Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 16/09/2021 10:47

@LadyWithLapdog

You’re welcome to get back to the office. For DP this adds 2.5 hours commuting time. His office is completely silent and there’s no camaraderie. The commuting is very stressful. At work he sits in silence doing a job which can be done from home. He’d be out of the house 8am-7pm, waking up at 7. That’s a very long day. My days are as well, I have to go to the office. I don’t think it’s better for the kids to come home and fend for themselves till evening. We’ve done this for many years but there has been a better way. Let’s keep that.

If jobs have to change, why not? Time to rethink what’s important.

My DH had a long commute too and would be out of the house at 6.50. Getting back 12 hours later (or more). He seems to have settled into a routine and does take breaks and occasionally gets out for a while and walks to the local shops. With his commute involving trains and tubes he is not in any hurry to get back to the office.
DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 10:45

Hmmmmm. That sounds like “I’m glad I don’t have to deal with irritating new recruits.” Far better they’re faceless beings in their bedrooms somewhere with their heads down.

LastGirlSanding · 16/09/2021 10:45

I don’t agree wfh is bad for younger people in some respects. I know of a few 20-somethings for example without the commitments of children who are now able to work remotely and travel to visit friends or people they are dating without needing to take time off. For some, what they lack in home office space is made up for by being able to be more portable.

lonelyapple · 16/09/2021 10:43

Why not just let people decide. Those that want to travel into an office can and those that prefer to WFH can do so?

It's not the publics duty to either fund transport wages or the profits of large coffee chains.

schnubbins · 16/09/2021 10:43

So what are your kids going to do when they leave schooling ten years time or so and go to online Uni because 'it works' and then start a new job again in front of a screen because everyone is WFH .They have no contact with real people and have to learn everything alone without any support from others.This is the current scenario from my very outgoing twenty something year olds and many of their friends .They are very despondent and many have just given up.

Ozanj · 16/09/2021 10:42

@Polkadotties

I will also add, wfh has enabled managers to see who is really good at their job and who isn’t. Some of those who shout the loudest and have been able to cover up mistakes by talking bollocks haven’t been able to get away with it.
Yes, this is true. We lost our Ofsted Outstanding Rating last year because a member of staff wasn’t logging progress updates. At the time she said it was a one off, shouted about it being unfair because she was updating it but there were system issues etc wtc, and as we had no processes to check we believed her. Now we share the updating during wfh days it’s obvious she isn’t as good at her job as the rest of the girls who take notes while delivering excellent childcare.
candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 10:40

@DottyHarmer then that's very different from my experience and I'm managing a large team in a large national business.

I would also say the younger ones are always the ones to leave bang on 5pm. I think it's people who may not have typically valued flexibility (aka non family people) more of them are coming out the wood work.

Frankly as someone senior in my org I'm grateful that I don't have to deal with the drama that every ten seconds where is the stapler. Ect it's forcing the young ones to learn critical work skills such as think really think if interrupting this person is a good idea. It makes them more independent, therefore steeper learning curve granted but also more productive long term.

Or maybe that's just my company. Fast way to split the wheat from the chaff in my head

Polkadotties · 16/09/2021 10:37

I will also add, wfh has enabled managers to see who is really good at their job and who isn’t. Some of those who shout the loudest and have been able to cover up mistakes by talking bollocks haven’t been able to get away with it.

Daisyandroses · 16/09/2021 10:37

t's like the poster who loves WHF as has more time with baby fast forward 10 years sat in empty house with a screen for company and remotely managed will WFH be so attractive then .
@rwalker

Not if you’ve used the time to build an active social life outside of work, and started hobbies/ got more active as you are less stressed and commuting less. Also spending more time in the local community. Getting to do school runs, making friends locally and so on. I enjoy socialising so much more since WFH, and always look forward to the weekends. I barely got the chance to talk to anyone anyway when I was in the office as I was always rushing around.

adoreyou · 16/09/2021 10:35

As people have already mentioned it should be about balance and doing what's right for you.

This time last year I was struggling to find a job I could do to fit around the school run/childcare and my earning potential not being as high as it was when i was working in the city.

Due to WFH I'm able to work full time hours, from home, which means I can do the school run. Plus it's a "city" job on city money!
Which means my DD isn't in childcare, she's at home with us.
DH is also able to do the school run, which we never expected, which means he is around more for DD then we could ever dreamed off!
We also have more expendable income due to not paying for travel and childcare.... it's still being spent, just elsewhere! So the economy is still benefitting.

I just think people need to realise that things change. Yes there will be coffee shops, for example, that will close or maybe need to move locations. But there will also be business that spring up BECAUSE of the new WFH culture...... I just wish someone would start a coffee van business! ....like an ice cream van, but just does coffee and sandwiches. So bored of making my own!

