Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
gibletjane · 17/09/2021 16:31

I am concerned about the whole travel industry and the impact of it folding. I'm concerned about young people finding it really hard to see the world outside the UK. I'm concerned about the impact on trade. There are plenty of reasons to be concerned about the travel industry (not just airlines) collapsing that don't involve going off on a jolly to the Canaries.

I think you can wfh & still feel the same though?

gibletjane · 17/09/2021 16:27

Who knew there could so much animosity regarding other people's working location preference.

bizarre!

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 16:25

Not everyone needs or wants to be BFFs with their colleagues. I like most of mine well enough, but spending 8-12 hours per day with them was more than enough time together. I never did after-work drinks anyway, because I'd rather just go home and do something of my choosing with people of my choosing. If someone calls or emails me about a problem they're having with an assignment, or that's otherwise related to my area of responsibility, I'll help them. If someone calls or emails me about an interpersonal problem, I'll do my best to help them if I have time, but it's not actually my job to do this. My employer has an HR department, and I'm not in it. If WFH makes those boundaries starker in most people's minds, I don't think that's such a bad thing.

PattyPan · 17/09/2021 16:13

Great, not threat!

PattyPan · 17/09/2021 16:12

@Rozziie @Tealightsandd

I’m glad you both think my life is so sad 🤣 my life is much bigger wfh because I have much more time to spend with my friends, family and DP instead of wasting it commuting and I can afford more hobbies and experiences now I have that £5k a year back in my pocket. I’ve spent 5 years working in offices in person and can’t say I gained anything from that that I couldn’t have from home. It’s because my team is a mixture of ages that we rarely socialise outside work (we get on threat, but people want to get home to their kids) but we chat all day on Teams and have frequent calls so it’s not like we don’t interact anymore now we’re at home.
My reference to MSN and social media from a young age clearly went over your heads - we used to come home from school and carry on chatting to our friends online, that’s not sad and insular 🤣

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 16:12

It really is shocking how many people seem utterly incapable of thinking of anyone except themselves. Complete self absorption all over this thread. "WFH suits me and my family so screw everyone else."

I haven't seen anyone suggest that anyone who'd rather work from an office should be forced to WFH because their doing so is somehow better for others. I've seen a whole lot of the opposite, though, where people suggest that I and others who prefer WFH should be forced to work from an office because me doing is somehow better for others.

If you're married or have children, it's your moral responsibility to prioritise your spouse/children over others. I'm not about to tell my husband that he has to live somewhere he hates so that we can prop up the local coffee shop market. Bonus points because neither of us drinks coffee anyway.

Icenii · 17/09/2021 16:06

Who knew there could so much animosity regarding other people's working location preference.

I'm fairly certain you could think up equal amounts of for and againsts for WFH, hybrid and office. And I'm fairly certain solutions could be identified for many againsts.

I think it's wrong to say someone is selfish because their preference is different to how you feel something should operate. It's better to identify the areas of concern and look for solutions. Then, you may have an even better way of doing things.

BreadPita · 17/09/2021 16:04

I don't have any kids and I might never have any. I could I'm Alright Jack it like most of the people on this thread. Why should I worry about young people when I'm alright? Why would I worry about the travel industry when I don't work in it? Why would I worry about someone in Glasgow becoming unable to visit their elderly parents in France when I can walk to St Pancras and hop on the train? Why would I worry about people in Cornwall being priced out when I live in London?

Since my first graduate role (around 7 or 8 years ago), online training has been the norm.
Sometimes this takes place in a classroom, sometimes this is over a web conference. It honestly did not make a jot of difference to me whether it was in person or not.
I've always had some sort of internal IM system and most people of my age used it preferentially. I find it odd that people would rather be interrupted in the middle of their flow of work by someone coming over to their desk.
It is not as big of an adjustment as you seem to think it is.
Some people prefer office working and offices will persist because of them. The only difference is that people who do not and never have liked working in the office have other options now.
I spent most of the last decade in a state of mild depression and didn't really realise until the WFH mandate.
I had actually been pushing for more work from home days for a few months prior to the lockdowns, but my line manager eventually out a stop to it because of "how it looked" to who he reported to. Genuinely nothing to do with my efficiency, it just wasn't the norm and I didn't have an excuse other than I don't like commuting or working in an open office environment.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 15:30

Ah so it's OK for London people to not think about their impact on wider society if it benefits only themselves?

