Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 14:49

Look at the 20 something poster a couple of posts up. It's not healthy. Already used to a more insular life - spent on social media as opposed to irreplaceable real life human interaction. She refers to looking to meet people her own age and at the same life stage. That's all she expects. She's missing out on being exposed to the rich diverse mix of people in an office - old and young, varied backgrounds, job roles, and life experiences. Nothing virtual can fully compensate for the subtle unconscious networking, social interaction, and professional (and personal) development of the physical office world.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 14:39
  • slowest
Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 14:38

The key to looking to when to emulate other countries is to follow the good (eg. real life in person human interaction + interests of national economy - which impacts on us all, except the very richest), but not the bad (eg. no maternity leave, etc).

We've been repeatedly told that the national economy is vital enough that we must accept 100-200 a day being killed and many more left disabled or long term ill. It's why we didn't get on top off Covid early on (ironically leaving us with both a very high death rate and the showest recovering economy in the developed world). That same national economy - that's important enough for so many to die for - relies heavily on the office based industries.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 14:36

@Hekatestorch

Well then I'm not talking about you, am I? I'm talking about the people who go to Tenerife every year for cheap and are expecting to resume that when they feel like it again, or who go to the continent on the Eurostar and expect to keep doing it after the pandemic for the same low prices they did before. If Eurostar stops running because nobody is using it, that's most likely it. We then have no train service to the continent and are even more cut off than before. Perhaps you would enjoy living in Little England but I certainly wouldn't.

Oh so if people flew alot before, they have to resume ASAP, to benefit you?

What's the cut off, if they flew once a year or more? Some people will have flown then and won't fly again. Or reduce the number of flights they want to take

Again, no obligation for them to resume old habits because that habit directly benefitted you

Who says any of these people expect it to be the same again. Most people know how it works and know if there isn't the demand services will disappear or become more expensive. Still doesn't obligate them to do anything, now.

And do fuck off with your little England comment. I am not even from England. I just know there are more ways of leaving the country than flying, so often don't.

You are complaining people are rhinking about themselves whilst onlying thinking about yourself and trying to make out taht if people did something before the pandemic, they must do it after

Totally unrealistic.

FFS, for the THIRD time now, it's not about ME! Unlike most of the people on this thread who are utterly selfish, I seem to possess a capacity which is very rare in today's Britain - the ability to see the world outside of my own tiny life.

I don't often fly either, because I hate it. I am one of the minority of people lucky enough to be 20 minutes away from the Eurostar terminal. But unlike you, I'm not an 'I'm Alright Jack' type. I am concerned about the whole travel industry and the impact of it folding. I'm concerned about young people finding it really hard to see the world outside the UK. I'm concerned about the impact on trade. There are plenty of reasons to be concerned about the travel industry (not just airlines) collapsing that don't involve going off on a jolly to the Canaries.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 14:30

@Tealightsandd

The world's changed.

America, including New York City, is back to work. In offices.

The USA has recognised the value in it. For the many people lacking the privilege of comfortable home working environment (eg the young and the poor), and also (perhaps more importantly for the politicians and big businesses) for the national economy.

And what? I wouldn't want to work in the US for a US company. Why would we look to the US for an improvement in the workplace?

The US also don't have any decent mat leave, shall we follow them in that too or are we just picking and choosing?

As for young people any manager really does need to ensure the younger people are getting experience and opportunities to learn. Many companies have had international teams for years and young people have been able to learn and get opportunities.

If young people on a company are being ignored, it's because it's a shit company.

PattyPan · 17/09/2021 14:30

@Tealightsandd

WFH would've been disastrous for me in my 20s. I'd have been so isolated, miserable, depressed. Office life was so much more than work. Social interaction, mentoring - learning in person is irreplaceable. So many natural unconscious moments of networking. And the social life side. The bonding with your team. Lunches and nights out with new friends from work. It's such a shame to deprive the young of that valuable life experience and opportunity.
I’m in my 20s and wfh is way better for me. Young people are used to socialising online, we grew up on MSN and social media so are perfectly capable of talking to colleagues on Teams. I’ve literally never been on a night out with coworkers anywhere I’ve worked in person. That only happens if your team are similar ages I think which is quite rare - the next youngest person in my team is 10 years older than me with a toddler and there are others old enough to be my parents. I’ve just had a promotion and I’m having mentoring via video so we aren’t being deprived of opportunities - if people are missing out on stuff it’s because their employer (or them) are being crap, not due to being at home.
Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 14:27

Well then I'm not talking about you, am I? I'm talking about the people who go to Tenerife every year for cheap and are expecting to resume that when they feel like it again, or who go to the continent on the Eurostar and expect to keep doing it after the pandemic for the same low prices they did before. If Eurostar stops running because nobody is using it, that's most likely it. We then have no train service to the continent and are even more cut off than before. Perhaps you would enjoy living in Little England but I certainly wouldn't.

Oh so if people flew alot before, they have to resume ASAP, to benefit you?

What's the cut off, if they flew once a year or more? Some people will have flown then and won't fly again. Or reduce the number of flights they want to take

Again, no obligation for them to resume old habits because that habit directly benefitted you

Who says any of these people expect it to be the same again. Most people know how it works and know if there isn't the demand services will disappear or become more expensive. Still doesn't obligate them to do anything, now.

And do fuck off with your little England comment. I am not even from England. I just know there are more ways of leaving the country than flying, so often don't.

You are complaining people are rhinking about themselves whilst onlying thinking about yourself and trying to make out taht if people did something before the pandemic, they must do it after

Totally unrealistic.

user1497207191 · 17/09/2021 14:26

@RosyPoesy

The young have already missed out on so much Still, I fail to see why I should inconvenience myself by dragging my butt into the office every day, at the expense of my own children and my mental health, just so 20-something strangers who I don’t give a shit about can learn from me.
Yet, I suspect you want other "strangers" to train and mentor your children when they join the workplace!
user1497207191 · 17/09/2021 14:25

@RosyPoesy

The young have already missed out on so much Still, I fail to see why I should inconvenience myself by dragging my butt into the office every day, at the expense of my own children and my mental health, just so 20-something strangers who I don’t give a shit about can learn from me.
Maybe because you may not have been in the favourable position you're in today if the older/experienced staff didn't give you training, mentoring, etc., when you first joined the workplace!
Rozziie · 17/09/2021 14:19

@LadyWithLapdog

Long boozy lunches have been a thing of the past for years and there’s nothing stopping young people from going out in the evening.
After-work drinks definitely haven't, though. They were a lifesaver for me when I moved to London a few years ago. Great not just for bonding with your colleagues but also making proper friends.

Who are people supposed to go out with if they don't know anyone? Yes, there are Meetup groups etc. but it takes a lot of nerve to attend one of those and it's a huge ask for someone with anxiety to meet up with a bunch of total strangers off an app. It also means you need to have the motivation to do it - if someone is already lethargic and depressed, it's not likely they'll be up for it, whereas being forced to get out of the house and go to work makes it an obligation.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 14:16

@RosyPoesy

The young have already missed out on so much Still, I fail to see why I should inconvenience myself by dragging my butt into the office every day, at the expense of my own children and my mental health, just so 20-something strangers who I don’t give a shit about can learn from me.
Ever heard of the concept of 'giving back'? I'm sure people were there to help and mentor you in your younger years, and now it's your turn to return the favour and do your bit, you don't want to. Ever considered that the '20-something strangers you don't give a shit about' are someone else's children?

This attitude is what I detest most about Britain. People just out for themselves, thinking of themselves, rinsing society for what they can get out of it and giving nothing back.

LadyWithLapdog · 17/09/2021 14:02

Long boozy lunches have been a thing of the past for years and there’s nothing stopping young people from going out in the evening.

RosyPoesy · 17/09/2021 13:55

The young have already missed out on so much
Still, I fail to see why I should inconvenience myself by dragging my butt into the office every day, at the expense of my own children and my mental health, just so 20-something strangers who I don’t give a shit about can learn from me.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 13:23

As people say wrt Covid. The young have already missed out on so much.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 13:22

WFH would've been disastrous for me in my 20s. I'd have been so isolated, miserable, depressed. Office life was so much more than work. Social interaction, mentoring - learning in person is irreplaceable. So many natural unconscious moments of networking. And the social life side. The bonding with your team. Lunches and nights out with new friends from work. It's such a shame to deprive the young of that valuable life experience and opportunity.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 13:19

[quote Tealightsandd]@rozziie A lot (obviously not all) the people who want full-time permanent WFH are affluent. It's not people living in tiny bedsits, studios, HMOs, or houseshares. Nor even those living in cramped smaller houses.

WFH is good for affluent middle class, middle aged, with a settled family life. They can afford more expensive holidays - and cars, to get around when they want to (because public transport will be further decimated by WFH). It's very much a case of I'm Alright Jack.[/quote]
Absolutely @Tealightsandd. It's utter selfishness and self absorption. People choosing to isolate themselves and not give back to society because it's not convenient. Most of them wouldn't be where they are now if they hadn't learned from others at work or had the opportunity to meet their partners at uni/work or other 'real life' places young people now have a hard time frequenting.

They don't need to worry about the train into town being reduced to once an hour because nobody is using it. They can just jump in the 4x4. They don't need to suffer the mental health aspects of living in a cramped space. They all have big houses with gardens. The same people who sailed through the pandemic having a jolly old time baking, having BBQs in the garden and ordering in nice takeaways are the same people who will benefit most from WFH while everyone else struggles.

Utterly selfish.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 13:14

@Fordian

Lots of interesting replies.

Hybrid must surely be the way to go?

Full WFH isn't great for young people. My DS spent 13 months wfh as his year in industry from uni. He never met a single fellow worker in person in that time; he learned nothing of 'office culture', got no informal mentoring, bounced not a single idea around among work mates around 'the water cooler'. He'd climb out of bed, head to the desk in his room, do a day's work, then repeat. It was an isolating experience, and, how do quieter, shyer kids ever meet new friends or partners?

DH wfh in the spare room. He's quite liked wfh, though his office is an easy 10 min commute away, but I think he's become quite insular. Even he's conceded the day or so a week he's had to go I have been good, catching up with some of his team.

I'm front-line HCP so I've headed into work 4 days a week throughout but, personally, I dislike never being alone at home. There's always someone here (a thing DH likes).

Fortunately DS2 went back to uni last week and DS1 is going later today. They need to get on with their lives, but I suspect both will be studying from home for the most part.

And I do agree that this will widen 'the divide' between younger and older people in that when we were young, we were taught, guided, mentored, learned from the example of the older people in 'the office'. Now we are 'the older people', we, by choosing to stay home, aren't reciprocating.

This is all absolutely valid. So many young people are now going to be deprived of important work and life experience and developing social skills as they move into adulthood. It was already bad enough, with many young people spending so much time on social media, and now we're taking away one of the few things that forced people to get out and about and talk to others in 'real life'. It's now possible to literally never leave your house. How on earth is that healthy or a good development?

Part of life is mixing with people from different backgrounds and discovering new things. Not surprising your son has become insular - I'm sure everyone has. Your world is now what you choose to curate it as. If you WFH in the spare room and only like watching anime, that's now your world. People's worlds have become absolutely tiny.

It's just insane how all the I'm Alright Jacks who already have their solid relationships, solid friendships and solid careers want to snatch it all away from everyone else just so their life is a bit more convenient.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 13:14

@rozziie A lot (obviously not all) the people who want full-time permanent WFH are affluent. It's not people living in tiny bedsits, studios, HMOs, or houseshares. Nor even those living in cramped smaller houses.

WFH is good for affluent middle class, middle aged, with a settled family life. They can afford more expensive holidays - and cars, to get around when they want to (because public transport will be further decimated by WFH). It's very much a case of I'm Alright Jack.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 13:08

The world's changed.

America, including New York City, is back to work. In offices.

The USA has recognised the value in it. For the many people lacking the privilege of comfortable home working environment (eg the young and the poor), and also (perhaps more importantly for the politicians and big businesses) for the national economy.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 13:08

@Hekatestorch

Why do so many people have so much trouble comprehending that not everyone is as selfish as them? I'm not talking about 'my' flights. I'm talking about the industry in general. A lot of people just aren't seeing that if they don't make use of things, they won't be there anymore. Applies to airlines, restaurants, gyms, pretty much everything. I can't wait for the whingeing and moaning in a year or two when people get bored of being at home all the time and realise all the things they took for granted are gone because they didn't support them.

It really is shocking how many people seem utterly incapable of thinking of anyone except themselves. Complete self absorption all over this thread. "WFH suits me and my family so screw everyone else."

This is such a hypocritical attitude.

I didn't fly much pre pandemic. Why should I have to start flying because it benefits you?

But you want people to willing give something up that benefits them?

So give up stuff that benefits them and starting doing things that only benefits others?

