Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
chaosrabbitland · 17/09/2021 18:03

@FantaCoke

I hope to see all the big chain coffee shops and high street shops to shut down by the end of this, and we go back to local businesses, run by local people so I feel I’m helping someone who needs the money. Buses are ridiculously expensive, so if they have to cut their fleet, so be it. Drivers are needed everywhere at the moment.

WFH is brilliant. I can walk to work but I still prefer WFH. I can watch TV whilst I work, and get things done in silence without my colleague pulling me away to chat and have a tea every 2 mins.

this must be the most idiotic comment yet , so your hoping to see all those poor fuckers that work in the big coffee shops and high street shops on the dole ,thus putting even more of a strain on a fragile economy , those people do actually need their bloody jobs you know , i rely on public transport i dont really want to see the buses cut thank you , most of these people are probably quite happy in their jobs and dont want to lose them to satisfy lazy arses who like sitting on their butts chilling away at home doing a bit of work inbetween other stuff , im hoping by this time next year all office workers will mostly be back in the office and those that dont want to go can be the ones on the dole
Eleganz · 17/09/2021 18:01

I'm a fan of hybrid working to be honest I think it is a good compromise.

However, what has surprised me about this thread is that the OP cites the DVLA as an example of wfh not working, and, apart from a couple of posters who've mentioned strikes no-one has pointed out that the DVLA have been making most of their staff in their Swansea contact centre attend the office throughout the pandemic. This has resulted in a massive COVID outbreak resulting in 600 cases (out of 6,000 staff, so 10%) and one death. Staff have alleged that COVID safety protocols were poor (and with a case rate like that I'd be inclined to agree). It has been reported that recent attempts to negotiate a resolution to this issue between the union and the government have failed and that is the reason for targeted industrial action. Really not a good example of the negative impacts of wfh.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/09/2021 17:58

100% wfh is very unhealthy, I agree. Bad for your mental health and bad for physical health.

Mintjulia · 17/09/2021 17:57

As someone with mild autism who has spent the last 35 years masking, wfh is a gift from god. My stress levels have dropped by 90%. I'm far more productive, no longer exhausted. My CEO is very delighted.

I never ever want to go back to the office. Smile

RantyAunty · 17/09/2021 17:57

I love WFH and will never go back.

The snarky office politics, gone
Creepy male co-workers hitting on me, gone
No more smelly food in the microwave
No more loud mouths on speaker phone.

LoisLane66 · 17/09/2021 17:52

What I find odd is that wait times are getting longer and longer, the options getting more tedious, the options within options are scream- worthy and recorded messages on a loop offering a million ways we can contact them other than by ☎️ and how they're protecting their workforce. Add in dropped calls, bad connections and my patience is stretched beyond its limits.
What % of workforces are too ill to work, even from home? It seems that nowadays that workforces have shrunk and I base that assumption on the fact that they have HUGE queues but I doubt more customers are ringing in. So what is going on. Whether WFH or in the workplace, surely the wait times would not, almost 2 years down the line, still be at pandemic levels. Most have been double vaccinated and cases have gone down so why can't the phones be answered in a timely fashion?

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 17:51

I have no idea what absolute nonsense you're even banging on about now. Keep grasping at straws and making no sense. I'll be on a thread with more coherent posters.

Its not hard to grasp.

Remote worker telling people they are terribly selfish and horrible members of society, for wanting to wfh.

Remote worker, telling people they shouldn't do what suits them best and benefits their health. Shouldn't put society first. Then claims they simply must be a Remote worker, so the above doesn't apply to them

Person who likes to travel telling telling people they have to travel if they did prepandemic because you want cheap travel. But then says your aren't travelling yourself.

If you can't see the hypocrisy, there's not much people can do.

I don't think you are terribly selfish person. I think you are doing what's right for you and thinking about the things that impact you. Its only by your own standards you are selfish. But you can't even see it.

monotonousmum · 17/09/2021 17:51

I think a flexible approach is good based on the job - we're about to return to the office, 1 day a week initially.
I don't think it can be left to the individual to 'decide', because it needs to be based on business needs too. But if the individual can demonstrate they can be as productive from home then businesses need to rethink the working from the office model. And targets to get everyone in 2/3 days a week are ridiculous if they're not assessing what works best for each role.

I think (hope) over the next few years we may see businesses move out of city centres, as if people are not having to travel in each day then the city centre location is not as vital. Cheaper premises outside of the city, smaller desk numbers needed. Hopefully better paid jobs outside of city centres!