Eh? You brought London up - attacking the London 'people', who have been done over for decades. Priced out and nobody gives a shit. Highest youth unemployment. No-one cares. Capital of homelessness. No jots given by most. Meanwhile London is that only place in the country to pay out more in tax than it gets back. The money certainly isn't going to the disadvantaged youth or the 165,000 London homeless.

You're not being coherent. You say you want WFH - but you then complain about one of the consequences. People who moved to London, pricing out locals, now moving back out. You can't have it both ways.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 15:25

[quote Hekatestorch]@Rozziie you are being selfish. You just think if you add 'but young people' (while disregarding a young person posting) and 'but cheap travel'

Again, you work remotely? Do you go buy a coffee everyday to benefit the staff?

Again, working remotely you are also part of the problem you are moaning about?

You completely ignored many things I said, because it doesn't suit you.

I have worked hybrid for years. No one has every expected me to not do out of some idea that my working life has to provide the maximum benefit to the rest of society. Rather than have a job that suits me and my family.

I take it you are ditching the remote job and also spending your spare time acting as a professional mentor?[/quote]
Yes, I work remotely because I have to right now.

Not sure what you're banging on about re being selfish when I've literally just explained how most of my concerns are things that don't personally affect me at all, but whatever makes you happy.

Yes, I do try to spend my money in small businesses. I buy coffee, I get deliveries from a family-run bakery and basically do my best to support things I think would leave a hole if they didn't exist anymore. It would save me money not to do this. It would be handier to just do everything using big chain stores. I choose to do what I can to support others.

I already mentor young people, and have done for the last few years, in my spare time, for free. Many of them have found the last year absolutely horrendous and are now aghast at the thought that this might be the 'new normal'.

I've also in recent weeks been helping out sorting donations for Afghan refugees and working (for free) with English schools and tutors to organise English classes.

Yeah, wild, isn't it? Imagine caring about other people! Imagine doing things for people you don't know! Imagine worrying about things that don't directly affect you! I'm sure your head is exploding at the very thought.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 15:23

Re the public health housing and homelessness emergency. Round my way, in an area with extremely high housing demand for those in desperate need, new homes are being built. Several new developments. Not one includes any social rented homes. Nor is the any of the so-called affordable housing to buy genuinely affordable for the average couple and particularly single person. It's a load of shoddily done overpriced new builds. That's the real problem with housing.

That inequality will only get worse with increased WFH. The huge numbers across the country living in overcrowded, often unsanitary, noisy, temporary accommodation and shitty private rented, and those who bought their home but are stuck in a too small for WFH household. They'll be fucked. Limited opportunities. They'll lose out to the people privileged enough to be able to afford a comfortable WFH environment.

Permanent full-time WFH will hit the poor and the young worst. Both on an individual level, and because of the wider impact on the national economy (that funds our valuable public services).

Fine, for the I'm Alright Jack's (until life happens and they find themselves or their families affected). Not so good for everyone else or for the country as a whole.

VeryLongBeeeeep · 17/09/2021 15:20

I agree there are negative aspects to wfh - I go for a walk every day and have still gained weight, it's difficult to replicate that commute rush and lack of nearby kitchen!

And conversely I've lost over a stone, because I now have time to fit in a run in the morning and still be logged onto work earlier than I used to, because I'm not commuting for over an hour each morning.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 15:19

@Tealightsandd

What about people on London wages moving out of London and taking up house in more affordable areas, so they can finally buy a home? Pushing up those house prices and often pricing locals out?

What's good for the goose. Where do you suggest London locals go, when priced out of (even renting) a home by people from across the UK moving to London and taking the jobs and homes? Anyway if people leave London, there's been talk for a while now that they'll lose their London weighting (rightly so).

WFH won't solve the public health housing and homelessness emergency. It might, as you say, spread the problem from the capital of homelessness to elsewhere - so making things worse, not better.

Lots more social housing is the answer. And, of course, separately, a more even spread of work opportunities across the UK (although youth unemployment in London is highest in the UK, so London certainly needs opportunity for the less privileged).

The desperately needed social housing could be part funded by a healthy national economy, boosted by office based industries...