Doubledoorsontogarden · 16/09/2021 10:34

I’ve been able to wfh since 2006 in a customer facing , so when not in meetings at home. It’s been productive but even I’m hacked off with 5 days a week at home. I drink more, move less, worry more. It needs to be a healthy mix IMO

AnxiousAbi · 16/09/2021 10:33

I love WFH too. The biggest challenge for me has been IT due to working for a LA. They really need to invest in IT.

As far as I am aware, our LA is very much going down the hybrid route. There are some roles that can be done from home, others that absolutely can’t, and some that can have a mix. Mine will be a mix I feel. And I’m fairly happy with that.

I’ve been in the office a quite a few times over the last 8 months and I’ve enjoyed seeing people when I’ve been in. I can definitely see the benefits of a hybrid approach in my role.

Agree with a PP - I think younger people are less likely to want to WFH. Obviously there will always be exceptions. But it’s made our life easier in terms of looking after the DC. Far less stressful, no need for childcare etc.

I imagine it might feel quite lonely if you live alone

Polkadotties · 16/09/2021 10:33

@DottyHarmer

As a generalisation, older, settled people with a family love wfh.

Young people starting out, with no home of their own and no wide group of friends just round the corner find it hard.

And change has happened so quickly. One year everyone in the office, a year later and you’re in your bedroom not able to talk to a real person.

As someone else mentioned up thread. Those under the age of 30 are very used to not talking to ‘real people’. Maybe working efficiently virtually will become a skill set, just like giving presentations or in person training.
user1497207191 · 16/09/2021 10:33

@Charlene91

Your issues with it seem very economical when it comes to not WFH. You've also mentioned the positives about the environmental aspect of WFH.

Environmental trumps economical every single time. If we don't have a planet to live on, what good is money? 🤷‍♀️

Without money, we'll be living in mud huts and foraging for food.

What IS needed is a balance.

MyPatronusIsACat · 16/09/2021 10:33

@MauvePinkRose I agree. I mean, it's OK to a degree, and is helpful for some - especially those who struggle with childcare.

And it's great to not have to commute, and to be able to roll out of bed 5 minutes before work starts, and not 2 hours before, and to 'finish' and be home at 5.10pm, instead of not getting home til 6.30pm!

But people need to start going back now, if only 2 or 3 days a week, to get back to normality. People cannot work from home forever. It's ridiculous. And there's simply no need for it anymore.

And as you say, many things are waaaaay behind now - some months in some cases, because of the lack of staff in the offices. People doing stuff from home - who work for DVLA, land registry, DWP, Inland revenue, councils, etc, is resulting in things being done much MUCH slower. 'Work from home' is clearly not doable long-term...

And I know I'll get flamed for this, but I don't think men should work from home. They need to go back to the workplace now.

As the OP says, many men have got complacent, lazy, and slovenly, whilst many women have had their workload doubled, and have struggled to run the home, look after the kids, and in some cases, do their own wfh job, with the men stuck in every day, dominating everything.

And whilst a few people say 'oh YOU wanna work from home and have that flexibility, and no commute etc, but don't want your husband to,' it's completely different.

It's wrong on so many levels for men of working age to be at home all the time, and moreover, when they ARE working from home, they do shag-all else. Their big important job, their schedule, their zoom calls, their big voice, their everything, trumps everything, and they generally don't lift a finger to help in the house, or with the kids. Multiple threads on here (and conversations with women in real life) have proven that spectacularly.

I know a 29 y.o. couple right now - no kids, but they have a home together. They have worked from home since last March, and the house is a shit tip half the time. Because neither of them ever does anything. HE won't do housework and general chores, and SHE won't do it because HE won't.

So they hire a cleaner 5-6 hours a week, (who does SOME of the housework,) and they do their individual washing. They do their own breakfasts and lunches, but he cooks dinner two thirds of the time, as he likes cooking, and she does the food shop. But she says 'like fuck am I gonna be doing the grunt work when he's sat there playing FIFA 2021 on the XBox, or watching netflix marathons!'

It's not a natural thing for men to knuckle down and do housework and chores, so it falls to the woman very often. If he is stuck at home all the time, dominating EVERYTHING, it's very difficult to maintain a normal home, especially with kids.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 10:32

@rwalker

The thing is in the UK we are only interested in what suits us personally . The big picture about redundant office space, service industries no longer needed jobs lost. The mental impact on some people WHF no space unable to switch off and cost of utilities . Lack of social interaction and mentoring at work .

People don't care about the big picture .
It's like the poster who loves WHF as has more time with baby fast forward 10 years sat in empty house with a screen for company and remotely managed will WFH be so attractive then .