As for coffee shops etc...these industries will be replaced with others that are now busier due to wfh.

gibletjane · 17/09/2021 17:50

@Rozziie do you work remotely? I don't understand why you are criticising others.

Thesandmanishere · 17/09/2021 17:45

I also tend to agree that the people who think WFH is great already had fully-equipped office spaces.

Worked from home for 5 years in a 500sq ft 2 bedroom flat with no garden. Still loved it.

Angelil · 17/09/2021 17:41

YANB entirely unreasonable.

I agree that getting out of the house more regularly is better for us all, physically and mentally. Working elsewhere means you’re forced to do that; otherwise, you have to make a much more conscious effort to build it in.

I also tend to agree that the people who think WFH is great already had fully-equipped office spaces. I work from the sofa; my husband works from the kitchen table. Occasionally one of us has to decamp to the bedroom if we’re both on calls simultaneously. Far from ideal. I’m returning to face to face work soon and couldn’t be more delighted. Husband has already returned to the office voluntarily. That physical separation between home and work spaces is so valuable and something we have both missed.

I agree, too, that Covid has just become an excuse for poor customer service now.

HOWEVER, I can’t agree with your initial point. Sandwich bars and coffee shops were unneeded luxuries to start with - not essential or high-skilled work. The people who worked in these places will find employment elsewhere. Public transport-wise, these services will before too long be replaced with self-driving vehicles. Cases such as the Paris metro (where many lines are automated/driverless) prove that this increases efficiency, decreases accidents and suicides, and does not result in a reduction in services.

slightlyworriedthissunday · 17/09/2021 17:38

I think what needs to happen is the hybrid model my own employers have implemented. I cannot imagine being in the office full time now. Having that flexibility has just completely changed my work life balance.

plumpynoo · 17/09/2021 17:34

YANBU, but the idea of work from home has made it seem possible for me to actually get a job that will allow me to do school runs and take care of my mother as well as earn an income. Surely Flexi work could become more acceptable to employers now...?

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 17/09/2021 17:33

I would much rather be in the office 4 days a week and l'm an introvert. I miss the structure and routine and l used to complain about those things. Talk about grass always being greener.

Jeannie88 · 17/09/2021 17:32

Personally I've found it to be a nightmare trying to contact any office based organisation. It isn't as productive because you're not mixing with others, therefore not as motivated, dynamic, on the ball etc. I have more than one job, one wfh and other in schools and hospitals. Believe me, wfh has been so much easier and less stressful to the point of lazy, ie not properly dressed, doing housework, playing with my dog during meetings Grin. Defo not as efficient as being actively part of a team, for ourselves and our customers. X

Mummadeze · 17/09/2021 17:30

I like working from home but I am getting lazy and fat. I don’t want to go back but I need a kick up the bum. And I agree with your points about the economy.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 17:23

I don't understand the "priced out" stuff. As you've said, it's been a huge problem in London for a long time. Major US metro areas like New York City and San Francisco have the same problem: too many high-earning professionals competing for housing in a limited geographic area leaves working-class people like those vaunted coffee shop workers unable to afford housing. If some of those professionals are leaving the major cities and buying homes elsewhere, reducing prices in the major cities, why is that bad? Yes, it might drive up prices elsewhere, but why is that worse? Everyone has to live somewhere, so there's going to be the same amount of demand either way - the only thing at issue is how it's distributed throughout the country. Spreading it around seems inherently more fair, even without the added bonus of enabling more people to live where they want.

Plumbuddle · 17/09/2021 17:23

@Shurl

Not exactly relevant to your post... but can you chase up your licence? I got mine back in just over a week when I moved 7 weeks ago.
Me too when it was lost.
Rozziie · 17/09/2021 17:21

@Hekatestorch

Yeah, wild, isn't it? Imagine caring about other people! Imagine doing things for people you don't know! Imagine worrying about things that don't directly affect you! I'm sure your head is exploding at the very thought.

Except for most of what you have said doesn't make sense or match with the rest of your posts on here

You don't have to work remotely. It works best for you. If it was just best for your company, you would have resigned rather than be so selfish. If its due to health, you really should make yourself sicker to benefit everyone else. Because that's what you are saying, people aren't allowed to loom at what's best for them. They have to sacrifice what's best for them for society.

You definitely shouldn't be moving to a much poorer area of the country just so you can selfishly own a home. Its not what's best for everyone else.

See how much sense that makes? It doesn't.

