Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
RobinPenguins · 16/09/2021 17:01

But I've always made employment decisions based on what's better for myself and my family

But you chose a 2 hour daily commute? I have had barely any time freed up as a result of working from home because I’ve always made employment decisions based on what’s better for myself and my family and that didn’t involve choosing a long commute.

LadyWithLapdog · 16/09/2021 16:59

@Rozziie it’s perplexing you’re banging the drum for office work when it’s quite obvious you don’t like people much. What do you hope to get out of it?

Thelikelylass · 16/09/2021 16:51

I agree, everything is sloppy and I see it in my own workplace. Colleagues not responding to requests, never online, inexplicably absent. There is a general air of malaise and at the start of the pandemic I said that organisations would be spending a fortune (and time) on tribunals trying to get people back into the office or even to do their normal workload.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 16:51

You're right that it impacts public transit and local businesses. But I've always made employment decisions based on what's better for myself and my family, not based on what's better for tangentially-related local service industries or their workers. I think that's true of most people, and I don't see why it should be different when we're talking about WFH. It's not my or anyone else's responsibility to prop up those industries. If decreased demand for public transit results in service cuts, then those tax dollars can either be spent on things more people actually want, or they can be returned to the people in the form of reduced taxes.

Turning family homes into workplaces definitely does have consequences, but whether those are good or bad depends on each individual situation. If two adults are trying to work from home in two different jobs in a 2-bedroom flat they share with their two young children who are home all day, yeah, they're not going to be very productive. But if someone has a spare bedroom that they've turned into a dedicated office, and either doesn't have children or has arranged proper childcare, they can be more productive than they would have been in the office. That's my situation, and my husband and I both love being able to eat lunch together.

As for exercise and whatnot, eliminating a commute leaves me with an extra 1-2 hours per day, and I often use that time for real exercise. I can multi-task and do things like laundry or cleaning while on work calls, which saves even more time. An hour-long run around the neighborhood is much more beneficial than an occasional stroll from my office down the hall to the water cooler. Plus, I can set up my home office however I like, so I can use things like standing desks, or rig up a sort of treadmill desk or stationary bike desk.

On that note, though, I think that if the job requires working from home, and therefore effectively requires the existence and full-time use of a spare room, the employer should pay the equivalent of fair market rent for that space, just as they'd have paid rent for a proper office. It should be factored into the employee's salary. For example, if the job would ordinarily pay enough for a single employee to have a one-bedroom, but it requires frequent remote work, the employee's salary should be increased by the cost of an extra bedroom. But if WFH is optional, and the employee could choose to go to the office 5 days a week if they wanted, I don't think that's necessary.

Looktotheright · 16/09/2021 16:39

WFH has many benefits. I’m now a mix of in office and WFH.

For me public transport is vital as I am partially sighted. If there is no bus or train I can’t just hop in the car to go to the city. I chose to live in a city to deal with that but then got a job in a town. Transport here is already a bit worse. If there is even worse transport my life will get smaller.

I do also think that the coffee shop jobs are an issue. It may be healthy that we eat at home and that there are cafes locally. However there may not be as many jobs. The chains must have some appeal as there used to be more independent coffee/tea/sandwich shops. It may have been just price but I doubt it and I expect that Pret and Costas are looking at ways to move to local areas.

futureghost · 16/09/2021 16:39

@Scr1bblyGum

My husband is stuck in doors 9-5 seeing nobody. It’s shit and having a real impact on mental health.
Me too. I'm pretty much reaching at breaking point. Been looking for other work but I'm at an age where its really hard to get anyone to give me an interview for jobs I have excellent experience and qualifications for - jobs I would have easily got an interview for 10-15 years ago.
FinallyHere · 16/09/2021 16:32

People cannot work from home forever. It's ridiculous.

The people with whom I work are scattered across different countries and locations. We communicate with a mixture of email, video, teams chat snd phone calls. It honestly makes no difference where I happen to be sitting, when I am engaged in this work.

We have had to manage our teams without relying on seeing how many hours they spend at their desk. We already manage their output, rather than what effort they put in, because that is what matters.

There has always been a lot of emphasis on involving the younger, less experienced members of the team. We do not rely on them 'picking things up' so much as much as more structured 'knowledge harvesting', post implementation reviews and making really good use of people's time.

Picking things up as they go along can work well but can also pass on bad habits.

As it happens, the hybrid model suits me, I'll go in one or two days a week. I'm less productive, but I enjoy having lunch with different people, catching up over coffee etc. and generally being with people.

Hybrid is all good for me.

Rainbowsew · 16/09/2021 16:26

All perfectly valid points op, I agree with you.

I hate the way work is creeping into home life and society expects instant answers to things.

There may be benefits to some about not commuting but city centres are dying, there's no vibrancy to life without getting out and meeting people. I worry about people s mental and physical health being stuck in one room all day without even walking to the car/train.

I think a happy medium is a mix of the two. Part of the week in a work environment part of it working from home

Hekatestorch · 16/09/2021 16:22

@minatrina

Why are the "back to the office" crowd so incensed by the idea of people being able to do what works for best for them?! You go and have your fun in the office, I would prefer to stay at home. What's the problem?! 🤣
I think, it's because if offices aren't as full of people and lots of us are elsewhere, they won't enjoy the office

I don't think some people who want to go back, want it back to exactly how it was before March 2020. Not all but some of them.

But it's not going to be

MajorCarolDanvers · 16/09/2021 16:18

WFH has opened up many opportunities in the job market in my sector.

No longer are we restricted to jobs or candidates who live within commuting distance.

I know several people (me included) who've been able to obtain excellent new jobs that wouldn't have be open geographically before.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 16:16

I could call you ableist for supporting mass WFH when it's terrible for many people.

I think as many people as want to WFH (and can) should be able to. I don't think anyone should be forced to WFH. But you seem to be suggesting that everyone ought to be going back to the office whether they want to or not, and also saying that parents who find WOHM difficult should jog on and stop whining. If I have that wrong, and you in fact believe that everyone should have the choice, then we agree.

MajorCarolDanvers · 16/09/2021 16:14

@minatrina

Why are the "back to the office" crowd so incensed by the idea of people being able to do what works for best for them?! You go and have your fun in the office, I would prefer to stay at home. What's the problem?! 🤣
Completely agree

Choice is the best way forward.

minatrina · 16/09/2021 16:11

Why are the "back to the office" crowd so incensed by the idea of people being able to do what works for best for them?! You go and have your fun in the office, I would prefer to stay at home. What's the problem?! 🤣

Scr1bblyGum · 16/09/2021 16:10

And he has a spacious home with an office. I dread to think how crap it is for this stuck in poor housing with distractions. Not sure I want my data in thousands of houses across the country either.

Rozziie · 16/09/2021 16:08

@lockdownmadnessdotcom But those people with a massive commute chose to do that. That was what they signed up for when they bought their house or started their job. Those who bought small flats near to their workplaces are now effectively being penalised because the situation has turned into one they never signed up for.

Scr1bblyGum · 16/09/2021 16:07

My husband is stuck in doors 9-5 seeing nobody. It’s shit and having a real impact on mental health.

Rozziie · 16/09/2021 16:06

@Thesandmanishere

Didn't expect the rest of the world to accommodate me. Just got on with it.

Your ableism is showing.

why do you think your needs are more important than everyone else's? It's incredibly arrogant. I could call you ableist for supporting mass WFH when it's terrible for many people.
seasidehouse · 16/09/2021 15:59

Regarding your driving licence , I changed details on line last Monday and had it returned last Thursday , so maybe contact them online ?

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 16/09/2021 15:52

@Thesandmanishere

I actually don't think everyone being stuck in their homes all the time is very healthy for anyone.

Yes, it was definitely much better when I left my home, sat on a stuffy train for an hour, went and sat in an air conditioned office all day and then came back home again.

People aren't stuck in their homes though. They can go out in the morning before work (which my DH tends to do), at lunchtime, after work. If you want to do things in the evenings, you can, because you don't have to commute.

There is going to be quite a difference in perspective between those who have to waste time and money commuting and those who have a 10 minutes walk, cycle ride or drive to the office. If you live close by and are home by 6pm anyway, you won't care whether you work from home or not. If you have a 90 minute commute which you've largely avoided for the last 18 months you are going to have a very different view.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 16/09/2021 15:50

@RosyPoesy

We are now all being forced to WFH most of the time There are lots of jobs that aren’t wfh. Go and get one of those, and stop trying to control other people’s lives and work.
People are not being forced to WFH. My husband's office is open and if he wanted to go in every day he could. He goes in one day a week.

My employer's office is also open and if I wanted to go in ever
y day I also could. I will probably go in one day a week from next month.

If you work for an employer that has got rid of its offices, I imagine there are plenty of other employers who haven't. There is a lot of "churn" going on at the moment as people who are being told to go back to offices and want to WFH change to employers who will allow them to do so, and vice versa.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 15:47

I actually don't think everyone being stuck in their homes all the time is very healthy for anyone.

Yes, it was definitely much better when I left my home, sat on a stuffy train for an hour, went and sat in an air conditioned office all day and then came back home again.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 16/09/2021 15:46

Not have to work in some soulless coworking space because all the offices have been sold off

I would have thought a co-working space was nicer than most offices. Obviously depends, but most seem to be really nice (but correspondingly expensive).

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 15:45

Didn't expect the rest of the world to accommodate me. Just got on with it.

Your ableism is showing.

thecatsthecats · 16/09/2021 15:40

Shittily run organisations will remain shitty, or become worse. Well run ones will thrive.

My husband has lost three stone. My mental and physical health have both improved due to wfh.

And my company's productivity and job satisfaction shot through the roof - including inducting and mentoring new staff.

It's not all of one or the other, and frankly I'm sick of the lobbying to continue a norm that wasn't working for many people for the sake of those it did suit.

(and since I'm bored of writing my homily on the matter - my role involves service automation and outsourcing, and I have an acute understanding of the likelihood of this)

StrongerThanA90sTrend · 16/09/2021 15:31

I got a work from home job last year. It was great while everyone was at home (dp was on furlough, dc1 back at school, dc2 occupied by dp)

When dp went back to work in the office, I was wfh, doing school runs, and looking after dc2 when not at preschool. It ended up being quite depressing really. And a bit lonely, actually.

I've just started my new job in an actual office and I'm so happy to get out the house, see actual humans that don't demand snacks all the time.

So, I agree. I think having that flexibility is a good thing, but I actually don't think everyone being stuck in their homes all the time is very healthy for anyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread