Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
BreadPita · 17/09/2021 10:31

@Rozziie
If businesses cannot weather the storm, yes, they will fail. The failure will be a response to the economic reality that people do not currently want what they are providing, so those services should not be provided.

The money goes elsewhere in the economy and when demand returns other companies offering those old services/products will spring back up. They might even do a better job than the companies they replaced.

Again, this is literally how our economy is supposed to work.

In practice, I'm a member of two gyms. One a large commercial chain and the other an independent provider of training for a niche set of sports. Both closed down during lockdown and both are back to running (mostly) as normal.

The demand for the services did not disappear so the companies are still extant, despite the turbulence (like most businesses).

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 10:20

@BreadPita it looks like short term thinking to me. People not really wanting to go on holiday right now because it's a hassle, but assuming their cheap Ryanair flights will still be there waiting for them in 2022 or 2023. People cancelling their gym membership but assuming their tailored classes will still be there in a year or two.

A lot of people can't seem to see beyond their immediate situation and think about the longer term impacts of their decisions. People thought I was silly for paying for online gym classes and bakery deliveries during lockdowns, but if we don't support businesses, they WILL disappear. Quite a few nice places in my area have already shut up shop, and people are moaning and unhappy, but where were they during lockdowns when those places were struggling?

Likewise the people boasting about how virtuous they are for not flying - they will get a nasty shock when they want to visit a relative or go on holiday to relax next year and that £40 flight is now £500 because there's no competition on the route. It would be one thing if all these people were genuinely doing it out of concern for the environment but I don't think most of them are.

BreadPita · 17/09/2021 10:03

@Rozziie

That is literally the economy functioning as intended. If people do not want to make use of resources in the way that they are currently used, those resources SHOULD be directed to another purpose that people, as a whole, find useful.
In reality, the airline industry is not going to disappear. People are flying less at the moment for a very obvious reason. Working from home may even be good for the airline industry as some of the money previously spent at Pret and it's ilk or commuting will be available for leisure activities such as holidays. Commuting and lunch was costing me close to an extra £10 per day.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 09:44

@WolfKnuckle

Cheap flights are terrible for environment. They go hand in hand with high volume as a business model.

I'm sure they will return but I'm not a supporter.

I'm not so sure they will. One of the routes I used to visit family has already been permanently discontinued.

The thing is, people will still need to fly for whatever reason. And if they can't go directly, they'll end up taking two or three different flights to get where they need to go. How is that better?

WolfKnuckle · 17/09/2021 09:33

Cheap flights are terrible for environment. They go hand in hand with high volume as a business model.

I'm sure they will return but I'm not a supporter.

WolfKnuckle · 17/09/2021 09:31

Join the local gym

WolfKnuckle · 17/09/2021 09:29

Demand for city centre sandwiches and coffee isn't exactly the backbone for economic growth. That would be shifted into other WFH pattern demands and maybe even increase economic growth overall: cloud and tech solutions, local coffee and sandwiches, home comforts, fixtures, food deliveries and online retail etc.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 09:25

@Hekatestorch

No, dear, I'm making the point that a lot of people are going to be very upset that they can no longer go on holiday abroad or see loved ones abroad once the dust settles. The routes won't be there. The affordable. flights won't be there.

Well, dear, you do think that telling people to book flights, to keep your flights cheaper 'isn't a bad idea'.

So yes, you would like the rest if use to pay for flights to keep yourself cheaper. Beyond entitled, to think telling people they must book flights so yours are cheaper, is a good idea.

Why do so many people have so much trouble comprehending that not everyone is as selfish as them? I'm not talking about 'my' flights. I'm talking about the industry in general. A lot of people just aren't seeing that if they don't make use of things, they won't be there anymore. Applies to airlines, restaurants, gyms, pretty much everything. I can't wait for the whingeing and moaning in a year or two when people get bored of being at home all the time and realise all the things they took for granted are gone because they didn't support them.

It really is shocking how many people seem utterly incapable of thinking of anyone except themselves. Complete self absorption all over this thread. "WFH suits me and my family so screw everyone else."

eleanoreleanoreleanor · 17/09/2021 07:52

@MauvePinkRose

Did you get an email from the DVLA at the time you applied?
We've moved twice this year and the first time DH and I both applied for new licence, his arrived within a couple of days and mine never did, I realised I didn't get an email after applying so just applied again and got an email straight away, the licence a few days later. I must have messed up the first application somehow or maybe a glitch meant it didn't go through but I honestly thought I'd applied perfectly.
Second (and third time after the second move) I got an instant email confirmation and the licenses arrived within a week.