Ah so it's OK for London people to not think about their impact on wider society if it benefits only themselves?

But no one else.

Also I know several companies who aren't removing London weighting. But it will be taken into consideration when pay rises are due.

But no immediate loss of wage.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 15:15

@Rozziie you are being selfish. You just think if you add 'but young people' (while disregarding a young person posting) and 'but cheap travel'

Again, you work remotely? Do you go buy a coffee everyday to benefit the staff?

Again, working remotely you are also part of the problem you are moaning about?

You completely ignored many things I said, because it doesn't suit you.

I have worked hybrid for years. No one has every expected me to not do out of some idea that my working life has to provide the maximum benefit to the rest of society. Rather than have a job that suits me and my family.

I take it you are ditching the remote job and also spending your spare time acting as a professional mentor?

gwenneh · 17/09/2021 15:15

The desperately needed social housing could be part funded by a healthy national economy, boosted by office based industries...

Right, because that happened in all the pre-covid years when everyone worked in offices.

Blessex · 17/09/2021 15:14

You are right. It’s awful. However going back in 2 days a week and actually think that 2-3 days in the office may be the happy balance. So maybe Covid has allowed that.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 15:11

@Rozziie

"No such thing as society".... Thatcherism at its most brutal finest is alive and well.

achainisonlyasstrong · 17/09/2021 15:08

Just because the 20 something above prefers Wfh to working in the office does not mean her world is tiny and sad and dull!!!! Being in the office can be sad and dull too depending on your office environment. I always preferred working from home to being in the office,, even when I was young 20 something. I think it just suits different people, that's all. People learn in different ways and enjoy different environments. I'm guessing hybrid working will work best for most people. There's no need for this for working from home people to be pitted against working in the office people.

Tealightsandd · 17/09/2021 15:08

What about people on London wages moving out of London and taking up house in more affordable areas, so they can finally buy a home? Pushing up those house prices and often pricing locals out?

What's good for the goose. Where do you suggest London locals go, when priced out of (even renting) a home by people from across the UK moving to London and taking the jobs and homes? Anyway if people leave London, there's been talk for a while now that they'll lose their London weighting (rightly so).

WFH won't solve the public health housing and homelessness emergency. It might, as you say, spread the problem from the capital of homelessness to elsewhere - so making things worse, not better.

Lots more social housing is the answer. And, of course, separately, a more even spread of work opportunities across the UK (although youth unemployment in London is highest in the UK, so London certainly needs opportunity for the less privileged).

The desperately needed social housing could be part funded by a healthy national economy, boosted by office based industries...

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 15:04

@Hekatestorch

FFS, for the THIRD time now, it's not about ME! Unlike most of the people on this thread who are utterly selfish, I seem to possess a capacity which is very rare in today's Britain - the ability to see the world outside of my own tiny life.

But it is about you. If may be about other people, bit it's something you were bothered about because it also effects you. You want the eurostar running when you want it and Cheap.

No actually, you don't. You are looking at what impacts you caring about that covering it with 'ots not about me it's about others in similar positions'

Don't you work remotely?

Do you know you can give back to younger people, not just in your own organisation? You don't need to be in the office. I really hope you spend alot of time outside your job, mentoring young people.

You don't need to travel if you don't want to. It's really patronising to think you must be right because you take the euro star.

You are acting like you are a rarity, you aren't.

Prices of things go up and down. Cheap air travel is relatively new and people managed to have good careers, different points of views and have varied experiences.

Cheap air travel is not a right. Its certainly not something other people have to do, so others can get it cheaper.

You are bothered about what impacts you. What about people who are bothered about their local coffee shops? Are you obliged to spend money in them? Because they benefit other people?

If hybrid or wfh or reducing travel makes people's lives better, it's ridiculous to say they shouldn't be allowed because others.

Less travel is good for everyone, fro. An environmental point of view.

I just beggars belief that you would expect someone to want to make their own life harder, so you (and others) can benefit.

What about people on London wages moving out of London and taking up house in more affordable areas, so they can finally buy a home? Pushing up those house prices and often pricing locals out? But while earning a bigger wage than that local person could get? I take it you think that's selfish too and can't believe people would contemplate it?

It really seems to be beyond you to imagine that other people do see the wider picture and consider things that don't necessarily benefit them directly.

