Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
CorianderAndCream · 16/09/2021 13:01

I like it because I don't like leaving the house at 5.45am to get on three packed tubes to make it to work on time :)

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 13:00

I think a lot of people don’t ‘exercise’ in a formal sense but just normal movement throughout the day can be hugely restricted if WFH.

Of course that varies from person to person but a lot of people won’t ‘go for a walk’ but will cycle into the office, or walk to a tube station. Even just walking from the car park into the office is a few hundred steps for me. I’ve done 8500 steps today just from moving around. When I was at home in the first lockdown I often didn’t manage 6000 even with an actual ‘walk’ built in.

OP posts:
NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 12:58

@MauvePinkRose also I am massively in favour of working from home. However I voted YANBU because if it doesn’t work for you I think you should have the option of an office. Like many others I guess. However if you shut down WFH for me, because you put pressure on employers to only do WFH or only suit your agenda, I’d be putting YABVVU because I’d then lose my only income!

Asthenia · 16/09/2021 12:58

Sorry but if you’re not showering/exercising/getting out of the house because of WFH that’s totally on you. I love WFH - totally rejigged my work/life balance. I’d like to go into the office for a change of scene 2 days a week, WFH for 3. I exercise more regularly than ever before as I’m not knackered, I keep on top of housework and I get out of the house now that everything is open again due to socialising/exercise classes/generally getting out and about to the shops and normal stuff like that. My commute used to make me utterly miserable but it would be bearable only a couple of days a week. I think the key element here is choice - WFH clearly works for a lot of people but doesn’t work for others. Why should everyone be forced into one or the other?

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 12:56

Surely this is showing that flexibility and a mixed approach is best?

For all my grumbling I can quite see that everyone being in five days a week Monday to Friday isn’t necessary and if that gives people a better work / life balance that’s all good.

But I do think there should be a bit more consideration to the fact that homes are not offices, that this can impact negatively on people as well as positively and that some office work is often necessary, if only do you don’t forget what your colleagues look like in the flesh!

OP posts:
NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 12:56

if it is permanent, means families will live in a workplace, and that isn’t always a good thing This needn’t be the case at all.

As companies save money by more WFH, that cost can be used for home office spaces, or local ‘hubs’.

And also for people like me - all I had was living with the family (being a carer of disabilities) - and now I can actually work which is massive to people like me and my family. The cost of childcare for those with severe disabilities is prohibitive.

I agree WFH does have it’s issues. But I think this is far, far outweighed by the advantages. And a hybrid with lots of flexibility is perfect - so that if people need or want an outside office space they can choose that.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 12:52

@Rozziie just to be clear my post wasn't to attack people with depression. My post it to highlight that the tools to your own prison are in front of you.
I say this as someone who's had very bad depression. Sad fact about it is, the only one who could help me out of the darkness was me.

The office isn't the only place to socialise, and going for a walk in the rain isn't the only second option. You have to find what suits you (whatever it is) but because some people prefer things a certain way (MH or preference) that doesn't mean that's anyone else's views are immediately discounted or invalid. Your opinions are your own. But you have options which is a choice, your choice shouldn't limit other people's choices just because.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 12:47

Love the empathy for people with depression etc.

You mean like all the empathy there was for me when I had to work in an office for 10 years because home working wasn't deemed viable?

I completely recognise a lot of people's mental health has suffered as a result of pandemic induced restriction, but you equally have to recognise that there were those of us who were drowning for years because we were forced to work in physical workplaces (plus other things), and if you complained you were told the problem lay with you and you just had to get on with it because, sorry and everything, but that's just how the world is.

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 12:43

I think what really is interesting about this thread is that while overwhelming the responses are in favour of WFH, the votes are not, and I do think that this might be because a lot of WFHers really can’t see the impact that this has on the rest of the family.

I know if my partner was asked he would say that WFH is entirely positive, because that’s his perception. Mine is totally different.

And yes people can reply that is an individual response but no more or less so than the several posts saying ‘well I never buy coffee.’