Well that's a common truth only people interested in their situation.

The system as it were was always biased against particular people with families or anyone who can't do the normal 9-5. If Most of the statics are to be believed , many far to many chose flexibility over pay. That standard is now being challenged as actually it should be as it's been proven a lot more jobs actually can be done from home.

We can talk about being inclusive but really the normal state of play was never that.

Also assuming that once someone's toddler, dependant isn't around that people will prefer to be in the office is a dangerous bias lumping everyone into one category and ignoring the universal truth, some people just don't want to go to the office and if there's another choice. They would chose differently.

However

Ozanj · 16/09/2021 10:32

People based in London, Birmingham and Manchester in many high salary industries have always worked from home 2-3 days per week. The only difference now is that wfh has filtered down into low salary and even manual professions where it’s still new & needs honing and development.

For example I never realised that we could wfh for any part of our role in nursery based childcare but actually we are far more productive by shifting out daily progress updates for the kids to wfh staff. Staff like wfh 1 day a week too and considering how low salaries are in our field it’s a good hiring perk. I’m def keeping it.

Wroxie · 16/09/2021 10:32

@rwalker to solve those problems, we need to ensure people are paid enough (by law) to cover the extra costs of WFH whether that's physical equipment or utilities or even a desk in a co-working space if they don't have space for a private desk in their own home or apartment. We need better mental health provision in the NHS. We need to support people at work to have a better work/life balance so they have the time and head space to build relationships in their community (instead of the relationships forced on them at work).

Artificially supporting coffee shops and office space landlords is the stupidest and most short-sighted possible solution to these problems- and, in fact, doesn't solve them at all for most people, who have found their mental health and work-life balance immeasurably improved without a pointless forced and expensive commute to go do work they could have done better at home.

RosyPoesy · 16/09/2021 10:32

It's like the poster who loves WHF as has more time with baby fast forward 10 years sat in empty house with a screen for company and remotely managed will WFH be so attractive then
That’s the whole point of hybrid working. People can have the flexibility to do what suits them. Those who want to be in the office can, and those who want extra time at home and no commute can wfh. People might change their working patterns at different times in their lives, or depending on their personal circumstances, either with the same employer or by switching jobs. Much better than before, where you had to be in the office and fuck you if that doesn’t suit you personally.

user1497207191 · 16/09/2021 10:31

@EveningOverRooftops

If anything WFH and the pandemic as a whole have shown our city centre based shops and supermarket culture is anything but good.

If we’d had the small high street shops - for reference my local one is mostly takeaways, a pound shop type place, several charity shops and a post office - and less focus on big supermarkets the last 18mths would’ve been an entirely different experience for all of us.

It’s about time we started rethinking our retail setup, our supermarket set up to something that is much more sustainable overall.

You mean go back to the 70s and 80s before the identikit chain stores took over the High Street and huge supermarkets/retail parks caused thousands of small "corner" shops to close down.

Trouble is that the general public voted with their feet and gave their custom to the chain stores, supermarkets, etc. If we want to reverse that, WE, i.e. all shoppers have to change back to giving custom to the small/independents.

DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 10:28

As a generalisation, older, settled people with a family love wfh.

Young people starting out, with no home of their own and no wide group of friends just round the corner find it hard.

And change has happened so quickly. One year everyone in the office, a year later and you’re in your bedroom not able to talk to a real person.

LST · 16/09/2021 10:28

I love it. It's changed my life for the better. I hope to never need to go back into the office

BootsScootsAndToots · 16/09/2021 10:28

One of my friends had a huge MH crisis as she needs people, she is a huge extrovert and it affected her terribly

And the flip is these extraverts who need so much attention affectionately introverts MH with their constant dramas in the office.

AnxiousAbi · 16/09/2021 10:27

In terms of the impact on the economy, people will spend their money in other ways. Villages and local shops are likely to see an increase in sales as people WFM will be more likely to use them more now that they are staying locally 5 extra days per week.

Supermarkets must also have seen an increase in sales too as people will need more food when working at home - this all creates jobs too. They are just different types of roles.

People won’t stop spending just because they are at home, but they will change the way they spend. And supply for things will gradually align to the demand for them.

Public transport is a tricky one as it will have an impact on people who don’t drive and also when people want to use it to socialise but I’m not sure what can be done about that. If the demand isn’t there then it’s tricky.

(I’m not underestimating the devastation involved in people having to close businesses and people losing jobs in those business)

Charlene91 · 16/09/2021 10:26

Your issues with it seem very economical when it comes to not WFH. You've also mentioned the positives about the environmental aspect of WFH.

Environmental trumps economical every single time. If we don't have a planet to live on, what good is money? 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread