Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have completely changed my mind about WFH?

890 replies

MauvePinkRose · 16/09/2021 07:30

I know there is a WFH thread but I mean this more generally than the specific things about it that are driving me to drink!

Pre pandemic, I would have said that WFH was a positive thing that employers should absolutely allow, reducing traffic and therefore pollution, allowing more quality time at home.

Now, I’ve changed my mind.

I think it’s having a negative impact on public transport, which in turn will lead to redundancies and reduced public transport, which is bad news for those who can’t drive. It is also having a knock on effect on things like coffee kiosks and sandwich bars.

Then, I’m not convinced that WFH is as productive as people think. I don’t know what’s going on with DVLA for instance but I am still waiting for a driving license I sent off for three months ago and you can’t get through on the phones.

It’s turned family homes into workplaces and thus impacts everyone. I’ve had some really stressful and unpleasant times because of it.

And I do think it’s not very healthy. Dp rarely leaves the house without me, has gained weight and falls ill all the time as I just feel he isn’t gaining any natural immunity.

I’ll probably be flamed by all the WFHers now Smile

OP posts:
KittyMcV · 17/09/2021 20:08

Completely agree - there are many more negatives, particularly in relation to mental health and difficulty with dividing work and domestic life. People are missing the social connection. It is good to be given the option though.

England101 · 17/09/2021 20:06

I work in the nhs where they was limited opportunity to WFH but when I did I loved it. I do think that there may be a reduction in salary though. For example if you live in London you don’t need as much London weighting if you’re not travelling in and can live much further afield. Plus for a Uk businesses they’re may not be a need to hirer Uk people as WFH could be working from anywhere in the world which means they could employ people from countries where wages are much lower and still get the same productivity. So I suppose we have to be careful about what we wish for

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 17/09/2021 20:03

WFH has been great for DH. He’s saved around £2k on travel costs as well as dry cleaning costs. He is fitter than before because he can easily spend half an hour exercising during his lunch hour which he couldn’t do when working in London. It has been good for our local parade of independent shops who have all seen an upturn in custom because people can shop locally as they are at home while the shops are open rather than having to go to the out of town supermarket because it’s open late. He is more productive too so it looks like this really is going to be his new normal.

Wincher · 17/09/2021 19:58

For me hybrid is ideal. I started a new job in lockdown and I was surprised at how hard I found it not being able to ask random questions easily, and I really missed overhearing conversations in the office and the way you pick up stuff in a new job by osmosis almost. As of this month we have to go in at least three days a week - any less and we would have to switch over to a home working contract with no London weighting, so less money. So far I’m really enjoying it - it is a novelty to put my work clothes back on rather than t-shirts and jeans (or nice tops and jeans if I had meetings), but my lunch from Pret etc. It is a bit of a shock to the system losing so much time to commuting again - though partly this is about learning where to get on and off the tube as I’m commuting to a new place, and getting used to a new journey.

I am finding I’m probably less productive in the office due to chatting to people but it’s all valuable in terms of learning the job and making connections. I’m a middle manager but the team I manage are all older than me and have been there for years and years so for us there’s no issues about teaching younger staff the ropes. I think in an ideal world I would do two days in the office and three from home rather than vice versa. Still hoping to convince management of that!

Kljnmw3459 · 17/09/2021 19:52

The public transport in my area has been minimal for over a decade already. Trains still run thankfully, though not because of commuters but because our station it's an only connection to a very popular tourist spot. Local independent shops have also been in decline for a decade. But cafés are doing very well and online businesses as well.

HarryBlaster · 17/09/2021 19:49

Totally agree. WFH looking at the same four walls day in day out. Listening to OH on his work phone droning on all day has gradually driven me barmy. None of my colleagues are that keen to go back to work so I am actually now actively job hunting because of it. And probably a divorce too 😂

Oreo78 · 17/09/2021 19:45

@Greensmurf1

Wfh means I'm not paying a fortune in commuting and wrap around childcare costs, arriving at work exhausted and stressed and then having to come home on sometimes unreliable public transport to rush through the bedtime routine, staying up to do chores before being too wound up to get a decent night's rest.

Wfh means I can have a desk with a window, the room temperature the way I want it, quiet to concentrate without interruptions from open plan office chatter and music, time to put on a load of laundry during lunch, time to get my child for an afternoon online lesson or take a walk in less polluted areas or any number or pleasant break options.
WFH means I don't catch every single lurgy that's going around when people come to work with colds, flu, tonsillitis or worse.

Amen to this. These are all valid reasons for WFH.

Also, seeing as the government is going to reduce the £20 weekly Universal booster for low-income families, it means many parents may struggle to afford travel into work and car parking fees.

Oreo78 · 17/09/2021 19:42

I now have a mixture of both and it works really well for me. I love WFH, but I can get rather lonely in the house on my own all day when my daughter is at school, but I do hate the pokey office I have to work in, and the less said about the traffic jams the better.

However, I think it is proper messing my cat up now that I am going into the office some days a week. He goes away for days and nights on end as I am not home to let him in any time he wants to come in. Then when he does comes home he hangs around me perpetually checking I won't leave him outside alone.

Do you think this is a good enough excuse to WFH all the time?

I wish I could afford to have a cat flap installed.

1974devon · 17/09/2021 19:36

We might not be using services where we used to work but probably using more local, small companies.. which is a good thing. I didn't used to shop in town where I live but now do

Greensmurf1 · 17/09/2021 19:36

Wfh means I'm not paying a fortune in commuting and wrap around childcare costs, arriving at work exhausted and stressed and then having to come home on sometimes unreliable public transport to rush through the bedtime routine, staying up to do chores before being too wound up to get a decent night's rest.

Wfh means I can have a desk with a window, the room temperature the way I want it, quiet to concentrate without interruptions from open plan office chatter and music, time to put on a load of laundry during lunch, time to get my child for an afternoon online lesson or take a walk in less polluted areas or any number or pleasant break options.
WFH means I don't catch every single lurgy that's going around when people come to work with colds, flu, tonsillitis or worse.

gibletjane · 17/09/2021 19:33

I agree that lower user numbers will impact cost & frequency of public transport services. However I would argue that the vast majority of people who wfh during the pandemic already had that ability to do so before & remote working was already a growing trend, London & places like Richmond had a much higher % of remote workers than other parts of the UK.

"The percentage of people who mainly work from home in the United Kingdom reached 17.4 percent in 2020, compared with 14.2 percent in the previous year"

exaltedwombat · 17/09/2021 19:32

Trouble is - for the world to survive we must do less travel, less unnecessary consumption. Yes, this will impact transport and sandwich bars. But we can't expect things to change but remain exactly the same!

Nearly47 · 17/09/2021 19:28

There is not holding this back. Its cheaper. Its better for people mental health once they realise they can invest their free time locally, with exercise, family or friends. My job doesn't allow to work from home normally but I can see the positive effect on my husband. Instead of commuting her goes for a run. Eats a healthy lunch, sees more of the kids and even has time for a hobby. And he works long hours when required. I can see him much happier. I think the focus of people lives will naturally focus to be more local. And new staff are so much more savvy with online life that I don't think they will miss out much on learning in person

Badbadbunny · 17/09/2021 19:27

@PurpleOkapi

You think public transport service isn't affected by user numbers? How much of a bubble do you live in? Plenty of places have no or almost no public transport. My local line is down to two trains an hour, and I'm in London. Very inconvenient and not covid safe, because the trains that do arrive are pretty packed.

But let me guess, you're alright because you've got a car?

If someone has a car and drove to work anyway, whether they WFH or not has no impact on public transit usage or funding. But are you seriously trying to argue that people who don't want to return to the office should be required to do so because some of them will commute using public transit, thus increasing its usage figures and shoring up its funding? And that those reluctant to do it are the selfish ones, while those demanding that everyone else rearrange their lives for the benefit of a minority of people who rely on public transit are just "doing what's right"?

No, the point is that people who want to WFH most of the time and only go into the office occasionally or 1/2 days per week by public transport, are going to get a rude awakening when their old journey now takes longer due to more stops, or isn't as frequent, or has fewer carriages or costs more. They can't expect to enjoy the same public transport that they previously had if there are far fewer passengers using it on a daily basis.

That may be irrelevant to those who didn't use public transport, but they, too, may find the now occasional commute more time consuming, more congested, etc., if lots of people are now using cars to do the occasional commute if public transport is more expensive, less frequent, etc.

The point is that people need to accept that the "new normal" will be different in lots of ways. From what I've read, it seems a lot of people seem to think that everything will be just the same and that their journey will be the same (though less often) and that they'll still be able to enjoy their shopping, cafe culture, etc as if nothing's happened.

riceuten · 17/09/2021 19:26

I think it's a bit perverse to say that WFH is a bad thing because a lack of commuting is affecting public transport and food outlets. Surely these should be remodelled to reflect different demands. More local transport is needed perhaps - many, many communities have no transport in the evening or on Sundays. And bars and cafes probably need to relocate. It's similar to saying that WFH is bad for commercial landlords - of course it is.

gibletjane · 17/09/2021 19:24

Any big shift in working style & pattern impacts the economy & individuals. I'm not sure why it's anymore selfish to remote work then it is to holiday abroad despite cheap overseas travel leading to decline of the UK seaside resorts. Or shop at Amazon despite it destroying book shops or use chains that swallow up independents. Or buy cars that used to be made here which are now manufactured abroad. Or go to Lidl or Aldi instead of Tesco or Sainsbury's. Or using youtube for exercise instead of a gym. Or buy a coffee machine instead of buying a coffee.

Badbadbunny · 17/09/2021 19:22

@FuckPolitenessSSDGM

Your driving license application has either been lost, or your bullshitting. I applied for a replacement and it took 2 weeks to arrive.