It isn’t just or even mostly about coffee. If is about a change that, if it is permanent, means families will live in a workplace, and that isn’t always a good thing .

OP posts:
Rozziie · 16/09/2021 12:43

@Thesandmanishere

Also to any poster that said they feel trapped at home, you know where your front door is, start going out of it

Yes! Who is keeping you "locked up"?! Go outside FFS!!

Love the empathy for people with depression etc. My mental health got so much better when I moved to office working from WFH because I was forced to go out, even if I really, really didn't feel like it. I am never, ever going to voluntarily go out for a walk on a gloomy November morning in the pissing rain.

Some of us really struggle to go out for the sake of it. I need to have somewhere to go, something to do. I really can't do the 'walk around for no reason' thing.

Ori3 · 16/09/2021 12:37

@candlelightsatdawn

Also probably because they are used to doing 100 things before 6am and can do it without breaking a sweat and value being valued .

Yes, very true. I think the way things were in the working world weren't really geared up to support working mothers. But this new hybrid solution with the flexibility to put in your hours and ensure you get your work done whilst also having to do mummy things - well, I think, I hope, it will open up more opportunities professionally for that tier of society. Not before time TBH

BreadPita · 16/09/2021 12:27

No.
Economy-wise, people aren't going to just hoard their pret money. It will stimulate other areas of the economy. I also think that losing businesses that rely on selling overpriced sandwiches to harried office workers are not a net loss to the world
In terms of the social aspect, I've never made friends with coworkers because I already have friends that won't go to HR if I say something that offends them.
I recommend that you all try it.
If you don't enjoy being around the people that you chose to create and spend your life with, that also shouldn't be made my problem.

RobinPenguins · 16/09/2021 12:21

Less traffic and public transport on the road. Honestly in the UK our roads are not coping with all the traffic, the pollution is something we are increasingly aware of esp for our kids growing up in it.

This isn’t a good argument for wfh. In many areas in my region data shows traffic is now higher than it was pre-pandemic, because people who would have commuted to the office via public transport are now driving in one or two days, are driving the school runs, are driving to the gym or the shops in the middle of the day.

TheFairPrincess · 16/09/2021 12:16

I think environmental factors need to be absolute priority in the times we are in.

I enjoy working from home but I can get on with work when I need to. Yes I have time to do more things for myself, have no commute time and admittedly love it, love being around more for my children, but.. Long term I imagine a mix would be the ideal.

100% WFH probably not ideal.
Back to 5 days in the office, definitely not ideal.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 12:15

I am so pleased that WFH has forced a lot of rethinking and I’m excited about the future.

Lots of good opportunities, such as ‘office hubs’ which are smaller but more social. Sometimes you can just rent part of an office if you don’t want to be at home, and meet people in all kinds of industries.

Less traffic and public transport on the road. Honestly in the UK our roads are not coping with all the traffic, the pollution is something we are increasingly aware of esp for our kids growing up in it.

Coffee places just can be more local - know of several new pop up coffee ‘bars’ that you can drive through or drink outside. They’ve become really popular with WFHomers out for their daily walk or people meeting outside.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 12:05

Also to any poster that said they feel trapped at home, you know where your front door is, start going out of it

Yes! Who is keeping you "locked up"?! Go outside FFS!!

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 12:04

When people see what a genuine free market looks like for their job, they really won’t like it. Why would anybody ever hire an administrator and pay them to live in the SE if they could outsource to a cheaper company with someone with the same English skills and higher qualifications? Likewise events organisation for anything virtual, or IT, or finance, or HR, or PAs, or even most creative roles, or comms.

I see this argument trotted out a lot as an argument against home working and it's utter tripe. In my industry as well as DH's that could have happened for years and hasn't. Particularly in DH's - they have the option to outsource work to India and pay a quarter of what they pay to British contractors. That option has existed for the last decade. It hasn't been done because they get much better work out of their British workers and they're perfectly willing to pay for it.

candlelightsatdawn · 16/09/2021 12:03

@Twins3007 this isn't a wfh issue, so much as a bad company that actually was probably pretty bad as the social element to begin with. A company that's bad at communicating will only get worse wfh.

