Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 16/09/2021 11:17

Different folks/strokes. Works really well for us.

MyPatronusIsACat · 16/09/2021 11:16

@PosiePerkinPootleFlump

It's shit for young people who have no middle management to learn from properly because they are all sitting at home.

And really selfish on the part of people who learned loads from interacting with colleagues when they were more junior, but now can't be arsed to go in to help develop more junior staff.

100% this! ^

Beautiful3 · 16/09/2021 11:15

I renewed my licence very recently, it came within 2 weeks. Can you send them an email? As that's a long wait time.

Rozziie · 16/09/2021 11:15

@olidora63

I think WFH is a disaster for young people.Sleeping and working in the same room , not exercising and being in the physical company of others, is not good for MH !
I agree. It really isn't. And I think people are still high on the novelty of it all, along with fear of covid (understandable) and will come to see how awful it is a few years down the line.

I spent several years working fully remote, as a freelancer. It was miserable. My mental health completely nosedived. It's so much harder to motivate yourself to go outside if you don't actually need to. Being in the office forces you to commute, walk to the station, etc. It forces you to interact with people. It's much easier to go along to after-work drinks or pop into the gym on your way home. For anyone who already struggles with depression and motivation, having no real reason to ever leave their home is terrible.

We are social beings. We just aren't made to sit at home alone all day, working and eating and relaxing and sleeping in the same space.

CrazySpanielLady88 · 16/09/2021 11:15

Haven’t read TFT but I advertise jobs all day long, for hundreds of different companies around the U.K., Europe and the states. I would say only 10% of these are allowing WFH. So I really don’t think WFH is going to be as big as people think it is. City centres will recover, it might just take time.

Personally I love WFH and have no desire to go back to an office. Actually, I lie, 1-2 days a week might be okay but no more than that.

burritofan · 16/09/2021 11:14

But people need to start going back now, if only 2 or 3 days a week, to get back to normality. People cannot work from home forever. It's ridiculous. And there's simply no need for it anymore.
This is all opinion, no facts. Why do they need to, why is it ridiculous, why can’t they WFH forever?

And I know I'll get flamed for this, but I don't think men should work from home. They need to go back to the workplace now… It's wrong on so many levels for men of working age to be at home all the time… It's not a natural thing for men to knuckle down and do housework and chores
Are you OK? Like, actually OK? Did you hit your head and wake up in prehistoric cave times? Is it that the penises get in the way of the hoover, or…?

minatrina · 16/09/2021 11:12

@Fairyliz

If you job can totally be done wfh with no need to go into the office, then surely it can be done from any home around the world and probably at a much cheaper cost to employers. I think a lot of people are likely to be made redundant when jobs are outsourced around the world.
Do you think that employers are giving us jobs out of the goodness of their hearts? Employers will try and do this where they can with or without U.K. employees WFH. Indeed, they've been doing it where they can since long before covid. I don't see why WFH would change that.
Wroxie · 16/09/2021 11:11

@Ozanj exactly - and in terms of the well-paid jobs that require specific skills, it may be true that some of those will open up to people outside of the UK (but not in most regulated industries). But it will also be true that people in the UK will find they can apply for similar jobs all over the world.

Needmoresleep · 16/09/2021 11:09

I can see DH getting WfH fatigue.

It was fine for 15 months. There was a pandemic, he was busy. Everyone else was on a screen. Now there is a choice, or rather his employer has a choice, he would like a decision. His employer is a bit of an outlier and so he is not yet required to go into the office, but others he has contact with are now required to be back in person, which has led to him having to go in anyway for specific meetings.

I think DH is sick of being stuck in the spare bedroom, which is fine as a workplace, but still the spare bedroom. I am sick of hearing the drone of Zoom calls, though I am able to get out and see friends, go for walks and go shopping (I am self employed and able to work flexibly). I also don't like the loss of privacy/independence, now we see each other all day. He also misses interaction with colleagues, and the chance to have casual conversations to explore topics, rather than always have formal meetings. He would like to know new colleagues better.

