Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:50

@NumberTheory well, obviously he should be. He should be being told that calling someone stupid is not how we speak to each other. I don’t know what you mean about the deep end.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:49

@mathanxiety

If I were the parent of the lower ability child I would be horrified that the lazy teacher had palmed off the responsibility of teaching my child on a classmate.
What would you do about it?
NumberTheory · 16/09/2021 19:49

@Pumperthepumper

How much of any of those things do you think OP's nine-year-old child possesses? Because that's who's being told to teach here.

But if he doesn’t have patience, or empathy or subtly or tact, what better way is there for him to learn these skills?

This is a terrible way for him to learn these skills because he's not getting any instruction or feedback on how to develop them. There is no "winning" in this scenario as the OP has described it for either child.

Simply dropping people in at the deep end is not a great way for most to learn.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:47

@Pumperthepumper

Its difficult to answer this post, because that’s still fundamentally misunderstanding the basis of peer support.

He’s not teaching anyone. Nobody expects or wants him to morph into a master teacher. He’s not responsible for the other kid learning. He’s explaining what he understands to another kid to consolidate his knowledge. That’s it. He could just as easily consolidate his knowledge to a wall, expect then he’d miss the opportunity to use new vocabulary and all the rest. Again: he’s not supposed to be teaching anyone anything. He’s not a teacher, nobody wants or expects him to be. He’s not teaching. Not a teacher. Not trying to be.

How do you think the other child will feel when OP's child says things like "Why are you so stupid?" or "I'm tired of doing this for you! I hate you!" If he is speaking like this to another member of his class, that’s a classroom management issue. That’s not a failure of peer support, it’s a failure of classroom management.

because nothing about this activity appears calculated to achieve anything other than a reduced workload for the teacher. This is genuinely really funny, a few people have said this. I promise, it’s much, much more work to set up and monitor peer support. Do you know what would massively reduce workload for teachers? Worksheets. And that’s funny, because that’s what so many people on here think is a better idea than peer support!

Sorry, that was to @PurpleOkapi
mathanxiety · 16/09/2021 19:47

@Coronawireless, no, bright students do not 'self extend', not in school anyway, without encouragement and facilitation from teachers.

Nor should they be expected to do this on their own. The teacher is there to teach every child, and if unable to do that for whatever reason, they should admit their incompetence and get into some other line of work.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:46

Its difficult to answer this post, because that’s still fundamentally misunderstanding the basis of peer support.

He’s not teaching anyone. Nobody expects or wants him to morph into a master teacher. He’s not responsible for the other kid learning. He’s explaining what he understands to another kid to consolidate his knowledge. That’s it. He could just as easily consolidate his knowledge to a wall, expect then he’d miss the opportunity to use new vocabulary and all the rest. Again: he’s not supposed to be teaching anyone anything. He’s not a teacher, nobody wants or expects him to be. He’s not teaching. Not a teacher. Not trying to be.

How do you think the other child will feel when OP's child says things like "Why are you so stupid?" or "I'm tired of doing this for you! I hate you!" If he is speaking like this to another member of his class, that’s a classroom management issue. That’s not a failure of peer support, it’s a failure of classroom management.

because nothing about this activity appears calculated to achieve anything other than a reduced workload for the teacher. This is genuinely really funny, a few people have said this. I promise, it’s much, much more work to set up and monitor peer support. Do you know what would massively reduce workload for teachers? Worksheets. And that’s funny, because that’s what so many people on here think is a better idea than peer support!

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:43

*That’s actually laughable - you brought up the league table. You did. Because you wanted to have a go, and it backfired.

When did I say a poster’s DH wasn’t as good at maths as they thought they were? Could you quote that? I’ll wait.

I absolutely did say that about your daughter, and I meant it. If she sat and listened to a teacher and then filled in a worksheet for the entirety of her education - which you said was true - she’s not nearly as good at maths as you think she is.

Slag off Jaxxon as much as you like then. Go ahead. Let’s hear more about how the Jaxxons of the world are holding your daughter back*

I think I will leave this here. You are deliberately mis-reading and misinterpreting my posts to the extent that I don't think you're perhaps entirely rational on here. I'm not the one who has had numerous posts deleted because of their offensive content.

So, I'm slowly backing away from you and the thread without making any sudden moves or any eye contact. Bye.

mathanxiety · 16/09/2021 19:42

If I were the parent of the lower ability child I would be horrified that the lazy teacher had palmed off the responsibility of teaching my child on a classmate.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 19:39

@Pumperthepumper

How much of any of those things do you think OP's nine-year-old child possesses? Because that's who's being told to teach here.

But if he doesn’t have patience, or empathy or subtly or tact, what better way is there for him to learn these skills?

Maybe by being instructed on the importance of them and given a supervised opportunity to develop them without harming others, rather than being flung into a situation where they might be helpful and hoping he spontaneously masters them all by himself, potentially at great cost to another child. Those skills are equally important for all children, not just the academically successful ones, so anything intended to develop them shouldn't be limited to academically successful children while those who are academically slower are excluded, as is the case here.

Let's suppose for the sake of argument that OP's nine-year-old doesn't magically morph into a master teacher who's the epitome of empathy, patience, and tact. Let's suppose he doesn't particularly like the child he's supposed to be helping, and resents being ordered to serve him (and the teacher) in this way. Let's further suppose that resentment is apparent to the other child. None of this would be at all surprising for nine-year-old. How do you think the other child will feel when OP's child says things like "Why are you so stupid?" or "I'm tired of doing this for you! I hate you!"

