Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 19:10

Actually I can’t work @NCBlossom , so, no, I don’t give a hoot about your particular circumstances. Why would I? Confused I’m jolly pleased you’ve found a job but in the overall scheme of things you do not I’m afraid rate in the top 1,000 things that I have to worry about.

Tealightsandd · 16/09/2021 19:07

dread to think how tough it is for those who have volatile relationships where the only time one partner is safe is whilst at work.

You see it all the time on the relationships board. An OP in a desperate situation advised to call Women's Aid when the abusive husband or partner is at work, or when she herself is at work. WFH is a gift for controlling spouses.

frazzledasarock · 16/09/2021 19:06

Public transport is too expensive and people I’ve suddenly become acutely aware of this having not had to use it during the pandemic.

I don’t think going back to working in the office because transport and shops is a good reason to be honest.

Clearly people are now fed up of working endlessly with nothing to show for it.

I think those who want to work in the office should do so, those who can WFH should br allowed to. And coffee shops will change to come thing that’s needed and wanted and public transport needs to be nationalised and priced at an affordable level. I let me team WFH if they want, I’m not having them stressed about ticket prices and trying to get into the office using services that are currently running fewer trains because pandemic or whatever excuse it is.

I prefer WFH too I do go in to the office but I’m getting once our lease is up we’ll be given a bigger WFH leeway.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 19:04

Well two pop up coffee vans have opened in my local town. Maybe the men you know don’t go there, but there you go!

Do you even care @DottyHarmer that I am now able to work because I can WFH? It was pretty tough before I can tell you. Do I count in any way?

gibletjane · 16/09/2021 19:03

You're right too OP that it's bad for the economy - and the environment, because public transport companies can't afford to run without ticket revenue.

There's a middle ground though. Trains are too expensive for the service that is (or isnt) provided.

DottyHarmer · 16/09/2021 19:02

All this “local coffee shops are booming” business…

I did a quick poll of wfh men I know. Not ONE has been to a coffee shop “to meet friends” and not ONE has bought lunch in a local cafe. Dh does not go out all day. Dd and ds’s friends’ dads wfh do not go out all day.

Men in general do not meet up for a coffee. Where have they suddenly found “coffee friends” anyway? (Same goes for women who were previously office-based.) you don’t suddenly know the whole town.

Pre-2020 Dh was buying a pricey London lunch every day, cappuccinos etc. Now he has (Waitrose!) soup.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 19:00

Ultimately I have no problem with someone WFH wanting to get back to some kind of office. (But you can do this now if you want)

You might want to do this because you are fed up/miss people/have relationship issues/just need it. Fair enough!

I do have a big problem with all the nonsense blanket statements that are just factually wrong just to back up wanting to not WFH - and trying to get it so that everyone has to go back to an office.

factually wrong and no data to back up assertions are

  • economy diving
  • coffee shop workers are starving
  • the buses will stop
  • the environment is going to hell (because houses (that already exist and don’t have to be built) are to be heated?!! Do you know how much of an environmental impact offices have?!)
  • a work colleague does no work and you can’t get through to the council about your bins
gwenneh · 16/09/2021 18:58

Being around partners too much kills relationships. There is literally nothing to talk about anymore.

I'll have to let my DH know our relationship was supposed to suffer. Thanks for letting me know!

Hekatestorch · 16/09/2021 18:56

@Tealightsandd

This is old but it's still relevant.

www.theguardian.com/business/2020/aug/30/no-return-workers-offices-could-cost-uk-economy-480bn-pounds-cebr

Of course WFH is great for the privileged. Inequality will increase but plenty don't care about that. For people who don't have the luxury of being able to afford a comfortable spacious home working environment, opportunities will be lost.

Many roles will be limited to people with housing privilege.

It's also shit for young people just starting out. Miserable and isolating. WFH is for older affluent workers with large homes and at a settled stage of life. It's crap for others (and for customers/clients).

Actually plenty of people who live I less than ideal houses, also like wfh or hybrid.

Its also not shit for all young people. For many it actually opens up opportunities. Young people are not one group.

They are like everyone else. Will suit some. Won't suit others.

But also why is it the obligation of people to work in less than ideal circumstances, for them, to to recover the economy?

What if 50% of office works decide they don't want to buy their morning coffee anymore? Or are they obliged to. What if they don't buy their lunch anymore?

Are we also telling sahp to make sure they go out and spend money everyday locally to make sure local businesses who are thriving, don't suffer?

Or are office workers obliged to do both?

