Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 16:17

I would hope that in the long-term these jobs would even out across both locations..

They won't. Because of the significant difference in population numbers. Far fewer people live and get coffee out in a small town than do in a city or larger town.

Huge numbers of jobs will go - and it's not just coffee shops. It's cobblers, dry cleaners, office cleaners, maintenance and postroom roles, newsagents, sandwich shops, tailors, taxi drivers (business meeting work is a significant proportion of their income).

It's a double whammy for the economy. Huge number of unemployed and massive loss of tax revenue (estimated by leading accountancy firms as around £460 billion per year).

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 16:09

But these things have been in decline for years which had nothing to do with remote working.

Yes like I said they're already in a bad state. The solution to underfunding, surprisingly enough however, isn't significantly more underfunding.

JustABloodyMinute · 18/09/2021 16:02

I consider myself really lucky that I have a job that allows me to choose where I work. Many people don't have the space or the luxury of a choice. I work a hybrid work pattern and it suits me, especially with school drop-off/pickups etc. However, I do worry about the world of work that my children will be joining and fear that if they work in an office job that could in theory be done from home then they would be forced to do just that. I can't see how that would work for young people, especially those still living with parents or in flat shares. We certainly don't have space for the whole family to work from this home!

We are also completely reliant on public transport, so would really struggle to manage if that was cut back at all.

I don't tend to use coffee shops very often, but I do not know my local ones have done really well out of the pandemic compared to the city centre ones. I would hope that in the long-term these jobs would even out across both locations.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 15:53

@Tealightsandd of course all those things are absolutely true. Nobody is able to refuse those points, because they're all valid. But people's desire to roll out of bed at 8.55 and be able to eat lunch in the garden outweighs all of that, apparently, so you're on a hiding to nothing in here.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 15:50

It's also a problem if you want decent functioning public services (nurseries, park maintenance, libraries, social care, mental health services, street lighting, public transport).

But these things have been in decline for years which had nothing to do with remote working. We have already seen tax rises & I don't doubt we will see more regardless if we work in an office or not. We have an ageing population, decades of under investment & Brexit.

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 15:43

It's also a problem if you want decent functioning public services (nurseries, park maintenance, libraries, social care, mental health services, street lighting, public transport).

If you think they're in bad enough state already after years of underfunding, you ain't seen nothing yet.

The office based industries contribute around £460 billion to the national economy. Money used to fund our public services.

The alternative is huge tax increases. Or no public services including public transport (ticket revenue is a major part of how it is funded).

Sadly for many, this is going to be a case of not appreciating what you're got until it's too late.

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 15:36

@speakout

*I think 99% of people arguing in favour of wfh just enjoy the creature comforts tbh
  • e.g. roll out of bed at 08:50 and switch laptop on and chill out in your dressing gown.*

And that is a problem?

It's a problem if WFH full-time becomes the default. Not for the privileged - those who have the luxury of a comfortable home environment suitable for WFH, and who are at a settled stage of life.

Huge problem for the disadvantaged - those living in noisy and/or cramped spaces and/or in difficult relationships, and the young (plus mature career changers) - who will miss out on the opportunities that in person interaction offers. Networking, professional development, in-person mentoring, the social interaction, experiencing the rich diversity of life by working with people of varying ages and with different life experiences, stages of life, and backgrounds.

Young people face starting their working lives stuck in a childhood bedroom or a shitty houseshare. A world-shrinking insular life.

And people without the privilege of a home environment conducive to work face being locked out of career opportunities.

Excellent way to significantly increase inequality in society (as if it isn't already bad enough).

Tealightsandd · 18/09/2021 15:25

@ArblemarchTFruitbat

No one wants to work anymore!

But how many people have ever worked because they enjoy it? I'm not saying no one has - there are people who love their jobs - but, particularly in the sectors that would formerly have been office-based and are now WFH, are there really so many people who would be working if they didn't have to?

I think so, yes.

Work is about so much more than just money. Sense of purpose, an identity - and face to face social interaction with other human beings.

We see it with big money lottery winners who were in low paid jobs before their win.

Many keep on working - often in the same low paid job.

Lots of people want better pay (particularly those not earning enough to meet the spiralling cost of living, especially housing).

They also want fair terms and conditions (inc. perhaps a balance of 1/2 days a week remote working where possible depending on the role - with further flexibility for the disabled, carers, and currently CEV).

But generally many people do want to work.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 15:16

I'm against businesses that don't allow choice, and the fact that it's only going to get more and more common for companies not to have offices at all. As I've been saying all along. I wish people could read.