I'm all for teaching children about empathy, even-handedly. I'm strongly opposed to this hamfisted attempt to prod some children into spontaneously developing empathy while using other, more vulnerable, children as props to be abused as needed in pursuit of that goal. I'm also very sceptical that that's actually what's happening here, because nothing about this activity appears calculated to achieve anything other than a reduced workload for the teacher.

LimitIsUp · 16/09/2021 19:34

Her confidence is improving now, mercifully

LimitIsUp · 16/09/2021 19:32

Thank you Smile

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:32

@LimitIsUp

Dyslexia has affected her confidence though 🙁
Ah that’s less good then. Dyslexia has historically been very poorly handled by schools, although it is getting better. Are there any groups online she can join? That might help, if she can speak to others who understand?
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:31

@LimitIsUp

19 now

She went to private school for secondary education (because I had zero confidence in state education for spLD) and was taught in classes of fewer than 15. She got great GCSEs and good (but not stellar) A levels (A,B,C)

That’s great, smaller class sizes are always beneficial. Glad it worked out for her Flowers
LimitIsUp · 16/09/2021 19:31

Dyslexia has affected her confidence though 🙁

LimitIsUp · 16/09/2021 19:29

19 now

She went to private school for secondary education (because I had zero confidence in state education for spLD) and was taught in classes of fewer than 15. She got great GCSEs and good (but not stellar) A levels (A,B,C)

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:26

@LimitIsUp

I feel sorry for the poor boy who has to be helped by a fellow pupil rather than by the teacher or TA. It's wholly inappropriate

My dyslexic dd was subjected to 'help' in year 5. The little charmer red penned her spelling errors underlining them several times and threw in some exclamation marks (obviously deeply shocked at her illiteracy)

I spoke to the teacher the next day and was quite forthright (she apologised and the arrangement stopped)

How old is your daughter now, is she getting better assistance for the dyslexia?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 19:25

@LimitIsUp

I feel sorry for the poor boy who has to be helped by a fellow pupil rather than by the teacher or TA. It's wholly inappropriate

My dyslexic dd was subjected to 'help' in year 5. The little charmer red penned her spelling errors underlining them several times and threw in some exclamation marks (obviously deeply shocked at her illiteracy)

I spoke to the teacher the next day and was quite forthright (she apologised and the arrangement stopped)

Such a good case in point about lack of tact and teacher training.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 19:23

Let’s hear more about how the Jaxxons of the world are holding your daughter back.

What has been said repeatedly is that both sides are being held back.

That Jaxxon needs proper teaching not random parlay from a more accomplished peer who is ‘deepening their knowledge’ at his expense.
And being upset like the boy in the OP who ‘doesn’t get it’.

That’s a demoralising school experience.

LimitIsUp · 16/09/2021 19:21

I feel sorry for the poor boy who has to be helped by a fellow pupil rather than by the teacher or TA. It's wholly inappropriate

My dyslexic dd was subjected to 'help' in year 5. The little charmer red penned her spelling errors underlining them several times and threw in some exclamation marks (obviously deeply shocked at her illiteracy)

I spoke to the teacher the next day and was quite forthright (she apologised and the arrangement stopped)

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:18

@peaceanddove

And are you going to 'think about' how you have stated that my DD2 or another poster's DH aren't nearly as good at maths as they think they are? Or bluntly telling other poster's that they're wrong? Or the other insults in your posts that MNHQ had to delete?

Because I don't think you actually give a toss about how the pseudo parents of the pseudo Jaxxon's feel. I think your losing your argument on why Singapore is so great at maths (not so much mastery and peer teaching, more the terror of being caned and the 14 hour school days) and so you're now trying for a desperate lunge at the moral high ground in order to score points.

That’s actually laughable - you brought up the league table. You did. Because you wanted to have a go, and it backfired.

When did I say a poster’s DH wasn’t as good at maths as they thought they were? Could you quote that? I’ll wait.

I absolutely did say that about your daughter, and I meant it. If she sat and listened to a teacher and then filled in a worksheet for the entirety of her education - which you said was true - she’s not nearly as good at maths as you think she is.

Slag off Jaxxon as much as you like then. Go ahead. Let’s hear more about how the Jaxxons of the world are holding your daughter back.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:15

Argh, Jaxxons plural, and you're not your. Bloody autocorrect.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 19:14

But if he doesn’t have patience, or empathy or subtly or tact, what better way is there for him to learn these skills?

That’s assuming that he is learning them, he may be learning something else you didn’t intend.

The better way would be life experience- these are all attributes that come with age (and training.)

I don’t really see why he should learn these at Jaxxon’s expense.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 19:14

And are you going to 'think about' how you have stated that my DD2 or another poster's DH aren't nearly as good at maths as they think they are? Or bluntly telling other poster's that they're wrong? Or the other insults in your posts that MNHQ had to delete?

Because I don't think you actually give a toss about how the pseudo parents of the pseudo Jaxxon's feel. I think your losing your argument on why Singapore is so great at maths (not so much mastery and peer teaching, more the terror of being caned and the 14 hour school days) and so you're now trying for a desperate lunge at the moral high ground in order to score points.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:09

How much of any of those things do you think OP's nine-year-old child possesses? Because that's who's being told to teach here.

But if he doesn’t have patience, or empathy or subtly or tact, what better way is there for him to learn these skills?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:07

@peaceanddove

Where have I said that Jaxxon is a waste of everyone's time in the classroom? God knows, he needs to be in the classroom as much as humanly possible. But it's not another child's responsibility to enhance and encourage his learning.
You’ve repeatedly said statements, as above that he’s not getting anything out of it because he doesn’t understand, and it’s all weird words to him. It’s not true. I’m just asking you to think of people on here who’s kids are level with Jaxxon, that’s all.
Swipe left for the next trending thread