Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it going to be just mums and just dads forever now?

283 replies

ParentsandParents · 15/09/2021 19:38

My wife has just had our first baby and well as splitting the load as much as possible I've been trying to join in with the community of new parents and be an active and equal participant. It's tough though. Partly because all the parenting classes, activities and meet ups are held during the week and I'm working at the moment, though I'll be doing three months of SPL later in the year. And partly because every new parents group, chat or meet up I join seems to either just be the women who've given birth and nobody else, or to quickly split into separate groups, meet ups and chats for 'mums' and 'dads' with the 'mums' often initiating this. Even when the point of meeting up or chatting is nothing to do with being a man or woman, and everything to do with being a new parent and / or meeting new people. It hasn't been like this so far in my life, I've always been in and seen mixed groups at work, in friendships and in activities. Is it unreasonable to have expected that new parents would want to spend time with other new parents, or that men and women could talk about our kids and be friends, or does something about new parenthood send everyone spiraling back to the 50's with the men in the pub talking about craft ale and what football team their kids will support and the women in the park talking about books and feeding? Will this change when our kid(s) are older or is this the way it's always going to be now we have a kid.

OP posts:
Cutabove · 17/09/2021 11:15

@Localocal

Dear OP, it sounds a Teeny bit like you have just noticed that sexism still exists because all of a sudden it's affecting you.

What you have observed is definitely true, but the reasons why it happens are complicated and numerous and not all bad. I personally missed having male friends when I became a mum, and always reached out to the dads who were regularly in the playground at school. I know it was hard for the stay at home dads and the co-equal dads to feel fully engaged and it's great that you are trying to correct that.

But hang in there, because as your child gets older the other dads will get more involved in their care and you will find it's more of a mixed crowd. By the time you are standing on the touchline watching your daughter play football you'll find both mums and dads on the touchline with you.

Other dads?

I see no indication that this is the first time OP has been affected by sexism.

Localocal · 17/09/2021 11:03

Dear OP, it sounds a Teeny bit like you have just noticed that sexism still exists because all of a sudden it's affecting you.

What you have observed is definitely true, but the reasons why it happens are complicated and numerous and not all bad. I personally missed having male friends when I became a mum, and always reached out to the dads who were regularly in the playground at school. I know it was hard for the stay at home dads and the co-equal dads to feel fully engaged and it's great that you are trying to correct that.

But hang in there, because as your child gets older the other dads will get more involved in their care and you will find it's more of a mixed crowd. By the time you are standing on the touchline watching your daughter play football you'll find both mums and dads on the touchline with you.

crackofdoom · 17/09/2021 10:07

Wow, as a heterosexual mother this thread has really given me an insight into the underlying homophobia still bubbling under in our culture. I guess that’s the thing about baby groups- when all you have in common is having recently given birth, you end up rubbing shoulders with the kind of people you’d never normally associate with. For me it was not having a partner, but it’s clear from this thread that anybody who strays from the traditional norm can receive short shrift in these kinds of groups 🙄

SarahAndQuack · 17/09/2021 08:58

And actually, the OP is the one who feels people are saying she can't be a real mother and they are bordering on homophobia, so I think you are wrong that she fully accepts/agrees with that assessment.

I didn't read her like that - I thought she was simply commenting factually on the way that references to 'the mums' implies she's not a mum?

It was me who said it might be homophobic to distinguish between 'the mums' and the OP, IIRC. I think it is, albeit in a very innocent way.

I see this a lot with adoptive parents too - there are regular threads on here where people talk through the benefits of terms like birth mother or bio mother (rather than 'natural mother,' which some of us grew up knowing as the term).

I don't think it's a bad thing to discuss how terminology might make people feel and I think it is not fair to say if a person is hurt by terminology that excludes them, the problem must be with them.

I do think it's really obvious the OP doesn't want to muscle in on the postpartum mums' group - she's said she's been invited to go but won't.

Finonia · 17/09/2021 07:23

There is always going to be the care provider and the money earner and often it's the Mum that provides the care initially therefore the Mum that goes to the baby groups. In my experience when the other parent is off work we would rather spend time as a family than going to groups, I used to use groups to get me out of the house to have some interaction with people but wouldn't necessarily want to take my partner along if he was free? We have kept in contact with the NCT group and do meet up as a group but it's a once every 6 months kind of thing.

mathanxiety · 17/09/2021 04:17

You refer to the women who have given birth as ‘the mothers’, and define me as a woman who hasn’t gone through what ‘the mothers’ have. This reads as you saying that I’m not a mother and never will be and that lesbians and bi woman whose partners have given birth (and from the sounds of it adoptive mothers too), aren’t or can’t be real mothers because they didn’t give birth. I’m sure you didn’t mean it that way, but the drip drip drip of hearing little things like this as a gay woman add up to what feels like homophobia.

@ParentsandParents
I am truly sorry for coming across that way - it is not my intention to cast aspersions on any mothers who have not given birth or to imply that they are somehow less the real thing than biological mothers. I should have been clearer and used the term 'biological mothers'. However, this has connotations of mothers who placed children for adoption too, so there is a fine line to be trodden when it comes to wording.

mathanxiety · 17/09/2021 04:09

Birthing and non-birthing parents don't have the same experience, and the biological element affects us in very striking ways around childbirth, more than most other things in modern society. That's one of the reasons it can be such a shock to some new mums, they haven't had that before in their lives. Recognizing that and observing it doesn't make people homophobic.

YY to that @LobsterNapkin.

New mothers in our society don't have ancient rituals or rites or the close companionship and help of other women that sustained and honoured women during and after childbirth in former times, and sometimes still do in other societies.

The physical, emotional, and spiritual transformation of a biological mother through pregnancy, childbirth, and the 'fourth trimester' is something society doesn't honour.

It is medicalised and commercialised instead.

DifferentHair · 17/09/2021 03:36

OP, who organised these events?

I'm going to take a wild guess and say it was a woman.

I recommend you do your bit for gender equality by organising your own catch up, instead. You could kick it off by saying you want everyone to mingle, not split into genders.

I don't like it when men complain about gender equality and then stand around waiting for a woman to fix it for them. Hmm

LobsterNapkin · 17/09/2021 02:47

@SarahAndQuack

But, *@LobsterNapkin*, the OP talks repeatedly about that very biological experience and biological difference you are describing?

Why do you think she doesn't get it - just because other posters keep reiterating the point, or because you think if she really truly understood the biological element the way you do, she wouldn't be interested in discussing parenting with both dads and mums any more?

It just seems to me totally natural that all of us, as whatever kinds of parents we are, want to find other people who share our experiences, and we want to be able to chat about them. Why wouldn't the OP feel weird in a situation where she belongs neither with the bio mums who've given birth, nor with the dads, who've not given birth and where those seem to be the only two options.

And actually, the OP is the one who feels people are saying she can't be a real mother and they are bordering on homophobia, so I think you are wrong that she fully accepts/agrees with that assessment.
LobsterNapkin · 17/09/2021 02:42

@SarahAndQuack

But, *@LobsterNapkin*, the OP talks repeatedly about that very biological experience and biological difference you are describing?

Why do you think she doesn't get it - just because other posters keep reiterating the point, or because you think if she really truly understood the biological element the way you do, she wouldn't be interested in discussing parenting with both dads and mums any more?

It just seems to me totally natural that all of us, as whatever kinds of parents we are, want to find other people who share our experiences, and we want to be able to chat about them. Why wouldn't the OP feel weird in a situation where she belongs neither with the bio mums who've given birth, nor with the dads, who've not given birth and where those seem to be the only two options.

Yes, it is natural she feels weird. But there isn't really anything to be done about it. As kids get older it tends to become less of a thing.
amispeakingenglish · 17/09/2021 00:46

The first 3 months of chat were mostly about sharing stories of birth and cracked nipples and discharge coming out of various orifices. That was my experience of why the group naturally went to men and women.

This and the other comments like this. Birth is not something men experience and as it is such a massive thing women like to discuss this with other women.
Accept this and maybe organise some groups yourself OP. You can't be included in everything, give you partner some space to discuss these things with the only people who can understand.

mathanxiety · 17/09/2021 00:40

I often find in a mixed group the men all gravitate towards each other & get panicked if stuck with the ladies.

My observation of several dads in a mixed group was that they gravitated toward the other men and left the 'parenting' of their children to whatever women were there.

Ticksallboxes · 16/09/2021 23:37

My SiL met some nice mums that lived locally through various baby groups when she was on maternity leave. BIL was working FT so didn’t mix with them.

He recently started to want to reach out to other dads, so SiL got the phone numbers of the dads from her friends and BiL created a WhatsApp group and organised a regular football meet-up. He's now made some great friends that he sees regularly.

Football may not be your thing (it's not my DH's!) but you could do similar.

converseandjeans · 16/09/2021 23:37

Some of our group set up 'Dads club' so they could meet up with kids in tow. Ours were slightly younger & DH never really fancied it.

I often find in a mixed group the men all gravitate towards each other & get panicked if stuck with the ladies.

PenelopeW · 16/09/2021 23:30

There is a nice website for dads here:
www.daddilife.com/

MarshmallowX1983 · 16/09/2021 23:08

I have also found that there’s a type of regression of gender roles once you have kids. I used to think that DH and I were quite progressive and equal but it’s felt like they went out the door when we had kids. After 6 years of being a working mum and dealing with mum guilt I recently quit my job and now it feels like the 1950s have truly landed in our house, but at the same time, it’s a huge weight off my shoulders not to have to do all that juggling. I almost think that (gulp) it was easier for women when they just did the house wife thing without it even being questioned…!!!! And then I feel terrible and worry about the example I’m setting for DD… you can’t win.

SarahAndQuack · 16/09/2021 23:00

But, @LobsterNapkin, the OP talks repeatedly about that very biological experience and biological difference you are describing?

Why do you think she doesn't get it - just because other posters keep reiterating the point, or because you think if she really truly understood the biological element the way you do, she wouldn't be interested in discussing parenting with both dads and mums any more?

It just seems to me totally natural that all of us, as whatever kinds of parents we are, want to find other people who share our experiences, and we want to be able to chat about them. Why wouldn't the OP feel weird in a situation where she belongs neither with the bio mums who've given birth, nor with the dads, who've not given birth and where those seem to be the only two options.

LobsterNapkin · 16/09/2021 22:49

I’m sure you probably didn’t mean it this way @mathanxiety and loads of people on this thread have used this form of words too. But it’s a bit upsetting when people say things like “even though you’re a woman, you’re not one who has gone through what the mothers have”. You refer to the women who have given birth as ‘the mothers’, and define me as a woman who hasn’t gone through what ‘the mothers’ have. This reads as you saying that I’m not a mother and never will be and that lesbians and bi woman whose partners have given birth (and from the sounds of it adoptive mothers too), aren’t or can’t be real mothers because they didn’t give birth. I’m sure you didn’t mean it that way, but the drip drip drip of hearing little things like this as a gay woman add up to what feels like homophobia.

Adoptive mothers know that their experiences are different from biological mothers, this is something that is considered important for them to know in the adoption process.

I sometimes get the impression from hearing people talk that people who have kids using reproductive technologies, including gay men and lesbians, don't get this kind of thing stressed in the same way? It seems like there is a lot of effort to say that it's the same, that they are "real" mothers or fathers. I'm not sure how helpful that is in the end.