My husband has worked from home for 15 years. It's fine. We've learnt to negotiate it. If you can't deal with even a few days a week working at home you are a bit precious IMO. If everyone worked from home 2 days a week it would be better for the environment, for the planet, for families. It makes sense.

It's been all over the media for weeks that there are long delays for some driving licence renewals due to staff shortages and WFH.
Tigger1895 · 17/09/2021 19:19

A hybrid approach would appear to be the answer going forward.
It was stressful for me as my daughter who lives at home had a baby last year and it was difficult to have video calls with babes screaming in the other room.
I’d agree with you on the lack of getting out, as unless I force myself to leave the house I wouldn’t get out Monday to Friday.
You mentioned coffee shops, in my area a whole bunch of independent coffee trucks have popped up, by using them you are supporting local businesses rather than large chains.

Hekatestorch · 17/09/2021 19:18

So because you don’t use it, people in other areas shouldn’t either? There’s an excellent network where I live, that’s currently only being sustained by £30M+ extra government subsidy this year. If it goes under that means millions more journeys on the road with all the resulting pollution and congestion.

No what I am saying is in some areas, wfh hasn't impacted who uses the limited public transport. And that people didn't use it before and won't use it after....so wfh is irrelevant to public transport in some areas.

Never mentioned people shouldnt use it.

Simply mentioned that not all areas are impacted the same.

But again, you can't expect people in areas where public transport is shit, to care make a decision about returning to the office based on someone having a good transport network elsewhere.

And people here aren't going to go back to the office to help public transport. Because its unreliable. So even if everyone had to go back, there would be no positive impact in this area.

Roxy69 · 17/09/2021 19:18

@FantaCoke

I hope to see all the big chain coffee shops and high street shops to shut down by the end of this, and we go back to local businesses, run by local people so I feel I’m helping someone who needs the money. Buses are ridiculously expensive, so if they have to cut their fleet, so be it. Drivers are needed everywhere at the moment.

WFH is brilliant. I can walk to work but I still prefer WFH. I can watch TV whilst I work, and get things done in silence without my colleague pulling me away to chat and have a tea every 2 mins.

Yes, well watching tv while you work doesn't sound very professional to me. I recently had a conversation with someone distracted by his kids and presumably wife. It was really annoying to know he wasn't focusing properly.
5128gap · 17/09/2021 19:18

@speakout

My real pleasure at going to an office, especially in winter, was a busy atmosphere; lights on, colleagues to chat to in the kitchen, go out to lunch with, and have meetings with. WFH has its benefits of course, but it can be lonely during the dark days of winter.

My real pleasure at WFH , especially in winter is having the time I would normally use to commute to attend an early morning yoga class, have a little chat with like minded people, do some exercise, and still be back by 8.30 am to start my working day.

And mine is not to have to leave my house in the dark and cold to wait for a train that probably won't turn up for hours if at all, if it snows, rains heavily or is particularly windy. I can start work at 7am from my cosy house rather than losing hours standing on platforms, then go for a walk at lunchtime to make the most of the daylight.
gibletjane · 17/09/2021 19:13

@Rozziie I can't be arsed to scroll that far back & I don't have the filter thing.

I saw something about having to do it but I'm confused by your stance.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 19:08

You think public transport service isn't affected by user numbers? How much of a bubble do you live in? Plenty of places have no or almost no public transport. My local line is down to two trains an hour, and I'm in London. Very inconvenient and not covid safe, because the trains that do arrive are pretty packed.

But let me guess, you're alright because you've got a car?

If someone has a car and drove to work anyway, whether they WFH or not has no impact on public transit usage or funding. But are you seriously trying to argue that people who don't want to return to the office should be required to do so because some of them will commute using public transit, thus increasing its usage figures and shoring up its funding? And that those reluctant to do it are the selfish ones, while those demanding that everyone else rearrange their lives for the benefit of a minority of people who rely on public transit are just "doing what's right"?

RobinPenguins · 17/09/2021 19:07

@Hekatestorch

I find it really odd on these threads how every assumes public transport is actually usually for large amounts of people, everywhere in the country.

Pre pandemic and now the only people here using public transport are the elderly. It's not frequent enough to sensibly use for work. Also skips far too often, it's just not reliable. Most people drive, walk, cycle or use taxis. The vast majority of people in this area are working in warehouses. Rather than office workers

There's the same elderly people on the bus now as there was before. But wfh, isn't impacting it.

So because you don’t use it, people in other areas shouldn’t either? There’s an excellent network where I live, that’s currently only being sustained by £30M+ extra government subsidy this year. If it goes under that means millions more journeys on the road with all the resulting pollution and congestion.
SpeakingFranglais · 17/09/2021 19:04

I agree with you OP and I’ve WFH over 16 years. Too many companies have just sent their employees home without any of the considerations or H&S that mine did over a decade ago.

wHF is not easy, the workplace has to be right, the H&S right, the support right. If it’s going to be long term it has to be right.