Its virtue signally. Pretend you care. Tell everyone else how selfish wfh and refusing to travel is. While wfh and not wanting to travel yourself. Funny how its fine for YOU to do it in your circumstances and it's OK for you to out yourself first, but no one else is. It's actually only selfish by your own standards. I don't think it's selfish to loon after yourself when it come to your job and health. But by your own standards you are the horrible people you are talking about.

So short sighted it's unreal

I have no idea what absolute nonsense you're even banging on about now. Keep grasping at straws and making no sense. I'll be on a thread with more coherent posters.
Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 17:14

@Tealightsandd

Ah so it's OK for London people to not think about their impact on wider society if it benefits only themselves?

Eh? You brought London up - attacking the London 'people', who have been done over for decades. Priced out and nobody gives a shit. Highest youth unemployment. No-one cares. Capital of homelessness. No jots given by most. Meanwhile London is that only place in the country to pay out more in tax than it gets back. The money certainly isn't going to the disadvantaged youth or the 165,000 London homeless.

You're not being coherent. You say you want WFH - but you then complain about one of the consequences. People who moved to London, pricing out locals, now moving back out. You can't have it both ways.

Um no, you aren't reading what u am putting.

I am not attacking anyone. I am incredulous that you and other printers think that people have to live their lives not regarding what works for them, but what benefits all of society most or are terrible people.

I mentioned London, not because I think London people are damaging the rest of the country but as an example of things that poster thinks is OK, because it would be if benefit to her. Even though it damages someone else.

She is complaining that people only think of themselves whilst only thinking of only herself.

I am also pretty sure 'London people' aren't offended.

I don't want to work from home I work hybrid and have done for years. Which I have said several times, if you can read. I also think hybrid, is the best compromise for most people (not all). You can be hybrid and work in the office most of the time. But having the choice is good.

I object to posters like you lying and being hypocritical, taking on quite serious issues, that you don't actily know much about and using it as a reason other people can't work from home if it suits them and their employer.

One of the 'you must all get back to work' posters is a remote worker Hmm and I am yet to see you actually say wetger you are at home or not, since you keep dodging questions about it. So again, hypocrites to tell people they must put everyone else first all the time, because that's what would suite them. Totally hypocritical.

You want people to act in a way that benefits you the most.

Its really quite odd and doesn't make sense. Like the posters who think dpa is broken by the simple act of having a laptop Hmm

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 17:05

Yeah, wild, isn't it? Imagine caring about other people! Imagine doing things for people you don't know! Imagine worrying about things that don't directly affect you! I'm sure your head is exploding at the very thought.

Except for most of what you have said doesn't make sense or match with the rest of your posts on here

You don't have to work remotely. It works best for you. If it was just best for your company, you would have resigned rather than be so selfish. If its due to health, you really should make yourself sicker to benefit everyone else. Because that's what you are saying, people aren't allowed to loom at what's best for them. They have to sacrifice what's best for them for society.

You definitely shouldn't be moving to a much poorer area of the country just so you can selfishly own a home. Its not what's best for everyone else.

See how much sense that makes? It doesn't.

Its virtue signally. Pretend you care. Tell everyone else how selfish wfh and refusing to travel is. While wfh and not wanting to travel yourself. Funny how its fine for YOU to do it in your circumstances and it's OK for you to out yourself first, but no one else is. It's actually only selfish by your own standards. I don't think it's selfish to loon after yourself when it come to your job and health. But by your own standards you are the horrible people you are talking about.

So short sighted it's unreal

JustDanceAddict · 17/09/2021 16:53

If I could, I’d choose 50/50 & I sort of do that but more home than work really.

gibletjane · 17/09/2021 16:42

Exactly

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 16:35

@gibletjane

I am concerned about the whole travel industry and the impact of it folding. I'm concerned about young people finding it really hard to see the world outside the UK. I'm concerned about the impact on trade. There are plenty of reasons to be concerned about the travel industry (not just airlines) collapsing that don't involve going off on a jolly to the Canaries.

I think you can wfh & still feel the same though?

It's hard to make solid plans with covid still an issue in most countries, but I expect to travel more because of WFH. Not being physically tethered to a specific location opens up a lot of possibilities there. For a while now, I've had plans in the back of my head for weeklong "working vacations" where I spend several hours per day working remotely, then enjoy some tropical scenery the rest of the time. I'm not going to do that while covid restrictions are in force everywhere, because too much can go sideways, but that's not a WFH problem.
gibletjane · 17/09/2021 16:34

Why would I worry about people in Cornwall being priced out when I live in London?

As a Londoner I don't worry about this tbh. I certainly empathise as it's been happening in London for years.