAZING. It has improved my quality of life no end. My production and quality of work is the same, if not more, WFH. I go into the office twice a week still, the trains and tubes are packed!

It's not my job to keep overpriced, tax dodging coffee chains in business Confused

tiddlysquat · 18/09/2021 11:15

Agree it should be individual choice where the work is done. I have no problem downing tools at 5pm as my work is fairly low down my life priority list but I know that's not the same for everyone and it's more difficult for many especially if they're having to work in their bedroom in a house share.

PattyPan · 18/09/2021 11:13

@daisytweet

Without a doubt it's bad for mental and physical health and terrible for the economy. It needs to stop.
I’ve lost 6kg and my mental health has improved vastly. I’ve got over £5k back for myself that I’m spending in lots of different places rather than the train company - is that worse for the economy?

@calvados I’ve never worn heels to work (or anywhere) because they are so bad for your feet. Nor do I wear restrictive pencil/suit skirts because I like to be able to move properly. My office also didn’t require suits for men, just shirt (no tie) and trousers. Workwear has been getting less formal for years even before the pandemic.

tiddlysquat · 18/09/2021 11:13

Best for me and my job to wfh full time. I had a 2 hour commute each way and wasn't very productive in the office. I brought my own coffee and lunch so it was just the rail fare I spent on- I'm not willing to go in to support public transport though I'm afraid, it cost me £50 a day

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 11:11

but the lockdown wasn't normal was it?

wfh during a lockdown is not the same as wfh.

Gwenhwyfar · 18/09/2021 11:08

"I don't think it's the norm to not move from the bed/room though is it?"

Isn't it? He couldn't go to the living room or kitchen as his parents were working in those.
At the height of lockdown, we were only allowed out once and for less than an hour, so yes, it was normal not to move much.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 10:54

I know another who is a student and was totting up a grand total of 200 steps a day while wfh in just his bedroom with other family members in all the other rooms. I checked and it really was 200 and not 2k steps.

I had days like this as a student where I barely moved from the bed!

I don't think it's the norm to not move from the bed/room though is it? Even during the height of lockdown my local park was rammed with people exercising pre, post work & around lunchtime.
I walk to work through a park & a few yrs ago I would be uncomfortable in certain parts as I wouldn't see a soul. Even at 6am it's busy now.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 10:50

yes something like that. As they are both freelance it was also a way of them socialising. I don't know what they paid but they felt it was with it.

Gwenhwyfar · 18/09/2021 10:49

@gibletjane

The young people I know are far more worried about

high rents/buying a house
wage stagnation/increased taxes/less disposable income
never being able to retire as pension won't be enough/state pension age moving out
not having a free at the point of care nhs in the future.

The young person I know who had to work from his bed should be worried about that if he understands ergonomics! I know another who is a student and was totting up a grand total of 200 steps a day while wfh in just his bedroom with other family members in all the other rooms. I checked and it really was 200 and not 2k steps.
Gwenhwyfar · 18/09/2021 10:48

"My brother & sil worked 100% remotely pre covid but they often used places where you could go to work (not sure on the name)."

Co-working spaces? There is one opening near me, but it's £10 a day. It might be cheaper to go for a light lunch in a cafe and have a drink every hour and a half or so.
I just hope we don't get another compulsory wfh order. I'm not in the Uk and it's still highly recommended here.