Bakingtraypan · 17/09/2021 06:50

@PurpleOkapi A former employer did this all the time pre-covid. If you're trying to use it to socialize, the dynamics are terrible. But if you stick to functional meetings where everyone knows what's on the agenda and what they're expected to contribute, and only discusses relevant work matters, it seems to works fine.
We are using it with clients at client sites we are attending, some clients dial in, we have had our team dial in too. We have used it with our in house teams too - the technology fails, the dynamics are awful - regardless of agenda, we are trying to solve complex problems and so relationships and communications matter, interactions matter, making them more difficult is not better - it is sub-optimal in our experience.

QOD · 17/09/2021 06:21

My company sold our office block ( 1000 employees) and now we are wfh
So bored uninspired and lonely
There will eventually be a once a fortnight/month day in another office we had (that staffed a completely separate part of the company) for team building and face to face coaching etc
But only with our own team
So all this inter office relationships, work babies, friendships made by sitting back to back with someone from a different department (I’m 52 and met one of my best friends at 18 when we started at a job same day back to back) - they’re all gone
My other friends son has just got a first class computing degree but also had a breakdown after one week at his first job and became suicidal at the thought of his life, stuck alone in his room for the next 40 odd years. Now working on a golf course.
Yes it’s great for those with commutes. Yes I can put the washing on but I work in sales where I have to work eg 9:45 to 5:15 one day and 8:30 to 1:30 another. Not a minute of flexibility and I have to logged in and actively active 80% of my shift including showing periods of inactivity of no more than 3 minutes or I’m pulled up on it
We’ve had 6 out and 6 in to our department over the pandemic as people can’t hack the absolute boredom and loneliness- our department turnover was static before
The local town is failing even more, I’m fat, miserable and soooo bored

SusieSusieSoo · 17/09/2021 06:11

As a working parent wfh has been an utter godsend. I rarely bought a coffee or even left my desk when I worked in town. I ran round like a mad thing to get me to work & Ds to school. Now we can chat, spend more time together and oh, blast, still not practised the blooming spellings for Friday spelling test - but we'll do it this morning before school!

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 06:04

@Bakingtraypan

Anyone tried to run a hybrid meeting yet - with some people wfh and some in a conference room together. We haven’t managed to make that combination a success yet - very hard to connect remotely on a screen to a group of people talking in a room , the dynamics are awful.
A former employer did this all the time pre-covid. If you're trying to use it to socialize, the dynamics are terrible. But if you stick to functional meetings where everyone knows what's on the agenda and what they're expected to contribute, and only discusses relevant work matters, it seems to works fine.
turtleshells · 17/09/2021 06:04

In our local town the trade has actually gone up. I now have to queue at our local grocers and actually see people my age instead of only elderly people.

I go for a walk for a coffee almost daily at our local cafe and meet up more for lunch now. So I'm my case local trade has been better as a result and the area is just nicer to be in because there's more younger middle class people roaming around.
My dc gets to go to more activities because I'm around more and she only stayed in after school anyway so that's still running without her. Also dh actually sees dd in the week now and it's made a massive difference to their relationship, before wfh he never took her school. Literally never due to his long commute. Now it's a few times a week.

The one thing that we haven't used for over a year though and used to use every day is the train. But then we also don't drive to the station anymore so there's that pollution gone from the local area. I don't miss London whatsoever and tbh me and dh felt exploited in our working hours and lives. Both of us feel much better without the long hours and extra stresses involved in going in. Dh work is looking into wfh 100% and we would be grateful if this happened. London's will undoubtedly go on, our village however would miss people like us.

Obviously I understand some people don't like wfh and am not talking on their behalf but for us it's been an absolute blessing in disguise.

EccentricaGalumbits · 17/09/2021 06:03

@Bakingtraypan

Anyone tried to run a hybrid meeting yet - with some people wfh and some in a conference room together. We haven’t managed to make that combination a success yet - very hard to connect remotely on a screen to a group of people talking in a room , the dynamics are awful.
We've been doing that for years with national meetings - multiple groups in meeting rooms and individuals joining from their desks. We use old fashioned videoconferencing technology that was around before the pandemic and adoption of Zoom and the like.

The meeting rooms have a big TV with camera and there's a mike on the table. Everyone in the room faces the TV, not each other.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 06:01

@Bagamoyo1

All the people I know who enjoy WFH say things like “it’s great - I can hang out the washing, go for a walk, pop to the shops, watch TV, prepare dinner” and so on. That’s what I always remember when I’m on endless hold to some company who says they’re experiencing a high volume of calls lately and staff may take longer to answer!
If you are wfh in a call centre, you can't really leave your desk all the time. Its heavily monitored, just like it was when they were in the office. Long absences would be picked up very quickly.

