Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:07

How much of any of those things do you think OP's nine-year-old child possesses? Because that's who's being told to teach here

Probably virtually none - which is perfectly normal for 9 year olds.

doadeer · 16/09/2021 19:07

This was the case when I was at school 15 years ago. Pretty standard. I think teaching others is good actually and gaining empathy that not everyone finds everything easy.

Lovely13 · 16/09/2021 19:06

Remember a school friend explaining algebra to me while waiting for the train home. She was brilliant. But that was optional help from her. Not enforced in classroom.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:05

@yodaforpresident

There were such high hopes for mastery but the main problem is that it just isn’t taught properly - Singapore invests a lot in teacher development - something that never happened here. It was just another supposed ‘easy fix’ for the generally woeful maths teaching approach in this country.
I absolutely agree. It always comes back to money, and education always being seen as the poor relation by the government.
PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 19:05

@peaceanddove

Or any experience of having learn teaching techniques or child psychology or theories of how children learn

Yep. Or patience or much in the way of empathy or any subtly whatsoever.

How much of any of those things do you think OP's nine-year-old child possesses? Because that's who's being told to teach here.
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:04

Where have I said that Jaxxon is a waste of everyone's time in the classroom? God knows, he needs to be in the classroom as much as humanly possible. But it's not another child's responsibility to enhance and encourage his learning.

yodaforpresident · 16/09/2021 19:04

There were such high hopes for mastery but the main problem is that it just isn’t taught properly - Singapore invests a lot in teacher development - something that never happened here. It was just another supposed ‘easy fix’ for the generally woeful maths teaching approach in this country.

Gingerandlemont · 16/09/2021 19:03

YANBU - unfair on your kid who obviously needs to be stretched more. And a bit humiliating for the other kid - having to have his peer explain it to him everytime. Very damaging for his self esteem. No wonder both are frustrated.

Maybe there is a subtle way to do it - ie they have a group exercise to do “together” as a team. But not every time.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:03

@PurpleOkapi

No. You’ve misunderstood what peer collaboration is.

It’s not for the benefit of the one being ‘taught’, it’s not to help the lower ability kids. It’s to help the kid doing the ‘teaching’ - because it helps them consolidate knowledge, it helps them reframe knowledge and it helps them reimagine known concepts. It also has loads of other benefits, like increased vocabulary, communication skills, empathy, community spirit.

If you want to relabel classroom instruction as "collaboration," fine, but that doesn't change the fact that what's being described here is one student being ordered to teach another. If it were truly intended to benefit the student (rather than for the convenience of the teacher), then the teacher would give all students equal opportunities to do it, and would monitor their performance as instructors so that she could give them useful feedback. It's not a coincidence here that 1) none of that is happening, and 2) the "collaboration" involves things that the teacher would have to do herself if she couldn't make the student do it instead.

Just telling a student to achieve an outcome, then paying no attention whatsoever to how they go about it or whether they succeed, isn't teaching them how to do it. At best, it's expecting them to teach themselves. At worst, it's taking advantage of knowledge they're assumed (perhaps incorrectly) to already have, for the benefit of the teacher rather than the student. That would be true if you just handed them a math worksheet consisting of problems they'd never been told how to do, and it's equally true of ordering them to teach others when they've never been instructed on how to do that.

It doesn’t sound like it’s being managed well in the OP’s son’s classroom, no.

But just to be clear, peer collaboration isn’t one kid teaching another. That’s not correct.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:01

Or any experience of having learn teaching techniques or child psychology or theories of how children learn

Yep. Or patience or much in the way of empathy or any subtly whatsoever.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:01

@peaceanddove

they’re deepening their knowledge while Jaxxon is picking up vocabulary (and his nose).

Except it's highly unlikely that Jaxxon is actually picking up any new vocabulary. All he is hearing are weird words that he doesn't know the meaning of and isn't interested in learning.

I know Jaxxon is invented, Peace, but a lot of your comments are flying a bit close to disablist. There will be a lot of people on here whose kids will be at Fake-Jaxxon’s level so maybe have a think about that before telling everyone that sort of presence is a waste of everyone’s time in a classroom.

Please spare me the ‘oh now I’m getting told off for being disablist against an imaginary kid’ chat, I think it’s fairly obvious that’s not my point.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 19:00

No. You’ve misunderstood what peer collaboration is.

It’s not for the benefit of the one being ‘taught’, it’s not to help the lower ability kids. It’s to help the kid doing the ‘teaching’ - because it helps them consolidate knowledge, it helps them reframe knowledge and it helps them reimagine known concepts. It also has loads of other benefits, like increased vocabulary, communication skills, empathy, community spirit.

If you want to relabel classroom instruction as "collaboration," fine, but that doesn't change the fact that what's being described here is one student being ordered to teach another. If it were truly intended to benefit the student (rather than for the convenience of the teacher), then the teacher would give all students equal opportunities to do it, and would monitor their performance as instructors so that she could give them useful feedback. It's not a coincidence here that 1) none of that is happening, and 2) the "collaboration" involves things that the teacher would have to do herself if she couldn't make the student do it instead.

