Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
rwalker · 16/09/2021 10:25

The thing is in the UK we are only interested in what suits us personally .
The big picture about redundant office space, service industries no longer needed jobs lost.
The mental impact on some people WHF no space unable to switch off and cost of utilities .
Lack of social interaction and mentoring at work .

People don't care about the big picture .
It's like the poster who loves WHF as has more time with baby fast forward 10 years sat in empty house with a screen for company and remotely managed will WFH be so attractive then .

AngelsWithSilverWings · 16/09/2021 10:25

My DH had been working from home since March of last year.

What he used to spend in the Pret next to his office he has been spending at our local artisan baker, local butcher , green grocer , second hand record shop. Our little high street is quite buzzy during the week now because lots of people are in the same position.

He makes sure he goes out for a half hour walk into town and back every day and has a routine of different shops he likes to visit.

He's been eating healthier food as a result and has lost almost two stone in weight ( as have I thanks to him preparing daily salads for us)

This week he has unusually been back in the office everyday ( the plan going forward is only two days a week) and I've been reminded how much harder life seems when he works in the office all week.

His commute takes just under two hours - dead time. He is far more productive at home ( we have a garden office thankfully) but he does prefer being able to see his clients face to face as although they can do business over Zoom with existing clients it's not the way to get new business in.

Our family life has improved beyond measure thanks to him WFH. I'm realising this week how bad things were before the pandemic so the future plan of two office days a week is a really good balance.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 10:23

@DottyHarmer

Well, that’s a load of Big Crap , *@Thesandmanishere* .

I can say with experience of both demographics that it is the exact opposite .

Interesting can you expand on that ? I'm neither old or young so sit slam in the middle and what PP has said about the young and the older groups is bang on what I keep seeing ?

No judgement generally curious

Rollercoaster1920 · 16/09/2021 10:21

I look forward to the day when a child, cat, dog or partner joining a work call is a rare occurrence again. It is unprofessional.

I include my family and pets in the above statement!

nc86952 · 16/09/2021 10:21

...because what else are those WFH worrying about other than transport workers being made redundant and sandwich shops closing. Yes, that's exactly what people WFH are listing as their top 2 priorities in getting back to the office
Hmm
Rather than childcare, commuting time and costs, environmental pollution - if this was a real OP, those would be mentioned.

CharityDingle · 16/09/2021 10:20

The ideal for me would be a mix of both. I'm not working at present (company closed down) but before all of this, I had a truly terrible commute. I was doing one day a week at home, and that saved my sanity.
I can see the pros and cons as described here, by various posters. The knock on effects on both on family life and on the business world. Talking to a friend recently who has recruited a new team, and training people from home, has been very difficult, she said.

Choice and hybrid models where possible, may be the way forward.

RosyPoesy · 16/09/2021 10:20

One of my friends had a huge MH crisis as she needs people, she is a huge extrovert and it affected her terribly. Another loves it because she had a 2 hour commute each way.
Part of choosing a career is going to be whether you can (or want to) wfh. Extroverts can purposely choose jobs that require you to be present (lots of jobs can’t wfh). Introverts or disabled people or parents can choose jobs that offer opportunities to wfh. In the long run I think people will get paid a bit more for jobs that can’t wfh.

DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 10:19

Well, that’s a load of Big Crap , @Thesandmanishere .

I can say with experience of both demographics that it is the exact opposite .

nc86952 · 16/09/2021 10:19

That OP doesn't read like a placed post by someone with a political agenda at all
Hmm

DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 10:18

Likewise local councils…. Only a local council would have been promoting and investing in a shopping mall in the last few years. Well before covid these were dying, yet my council were dead keen on a big new mall, “with the big name retailers” (heard with my own ears). Strewth.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 10:16

IME the younger generations are very happy with WFH and hybrid and co-working spaces and the like. It's the older generation who have the bums on seats presentee mentality, and can't accept that things are changing.

Polkadotties · 16/09/2021 10:15

I have found that wfh has helped junior members of staff to think on their feet and not be so reliant on us more senior staff. In the office I constantly get questions that I know they can answer if they just took two seconds and thought about it.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 10:15

It's interesting. I have seen managers go into full meltdown at not being able to see their staff - bums on seats and use it as a reason why they can't manage effectively and customer service slides .

Problem is they couldn't manage effectively in the office. The problem is the managers not WFH.

