Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it going to be just mums and just dads forever now?

283 replies

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 19:38

My wife has just had our first baby and well as splitting the load as much as possible I've been trying to join in with the community of new parents and be an active and equal participant. It's tough though. Partly because all the parenting classes, activities and meet ups are held during the week and I'm working at the moment, though I'll be doing three months of SPL later in the year. And partly because every new parents group, chat or meet up I join seems to either just be the women who've given birth and nobody else, or to quickly split into separate groups, meet ups and chats for 'mums' and 'dads' with the 'mums' often initiating this. Even when the point of meeting up or chatting is nothing to do with being a man or woman, and everything to do with being a new parent and / or meeting new people. It hasn't been like this so far in my life, I've always been in and seen mixed groups at work, in friendships and in activities. Is it unreasonable to have expected that new parents would want to spend time with other new parents, or that men and women could talk about our kids and be friends, or does something about new parenthood send everyone spiraling back to the 50's with the men in the pub talking about craft ale and what football team their kids will support and the women in the park talking about books and feeding? Will this change when our kid(s) are older or is this the way it's always going to be now we have a kid.

OP posts:
ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 23:30

@OppsUpsSide

I think you feel like you don’t fit in either group and are understandably disappointed and frustrated, possibly even a bit scared. However, I think you are not acknowledging the experiences of the other people and what support they might seek/need at this time.
Not really no. I think it's really important that groups and spaces for women who have given birth exist. I founded my university's feminism society and volunteer for a women's crisis line alongside my day job. I never said they shouldn't exist, or that men (or other mothers) should be in them. I was just hoping for some mixed groups as well. Perhaps the field of parenting will be a bit wider when the baby is a bit older. For the record my wife feels the same way, she's always had a mix of male and female friends and colleagues and is hoping more dads will be around and involved with play dates and pick ups and classes in the future - both to chat to and for our son to see and learn from.
OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 15/09/2021 23:21

@SarahAndQuack

I did a load of reading about same-sex parents after we had DD, and relatively few lesbians seem to feel experiences of parenthood are driven primarily by whether or not you're the birthing parent. The early days, yes. Later on, no

Yes I was really thinking of parenting in the first year.

Babies are a world away for me now and as my DC have grown I’ve been much more open to parent friendships of either sex.

However my overarching recollection of new fathers was how fucking dull they all were. And sanctimonious. Nothing worse than a snug dad who dies precisely 5 hours of “babysitting” a week playing competitive parent with you or patronising you whilst your baby screams because he “never [had] that issue with Jago, have you tried a genuine organic cotton swaddle?!”

CornedBeef451 · 15/09/2021 23:19

I generally find men a bit boring and overbearing in group conversations so I prefer to meet up just with women, whatever the topic.

There's lots of research about how mixed groups become dominated by men so I can see why the women would initiate splitting into a separate group.

WTF475878237NC · 15/09/2021 23:15

Ah you're a woman! Then surely you should understand this even more! This is about people needing to be around people who have gone through a similar experience. Unfortunately if you haven't given birth, you aren't going to be able to relate to a lot of it. That's not to say you can't understand and contribute to conversations about parenting, but there are unique aspects of the journey you are naturally excluded from. I'm sure once the babies get older it'll even out as people naturally move to parenting conversations and then other topics, not just childbirth and how their partner who didn't give birth are doing.

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/09/2021 23:13

Bookmark

Today 20:27 ParentsandParents

For the record @AntiSocialDistancer I have both organised and joined parenting groups / chats, they still always seem to split along gendered lines no matter the original intention or description. I posted this in frustration after a mum in a new parenting chat that I'm an admin for suggested starting a separate group for dads and about ten others have responded saying this would be great and can their lonely husbands join. This is despite all the meet ups the group has organised so far specifically being for everyone, with partners specifically welcome and some of the meet ups happening at weekends or at times when WFH dads / teacher dads and other mums on summer holidays could join.“

Sorry but doesn’t this give you a very strong hint that most new mums don’t want dads there too?

You need to respect that even if you don’t understand it.

OppsUpsSide · 15/09/2021 23:09

I think you feel like you don’t fit in either group and are understandably disappointed and frustrated, possibly even a bit scared.
However, I think you are not acknowledging the experiences of the other people and what support they might seek/need at this time.

WTF475878237NC · 15/09/2021 23:09

I suppose I was just hoping we were a bit more advanced along the road to equality than we seem to be.

^ equality doesn't mean ignoring the very real sex based differences that go along with the experience of having given birth and wanting to be around others who have had that shared (often traumatic!) experience at a time when one feels most vulnerable. For women to be able to speak up and ask for women's only groups is not a regression. Men telling women that men shouldn't be excluded even if it's what women want is.

AgathaAllAlong · 15/09/2021 23:04

I think it depends on how long after they've given birth. It's a weird and irrational time. I have always had and sought mixed friendships, but increasingly during pregnancy and intensly after having DS I just did not want to befriend men I didn't know. It was fine if they were there, didn't care, but I had absolutely no interest in talking to them or being their friend. In the early days I really struggled and was not in a position to put other people first. I would not have struck up a conversation with a man, certainly would not have exchanged phone numbers (although obviously would not have ignored them if they had talked to me). No idea if this is a common experience, but it might go some way towards explaining it.

The feeling has slowly decreased and I am no longer struggling and happily talk to anyone at the park, and would not seek to exclude men from groups. For the reasons you mention, I'd be in favour of mixed groups - good role models for my son, encourages dads, etc. But honestly I still have no interest in being friends with men. The thought doesn't set off the negative feelings it used to, I just lack the interest.

So in answer to your last question, I would actively seek being friends with you if we got on, since you are a woman. It's not about who gave birth.

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 23:04

Anyway, this has been interesting. I'm off to do the next feed (pumped) so my wife can get a bit more sleep. Hope all the dads and other mums out there are doing the same. Sleep tight

OP posts:
bluedart · 15/09/2021 23:03

Also, not everyone particularly wants to talk about those experiences. In (rare) mixed groups when the kids were young, I would tend to gravitate towards the men, precisely because they weren't talking about cracked nipples and episiotomies. I had a bloody awful time with birth and breastfeeding, and had no desire to spend much time talking about it. I found it was far better for my wellbeing to spend half an hour talking about sport or politics or books or TV, or just having a laugh about universal aspects of parenting, rather than talking about the very specifically female business of childbirth and feeding. But then to be honest I feel the same way now if the talk in my largely female office turns towards periods and menopause and relationship issues - I'm much happier getting that sort of 'support' from my GP or the internet, and prefer my actual social interactions to centre on less gendered things.

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 23:02

[quote ParentsandParents]@SpindleWhorl not sure that implies I'm a man. I meant that I had hoped that men and women in general could talk about their kids and be friends in general. I also talked about parenting groups largely being "just women who had given birth or quickly splitting into mums and dads." Which implies I'm a woman, just not one that has given birth. I wasn't trying to trick anyone, I'm was just writing from my own perspective where being a woman and having a wife is normal and not something I need to specifically announce unless it's directly relevant.[/quote]
Realise this could come across as me calling out people who assumed I was a man. Not my intention. I get it. People make assumptions based on general norms - and I'm not the norm. But I am the norm for me

OP posts:
Talkwhilstyouwalk · 15/09/2021 23:00

[quote ParentsandParents]@SpindleWhorl not sure that implies I'm a man. I meant that I had hoped that men and women in general could talk about their kids and be friends in general. I also talked about parenting groups largely being "just women who had given birth or quickly splitting into mums and dads." Which implies I'm a woman, just not one that has given birth. I wasn't trying to trick anyone, I'm was just writing from my own perspective where being a woman and having a wife is normal and not something I need to specifically announce unless it's directly relevant.[/quote]
Maybe don't start a Dads group then!

Apologies that I made assumptions, I'm quite shocked with myself! As someone who went through IVF I do know that there are many ways to make a happy family and I am absolutely for all of them......

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 22:52

@SpindleWhorl not sure that implies I'm a man. I meant that I had hoped that men and women in general could talk about their kids and be friends in general. I also talked about parenting groups largely being "just women who had given birth or quickly splitting into mums and dads." Which implies I'm a woman, just not one that has given birth. I wasn't trying to trick anyone, I'm was just writing from my own perspective where being a woman and having a wife is normal and not something I need to specifically announce unless it's directly relevant.

