Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
thenovice · 16/09/2021 21:01

ones not one's

thenovice · 16/09/2021 21:01

Because the clever kids are continually interrupted by the one's who can't or don't want to do the work.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 21:00

@bellie710

Our school have a ridiculous 3 before me rule, you have to ask 3 children in the class first before you are allowed to ask the teacher!

It is so unfair on the clever kids in the class as they never get time to do their own work.

I quite like this! Why don’t you like it?
iloveruby · 16/09/2021 20:59

@bellie710

Our school have a ridiculous 3 before me rule, you have to ask 3 children in the class first before you are allowed to ask the teacher!

It is so unfair on the clever kids in the class as they never get time to do their own work.

That is appalling!! I would definitely complain if I were you.
thenovice · 16/09/2021 20:58

ALL THE TIME. My DD2 finishes her work quickly and then has to spend her time helping another kid who can't do stuff. It's unfair on her and unfair on him.
She is also put as a human shield between 2 warring boys to try to keep them in order. If she is hit by one of the boys (a trouble-maker who arrived from another local school in Y5) the teacher tells her that "its just his way" and he should be left to calm down. He is never told off and she is never defended. When she hit back once, she was severely told off but he was not. Since the boy arrived, the girls have been stopped from playing football because he is violent towards them. But he gets to play football. I am so looking forward to her leaving. The school is full of weak teachers who leave the kids to do their work for them.

bellie710 · 16/09/2021 20:56

Our school have a ridiculous 3 before me rule, you have to ask 3 children in the class first before you are allowed to ask the teacher!

It is so unfair on the clever kids in the class as they never get time to do their own work.

Bleachmycloths · 16/09/2021 20:54

@Bimblybomeyelash

I’m not necessarily a fan of ‘extension work’ when tasks are completed. If a child is completing their work more quickly, then they should be getting more challenging work to start off with, not just MORE work. So I’d question if your child is being stretched and challenged sufficiently if he is always finishing ahead of others.
I’m a teacher. Extension work should not just be ‘more of the same.’ It should be more difficult, challenging work designed to widen and deepen a child’s knowledge and skills. Extension tasks ought to be built into good schemes of work. This is what OP’s son is missing out on. I would advise OP to speak to the teacher, have a discussion and request that her son gets extension tasks before being asked to help another child.
CaptainNelson · 16/09/2021 20:30

This happened to my DS in primary school, but only once he got to Y6 ... before that, he'd be given extension work. Come Y6, and suddenly he's helping his friend, who happened to also be dyslexic (yes, I know - more and more inappropriate) to complete his English.
In secondary, they've just reorganised the whole year, so apart from maths, science and computing, where they're in sets, he's now in a class (Y9) with people who, according to him, think Asia is a country and don't know where India is. The girl next to him apparently spends most of the lesson drawing pictures around the heading in her book. I'm in favour of mixed ability teaching, but I do wonder about some kids' attitude to learning

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 20:28

@ostravagirl

I just asked my 9yo (Year 5) about it and he told me that he often has to help other classmates when he has finished work. Apparently he is OK about it sometimes but not always and would prefer to get some extension or read when he has finished. It also bugs him when some of the children keep calling "child's name! child's name"! come and help!". He said that last year his teacher was better as she had extension at hand for him but this year not so much. So it obviously depends on a teacher. sigh*
This is definitely something you should take up with the school. They’re doing it wrong.
ostravagirl · 16/09/2021 20:27

I just asked my 9yo (Year 5) about it and he told me that he often has to help other classmates when he has finished work. Apparently he is OK about it sometimes but not always and would prefer to get some extension or read when he has finished. It also bugs him when some of the children keep calling "child's name! child's name"! come and help!". He said that last year his teacher was better as she had extension at hand for him but this year not so much. So it obviously depends on a teacher. sigh*

Horst · 16/09/2021 20:16

I’ve read mastery so many times I’m expecting Harry Potter to appear any moment.

What we all need is smaller class sizes, more ta’s and effective punishment/help depending for bad behaviour disrupting lessons, and extra work set for those how have finished and are bored and thus start acting up.

We are lucky in our primary we have a lot of ta’s and we take in multiple trainee teachers every year but we still have class size issues and lack of control over disruptive lessons. We however again do have a local secondary school that’s a only 20 per class school so hopefully the tide will turn.

Empressofthemundane · 16/09/2021 20:16

This is what happens in primary schools as the children get older. The gap between the most and least able widens considerably. The poor teacher with 30 students juggle tries deal with outliers on both sides of the spectrum by matching them up, to entertain each other while she gets on with the large chunk in the middle.
In the best case the more academically able child learns more deeply by explaining the topic, and learns about helping others. While, the less able child at least gets some peer support.
In the worst case, the most able child feels a responsibility beyond what he can handle or deliver, while not being stretched himself, and the less able child feels humiliated by being singled out and but below another child in front of the class.

Mixed ability classes of 30+ children in junior schools just aren’t reasonable.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 20:13

@GrannyRose15

This was common practice when I was child 60 years ago. Although I didn't relish having to help John with his reading I did learn from it. I have spent my adult life teaching children like John to read and always have the satisfaction of knowing that John and I both got into grammar school when we were 11.
Ahh, that is a lovely story!
lemonadecar · 16/09/2021 20:12

@grannyrose that's a lush story! Well done

cabbageking · 16/09/2021 20:12

Peer support is appropriate when it benefits both students.