Also, plenty of office workers, who are at home are spending the money on other things or in other places. Therefore it's contributing to the economy.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 18:53

@gwenneh

As for people dismissing the plight of the low waged coffee shop workers. You may not care about the less privileged - people who aren't fortunate enough to have a comfortable WFH job and a spacious home environment suitable for working from, but huge numbers of lower paid workers are facing loss of livelihood.

The low waged coffee shop workers where I used to work might be having their hours cut, it's true. The low waged coffee shop workers nearer my house are having them increased.

People still go for lunch, get their coffee, etc. They're just not doing it in the same place.

This. Everyone's still eating more or less the same amount of food (maybe more), and drinking more or less the same amount of coffee. Local restaurants outside of commercial centers are getting much more weekday business than they used to, and at least in the US, they're all begging people to work there because they're understaffed. If less food is being eaten in restaurants, that means more food is being purchased from grocery stores. That, in turn, means additional job openings for staffing those stores and producing and transporting that food. They may have to change jobs or even move, but many people have had to do that because of covid. They're not going to end up worse off economically than they were before.

I don't care any less about coffee shop workers than I do anyone else who isn't a family member, and it has nothing to do with their earning capacity or degree of "privilege." The well-being of people outside my immediate family simply doesn't factor into my employment decisions or other major life choices. Honestly, I find the view that I'm morally obligated to arrange any aspect of my life around the economic well-being of complete strangers to be quite bizarre. I don't work for them, I'm not married to them, and I'm not their mother. My obligation to do what's best for my own family - including myself - greatly exceeds any obligation I might have to random coffee shop workers, or to anyone else. Likewise, their obligation to their own families greatly exceeds any obligation they might have to me (which, IMHO, is zero).

chocolateorangeinhaler · 16/09/2021 18:52

Completely agree with you OP. There is resentment growing too in workplaces where output isn't monitored. Especially when you hear WFH colleagues saying they don't do any work in the day and do it all once the kids are in bed. So you get no response from them in working hours and they get paid for 7.5 hours and only actually do 3 hours work a day.

It's dreadful for the environment. All those thousands of houses having to be heated during the day.

Uneconomic bus routes will be cut if nobody uses them - not everyone lives in London.

Loss of mojo for work projects as you can't have a quick 5 mins with a colleague or boss to discuss things.

Being around partners too much kills relationships. There is literally nothing to talk about anymore.

Depression creeps in but you can't get out as you're supposed to be working so effectively a prisoner in your own home.

I dread to think how tough it is for those who have volatile relationships where the only time one partner is safe is whilst at work.

I'm sure there are loads more reasons not to carry on with it.

JayDot500 · 16/09/2021 18:52

It's been amazing for me dances all over this thread

Seriously though, 'work' as we know it is changing, and changing forever. Hooray for choice.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 18:51

Of course WFH is great for the privileged. I’m not privileged. I am unable to work in an office because of caring responsibilities!

Making blanket statements for WFHomers isn’t really in the spirit of listening debate.

(Really wish I hadn’t ticked YANBU now… I was all for WFH having an option of an office if so wished! But see that many just don’t care about those who cannot… sigh… Confused)

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 18:48

@Tealightsandd

worker productivity increased

They obviously didn't check out the companies I've tried to deal with over the past 18 months. Phones go unanswered, emails ignored, people don't call you back, staff seem incapable of transferring you to a colleague or manager.

Incompetence has flourished whilst customer service has nosedived.

Most reports I’ve looked at say that the majority have increased productivity across the board.

That is not to say that all have. And for those companies with bad communication, I imagine they weren’t that great before hand - as if I had a company and my employees were not answering basic calls wFH - I would be on it!

And two of my son’s friends are coffee shop workers. Happy to be on furlough. And now have lots more options as there are two new ‘pop up’ coffee places nearer us - so they don’t have to traipse on long commutes.

futureghost · 16/09/2021 18:48

WFH is for older affluent workers with large homes and at a settled stage of life. It's crap for others (and for customers/clients)

This.

Tealightsandd · 16/09/2021 18:40

This is old but it's still relevant.

www.theguardian.com/business/2020/aug/30/no-return-workers-offices-could-cost-uk-economy-480bn-pounds-cebr

Of course WFH is great for the privileged. Inequality will increase but plenty don't care about that. For people who don't have the luxury of being able to afford a comfortable spacious home working environment, opportunities will be lost.

Many roles will be limited to people with housing privilege.