I am not bothered by the plight of city centre coffee shops. Where we are there were always a lot of wfh'ers and a good local coffee shop where people used to congregate mid morning for a change of scenery and the chance of social interaction. Those Prets will move to the suburbs. And I see longer distance train routes thriving. We have spent the summer two hours from London. DH got the 6.45 this morning. At the moment it looks like he will need to do this once a week, not cheap but cheaper than a weekly season ticket from where we were, and less time than a daily commute.

Part of the problem is that no one really knows what will happen with the pandemic over the winter. DHs employer may be right in being cautious and not setting out clear requirements until we have this winter over. But generally I assume many people are yearning for normal, albeit a new normal informed by practices and routines that worked through lockdown.

MossyBottom · 16/09/2021 11:08

@PosiePerkinPootleFlump

It's shit for young people who have no middle management to learn from properly because they are all sitting at home. And really selfish on the part of people who learned loads from interacting with colleagues when they were more junior, but now can't be arsed to go in to help develop more junior staff.
This. DS2 graduated in 2019 and started work in 2020. His entire working life to date has been WFH. He knows no different and can't see any disadvantages. I see what he is missing out on. Mentoring, the experience and expertise of colleagues. Yes he can ask for help but it's not the same as sitting in an office with people who know your job. Socially it's rubbish as well. New career, new city, but no new friends. I remember making lifelong friends among all the young people who started work around the same time as me. DS hasn't even met them. In fact there was really no point in moving to the location of his workplace. At the time he assumed it would be temporary and of course he wanted the excitement of living in his own place.
TimeForTeaAndG · 16/09/2021 11:08

Some of the issues for folk has been that sports centres, clubs etc haven't been able to run because of guidelines. Young folk will have social lives again, just not necessarily around their desk at work.

schnubbins · 16/09/2021 11:05

Google has already started cutting the pay of employees who have moved to less expensive areas than the Bay Area and are working from home.Other companies such as Zillow and Reddit are following suit.the pay cuts are from between 10-25 percent of Gross Salary.

MyPatronusIsACat · 16/09/2021 11:03

@schnubbins

So what are your kids going to do when they leave schooling ten years time or so and go to online Uni because 'it works' and then start a new job again in front of a screen because everyone is WFH .They have no contact with real people and have to learn everything alone without any support from others. This is the current scenario from my very outgoing twenty something year olds and many of their friends .They are very despondent and many have just given up.

This exactly. In addition to the service industry/travel/cafes/coffee bars/shops suffering, the young are being badly affected by this 'work from home' obsession too ... (school age young, AND younger people in the workplace...)

The lack of contact and support with their peers, is affecting many young people massively. It's OK for the jaded and cynical not-so-young (who have been working 20-odd years or more,) as they are glad to be away from the commute, and working with people they dislike. They want to stay working from home because it suits THEM.. It's massively selfish to want to continue working from home permanently, and expecting that this is the way it should be forever.

It's unsustainable, and is bad for the well-being and mental health of many. As WELL as being bad for society.

(Some) people need to stop being so narrow minded and self absorbed. Things need to get back to normal. People need to get back to work in the workplace/office, and 'work from home' needs to be reined right in...

Ozanj · 16/09/2021 11:03

[quote Wroxie]@Fairyliz I work for several multi-national companies as a consultant and that COULD have happened years ago. It hasn't. The jobs that could be outsourced to save money (call centre and some development/coding) already have- a long time ago in most cases. The other jobs will stay right where they are.[/quote]
Wfh might bring a lot of coding and even call centre jobs back from India. I know it has in certain banks.

StarCat2020 · 16/09/2021 11:03

Haven't RTFT but DVLA have been striking

www.pcs.org.uk/news-events/news/strong-support-dvla-strike-month-long-action-underway

FinallyHere · 16/09/2021 11:00

without the demand things start to grind to a halt. That’s what causes recessions.

There are usually winners and losers in times of structural change. The end result is seldom an overall drop in the economy, even if there might be a drop for a few months or even quarters.

Winners from WFH have been home extensions snd furnishers, garden rooms and furniture, BBQs. Local providers of daily/temporary office space. Home delivery of grocery services etc.

Loads more things can be done online. My solicitors have even accepted on line payments. No minimum on contact payments in our local store have been brilliant for me less good for them because I used to have to pad out my shopping to the min £5.