In the most basic, medical sense, being a mother or father is about reproductive role. "Mothering" or "fathering" in the cultural/relationship sense is derived from the biological one. Even when a non-parent feels parental to an unrelated child, that comes out of the biologically created capacities we all have, which is why we recognize those feelings and the behaviour that comes from them as a kind of parental action, and the effect on the child as being in the same mode. To talk about "real"motherhood really depends on context, it has to or the whole concept loses its meaning. It's real when someone acts as a mother, but being a biological mother is also real, and so is a genetic connection.

Birthing and non-birthing parents don't have the same experience, and the biological element affects us in very striking ways around childbirth, more than most other things in modern society. That's one of the reasons it can be such a shock to some new mums, they haven't had that before in their lives. Recognizing that and observing it doesn't make people homophobic.

CrankyFrankie · 16/09/2021 22:41

Have to admit that I haven’t RTFT but I wanted to comment because I’m sorry you’re feeling alone but I do think the first 6 months to a year of parenthood can leave anyone feeling marooned. My bro did SPL and felt similarly. But I’m just wondering why things are still split along gender lines for you? COVID messed lots up but presumably you’re able to go to groups/classes etc now? The only WhatsApp/Mums-v-dads stuff I’ve participated in was NCT; if I’m at a playgroup, I’ll chat to anyone, swap numbers or whatever. 1-on-1, not groups. NCT is only to get everyone through the first few months alive. You sound awesome by the way!

saggymattress · 16/09/2021 22:39

I've met various Dads at things, a few quite friendly to chat to, but I'd feel uncomfortable to say invite them over so it's just me, the Dad and their DC.

The one Dad that did a shared maternity leave didn't do any groups. I just knew him from the park.

LobsterNapkin · 16/09/2021 22:28

Honestly I don't think this is really about sexism or "regressing."

Part of it is just numbers, there are generally more mothers at some things like toddler groups. And on an individual basis there are some other elements that come into play. Sometimes mums are a little inclined to be wary of men they don't know with their kids, and some may also be wary of pursuing one on one friendships with other men outside of a controlled environment like work.

But I also think this sort of thing, even at couples events, is too common, including among people used to mixed sex environments, to be just random or imposed. I think for a lot of people this is the first time they've encountered really different sex based experiences.

Before I had kids, I was always in very male dominated work environments as well as having mostly male friends. Being a mum was the first time that changed and it did create a new sense of solidarity and shared experience.

I don't think this is something to denigrate. Better to think of it as a good time to learn to appreciate the different vibe of a single sex group, which can be quite enjoyable.

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/09/2021 22:17

You and your wife have plenty of male friends @ParentsandParents, why are you stressing about this?Confused

ParishSpinster · 16/09/2021 21:53

@ParentsandParents you come across like a man in your OP by complaining about the gender divide between parents.

The forcefulness isn't something that is masculine. I know some very forceful women who make others (men and women) uncomfortable by the way they talk and wrote to others.

Tam20779 · 16/09/2021 21:42

I am part of a WhatsApp group set up by another mum from my son’s primary school. It is just mums on that group. Not that dads were not invited, I’m sure if one showed an interest they would have been welcome. The husbands/partners of the group were not the ones who tended to do school runs. It was us mums who formed our little social circle after getting to know each other on the playground. Now our kids have moved on to secondary school. We tried to get dads involved a few times but they just weren’t bothered. It was just one unfortunate truth for us.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 16/09/2021 21:37

suggesting organising a dads group for all the lonely dads to go to the pub. As though these dads couldn’t be friends with women, or make friends with other men in the presence of women
If that's what she meant then she's being ridiculous.
But if she meant the dads may have different experiences from mums that they want to discuss privately then she may be right. I know my DH had conversations with his male friends about role models, about how to parent as a dad, about the patterns they'd witnessed in their dad's behaviours and the ones they wanted to replicate and the ones they didn't.
I don't think it's your job as a mother to organise a dads-only group. They're capable of organising one themselves if they want it.