OP posts:
EarlGreywithLemon · 15/09/2021 22:50

I also found it easier to talk about our daughter’s birth with some men than some women. I had a difficult birth - back to back, forceps, episiotomy, 3b tear, PPH, went home with a catheter and leg bag and no one could tell me at that point if the incontinence was going to get better. My experience was on a different planet from my (otherwise lovely) friend who turned up at the NCT reunion patting herself on the back about how she gave birth without a scratch thanks to hypnobirthing. I found some male friends much more respectful and sympathetic to my experience than she was. By contrast I found the newborn stage relatively easy whereas other friends struggled. There is such a variety of experiences out there - of birth, parenting etc - that I do not find that giving birth to a child guarantees understanding or sympathy from a fellow mother. In fact, quite the opposite at times.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 15/09/2021 22:45

I think you need to start a Dad's group. Dads are every bit as important as mums when it comes
to child rearing but they don't breast feed, haven't pushed a small human out and often don't wake up when the baby cries (perhaps this is in my experience but I do think the mother is more wired to hear a fuss in the night). Women tend to bond very quickly as new mothers and I found
myself discussing the innermost details of the birth with a fellow new mum who I met for the first time in costa coffee. We have become firm friends.

I have seen Dad's at baby groups, quite often actually! They are always made very welcome and some have formed friendships with the mums. My husband has made new Dad friends through the children. They tend to bond over children, beer, sports, work etc but you don't often catch them discussing birth experiences in the same detail as their partners do (not to say they avoid the topic).

SpindleWhorl · 15/09/2021 22:36

@PermanentTemporary

Yes I thought you were a straight man. It did shift things a bit for me. I think I'm self conscious in front of men and women who say they dislike women-only groups, because I am a very ordinary mum who found the experience of making lots of female friends and being able to talk about the physicality of pregnancy, birth, feeding and new parenthood really wonderful. My closest friends are still those women. But I know that those intimacies aren't valued by a lot of people. I have made friends with other parents over a much longer timescale, mainly around school and being on the governing body for a bit. Then people knew my name and my child also was quite recognisable so connections happened that way.

Essentially just as nothing lasts forever with babies, nothing lasts forever with parenting.

I'm not surprised you were thinking that way, as this was in the OP's original post:

Is it unreasonable to have expected that new parents would want to spend time with other new parents, or that men and women could talk about our kids and be friends

airforsharon · 15/09/2021 22:33

The reason it's so "gendered" in those early months is down to men & women have different experiences of the whole thing. As I said in my earlier post it's natural to gravitate towards people who've shared your own experiences. I also think many women need a female space to discuss the physical side of childbirth, esp if they had a difficult birth, and get to grips with breastfeeding. My local breastfeeding group is strictly female attendees only.

A couple of close friends are a (female) gay couple, and have children they adopted as babies. I didn't know them at that time but i'm going to ask how they got on in those early days and what/if any groups they went to.

PermanentTemporary · 15/09/2021 22:29

Yes I thought you were a straight man. It did shift things a bit for me. I think I'm self conscious in front of men and women who say they dislike women-only groups, because I am a very ordinary mum who found the experience of making lots of female friends and being able to talk about the physicality of pregnancy, birth, feeding and new parenthood really wonderful. My closest friends are still those women. But I know that those intimacies aren't valued by a lot of people. I have made friends with other parents over a much longer timescale, mainly around school and being on the governing body for a bit. Then people knew my name and my child also was quite recognisable so connections happened that way.

Essentially just as nothing lasts forever with babies, nothing lasts forever with parenting.

FunnysInLaJardin · 15/09/2021 22:28

[quote ParentsandParents]@ManifestDestinee I'm a woman, in a same sex relationship, with another woman who is the one who gave birth to our baby. It's entirely irrelevant to this conversation whether I'm a man or a woman. I wasn't talking about me, as a woman (or a man) wanting to force myself into groups of women talking about discharge and cracked nipples, or groups of men talking about ale and power tools. I was just expressing 1. my general shock and disappointment at how bloody gendered new parenting seems to be, 2. my worry about what this is going to mean for future friendship groups and 3. my worry that new parenting being so gendered is going to fuck over women and men who want equality[/quote]
it has been the same for years, and will continue while people show the same attitudes as shown on this thread.