Losers sandwich bars and coffee houses around office only areas.

MrKlaw · 16/09/2021 10:59

if you wfh, you're just moving your office. So the demand profile of locations changes. Maybe there isn't a pret on every corner in central london. But maybe instead there is a pret in one corner of a few more towns with lots of people workign from home and popping out locally for lunch?

TimeForTeaAndG · 16/09/2021 10:58

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MauvePinkRose I agree. I mean, it's OK to a degree, and is helpful for some - especially those who struggle with childcare.

And it's great to not have to commute, and to be able to roll out of bed 5 minutes before work starts, and not 2 hours before, and to 'finish' and be home at 5.10pm, instead of not getting home til 6.30pm!

But people need to start going back now, if only 2 or 3 days a week, to get back to normality. People cannot work from home forever. It's ridiculous. And there's simply no need for it anymore.

And as you say, many things are waaaaay behind now - some months in some cases, because of the lack of staff in the offices. People doing stuff from home - who work for DVLA, land registry, DWP, Inland revenue, councils, etc, is resulting in things being done much MUCH slower. 'Work from home' is clearly not doable long-term...

And I know I'll get flamed for this, but I don't think men should work from home. They need to go back to the workplace now.

As the OP says, many men have got complacent, lazy, and slovenly, whilst many women have had their workload doubled, and have struggled to run the home, look after the kids, and in some cases, do their own wfh job, with the men stuck in every day, dominating everything.

And whilst a few people say 'oh YOU wanna work from home and have that flexibility, and no commute etc, but don't want your husband to,' it's completely different.

It's wrong on so many levels for men of working age to be at home all the time, and moreover, when they ARE working from home, they do shag-all else. Their big important job, their schedule, their zoom calls, their big voice, their everything, trumps everything, and they generally don't lift a finger to help in the house, or with the kids. Multiple threads on here (and conversations with women in real life) have proven that spectacularly.

I know a 29 y.o. couple right now - no kids, but they have a home together. They have worked from home since last March, and the house is a shit tip half the time. Because neither of them ever does anything. HE won't do housework and general chores, and SHE won't do it because HE won't.

So they hire a cleaner 5-6 hours a week, (who does SOME of the housework,) and they do their individual washing. They do their own breakfasts and lunches, but he cooks dinner two thirds of the time, as he likes cooking, and she does the food shop. But she says 'like fuck am I gonna be doing the grunt work when he's sat there playing FIFA 2021 on the XBox, or watching netflix marathons!'

It's not a natural thing for men to knuckle down and do housework and chores, so it falls to the woman very often. If he is stuck at home all the time, dominating EVERYTHING, it's very difficult to maintain a normal home, especially with kids.[/quote]
What a load of utter sexist nonsense. If men have got lazy that's on them, that's not a WFH/office thing. If women ditched men who are lazy, unhelpful etc they wouldn't be stuck in passive aggressive households.

And what is a normal home? We have a child, we split the household chores and we pick up the slack if one of us is ill/out/whatever. Or do you mean the status quo expectation of women doing everything while the big man goes to his big important job and does fuck all else cos he is the penis-haver?

DynamoKev · 16/09/2021 10:57

@Rollercoaster1920

I look forward to the day when a child, cat, dog or partner joining a work call is a rare occurrence again. It is unprofessional.

I include my family and pets in the above statement!

Yeah bollocks to any manifestation of actual real life in work. Hmm

I look forward to never having to share an open plan battery farm office with some cunt who has swallowed a fucking loud hailer shouting into their phone making it impossible to concentrate on my work.

Wroxie · 16/09/2021 10:57

@Fairyliz I work for several multi-national companies as a consultant and that COULD have happened years ago. It hasn't. The jobs that could be outsourced to save money (call centre and some development/coding) already have- a long time ago in most cases. The other jobs will stay right where they are.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 16/09/2021 10:56

I hate the lack of day to day interaction. You find out more by walking around an office and listening than in any management meeting. I miss out on working with new colleagues, comradeship, just feeling like an actual person.
I am however bloody glad that I have a job.