Sometimes it is useful and sometimes not

GrannyRose15 · 16/09/2021 20:10

This was common practice when I was child 60 years ago. Although I didn't relish having to help John with his reading I did learn from it. I have spent my adult life teaching children like John to read and always have the satisfaction of knowing that John and I both got into grammar school when we were 11.

Tiredtiredtired100 · 16/09/2021 20:08

I am teacher and never set this as extension work, it was common practice during my education in the 90s but when I trained as a teacher we were categorically told this was not appropriate as it held back more able children rather than challenging them. I didn’t really need to be told that though, as I had spent most of my school life doing other peoples work for them once I had finished.

lemonadecar · 16/09/2021 20:04

I was always made to do this at school and I hated and resented it.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 20:02

@Pumperthepumper

Its difficult to answer this post, because that’s still fundamentally misunderstanding the basis of peer support.

He’s not teaching anyone. Nobody expects or wants him to morph into a master teacher. He’s not responsible for the other kid learning. He’s explaining what he understands to another kid to consolidate his knowledge. That’s it. He could just as easily consolidate his knowledge to a wall, expect then he’d miss the opportunity to use new vocabulary and all the rest. Again: he’s not supposed to be teaching anyone anything. He’s not a teacher, nobody wants or expects him to be. He’s not teaching. Not a teacher. Not trying to be.

How do you think the other child will feel when OP's child says things like "Why are you so stupid?" or "I'm tired of doing this for you! I hate you!" If he is speaking like this to another member of his class, that’s a classroom management issue. That’s not a failure of peer support, it’s a failure of classroom management.

because nothing about this activity appears calculated to achieve anything other than a reduced workload for the teacher. This is genuinely really funny, a few people have said this. I promise, it’s much, much more work to set up and monitor peer support. Do you know what would massively reduce workload for teachers? Worksheets. And that’s funny, because that’s what so many people on here think is a better idea than peer support!

Maybe someone should tell OP's child that that's what he's supposed to be doing, because OP seems to think he's supposed to be teaching the other child and helping him do the work. If someone is given the title of "learning mentor" and told to "help" their classmate, most people would understand that to mean that the purpose of the activity is for their classmates to learn the material, not for them to learn to teach or develop empathy. If the purpose was for OP's child to consolidate his knowledge, then the instructions should have been something like "Tell Johnny about what you learned today," not "help Johnny finish his worksheet." Those are commands to do two very different actions.

Of course it's a classroom management issue. Putting a child in a situation where he's been told to do something he doesn't know how to do, and by rights shouldn't have to do, is just begging for those expressions of frustration. Punishing him for them is more likely to fuel his resentment of the other child than it is to teach him empathy. And even if it worked, that doesn't justify the harm to the other child, who's no doubt aware that he's having more trouble than most, and probably already feels stupid. Everything about that situation is a classroom management issue, starting with its creation.

I don't doubt that a reasonably-constructed attempt to instruct children on teaching and empathy is a huge amount of work. Ordering some children to help others finish their work, with nothing more, isn't. There's no indication here of the sort of monitoring or forethought that would actually make it labor-intensive for the teacher.

Oreo78 · 16/09/2021 20:00

As people have rightly said in this post, there is a difference between helping another student who is struggling and so gaining skills and knowledge in the process and just exploiting the clever kids. It sounds like your child's school is doing the latter. Your child need to be supported and pushed to achieve their very best.

I hope it's okay for me to post this here, but I wrote a post all about returning to school. I cover every year group from reception to Year 11. There is also a section for parents with SEND children and for those with High achievers and what support is available to them, as well as useful websites.

I hope it helps. theonlychildclub.net/returning-to-school/

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:58

[quote mathanxiety]@Pumperthepumper, if I were the parent of the lower ability child I would complain to the teacher and demand appropriate professional attention to the teaching of my child. I would question the qualifications of any teacher who thought this arrangement was appropriate.

If I were the OP I would demand an immediate end to what's going on, that my child should be given extension activities, and not put in the position he is in, with his own academic development thwarted and his social bonds with his peers negatively affected.

The brighter DC is soon going to realise that there is no upside to working diligently to finish his work quickly.
[/quote]
What extension activities would you want?

mathanxiety · 16/09/2021 19:58

@Pumperthepumper, if I were the parent of the lower ability child I would complain to the teacher and demand appropriate professional attention to the teaching of my child. I would question the qualifications of any teacher who thought this arrangement was appropriate.

If I were the OP I would demand an immediate end to what's going on, that my child should be given extension activities, and not put in the position he is in, with his own academic development thwarted and his social bonds with his peers negatively affected.

The brighter DC is soon going to realise that there is no upside to working diligently to finish his work quickly.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 19:54

And @PurpleOkapi I should add, in case you missed it earlier in the thread - Jaxxon will also have his chance to demonstrate his knowledge. It might be language, it might be climbing a rope, it might be technology. It’s a two-way street.

Teachertired92 · 16/09/2021 19:53

@HeronLanyon

As an occasional it’s an excellent learning aid to teach someone else. It often makes you think about the ‘right answer’ which you may already have arrived at in a different and mind stretching way. So if it’s occasional I’d positively welcome it. If it’s constant then I would question it.
This! I am a teacher and will occasionally use this to help a student master a subject, but will also have extension activities some lessons and puzzles etc other. So I agree it’s a good thing but needs to become one of the additional tasks, not an every lesson task. Hope that makes sense!!
Tessabelle74 · 16/09/2021 19:52

I wouldn't be happy with that arrangement as parent to either child in thid arrangement. It's unfair on them both. The teachers job is to teach, not the pupils and the poor child will never understand subject that's being taught by a fellow pupil

Swipe left for the next trending thread