Equal paternity/maternity leave would help even it out, but while the gender pay gap persists, even that won't help.

Very interested in your perspective OP, most interesting discussion

Hekatestorch · 15/09/2021 22:19

@ancientgran

The group i went to (30 years ago) was mainly women but we had two dads who always attended and others who did when they could. I don't remember anyone talking about cracked nipples or anything intimate, we talked about babies/toddlers and tips about buying stuff, toys they liked etc.

Are we going backwards?

How would be able to bring up intimate issues be going backwards?

Getting support for the physical and emotional struggles of physically carrying a baby is going backwards?

30 years ago, women were as open about this side of giving birth. And we weren't better for it.

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 22:17

Genuine question, to those who (thinking I was a straight man) told me that women who have given birth need women only spaces to talk about the female experience of giving birth and that I shouldn't try to push into these spaces, (not that I was suggesting this, I was just expressing disappointment that there weren't spaces for parents as well as the spaces for birthing women).

Now you know I'm a gay woman, what do you think?

This wasn't what I came here to ask about btw, but so many people thought I was a man and suggested that my wish to be seen as a parent (rather than a man or a woman) and disappointment that parenting was so gendered was akin to me trying to displace women from their spaces, that I'm curious to know what you think now

OP posts:
WhatMattersMost · 15/09/2021 22:15

[quote ParentsandParents]@ManifestDestinee I'm a woman, in a same sex relationship, with another woman who is the one who gave birth to our baby. It's entirely irrelevant to this conversation whether I'm a man or a woman. I wasn't talking about me, as a woman (or a man) wanting to force myself into groups of women talking about discharge and cracked nipples, or groups of men talking about ale and power tools. I was just expressing 1. my general shock and disappointment at how bloody gendered new parenting seems to be, 2. my worry about what this is going to mean for future friendship groups and 3. my worry that new parenting being so gendered is going to fuck over women and men who want equality[/quote]
I agree personally. I'm a woman who was in a hetero relationship when I had a newborn, and still I felt that the groups I attended gently but irrevocably favoured a certain kind of interaction and conformity. I stayed away.

Goldenbear · 15/09/2021 21:59

I agree and being asked for your number by a Dad to organise playdates is not the pathway to infidelity. I,shock horror, go to the pub garden with my DD's friend's Dad, the park with another. We all work from home and the Mum's in these scenarios don't, if my DD wants to socialise with her friends then I have to get over the fact they are men!

bluedart · 15/09/2021 21:57

I totally agree with you OP. I've never been terribly happy in all-female company (girls' school was not ideal!), and I hate the fact that I now find I can only access male company through 'couples' evenings (ie via mum circles having a get together where husbands are invited too) rather than getting to know men as friends in their own right. It does get a bit better later on - I've found that social events at secondary school are attended by dads almost as much as mums - but throughout babyhood and primary school it was incredibly mum focused.

RoseAndGeranium · 15/09/2021 21:53

Other posters have given some really good explanations of why women very naturally gravitate towards one another in the first few months after having a baby. After that I think it’s just a question of finding the right people. There are quite a few women who just don’t really do friendships with men (and vice versa) so you will inevitably run into a bit of that too. That was, for me, one of the problems with my NCT group. It was a very ‘girly’ crowd, and The Husbands were kept strongly in the background. Fair enough, that was how the others liked it and I don’t want to suggest that traditionally ‘girly’ chat or ways of interacting are somehow inferior (I use that word, by the way, because there was a lot of talk of ‘girls’ nights out’ and ‘girly film evenings’) but it’s really not my scene so I drifted away from the group. Conversely I have a couple of pretty good dad playground pals now because I’ve found it easier to get talking to them than a lot of the mums. So I think there’s a bit of backsliding into traditional gender roles going on, especially while the memory of birth is still so strong, but mostly it’s just that the people you meet at baby groups are people with whom you may have nothing in common other than the fact of a baby, so it’s always going to be pretty hit and miss socially, and for men that’s further complicated by the reality that a lot of people of both sexes naturally gravitate towards single sex friendship groups, which makes it harder for men in a strongly female dominated environment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread