Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
Hekatestorch · 16/09/2021 09:29

@Knittingupastorm

Actually I agree, it’s bad for the economy in areas where people used to work

Better where they live though.
Our local little high street is busier than ever and the coffee shop has extended its hours. When I was on mat leave just before March 2020 it was very quiet, it’s now got more customers.
My DH works for a company that supplies parts to coffee shops (spares for coffee machines etc etc), and as a business they are doing better than they were pre-pandemic.
It’s not a comfort to the those in city centre locations of course, but everyone going back to the office wouldn’t be good news for our little local coffee shop either.

Agree with this.

Its moved where people are spending. Not stopped them. And ots more beneficial to them personally to spend locally.

Businesses often have to go through periods of Change and change their business model. The ones suffering, will need to do the same.

Topseyt · 16/09/2021 09:28

All fair points, but I haven’t entirely changed my mind. We have saved a huge amount of money in fuel costs since working from home. We are fortunate too in that DH has a designated study area upstairs, so that is the only area that is the workplace in our house.

It is a balance that is required in many cases. DH will be working three days a week in the office and two from home as of next week. Alternating at times. It sounds OK to me, but we will see how it goes.

Knittingupastorm · 16/09/2021 09:25

Actually I agree, it’s bad for the economy in areas where people used to work

Better where they live though.
Our local little high street is busier than ever and the coffee shop has extended its hours. When I was on mat leave just before March 2020 it was very quiet, it’s now got more customers.
My DH works for a company that supplies parts to coffee shops (spares for coffee machines etc etc), and as a business they are doing better than they were pre-pandemic.
It’s not a comfort to the those in city centre locations of course, but everyone going back to the office wouldn’t be good news for our little local coffee shop either.

Notjustanymum · 16/09/2021 09:25

I don’t think YABU, but I would point out that your circumstances are leading you to your conclusion.

My circumstances are very different. Before COVID19, I commuted a long distance daily by car, took my own lunch to work and struggled with keeping on top of everything at home. Now I work from home, in my own office (I know that some people don’t have that luxury), my DH is retired, my DC are grown and working, my team is spread out across different sites, so Zoom meetings from my desk in the office or the home office are the same wherever I am.
Since I didn’t use public transport, cafe bars or sandwich kiosks anyway , the only differences between me being in the office or at home are A) I now use hardly any fuel - so I’m contributing less to climate change and B) I’m saving money and time, making my work/life balance much easier!
I think that there should be more flexibility and those that prefer to be in the office should do that, while those that don’t should be allowed to WFH where their role allows it.

DeborahAnnabel · 16/09/2021 09:25

I love the nature of WFH because I can do my job flexibly in my own time as long as the job gets done. I guess it helps that I’m fairly senior and am not micro managed but if I need to take my child to a swimming lesson, I can but then I’ll be logging on in the evening after they’re in bed, for example.
However I agree that for juniors and for people without houses and gardens, it’s probably not ideal. I like the idea a hybrid model so 2 days in/3 days home or vice versa.

Newschapter · 16/09/2021 09:25

I live WFH.

Prior to this I was furloughed for 9 months and that was worse for me than WFH.

I worked between two offices, one was full of colleagues of different natures, some who didn't say good morning, some who were full of the joys of spring all year round, some who bathed and some who sat in running gear all day Envy < not envy

In the other office I was alone. A cold office where the heat never worked and I had to wear a coat. Where I was once verbally assaulted when I was alone and had to get a passer by to come into the premises as I was afraid of a service user. I was also expected to do two different roles in the office I worked in alone, for no more renumeration.

Years ago when we built our house i was studying for a degree, I knew we would like to have kids and I wanted them to have a space to do homework in. We included a study/office into our plans which means I now have a dedicated space where I keep the PC/printer/scanner etc and close the door on the way out.

I can keep in touch with the office via in house chat system, emails, phone calls etc
My manager can contact me any time between 9am and 5pm and I will reply immediately.

Having no commute means I am able to attend a morning gym class, walk the dogs in my lunch break, eat earlier in the evening - speaking for myself I am happier and healthier than when I was in the office. I can see it doesn't work for everyone mind you, but for me it's ideal.