I don't have any kids and I might never have any. I could I'm Alright Jack it like most of the people on this thread. Why should I worry about young people when I'm alright? Why would I worry about the travel industry when I don't work in it? Why would I worry about someone in Glasgow becoming unable to visit their elderly parents in France when I can walk to St Pancras and hop on the train? Why would I worry about people in Cornwall being priced out when I live in London?

It's called not being a selfish, self centred arse. Perhaps you should try it.

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 15:00

@Tealightsandd

Look at the 20 something poster a couple of posts up. It's not healthy. Already used to a more insular life - spent on social media as opposed to irreplaceable real life human interaction. She refers to looking to meet people her own age and at the same life stage. That's all she expects. She's missing out on being exposed to the rich diverse mix of people in an office - old and young, varied backgrounds, job roles, and life experiences. Nothing virtual can fully compensate for the subtle unconscious networking, social interaction, and professional (and personal) development of the physical office world.
Yes - it's very sad. She has no idea what she's missing out on. Her world is already tiny and sad and dull.

Having to do things that aren't always fun is part of life and part of social development. Learning to get on with people that aren't exactly like you, being exposed to different view points, etc. is an essential part of growing up. How can you possibly become a well-rounded person if all you do is talk to people your own age online?

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 14:59

@Tealightsandd

Look at the 20 something poster a couple of posts up. It's not healthy. Already used to a more insular life - spent on social media as opposed to irreplaceable real life human interaction. She refers to looking to meet people her own age and at the same life stage. That's all she expects. She's missing out on being exposed to the rich diverse mix of people in an office - old and young, varied backgrounds, job roles, and life experiences. Nothing virtual can fully compensate for the subtle unconscious networking, social interaction, and professional (and personal) development of the physical office world.
It amazing me how patronising you are.

Someone tells you they are happy and you still can't accept it?

You think you know better than that her about wether she should be happy with teh situation?

Or do you just feel you need to patronise someone who you were using as an excuse to wfh?

Do you wfh? Or are you back in the office?

Rozziie · 17/09/2021 14:58

@RosyPoesy

Ever considered that the '20-something strangers you don't give a shit about' are someone else's children? Not my children, not my problem 🤷‍♀️
Wow. It's quite horrifying to see how some people think. Not much of a surprise - the events of the past 18 months have shown me how incredibly selfish many people are - but seeing it in black and white...wow.

I'm sure you'll be on here whingeing in 15 years about what a hard time your children are having without a trace of irony as well.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 14:56

FFS, for the THIRD time now, it's not about ME! Unlike most of the people on this thread who are utterly selfish, I seem to possess a capacity which is very rare in today's Britain - the ability to see the world outside of my own tiny life.

But it is about you. If may be about other people, bit it's something you were bothered about because it also effects you. You want the eurostar running when you want it and Cheap.

No actually, you don't. You are looking at what impacts you caring about that covering it with 'ots not about me it's about others in similar positions'

Don't you work remotely?

Do you know you can give back to younger people, not just in your own organisation? You don't need to be in the office. I really hope you spend alot of time outside your job, mentoring young people.

You don't need to travel if you don't want to. It's really patronising to think you must be right because you take the euro star.

You are acting like you are a rarity, you aren't.

Prices of things go up and down. Cheap air travel is relatively new and people managed to have good careers, different points of views and have varied experiences.

Cheap air travel is not a right. Its certainly not something other people have to do, so others can get it cheaper.

You are bothered about what impacts you. What about people who are bothered about their local coffee shops? Are you obliged to spend money in them? Because they benefit other people?

If hybrid or wfh or reducing travel makes people's lives better, it's ridiculous to say they shouldn't be allowed because others.

Less travel is good for everyone, fro. An environmental point of view.

I just beggars belief that you would expect someone to want to make their own life harder, so you (and others) can benefit.

What about people on London wages moving out of London and taking up house in more affordable areas, so they can finally buy a home? Pushing up those house prices and often pricing locals out? But while earning a bigger wage than that local person could get? I take it you think that's selfish too and can't believe people would contemplate it?

RosyPoesy · 17/09/2021 14:53

Ever considered that the '20-something strangers you don't give a shit about' are someone else's children?
Not my children, not my problem 🤷‍♀️