I’m sure you probably didn’t mean it this way @mathanxiety and loads of people on this thread have used this form of words too. But it’s a bit upsetting when people say things like “even though you’re a woman, you’re not one who has gone through what the mothers have”. You refer to the women who have given birth as ‘the mothers’, and define me as a woman who hasn’t gone through what ‘the mothers’ have. This reads as you saying that I’m not a mother and never will be and that lesbians and bi woman whose partners have given birth (and from the sounds of it adoptive mothers too), aren’t or can’t be real mothers because they didn’t give birth. I’m sure you didn’t mean it that way, but the drip drip drip of hearing little things like this as a gay woman add up to what feels like homophobia.
Adoptive mothers know that their experiences are different from biological mothers, this is something that is considered important for them to know in the adoption process.
I sometimes get the impression from hearing people talk that people who have kids using reproductive technologies, including gay men and lesbians, don't get this kind of thing stressed in the same way? It seems like there is a lot of effort to say that it's the same, that they are "real" mothers or fathers. I'm not sure how helpful that is in the end.
In the most basic, medical sense, being a mother or father is about reproductive role. "Mothering" or "fathering" in the cultural/relationship sense is derived from the biological one. Even when a non-parent feels parental to an unrelated child, that comes out of the biologically created capacities we all have, which is why we recognize those feelings and the behaviour that comes from them as a kind of parental action, and the effect on the child as being in the same mode. To talk about "real"motherhood really depends on context, it has to or the whole concept loses its meaning. It's real when someone acts as a mother, but being a biological mother is also real, and so is a genetic connection.
Birthing and non-birthing parents don't have the same experience, and the biological element affects us in very striking ways around childbirth, more than most other things in modern society. That's one of the reasons it can be such a shock to some new mums, they haven't had that before in their lives. Recognizing that and observing it doesn't make people homophobic.