I've been reading you calling people selfish & vile because they prefer to remote work some or all of the time because that is better for them personally. No point blaming individuals because some businesses close their offices. Business will always do what ultimately benefits them.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 15:12

I'm against businesses that don't allow choice, and the fact that it's only going to get more and more common for companies not to have offices at all. As I've been saying all along. I wish people could read.

But where are you reading that offices are going to disappear? And thousands of jobs don't involve offices.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 15:10

@gibletjane

I said that middle class, well off people won't suffer as much from WFH because unlike people living in inner cities with no cars, they can drive to the countryside or a nice walk

But you can live in inner cities & not have a car & be middle class. You can be middle class & have a car but never drive to the countryside because cities tend to have lots of parks.

Hybrid' often means that people can't be in the office five days a week if they want to be because of lack of space. That means those who don't want to WFH are forced to do it, whether they want to or not.

So you are against any remote working then? Or are you against businesses that don't allow choice?

God, you're pedantic.

Yes, that's theoretically possible. But it's not exactly news that middle class people TEND to have nicer houses, with more space, bigger gardens, access to a car, etc. is it? Are you refuting this? You think it's not a fact that WFH disproportionately benefits those who are financially comfortable?

I'm against businesses that don't allow choice, and the fact that it's only going to get more and more common for companies not to have offices at all. As I've been saying all along. I wish people could read.

speakout · 18/09/2021 14:49

*I think 99% of people arguing in favour of wfh just enjoy the creature comforts tbh

  • e.g. roll out of bed at 08:50 and switch laptop on and chill out in your dressing gown.*

And that is a problem?

Whitewolf2 · 18/09/2021 14:44

For me with 2 young children WFH has certainly been helpful, my husband and I haven’t had the stress of commutes and pick ups. Train commuting, no seats etc was horrible.
However, now I do feel more lonely than ever before. I miss people, I miss the buzz of London. I do think WFH forever won’t work for me personally.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 14:12

The statistics all show that the well off middle classes are far more likely to wfh. The poorer & working class are less likely to have that option in the first place.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 14:09

I said that middle class, well off people won't suffer as much from WFH because unlike people living in inner cities with no cars, they can drive to the countryside or a nice walk

But you can live in inner cities & not have a car & be middle class. You can be middle class & have a car but never drive to the countryside because cities tend to have lots of parks.

Hybrid' often means that people can't be in the office five days a week if they want to be because of lack of space. That means those who don't want to WFH are forced to do it, whether they want to or not.

So you are against any remote working then? Or are you against businesses that don't allow choice?

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 14:04

[quote gibletjane]@Rozziie why do you think so many people are going to be fully remote when that isn't the model that is being used? The vast majority of companies are choosing a hybrid, flexible model.

Why do you think only remote workers use online shopping? I agree that during the pandemic some wanted to stay safe in their homes & have stuff brought to them by others but that's a separate point to remote working when not in a pandemic.

Why do you think only remote workers drive to the countryside for a walk? [/quote]
'Hybrid' often means that people can't be in the office five days a week if they want to be because of lack of space. That means those who don't want to WFH are forced to do it, whether they want to or not.

I never said only remote workers drive to the countryside for a walk. Your lack of reading comprehension is truly something to behold. I said that middle class, well off people won't suffer as much from WFH because unlike people living in inner cities with no cars, they can drive to the countryside or a nice walk.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 13:49

Why didn't the people who claim WFH is essential for their mental health get one of those jobs? Why don't the people you know what hate fully remote working find a job that isn't since 100% remote working jobs are by far the minority?

ColorMagicBarbie · 18/09/2021 13:45

I think 99% of people arguing in favour of wfh just enjoy the creature comforts tbh

  • e.g. roll out of bed at 08:50 and switch laptop on and chill out in your dressing gown.
gibletjane · 18/09/2021 13:42

It is not self centred or vile to want to work 100% in a workplace, or 100% remotely or 50/50.

BreadPita · 18/09/2021 13:42

Yes, most people on this thread are utterly incapable of seeing anything outside of their own life and interests. That's the entire point.

One person really stands out...

Before the pandemic, lots of industries already had a genuine choice. I was always able to work at least one day a week from home if I wanted, even two. Why didn't the people who claim WFH is essential for their mental health get one of those jobs? Why do they now expect people who didn't sign up for a life of working from their bedroom to be OK with it?

Every place I've worked at has had a "flexible working" policy. In reality that meant that you would work evenings and weekends if necessary. In return you can work from home every once in a while, with a good excuse (despite perfectly adequate homeworking infrastructure).