I have a routine, one which involves showering and dressing every single day first thing (like when in the office) there's no excuse for not showering or staying in pyjamas, even when I was sick I was dressed.

I never wore make up so that's not part of my routine, I am happy in my own skin.

I hope I never have to go back full time to the office, but hybrid working may suit me!

Icenii · 16/09/2021 09:24

I think it's great that excessive consumerism and consumption is being challenged.

Completely agree with this. We dont exist so that public transport runs, coffee shops are open and city centre thrive. How was that life working for many people? We had a mental health crisis pre covid.

For me, society has to change for all. It may start with some changes that benefit some people more, but we really need to look at ways life can change and be better for all. If WFH works for some people it really should stay and could be that start society needs. In the US, my old organisation had employees do x hours of charity work as part of their objectives. Maybe organisations that eable WFH should actively encourage this too.

I WFH now as I purposely switched to a role last year that was WFH with site visits once a month. I'm no longer leaving the house at 0545. I may not be present in an office for junior staff to learn from, but I am now present for DD and can give her the full support she needs. A good company will put in processes that give grads and junior member what they need. It may be different, and change may not be perfect from day one, but maybe we need to adapt to new ways for working.

And I'd also challenge the idea that people should be chained to their desk for set hours a day. Why? Because other sectors have to work set hours at a set location? Doesn't mean all should. There has to be a way to offer the services society needs and to keep the majority of people working in all those services happy. One change could kick off a whole host of others for other people.

Serendipity79 · 16/09/2021 09:23

OP please don't compare your situation to one of domestic abuse, do you realise how insulting that is to people who've gone through it?

Having to sit and watch your DP eat biscuits, and having his voice annoy you from a few Teams calls is not in any way comparable to some of the awful situations that domestic abuse victims found themselves in during the pandemic, where they physically couldn't escape and in many cases the violence escalated. Some even died.

Not comparable at all

JoanOgden · 16/09/2021 09:22

@LadyWithLapdog

I also think young people are much more adept at online working and don’t need the physical presence of middle managers to be turbo charged. (And I hope the PP using such language doesn’t use it around the young people in their team, they’ll run a mile.)
I think this is an odd generalisation - young people vary as much as anyone else, and the young people in my team have really appreciated going back 2 days a week.
Hekatestorch · 16/09/2021 09:18

@HarrietsChariot You're meant to get up every hour. Sitting still for hours on end is bad for the eyes and for the body. You should take at least five minutes away from sitting at a desk every hour.

I didn't say anyone should sit at their desk and not get up.

I answered the point that people that wfh don't sit at their desk 9-12.30 being completely productively.

Neither did the vast majority do that in the office. So the comparison is pointless.

LastGirlSanding · 16/09/2021 09:15

@HarrietsChariot

Why not just allow people to work where they feel they are most productive and happiest? Forcing people to return to the office is just as bad as not allowing them to. WFH works for many people and helps the environment. What I lose in face to face interaction I more than make up in efficiency because of fewer interruptions and wellbeing because of reduced stress.

Also, it's not my job to keep sandwich shops and coffee bars going. WFH means people spend less on these things, but the money gets spent somewhere else instead. My local coffee shop might shut due to lack of business, but another business in a different sector gets my money instead.

The problem with saying WFH is bad is that it's a very reactionary view. It basically says that the situation pre-pandemic was normal and must be maintained at all costs. That's not true, society evolves and businesses need to adapt to fit. Businesses have always gone under because they were not used enough. People just spend their money elsewhere.

The DVLA was always shit, by the way. Any business or agency that is a monopoly can afford to be shit because people cannot go elsewhere.

I agree with this. Business and industry adapts to the times. Look at the internet for example which has totally transformed the way we work and the types of jobs on offer - many of which simply didn’t exist 20 years ago. Looking at it that the economy will suffer because things won’t stay exactly the same is short sighted IMO.
discombobulatedonion · 16/09/2021 09:15

I agree. When I started my current job, I was in the office for the first 4 weeks for training. That was back in March. Now I’ve been there nearly 7 months and I WFH more than I’m in the office. Unfortunately I can’t do much about that as they are rotating who is in the office each week, and it just happens that because I work part time, it’s easier to have me WFH.
I love my job and admittedly they are very flexible, but I hate WFH. It’s boring and I struggle with work more.