People working flexibly or being missing from their desk, won't be the reason you are waiting.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 05:59

@Bakingtraypan

Anyone tried to run a hybrid meeting yet - with some people wfh and some in a conference room together. We haven’t managed to make that combination a success yet - very hard to connect remotely on a screen to a group of people talking in a room , the dynamics are awful.
We use conference or teams video in on or off. Sometimes we might have a few people in one room for teams if they are all in office and can't find a quiet room on there own.

We ditched conference calls quite early on.

That seems to work.

Rhubarbcrumblerules · 17/09/2021 05:36

Re driving licence, if you applied online it is still a fast process in under a week, if you have to submit a paper application and/or have to supply a photo as they can't use a previous photo or passport photo, then the current delays ( due to covid and strike action) is 10-12 weeks.
I called dvla on 0300 790 6801, tried about 5 times before I got through, on hold waiting for an agent for 20 mins. Nice lady checked the progress of my application, said it would be about 2 more weeks and it arrived when she said. Hope that helps

Bakingtraypan · 17/09/2021 05:03

Anyone tried to run a hybrid meeting yet - with some people wfh and some in a conference room together. We haven’t managed to make that combination a success yet - very hard to connect remotely on a screen to a group of people talking in a room , the dynamics are awful.

Jobseeker19 · 17/09/2021 04:14

Where i am the trains and buses are busier than ever

candlelightsatdawn · 17/09/2021 04:13

@Bakingtraypan the problem is with this argument is a) bad managers really struggle to manage effectively in pandemic, one of the issues are the managers not holding people accountable not WFH. B) It's easier to manage effectively in pandemic if you knew how to manage before. To many lazy managers who don't know their heads from their tails and typically a company who hires managers like this have always had long wait times to contact, pre pandemic.

Also most businesses have seen a steady increase in contact during the day when typically people would be quieter. Contact patterns have changed and planning for this has made resourcing issues a nightmare as it's like trying to predict the weather based on clouds in the sky. The patterns of contact used to be fairly predictable they are not at the moment. This will settle.

Bakingtraypan · 17/09/2021 04:03

Would love to support the idea of wfh but like the OP I find the quality of customer service has bucketed - I’m mainly talking about business to business - finance dept, don’t answer emails, pay bills, issue Purchase Orders - when previously we did have a problem - we deal with more than one business and across the board it has all become more difficult. I sit on the phone for an hour to our back, half an hour to the insurance company - they all blame COVID and WFH and I don’t understand how everyone is supposedly much productive when WFH and yet no one can answer a phone or an email or fix a query in a reasonable period of time any longer - it’s bloody annoying,

candlelightsatdawn · 17/09/2021 03:14

@CharityDingle

I have commented upthread, but just to add, I wrested the chance to wfh one day a week from an absolute bitch of a micro managing boss. There was no reason not to have it in place. We had all the necessary technology and systems. She just wanted to be a bitch.

I'm guessing that when wfh became the norm in 2020, it killed her. Not literally more's the pity

People who can't manage effectively are always 9/10 micro managers and their worst nightmare is wfh as they see it as a loss of control. Madly enough if they weren't such lazy managers they can effectively manage much better when WFH actually and have more control than ever before and it's easier to monitor someone's work remotely rather than watching over their shoulder hovering (like that ever gives a true indication of work output)

People leave managers, not jobs on the whole. I for one am sorry about your manager.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 01:21

@TwoShoess

I don’t think managers have time or capacity to enforce anything further because I imagine they’re very busy with their existing workload and responsibilities.
MN doesn't allow multiquotes, so you can't quote me because I quoted you. Grin You can use @ in front of someone's name to notify them that you're replying to them.

Pre-covid, managers always seemed to be able to enforce these things just fine when they so chose, though of course some were stricter than others, and favoritism was often an issue. But generally, anyone who said "Sorry, I can't do a 3:00 meeting because I'm picking my children up from school" would be in a fair amount of trouble if this was neither an emergency nor approved in advance. Everyone knew that, which is why it was rarely an issue. All they'd have to do is announce that they would be enforcing this rule starting two weeks from now, then throw the book at the first 1-2 people who broke it. They must have disciplined people occasionally pre-covid, or everyone would have been doing it all the time, so this just doesn't sound like that much extra work to me.

Susannahmoody · 17/09/2021 01:11

WFH is a gift for controlling spouses.

^

Let's face it, if you have a controlling spouse, they'll find any way to control. Wfh irregardless. That's what control is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread