Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people (especially children) don’t need to be eating constantly?

167 replies

constantlyeating · 15/09/2021 13:01

NC because I am going to get flamed for this.

I’m wondering whether this is why we have an obesity crisis. We are all constantly snacking!

For children it seems to have become: breakfast, morning break snack, school lunch, snack on the way back from school, dinner and then another something before bed— if not more often.

Does anyone have just 3 meals a day anymore? What ever happened to food only being eaten at the table?

OP posts:
MilduraS · 16/09/2021 12:28

It sounds right in theory but I don't think snacking is the problem. More likely a combination of portion sizes and lack of physical activity. When I worked as a nanny in France the children had 3 course lunches at school then had numerous snacks in the park after school followed by a 3 course dinner late in the evening. It sounds like a lot but the portions were small and the 3 courses were to keep their diet varied. The after school snacks were often biscuits and orange juice but I think the rest of their diet balanced it out. I didn't see a single overweight child while I was there.

honeylulu · 16/09/2021 12:07

I think sometimes it’s chicken and egg - kids snack so they eat less at mealtimes so they’re hungry an hour later, so they snack and on it goes

Yes this is certainly true for my youngest who is also a fussy eater. She is always moaning that she is "hungry" and her dad gives in and lets her have a snack despite me saying she should wait sometimes. She can then afford to pick at her meals, eating tiny amounts and not trying new things because she knows she can hold out for the biscuit/banana/scoop of ice cream she will nag her dad for an hour later.

I was much stricter with eldest and husband wasn't as hands on in those days and he is much less fussy and eats substantial meals. (He currently snacks a lot as well but he's a very tall active and skinny teenager!)

BoPeeple · 16/09/2021 11:47

@BoredZelda

The trend I particularly hate is for parents to meet their child after school with a snack in hand. As if they can’t even wait until they get home ffs!

Ever tried doing a 30 minute walk home with a 7 year old with low blood sugar? What difference does it make to your life if other parents choose to give a snack at the school gate?

We’re not designed to do it.

That’s just nonsense. If you snack when hungry, you are far less likely to overeat at mealtimes.

If a child is having a decent-sized packed lunch or hot dinner with plenty of protein then I don’t understand why they should have low blood sugar less than 3 hours later?

And we’re not designed to do it - our mitochondria are designed to have a break from being constantly fuelled. We are designed to eat, get hungry, then eat again, not snack every couple of hours. Three good meals a day with protein, veg and complex carbs should fill kids up for longer than an hour or two.

I think sometimes it’s chicken and egg - kids snack so they eat less at mealtimes so they’re hungry an hour later, so they snack and on it goes…

ASEAskeptic · 16/09/2021 11:39

Like PP I don't think it's how many meals or snacks you eat each day that is definitive. Individuals have very different responses to snacking/fasting/getting hungry; I see it in the differences in my family members. Some get tired, brainfogged, emotional etc if there is too long between eating and blood sugar gets too low, others can go much longer and not experience any change in mood/energy levels. They're eating the same stuff they just process it differently. I really don't think it's a 1 size fits all thing.

QueenofKattegat · 16/09/2021 11:29

Ahh good old Mumsnet. Home of competitive undereating and relentless threads about food and weight and fatties and who is 5 foot 5 and a size 8. It is so utterly tedious.

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 16/09/2021 11:24

Mine don’t always have breakfast. Youngest isn’t really a breakfast person.

We have breakfast
Elevenses (time depends when they were up) or snack at playtime at school usually just food
Lunch
3 oclockses small snack
Dinner
7/8pm supper

Meals aren’t huge although my 11 year old must be having a growth spurt as he’s hungry all the time just now. I think if you’re mindful of what they are having, when they are having it isn’t such a big deal. They don’t just sit and eat all day long. And they don’t always have a snack.

BoredZelda · 16/09/2021 10:51

The trend I particularly hate is for parents to meet their child after school with a snack in hand. As if they can’t even wait until they get home ffs!

Ever tried doing a 30 minute walk home with a 7 year old with low blood sugar? What difference does it make to your life if other parents choose to give a snack at the school gate?

We’re not designed to do it.

That’s just nonsense. If you snack when hungry, you are far less likely to overeat at mealtimes.

BoredZelda · 16/09/2021 10:46

This is not a new thing. 40 years ago the pattern was the same, we had a snack at playtime, and a snack when we came home. The only difference is there are more high calorie, high sugar options available to people nowadays.

Snacking isn’t a bad thing, it depends what you snack on. Having snacks of fruit two or three times a day isn’t unhealthy.

BoPeeple · 16/09/2021 10:17

We KNOW that constant snacking/grazing is bad for us. We’re not designed to do it. My kids have always had three meals a day and only have snacks if they’re really hungry and it’s admittedly been a long time since lunch/breakfast. Other parents think I’m weird!

The trend I particularly hate is for parents to meet their child after school with a snack in hand. As if they can’t even wait until they get home ffs!

SafeMove · 16/09/2021 09:20

@itsgettingwierd - it will be the norethisterone. Do you have endo/adenomyosis or fibroids? I have all 3 and even though I fast 18:6, don't eat puddings and walk up mountains i am stuck at 10.5 stone. If you are oestrogen dominant weight gain/loss is a constant battle, especially if you are taking hormone therapy. I went from 9.5 stone to 11 stone on the merina and then norethisterone. In all the endo support groups I am on, women report the same.

itsgettingwierd · 16/09/2021 08:03

Could be.

But I only eat 3 meals a day and walk a lot.

I'm still fat Confused

I have porridge or crumpets for breakfast or a banana.

Homemade soup, fruit and yoghurt for lunch.

Dinner is always healthy but really varies and is always a small portion.

I'd hate to think if I added snacks what my weight would be.

I'm desperate to lose it and really trying hard but I'm just not. I do wonder if the fact I'm on daily northisterone is affecting this.

onelittlefrog · 16/09/2021 07:57

I can see what you're saying but sometimes there is a long time between meals. A lot of the general advice for a healthy lifestyle states that it's good to eat regularly, but less. So "grazing" is actually pretty healthy if you are eating healthy foods and not too much of them.

If you have lunch at 12.30 and dinner at 7.30 that's 7 hours without eating anything, which is actually quite a long time if you are physically active or busy doing a lot.

A healthy snack between those two meals isn't going to cause obesity.

Mindlessly eating crisps and chocolate would.

There's a balance but there is with meals as well, which for some people are carb and fat heavy and bigger than we need.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 16/09/2021 07:41

@Kanaloa

I don’t know why people act like this is a brand new thing that just started in recent years.

When I was a kid it was

Breakfast - sugary cereal
Play piece at school - crisps and fruit shoot
Lunch - school lunch
Dinner - something chips and beans
Supper - tea and toast, usually with jam

My kids eat way healthier than I did, and so do the majority of children I know. The biggest difference is that my kids walk less/play out less. Their exercise is mainly coming from extra curricular clubs, and a lot of children in my area don’t do sports clubs/activities.

You don't say how old you are but you mention having 'fruit shoots' when you were at school, so your childhood can't have been that long ago.
Brokensunflower · 16/09/2021 07:39

I don't think a couple of structured snacks is inherently a problem. Especially if it's fruit or veg say mid morning and mid afternoon and part of a routine. What is very problematic is kids that say "I'm hungry" and have access to food every time. They never learn to be a bit hungry. I also hate seeing children in pushchairs with food or children walking along with their hands stuffed in crisp packets. I also hate seeing kids being fed just to keep them quiet.

The constant mindless eating is definitely a major problem with childhood obesity.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 16/09/2021 07:39

@BogRollBOGOF

Grazing is the issue rather than a planned, concious snack/ light meal.

It is easy to sink into a cycle of eating something that causes a spike and crash in blood sugars then repeating through the day.

Yes. There used to be conscious, planned snacks - 'elevenses' (mid-morning) and 'supper' (in the sense of something light before bed, not the modern use as an informal evening meal). These have been replaced by grazing.
Underamour · 16/09/2021 07:35

I got gut inflammation and bloating suddenly at 40. I have cured it by fasting all day. I can’t say that I am much thinner but much healthier and happier for it. Doctoes even recommend 800 cal diets for curing illnesses such as diabetes. So for me, not eating is great. The kids however, are skinny with high metabolism and need to eat every few hours or they feel tired and hungry. So, I can see every point of view. Personally, I don’t see myself ever going back to three meals a day and snacks. It’s so much food!

kinzarose · 16/09/2021 07:24

I consider us to have a really good diet but one of my dc had to see a dietician due to underlying health condition and we had to do a food diary. She thought it was weird that we didn't have 'afters' after every meal!

SafeMove · 16/09/2021 06:37

@Anotherbrokenairer no, it's fine. So between 2013-19 I was a lone parent of 3dc with no maintenance coming in due to abusive exH and we were homeless twice due to crappy rentals. Me and the kids had to sleep on mattresses on my parents floor and then a friend's floor in one bedroom for a couple of months each time. I worked PT because DD was a toddler so was on a low income, then got made redundant in 2015, so decided to study for an MSc and had x2 min wage, zero hours contract jobs that only gave me between 16-20 hours per week work but were so variable.

This was the worst time, we had to use food banks and my MH was on the floor due to a court case. Then I got a FT job in 2017 but it had to support the four of us (me and 3DC), and tax credits reduced and I was paying off my masters, so wasn't much better off tbh. In late 2018 I met DP, went to a two income household in 2019, got a big promotion in 2020, DP got a promotion beginning of 2021 so our income is now 70k and we have just bought a house together. Even yesterday the DC were talking about how in one of the crappy, tiny rental houses we never had food in the fridge. Food scarcity is a thing in this country. I went from a middle class income marriage, big house etc, to leaving with a broken jaw, about 6 years of being very poor, to returning to the middle class income, decent house etc. It can happen so easily and life feels very precarious tbh. I don't think I'll ever rest on my laurels. I just feel terrible I dragged the DC through it Sad

YourFinestPantaloons · 16/09/2021 01:28

YANBU.

We went away with another family in the summer and I was Shock at how often their kids ate. A snack would be a jacket potato, tin of pasta shapes, a couple of sandwiches or similar! Day consisted of:

Breakfast
Post-breakfast snack
Brunch of some sort
Lunch
Early afternoon snack
Late afternoon snack
Dinner
Post dinner snack
Supper

They also obsessed about about the kids being hungry and if I had a pound for every time they said "you kids must be starving" I could she paid for the holiday

I'm no perfect parent but so many people don't seem to understand what a healthy relationship with food looks like. And these people have kids and pass those bad habits on to them

Gothichouse40 · 16/09/2021 01:24

I think it's the increase in eating takeaway meals. This now seems to be normal whereas we had them as a treat/special occasion. No one seems to cook from fresh anymore and this is not a judgement. I was a young mum once, I appreciate many people may not have the time to cook with demanding jobs, after-school clubs etc. Ive got to confess, Im not a great fruit eater, prefer vegetables.

Notimeforaname · 16/09/2021 01:19

Pre school I worked at in france only gave lunch at 11am and then a snack at 3pm.
For the slightly older kids it was midday and 4pm.

Majority of those children arrived between 7.30am -8.30am and didn't get home til 6-7pm in evenings.

I'm hard pressed to remember even a handful of children /adults who were overweight there. This is of course only my experience in one setting but it must be correlated.

Kanaloa · 16/09/2021 00:54

Although I’m not that bothered if other kids snack really. Encourage mine to eat healthily and I don’t snack much myself, but people do what works for them. Some people will have healthy snacks and be a healthy weight, others will not snack but have unhealthy meals and be fat.

Kanaloa · 16/09/2021 00:52

I don’t know why people act like this is a brand new thing that just started in recent years.

When I was a kid it was

Breakfast - sugary cereal
Play piece at school - crisps and fruit shoot
Lunch - school lunch
Dinner - something chips and beans
Supper - tea and toast, usually with jam

My kids eat way healthier than I did, and so do the majority of children I know. The biggest difference is that my kids walk less/play out less. Their exercise is mainly coming from extra curricular clubs, and a lot of children in my area don’t do sports clubs/activities.

QueenofDestruction · 16/09/2021 00:33

I remember growing up in the 80s and had 3 meals a day, if I was hungry in between I was pointed to the fruit bowl. On weekends we were allowed a chocolate and 1 packet of crisps as a treat. In school my lunchbox had a sandwich, a fruit and juice. This was similar to most if my friends and we were all skinny.Breakfast was egg on toast or porridge and dinner was usually meat, 2 veg and a starch.

Things like ice creams, takeaways were very rare treats maybe 6 times a year and food was all cooked from scratch.No snacking except for fruit and if you were really lucky a yoghurt.

Bobsyer · 16/09/2021 00:16

I disagree. Because I think it’s particularly adults that don’t need to continually snack.

Some kids too, of course, but I have one kid who would constantly nibble on fruit and veg and have smaller meals if he could - he’s slightly underweight.

No adult that isn’t a pro athlete needs to though.