If your a decent manager you can manage without seeing someone day in and out and it can be done remotely but it requires work, rather than just seeing someone and assuming they are busy.

People always wanna take the easy way out it would seem.

WFH is a personal preference, I used to work from home pre pandemic but during it - the workload tripled as if to try and convince people no one was slacking. Madness. I never used to have back to back meetings in the office 8-6 during the pandemic it was a daily occurrence.
It really put me off but I think that companies assured in their staff will relax somewhat. We are all human at the end of the day

I think another poster said people will move from companies that won't change with the times and allow hybrid working. Those companies that wont adapt, won't survive because you need the youngsters to keep momentum going and they don't have the same views as most boomers ie "what work life balance" vs youngesters "I'm a human and I have needs outside of work"

The generational tide will polarise in companies. And in a recession it's not doing the same thing over and over that wins. It's being adaptable.

Hybrid gets my vote just because I like people. However this whole nonsense about the economy collapsing because of WFH is ridiculous because smart companies adapt. It's often spouted by people who have a vested invest in working in the office. Which is perfectly fine for that to be your preference. But your preference doesn't mean everyone's going to agree with it. People will make informed choices based on what's presented to them.

I wouldn't assume actually that a business that forces people back to the offices for no reason other than they prefer it that way is going to attracted the biggest or the best of the recruitment selection.

I say this all as a manager myself.

Nc123 · 16/09/2021 10:15

Disagree. I have team members all over the uk. It makes no difference to me whether they’re in the office or not and it makes no difference to them whether I am.

I didn’t buy coffee or sandwiches regularly in the bad old commuting days so it’s not like the vendors are losing my custom.

My life is a bit monotonous WFH but the upside is massive - no horrible commute, increased ability to focus and do deep work without being surrounded by people discussing Love Island or football results, being able to do the school run, etc. Also, working in the office was monotonous too, just in a different way. It wasn’t fun or stimulating and I didn’t get nearly so much done.

I object massively to the pushing of people back to the office when they’ve proven they can work more productively from home - and the supporting media narrative is very pushy. WFH has enabled many industries to keep going at minimal individual risk during the pandemic and it’s brought many people great benefits.

RosyPoesy · 16/09/2021 10:14

Just a perspective from someone who has been involved in recruiting recently. I’ve noticed that young candidates are asking how often they can wfh and are rejecting jobs that don’t offer the opportunity. They’ve realised they don’t have to get on that treadmill of commuting every day, and wfh offers the opportunity to get up an hour later some days and finish in time to be able to attend a hobby in the evening. Young candidates (20s) were asking for 2 days wfh per week. Older candidates (30+) weren’t asking for that, perhaps because they’re used to the grind of commuting. But I certainly think we’re going to see the younger generation refusing to commute every day. Progressive businesses are already developing smaller offices with hot desks used by people who come in on different days.

LindaEllen · 16/09/2021 10:14

YANBU but I am glad everyone has had the chance to try it. I've WFH since graduating in 2012, and people thought I was living the dream and that they could just pop in whenever they felt like it. This last year has opened their eyes to the reality of it.

Wroxie · 16/09/2021 10:12

@DottyHarmer you're right, and taxes/business rates/social care need to change just as drastically as urban geography - the current system relies on income that will simply cease to exist. It wouldn't be impossible for real thinkers and brave policy-makers to change the tax and investment landscape to recover the money that will (if nothing is changed) just go back into profits of large multi-national companies, but unfortunately "real thinkers" and "brave policy-makers" are not to be found in the current government (nor in any that are currently waiting in the wings). It's scary to think about, especially as someone who hoped to retire a bit early in about ten years.

RobinPenguins · 16/09/2021 10:11

The productivity thing is interesting. Most “interruptions” when I’m in the office are work related - my colleagues asking me a question or wanting to discuss something. It can stop the flow of my individual pieces of work so may make them take longer. But it means my colleagues’ queries are resolved far more quickly and easily than if they had to email me or have a Teams call. So the work of the team as a whole functions better. It’s hard sometimes for individuals to judge productivity because unless they’re seeing the overall picture they don’t necessarily appreciate how their decisions are impacting on the wider team.

I’m not sure I really get to complain about “interruptions” when they are a necessary part of my job.

edwinbear · 16/09/2021 10:08

Pros for me:

No longer have to get up at 5.30am to be in the office for 7am. I'm much less tired.

DC don't have to get up early to be dropped at breakfast club. They are much less tired.