Flowers500 · 16/09/2021 10:56

@Fairyliz

If you job can totally be done wfh with no need to go into the office, then surely it can be done from any home around the world and probably at a much cheaper cost to employers. I think a lot of people are likely to be made redundant when jobs are outsourced around the world.
This, 100%. When people see what a genuine free market looks like for their job, they really won’t like it. Why would anybody ever hire an administrator and pay them to live in the SE if they could outsource to a cheaper company with someone with the same English skills and higher qualifications? Likewise events organisation for anything virtual, or IT, or finance, or HR, or PAs, or even most creative roles, or comms.
Fairyliz · 16/09/2021 10:50

If you job can totally be done wfh with no need to go into the office, then surely it can be done from any home around the world and probably at a much cheaper cost to employers.
I think a lot of people are likely to be made redundant when jobs are outsourced around the world.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 10:50

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MauvePinkRose I agree. I mean, it's OK to a degree, and is helpful for some - especially those who struggle with childcare.

And it's great to not have to commute, and to be able to roll out of bed 5 minutes before work starts, and not 2 hours before, and to 'finish' and be home at 5.10pm, instead of not getting home til 6.30pm!

But people need to start going back now, if only 2 or 3 days a week, to get back to normality. People cannot work from home forever. It's ridiculous. And there's simply no need for it anymore.

And as you say, many things are waaaaay behind now - some months in some cases, because of the lack of staff in the offices. People doing stuff from home - who work for DVLA, land registry, DWP, Inland revenue, councils, etc, is resulting in things being done much MUCH slower. 'Work from home' is clearly not doable long-term...

And I know I'll get flamed for this, but I don't think men should work from home. They need to go back to the workplace now.

As the OP says, many men have got complacent, lazy, and slovenly, whilst many women have had their workload doubled, and have struggled to run the home, look after the kids, and in some cases, do their own wfh job, with the men stuck in every day, dominating everything.

And whilst a few people say 'oh YOU wanna work from home and have that flexibility, and no commute etc, but don't want your husband to,' it's completely different.

It's wrong on so many levels for men of working age to be at home all the time, and moreover, when they ARE working from home, they do shag-all else. Their big important job, their schedule, their zoom calls, their big voice, their everything, trumps everything, and they generally don't lift a finger to help in the house, or with the kids. Multiple threads on here (and conversations with women in real life) have proven that spectacularly.

I know a 29 y.o. couple right now - no kids, but they have a home together. They have worked from home since last March, and the house is a shit tip half the time. Because neither of them ever does anything. HE won't do housework and general chores, and SHE won't do it because HE won't.

So they hire a cleaner 5-6 hours a week, (who does SOME of the housework,) and they do their individual washing. They do their own breakfasts and lunches, but he cooks dinner two thirds of the time, as he likes cooking, and she does the food shop. But she says 'like fuck am I gonna be doing the grunt work when he's sat there playing FIFA 2021 on the XBox, or watching netflix marathons!'

It's not a natural thing for men to knuckle down and do housework and chores, so it falls to the woman very often. If he is stuck at home all the time, dominating EVERYTHING, it's very difficult to maintain a normal home, especially with kids.[/quote]
This isn't a working from home issue. This is a if you get in a relationship with someone who's been mollycoddling his entire life issue.

I promise you if your pal had a kid with this man, he won't be anymore and will probably do less. Because he's been allowed to.

Not all women accept that behaviour of men. If anyone settles for less that was your choice.

I mean people don't have to go back to the office, that's the point because the masses are going no thank you, for reasons you may notice deem valid but are valid to them.

Wroxie · 16/09/2021 10:47

@MyPatronusIsACat

And I know I'll get flamed for this, but I don't think men should work from home. They need to go back to the workplace now.

Or they could, you know, take some responsibility for themselves and their families and their homes. Just like my partner does. Just like my friends' partners do. If my husband acted like what you describe - well, he wouldn't, because I wouldn't have been stupid enough to marry someone like that, but if he hit his head and his personality changed into something like that, I'd go on strike until he sorted himself out and then I'd fucking leave if he didn't.
The answer isn't just to shove men out the front door with their briefcases so the women can get on with cleaning the house in peace - honestly, what nonsense.