Just telling a student to achieve an outcome, then paying no attention whatsoever to how they go about it or whether they succeed, isn't teaching them how to do it. At best, it's expecting them to teach themselves. At worst, it's taking advantage of knowledge they're assumed (perhaps incorrectly) to already have, for the benefit of the teacher rather than the student. That would be true if you just handed them a math worksheet consisting of problems they'd never been told how to do, and it's equally true of ordering them to teach others when they've never been instructed on how to do that.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:58

they’re deepening their knowledge while Jaxxon is picking up vocabulary (and his nose).

Except it's highly unlikely that Jaxxon is actually picking up any new vocabulary. All he is hearing are weird words that he doesn't know the meaning of and isn't interested in learning.

Holskey · 16/09/2021 18:57

@PurpleOkapi

I wouldn't alter my practice because of the opinion of an anonymous mnetter who went to school decades ago and has decided peer collaboration has no value in general.

The situation being described isn't peer collaboration, or any kind of collaboration. It's the teacher ordering one student who understands the material to teach it to another who doesn't. The only thing they're "collaborating" on is the completion of the second student's worksheet that he was supposed to be doing himself in the first place.

@purpleokapi Agreed. My first comment way back on page 3:

I'm a teacher. Getting students to teach each other is pretty much gold standard if done correctly. Your child's teacher isn't doing it correctly because:
it's always one way;
it's always the same child;
the students aren't engaged or on board;
and it's always the same, boring routine which is too general ("help Ben finish" is a crap instruction)

It's a lazy application of a very valuable and useful concept. And your child's teacher should ensure your ds knows he is not responsible for this other child's work or behaviour!

Since then, there has been a lot of nonsense talked about how children should only be taught by the teacher, private schools wouldn't allow children to teach other (they do!) etc. etc.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:56

@yodaforpresident

Singapore has a G&T programme for children identified as being in the top 1% academically, so even they understand that some children need more from school than mastery.
‘Even they’ 😂😂😂
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:56

@peaceanddove

It would be very interesting to see how well Singapore continued to do at maths if suddenly the fear generated by the cane was removed and their school day was reduced to 5.5 hours with no extra tuition.
Do you think they would change their teaching methods?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 18:55

Yes, absolutely. Most 10 year olds aren't known for their tact and diplomacy.

Or any experience of having learn teaching techniques or child psychology or theories of how children learn.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:54

It would be very interesting to see how well Singapore continued to do at maths if suddenly the fear generated by the cane was removed and their school day was reduced to 5.5 hours with no extra tuition.

RantyAunty · 16/09/2021 18:52

Maybe once a week would be ok but not all the time.
A misbehaving child isn't your DS's responsibility.

The last time I went back to uni, nearly every class was this bs. Grading each other's work. Lots of group projects. Hated it. It usually ended up with the slackers getting a free ride.

yodaforpresident · 16/09/2021 18:51

Singapore has a G&T programme for children identified as being in the top 1% academically, so even they understand that some children need more from school than mastery.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 18:50

@traumatisednoodle

What the Jaxxons of this world need is almost certainly more small group or one to one support, revisiting concepts, possibly visual aids. What he doesn't need is clever cloggs Dd saying " but WHY don't you understand? it's easy, look I told you before, why can't you remember?"
Yep.

In all the places peer support is not likely to work is primary school.

But if course it’s all for the benefit of the learning mentor according to some - they’re deepening their knowledge while Jaxxon is picking up vocabulary (and his nose).

Morgysmum · 16/09/2021 18:47

I know how you ate feeling, my son also got landed with that roll, he is very good at maths, so seems to get roped into helping friends. I don't know if he does it as a role, or more that anyone on his table, needs a hand they ask my son.
It's does annoy him as, they don't always ask when he has finished. So he goes I am trying to do my work and there's. I did tell him, to get his friends to ask the teacher not him for help.
But in your sons case, it sounds like this child has some learning difficulties. That need to be picked up by a teacher.
I would speak to his teacher and say, what your son has said about this other child, maybe say its putting your child off wanting to go to school, as he doesn't want to tutor this other kid (small white lie,) but it might get them rethinking the idea. It's OK if like my son, someone asks for help, as he can say no, but in your sons situation, he doesn't seem to have a choice.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:46

@traumatisednoodle

What the Jaxxons of this world need is almost certainly more small group or one to one support, revisiting concepts, possibly visual aids. What he doesn't need is clever cloggs Dd saying " but WHY don't you understand? it's easy, look I told you before, why can't you remember?"
Yes, absolutely. Most 10 year olds aren't known for their tact and diplomacy.
ThePluckOfTheCoward · 16/09/2021 18:45

I think it is inappropriate for a 9 year old to be used as an unpaid teaching assistant on a regular basis.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:45

@traumatisednoodle

What the Jaxxons of this world need is almost certainly more small group or one to one support, revisiting concepts, possibly visual aids. What he doesn't need is clever cloggs Dd saying " but WHY don't you understand? it's easy, look I told you before, why can't you remember?"
All of that, as well as our old friend, peer support.