Why don't you just give up flying to see family? That would benefit the planet and everyone else? I would imagine because, it would be ridiculous to expect you to something taht into benefits other people and never yourself.

The world's changed. Big events change it. A pandemic is a big event. Things never go back to exactly how they were before.

I have had my own business. Business need to be able to adapt to the current situation. If they can't, they fail. But when things change new businesses are created to fit the change.

I do think hybrid is the best solution. But I can't agree anyone should be obliged to make their own life worse.

Well then I'm not talking about you, am I? I'm talking about the people who go to Tenerife every year for cheap and are expecting to resume that when they feel like it again, or who go to the continent on the Eurostar and expect to keep doing it after the pandemic for the same low prices they did before. If Eurostar stops running because nobody is using it, that's most likely it. We then have no train service to the continent and are even more cut off than before. Perhaps you would enjoy living in Little England but I certainly wouldn't.
TokyoSushi · 17/09/2021 12:36

I'm permanent WFH now as we've closed our office (very small company) sometimes I like it more than others. It is quite isolating but I enjoy no commute, putting a wash on instead of having to do it in the evening etc.

I see Mark Drakeford has just gone back to a WFH if possible policy for Wales so I wonder if we will be too far behind?

frazzledasarock · 17/09/2021 12:33

It’s free market economics. People pick and choose what thrust wish to spend their money on.

If demand increases for something loads of companies/entrepreneurs jump in to supply it and take peoples money.

Which is exactly what will happen here with current supply and demand chains.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 12:14

Why do so many people have so much trouble comprehending that not everyone is as selfish as them? I'm not talking about 'my' flights. I'm talking about the industry in general. A lot of people just aren't seeing that if they don't make use of things, they won't be there anymore. Applies to airlines, restaurants, gyms, pretty much everything. I can't wait for the whingeing and moaning in a year or two when people get bored of being at home all the time and realise all the things they took for granted are gone because they didn't support them.

It really is shocking how many people seem utterly incapable of thinking of anyone except themselves. Complete self absorption all over this thread. "WFH suits me and my family so screw everyone else."

This is such a hypocritical attitude.

I didn't fly much pre pandemic. Why should I have to start flying because it benefits you?

But you want people to willing give something up that benefits them?

So give up stuff that benefits them and starting doing things that only benefits others?

Why don't you just give up flying to see family? That would benefit the planet and everyone else? I would imagine because, it would be ridiculous to expect you to something taht into benefits other people and never yourself.

The world's changed. Big events change it. A pandemic is a big event. Things never go back to exactly how they were before.

I have had my own business. Business need to be able to adapt to the current situation. If they can't, they fail. But when things change new businesses are created to fit the change.

I do think hybrid is the best solution. But I can't agree anyone should be obliged to make their own life worse.

Fordian · 17/09/2021 11:04

Lots of interesting replies.

Hybrid must surely be the way to go?

Full WFH isn't great for young people. My DS spent 13 months wfh as his year in industry from uni. He never met a single fellow worker in person in that time; he learned nothing of 'office culture', got no informal mentoring, bounced not a single idea around among work mates around 'the water cooler'. He'd climb out of bed, head to the desk in his room, do a day's work, then repeat. It was an isolating experience, and, how do quieter, shyer kids ever meet new friends or partners?

DH wfh in the spare room. He's quite liked wfh, though his office is an easy 10 min commute away, but I think he's become quite insular. Even he's conceded the day or so a week he's had to go I have been good, catching up with some of his team.

I'm front-line HCP so I've headed into work 4 days a week throughout but, personally, I dislike never being alone at home. There's always someone here (a thing DH likes).

Fortunately DS2 went back to uni last week and DS1 is going later today. They need to get on with their lives, but I suspect both will be studying from home for the most part.

And I do agree that this will widen 'the divide' between younger and older people in that when we were young, we were taught, guided, mentored, learned from the example of the older people in 'the office'. Now we are 'the older people', we, by choosing to stay home, aren't reciprocating.

Thesandmanishere · 17/09/2021 10:57

Not being funny but our insanely consumerist way of life (including international air travel at the drop of a hat) needs to change drastically anyway. I really don't think most people are aware of how immediate the threat of climate change is. I don't mean it gets a bit warmer or we have more storms. I mean extreme, fatal, life and humanity changing weather events by 2040 (and that's being optimistic).

I won't be going back to my pre covid way of life. Others I daresay will. Haven't got any control over that, only what I do. It does terrify me though.