Nhytfdetykbcz · 16/09/2021 09:12

On another point about WFH. My commute is just under 30 miles, mostly motorway. Now that I mostly work from home, it's saving that pollution that my petrol car kicks out. That is good.

mewkins · 16/09/2021 09:10

@RandomLondoner

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

These points are silly. Services don't exist for their own sake, they exist to service demand.

You don't have someone making coffee because that's their job and if they didn't do it they wouldn't have a job. They make coffee to the extent that people are willing to pay to have it made, and when that demand goes away, the coffee maker needs to find something else to do, that is more useful than making cups of coffee no-one is drinking.

The interests of the barista are completely incidental to the coffee-serving business. If someone invents a robot that can do his job more cheaply, then his job can and should disappear. He needs to go away and do something else that robots can't yet do.

Agreed. It's bonkers to think that people are spending money and time each day to get to a workplace in order to keep a coffee bar in business!
RobinPenguins · 16/09/2021 09:09

Really surprised during the pandemic that not more businesses have set up a mobile offering. Maybe I should jack in my job which I now hate because wfh and set one up.

Why do they need to set up a mobile offering? According to lots of WFH aficionados it’s revitalising local high streets because people are definitely going out and using them every day and not just staying at home making their own sandwiches…

Idontwantyourfreedom · 16/09/2021 09:08

@HeartsAndClubs

I think there has to be a balance. Not a popular view, but in general people are a lot less productive than they think they are, because very few people work exclusively from home. I.e. you go into your home office at 9 and don’t come out until 12:30, and then go back in at 1:30 and don’t come out until 5. So many people just “nip out to put the washing on/hang the washing out/do the school run/answer the door” and the list goes on, whereas these are things you shouldn’t be doing in the working day. You’re at work, not at home, and most people find it impossible to be that disciplined.

And how many companies have we heard that “we may be delayed in calling back due to the pandemic” because in truth call centre staff aren’t working as efficiently from home and as a result customer service has plummeted.

And then there’s training, learning a job, joining an organisation where you will never get to meet your colleagues face to face because you work from home. I know people who have started new jobs during the pandemic and they have felt completely on the sidelines because colleagues who did previously work together know each other and they’re an incomer who has never met any of them.

There are definitely pro’s to working from home, but I think it’s unrealistic to expect full-time working from home to remain, unless you’re working in a role where you’re not responsible to or for anyone else.

When I was in the office, people were always popping off for a coffee break, a fag break or just to stretch their legs. Of course nobody sat there for 3 or 4 hours straight, everyone needs a few minutes out. I know I have been more productive and less distracted since not being there, but accept some people prefer it and need to be there.
minatrina · 16/09/2021 09:07

Oh also I'm 24 so fairly young, I definitely personally don't find WFH a problem when it comes to socialising with colleagues. I grew up with the internet! Bonding and chatting with people using emails and instant message is honestly no problem for me 🤣

PersonaNonGarter · 16/09/2021 09:07

YABU - the office is a recent invention by the standards of civilisation and not mandated by God.

WFH is essential to reducing carbon footprint. We NEED people to stop travelling so much and the commute is the best way to cut that out. If they love coffee and sandwiches they can buy them locally. If they don’t, the sandwich shops will need to adapt.

TempsPerdu · 16/09/2021 09:07

As others have said, older workers are sitting comfortably at home, the ladder firmly pulled up

Lots of truth in this I think. It’s not just about young people being able to use the tech; it’s all the soft skills, relationship building and other intangible stuff they’re missing out on by not being around older, more experienced colleagues. Plus the huge disparity between old and young in terms of the average home set-up (purpose built home office vs bed sit with dodgy WiFi).