Young people will adapt and probably over take us oldies because they adapt quicker than us. I have yet to meet a new grad that hasn't struggled in some area of getting the lay of the ground.

Also to any poster that said they feel trapped at home, you know where your front door is, start going out of it. Instead of laminating with rose tinted glasses on about going out your front door, to sit in car alone to walk through another office door to sit on your computer being asked about where's the stapler 5 days a week.

Communication face to face in office is one form of communication, it's just we are so used to it, we don't know how to do anything else. Social meet ups can still happen wfh (even in pubs I hear now), it can it be done mid pandemic/contactlessly via zoom, we all have some version of teams, Skype slack. And all have mobile phones, social media but yet communication and social fun must be done f2f ? Really ? 😵‍💫

I have spoken to my neighbours so much during lockdown I know everyone by name and the community spirit is coming back. It wasn't there before and it's only because people aren't running off to their own hamster cube.

People are getting friendlier because they have to get their social fix elsewhere and that's a good thing.

unluckyinlife · 16/09/2021 11:57

I think it is entirely dependant on the job and the person. Working from home has massively improved my mental health.
I spend less time commuting and more productive time at home.

I see my kids more and have less working mum guilt.

I left a role I loved to swap to work from home for 2 days a week in office 3. I now primarily work from home but go into the office when needed, at the moment twice a week. I think my mental health needed the flexibility of WFH.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 11:54

It’s been a boon for people with disabilities or caring duties though. Including me. Suddenly a lot of work is open to me that wasn’t before.

And those that cannot afford to live in expensive parts of the city, or afford extortionate.

At last something that has evened up a bit of the inequalities divide. I’m all for it! I think that trumps coffee shops any day.

ToastieSnowy · 16/09/2021 11:54

Completely disagree. I love wfh, I’ve lost 3 1/2 stone during the pandemic, saved a load on petrol and my work/life balance is brilliant without the commute and rigid office hours. My work can easily be monitored (and is) and I have to account for every minute but the flexibility in when I work benefits both myself and my employer.

I’m nipping our for lunch to my local independent sandwich shops so supporting my local economy.

My mental health is great, I’m relaxed & happy. I see my kids more and am a lot less tired. Needless to say I am not looking forward to going back into the office even if it’s part office, part wfh.

PattyPan · 16/09/2021 11:53

As a youngster I am loving wfh! I can’t afford to live near my office so I don’t have to commute 3 hours a day and the money I save on my commute makes a real difference to my budget. My work has never gone for after work drinks anyway although we usually go for lunch about twice a year.

Moonface123 · 16/09/2021 11:52

It's just natural change, nothing will ever stay the same, pandemic or not.
I personally would love to work from home than in a noisy and stressful environment like a supermarket, but even that is gearing up for huge warehouses where it's all done online. Most shops and offices will become a thing of the past like the tin and coal mines.

Twins3007 · 16/09/2021 11:48

I feel sorry for the youngsters , they are not gaining the social skills they need wfh. They need the interaction working with senior colleagues to learn and move forward. My son has been wfh the last 18 months , so misses all the team building, going out to lunch, after work get togethers , he has lost out on so much as the career he has chosen relies on him meeting clients etc, he has passed all his financial exams but failed the last role play exam as he has had no experience of learning this side of the job

Polkadotties · 16/09/2021 11:48

@Noshowlomo

I have to work in the office twice a week. It’s not that bad BUT there was a huge crash coming home, I spent 1.5 hours on the road when it should have been 45 mins. I missed my sons bed time because of this and spent the evening stressed to fuck. Every single thing I did in the office that day I could have done from home. WFH is brilliant and long may it continue. Being stuck in traffic with people driving up my arse does nothing for my mental health.
This. I drove to work one day last week, sat in traffic for ages and could literally feel myself getting more and more annoyed as time went in. I got into the office all huffy and stressed as I was running late. I left home at 7.30 and got in at 9.30. Had I been at home I would have logged on at 8 and that’s with getting up later.