It's also shit for young people just starting out. Miserable and isolating. WFH is for older affluent workers with large homes and at a settled stage of life. It's crap for others (and for customers/clients).

Hekatestorch · 16/09/2021 18:34

@Tealightsandd

worker productivity increased

They obviously didn't check out the companies I've tried to deal with over the past 18 months. Phones go unanswered, emails ignored, people don't call you back, staff seem incapable of transferring you to a colleague or manager.

Incompetence has flourished whilst customer service has nosedived.

Do you understand lots of people in offices don't work in customer service?
Tealightsandd · 16/09/2021 18:33

worker productivity increased

They obviously didn't check out the companies I've tried to deal with over the past 18 months. Phones go unanswered, emails ignored, people don't call you back, staff seem incapable of transferring you to a colleague or manager.

Incompetence has flourished whilst customer service has nosedived.

gwenneh · 16/09/2021 18:32

As for people dismissing the plight of the low waged coffee shop workers. You may not care about the less privileged - people who aren't fortunate enough to have a comfortable WFH job and a spacious home environment suitable for working from, but huge numbers of lower paid workers are facing loss of livelihood.

The low waged coffee shop workers where I used to work might be having their hours cut, it's true. The low waged coffee shop workers nearer my house are having them increased.

People still go for lunch, get their coffee, etc. They're just not doing it in the same place.

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 18:31

There isnt the evidence @Tealightsandd that huge numbers of low paid workers are being impacted compared to wealthy people in their offices - or if there is - could you share?
Low paid workers, on the whole, have not had the luxury of being able to WFH being cleaners, hospital workers, shop workers and many may have liked to have not been in the front line!

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 18:30

@Tealightsandd

It's been absolutely shit from a customer and client perspective.

You're right too OP that it's bad for the economy - and the environment, because public transport companies can't afford to run without ticket revenue.

I don't understand why this is supposedly bad for the environment. Many people drove themselves to the office every day, and are no longer doing that. That means a lot less pollution. Public transit generally means less pollution per person than driving in a car, but it's still not zero. If so few people take it that it runs less often, fewer buses running still means less pollution than before. If more people are having coffee and lunch at home rather than going to a coffee shop in the morning and having a meal delivered to the office at lunch, that means much less disposable packaging is ending up in landfills.

I don't really see an environmental downside here. If at some point in the future, more people end up driving themselves places because public transit is no longer available, that increased demand for public transit would justify an expansion of routes. But I think we should assume that public transit demand and availability will eventually reach the same equilibrium they were at pre-covid, so there's not going to be a net increase in miles driven per person.

Tealightsandd · 16/09/2021 18:28

So improve the public transport? Or, even better, make it free??

Funded by what? Tax increases?

NCBlossom · 16/09/2021 18:28

It hasn’t been bad for the economy or the environment. It’s been overall good (but of course, some gain, some lose)

This is from a report, it says

  • worker productivity increased - and an analysis showed ‘Higher meeting attendance rates, more attentive managers, simplified communication, and more breaks’
  • it redistributed opportunities - so that areas with not much work had a fairer chance of work - not all concentrated in the South East / London.
  • more likely to hire independent talent and more diverse workforce
  • time and money saved on commutes/expensive areas is money that is freed back into the economy boosting economic growth
  • pandemic remote work is not the same as remote work - the pandemic saw families having to juggle families, set up ad hoc office spaces - whereas remote work can be hub office/hybrid based, local areas will have ‘hubs’ for work and social needs are more addressed.

Above seems very positive!

Tealightsandd · 16/09/2021 18:27

@Pokhora

I agree OP. It is a nightmare getting hold of anyone at our council at the moment. They are all supposedly working from home but never answer their mobiles. My DH now only showers on the days he has to go into the office, he just can't be bothered when he is at home all day.
Same for my council, and many other places too.

Customer service has gone down the toilet.

As for people dismissing the plight of the low waged coffee shop workers. You may not care about the less privileged - people who aren't fortunate enough to have a comfortable WFH job and a spacious home environment suitable for working from, but huge numbers of lower paid workers are facing loss of livelihood.

Office based industries bring in billions to the economy. I guess you might prefer large tax increases instead? I hope your wallet is big because the 1% NI rise is nothing compared to the tax rises required to compensate. (The alternative is complete destruction of public services - nurseries, social care, park and playground maintenance, street lighting, mental health, etc).

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 16/09/2021 18:26

It's great for our work-life balance. The relationship is thriving.
We have some interesting lunch time fun too.👌
She commutes once a week 4 bloody hrs it takes.