I think a hybrid model can work just fine, but there are lots of downsides to permanent WFH that need to be acknowledged. We’re in a nice but typically small London house, with a preschooler who’s only at nursery part of the week, and DP has WFH throughout the pandemic. He’s been stuck in a 5x5ft box room for 8.5 hours a day, and my stress levels have increased massively trying to occupy DD at home without her making excessive noise and interrupting him (we go out lots, but not feasibly all day). Because his work consists largely of conference calls he spends much of the day broadcasting random IT stuff to DD and me in a booming voice while wearing headphones. We’re all suffering from lack of personal space. DP has put on a substantial amount of weight due to lack of incidental exercise, which he’s now dealing with through an expensive gym membership. Our newish house is overly well insulated, and therefore DP’s box room has been boiling hot (35 degrees plus) throughout most of the summer.

We’re more privileged than the vast majority of others - I’m at home and DP is in the top 10% of earners - but I think those who are most evangelical about full-time WFH are forgetting that spacious houses with large gardens, noise insulation and fast, efficient technology are not the U.K. norm. It’s certainly not ours, nor those of most of our friendship circle who are also WFH.

Thankfully as of a couple of weeks ago DP back in the office two days a week, which is saving everyone’s sanity somewhat. As with so much else, I think it’s about balance.

Dozer · 16/09/2021 09:06

Specific organisations don’t necessarily know it’s ‘worked well’ unless they’ve evaluated this, and tried to assess WFH impacts vs other factors, eg brexit, other covid impacts such as supply issues.

For the organisation I work for my guess is that overall, the organisation’s performance has dropped with most people WFH.

EveningOverRooftops · 16/09/2021 09:05

If anything WFH and the pandemic as a whole have shown our city centre based shops and supermarket culture is anything but good.

If we’d had the small high street shops - for reference my local one is mostly takeaways, a pound shop type place, several charity shops and a post office - and less focus on big supermarkets the last 18mths would’ve been an entirely different experience for all of us.

It’s about time we started rethinking our retail setup, our supermarket set up to something that is much more sustainable overall.

rookiemere · 16/09/2021 09:05

Regarding Pret and the like, it's pretty obvious to me - and I'm not an entrepreneur with a vested interest in this - that they needed to change their business model. If a pret van turned up at lunchtime at our suburban part of town, they'd do an absolutely roaring trade, in the same way that the fish van man is coining it in these days.

Sure it would require set up costs etc. but they could move out of costly city centre premises to offset that.

Really surprised during the pandemic that not more businesses have set up a mobile offering. Maybe I should jack in my job which I now hate because wfh and set one up.

RumHoney · 16/09/2021 09:04

I felt like I was quite happy WFH and was quite enjoying not commuting for a while. I was a bit anxious the first few times I went into the office (not compulsory, more for a catch up with my team and leaving dos).

Then I got a new job. I'm officially office based although my predecessor and the rest of my team are 100% remote so we agreed there was some flexibility to see what working pattern works best as long as I'm able to get to the office when needed.

Since I started I've felt so much better and more engaged with work. It's partly the new job effect but I can tell the difference between my office days and my WFH days and I've been going in more than I officially need to.

It won't help public transport or coffee shops though as the new office is in a quiet village so I drive/cycle and take my lunch in. Lunch out is a WFH treat!

ChrissyPlummer · 16/09/2021 09:03

I can’t WFH in my role, but if I went back to office/based work, I’d absolutely love it!

One of my colleagues has been waiting for over 7 weeks for a straight passport renewal. The DVLA told my mums cousin that her over-70 renewal would be up to 20 weeks if she applied on paper.

minatrina · 16/09/2021 09:02

@Gothichouse40

We are already having our bus services cut, they are also talking about cutting train services, be careful what you wish for. If I lived rurally, Id be rather concerned, as it is where I am we already had bus services cut. It's vital to me as I don't drive and I think many people are under the mistaken impression that you are able to drive forever. Old age has a funny way of creeping up on you, as do ailments. Take nothing for granted. If Ive learned anything during the Pandemic, Ive learned this.
I live very rurally and they've been cutting our bus services despite them being well-used for decades - I really don't think that going back to the office is going to stop that sadly