I tested this with my current role by asking to work from home once a day each week, with a view to working this up. I made it 2 months before my line manager stopped me because it looked bad to the person he reports to (nothing to do with my output(. Then covid happened and I haven't looked back.

Many of my friends are in the same position of enjoying the increased freedom and reduced cost. Some (fewer) want to be back in the office and are able to do so.

Lucky for your friends, office jobs still outnumber WFH jobs so they should be perfectly capable of getting one of those jobs (like we should have done when work from home roles were far less abundant). Companies that have completely shut down their physical offices are in the minority, so they should have no trouble moving.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 13:39

But guess what? The young people I mentor are really struggling with the motivation to do any of this, and dreading the thought of this being the norm. Many of them had really been looking forward to working in an office in central London and networking and meeting people from different backgrounds. Now they're stuck in their parents' council flat doing everything on Zoom, feeling cut off and lonely.

Yet, the idea of thinking of anyone except your own self-centred self is so alien to you that you can't imagine anyone else doing it.

Why do you keep labouring the same point. I have already stated people should have a choice & I personally like the hybrid model. How is that self centred?

The vast majority of companies and jobs are not fully remote & even during the pandemic they weren't.

"The Office for National Statistics (ONS) said about a quarter of people (25.9%) had worked at home at some point in the week before they responded to officials conducting its annual population survey. It said that this compared with 12.4% of workers in 2019."

You need to stop extrapolating your unusual experiences to everyone else because that is self centred.

gibletjane · 18/09/2021 13:35

@Rozziie why do you think so many people are going to be fully remote when that isn't the model that is being used? The vast majority of companies are choosing a hybrid, flexible model.

Why do you think only remote workers use online shopping? I agree that during the pandemic some wanted to stay safe in their homes & have stuff brought to them by others but that's a separate point to remote working when not in a pandemic.

Why do you think only remote workers drive to the countryside for a walk?

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 13:30

@gibletjane

Other people are selfish because you don't want to take responsibility for creating a daily routine for yourself?

Exactly, it's not about public transport or other strawman it's about that posters own needs & wants & wanting others to change to what suits them whilst simultaneously calling others selfish! It's astounding!

I have a daily routine for myself. I go to a gym class almost every morning and then a walk around the area with a coffee, and sometimes do an online class in my lunch break as well. My language classes are starting up again in person soon, several evenings a week.

But guess what? The young people I mentor are really struggling with the motivation to do any of this, and dreading the thought of this being the norm. Many of them had really been looking forward to working in an office in central London and networking and meeting people from different backgrounds. Now they're stuck in their parents' council flat doing everything on Zoom, feeling cut off and lonely.

Yet, the idea of thinking of anyone except your own self-centred self is so alien to you that you can't imagine anyone else doing it.

Rozziie · 18/09/2021 13:26

@ididitsocanyou

I don’t know why people get so triggered by a bit of logic. If you don’t like commuting, either move or get a job closer to home. If we all did that then there would be more jobs on our doorsteps (as people from outside the area are not filling them) and house prices would reflect local wages. It’s what people used to do. The only alternative is to commute or wfh. The latter is not in my opinion the answer it’s being made out to be. I am the perfect example of a wfh person and why you may want to consider your options I left a career 16 years ago and have tread water ever since. I have to fork out myself for training that I would have got for free had I stayed in the office, from just watching and learning from my peers. I used to be sociable before isolation made me socially anxious. I can’t mentally unload on anyone as I am completely alone and deal with the bad days alone and never get to laugh or share or run my ideas past anyone. I am paranoid that I am missing out on new techniques and better ways to do things because I am not connected to a broader team or workforce.

It has its uses yes but wfh is not the answer to our modern day problems. As other people say, a bit of both is probably best.

Yep this was my point as well. I spent years working remotely and it took a huge toll on my mental health and wellbeing in the long term. I ended up changing career specifically so I'd be able to get a good job in an office. I think a lot of the people currently enjoying the novelty of WFH will feel very differently in a decade, when people are more isolated than ever, public transport is cut to the bone and their own children are struggling with loneliness and isolation.

But then it probably won't affect the I'm Alright Jacks on this thread as much as underprivileged groups, so maybe they'll just be enjoying the new, even more segregated society where they get to pay poor people to deliver everything to their door and can jump in the car for a nice walk in the countryside when they feel cooped up.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 18/09/2021 13:22

'buzz' in the office,

Good riddance.