I was at home when DS started getting himself to/from school when he started Y7 last year, so an easy transition.

I can pop out to collect from sports matches that get back at 4.30pm/5pm etc. This was a logistical nightmare when I was office based FT. Ditto having plumbers round/deliveries/dentists appointments/taking the car in for a service etc.

I've saved a fortune on commuting costs.

I've lost 2 stone because I can go to the gym in the evenings rather than commuting and getting home at 8pm. I also eat a healthier lunch as I'm not eating 600 calorie sandwiches from Pret every day, and/or fish and chips from the canteen on Fridays.

Cons

My house is an absolute tip and there is noticeable wear and tear as I'm in it all day.

Energy costs, heating, electricity etc are higher. Food bill is a bit less as it's cheaper to eat at home, rather than buying lunch/coffees.

I've pulled DD out of breakfast club, as I can drop her at school now. Good for me, but not so much for wraparound club.

I get distracted by home chores. Although if I have an urgent deadline, I can work late into the evening or weekends if necessary. Ordinarily, I'd have to stay in the office until midnight as we had no WFH capability. I didn't even have a laptop.

I feel isolated and miss my colleagues. I don't feel we're as productive as a team without the informal interactions, although when I have to write a paper, work on a complicated spreadsheet, it is easier to focus without office noise.

DH and I spend far too much time together than is healthy.

I've become quite introverted, without the usual office socialising.

We''ll be going back to the office 2-3 days, which I think will be perfect for me and strike a good balance.

Auntienumber8 · 16/09/2021 10:08

It’s so circumstantial, it’s obviously bad for city centres. One of my friends had a huge MH crisis as she needs people, she is a huge extrovert and it affected her terribly. Another loves it because she had a 2 hour commute each way. DH was perfectly happy but he could have a room to himself as an office and we have one adult DS at home.

DH works mainly from home but also goes in, I think a mixture is probably for the best. I’m sure some people have taken advantage but many will have worked harder, there is no one size fits all.

LukeEvansWife · 16/09/2021 10:07

@Horriblewoman

I'm working in a hybrid model in the future and have started going back a day or so a week as I build up.

A couple of observations

  • commuting, even when it's not busy, is horrible and tiring
  • I get much less work done when I'm in the office as I start work later and leave earlier and also I'm talking to people all day
  • I exercise less on the days I'm in the office
  • I prefer spending my income in the area where I live which is mostly non-chain coffee shops, restaurants, bars and cafes

Also during the pandemic I've never ever worked in my pjs or not showered!

This!

I don't get people who don't shower in the morning when wfh - you would hopefully do it if you were going into work so sitting there unshowered in pyjamas seems a little scummy!

The other issue we have is that parents with young children don't always put them in childcare when working from home. (Not talking about lockdown, but now when more people are returning to the office).

So Zoom calls are interrupted by the DC, and they spend more time having to look after them than working. Which means they either have to work in the evenings or someone else has to pick up the slack. So it is harder for them and impacts the rest of the team.

LukeEvansWife · 16/09/2021 10:02

There isn't a "one size fits all" solution. I worked from home for several months, I was lucky enough to have a spare room to convert to an office.

I was so much more productive, I was available outside of my normal hours without arsing about getting a later train (or even available at a weekend), I didn't get disturbed, my anxiety was a million times better because there was some distance between my boss and me and now I am hybrid working it is not the same.

Daisyandroses · 16/09/2021 10:01

Haven’t read the full thread. I disagree, as I love WFH as a parent of 3 young DC, including twins it’s going to mean I can stay in work.

I just think you need to go about it in a certain way. For example, plan meet ups/ lunches with friends, go for a walk to exercise and get fresh air. Have a life outside of the house.

I actually think it would be a good opportunity to revive small towns and village coffee shops, as people can pop out locally on their lunch breaks. I would love to see that happen.

Horriblewoman · 16/09/2021 09:58

I'm working in a hybrid model in the future and have started going back a day or so a week as I build up.

A couple of observations

  • commuting, even when it's not busy, is horrible and tiring
  • I get much less work done when I'm in the office as I start work later and leave earlier and also I'm talking to people all day
  • I exercise less on the days I'm in the office
  • I prefer spending my income in the area where I live which is mostly non-chain coffee shops, restaurants, bars and cafes

Also during the pandemic I've never ever worked in my pjs or not showered!

DynamoKev · 16/09/2021 09:58

Not generating of course