Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
GetMeOut22 · 17/09/2021 05:27

This brings back such bad memories of school around the same age. I was the bright diligent little girl sat next to a naughty lazy boy and made to help him all the time. I got so frustrated, anxious and fed up and refused to do the work anymore. No one noticed until I failed my classes! It's such a lazy way for teachers to discipline the naughty/distracted kids.

PurpleOkapi · 17/09/2021 02:33

I was sometimes told to do this as a child, too. And I hated it. I hated many things about school, so if that had been the extent of the problems with the practice, it wouldn't have mattered much. It wasn't.

From my perspective, helping other students was extra work that no one else was required to do, so it was unfair to single me out and force only me to do it. When other students finished, they got to either quietly amuse themselves with a book or just sit there with their own thoughts. I would have greatly preferred to do either of those things, just like everyone else was allowed to. But from my perspective, I was being punished by being treated differently, which made me suspect that understanding the material better than most of my peers was a bad thing. As a strong introvert, being stuck in a room with 20+ other people all day was hard enough, and all I wanted was a few precious minutes where I wasn't required to interact with anyone. But I wasn't allowed to do that until whomever I was supposed to be helping had finished. I couldn't wave some magic wand and make them understand these concepts - if the teacher couldn't make them understand it, why would I be able to? And I wasn't allowed to just do it for them, so the end result was that I rarely got the same amount of free time most of the other children got. Depriving me - and only me - of those little slivers of downtime just seemed sadistic.

Naturally, I resented this. It didn't teach me empathy or compassion - it did the opposite. If other students' academic success hadn't been linked to my own treatment in this way, I wouldn't have felt anything negative toward them. But because I was being punished for what I perceived as their shortcomings, I was effectively being trained to view them as bad, harmful, and toxic. Their very existence was an affront to me, because so long as they were there, I could never be treated fairly.

I grew to hate them on a personal level, and I made that clear, loudly and often. Doing that enough times usually got me removed from involuntary TA duties, which was all I'd wanted in the first place. So of course, it did nothing at all to impress upon me why that conduct was wrong. I'm sure many people tried to explain it, but no amount of lectures or explanations will erase the simple equation of "bad behaviour = getting what I want" from the mind of a child who's just done exactly that. Year after year, teachers would try to make me do this, and year after year, I'd eventually get out of it by saying horrible things that made the other child cry. Sometimes it took a while, and the other child did a lot of crying before we were finally rid of each other.

I deeply regret many of the things I said and did to the classmates I'd been taught to resent. As an adult, it's apparent in hindsight that many of them had terrible home lives, drug-addicted parents, or undiagnosed learning or emotional disorders. Some others simply weren't very smart, but that's not a character flaw, and it's deserving of compassion rather than scorn. I understood none of those things as a child, because I was a child and not a trained teacher. If this was actually a misguided attempt to teach me anything, my poor classmates certainly paid the price for it.

NumberTheory · 17/09/2021 01:46

@Dogmummastepmumma

Just 2 alternative opinions from a Mother of a child that needs the extra help and a child whk gives the extra help. SD10 has always had trouble in lessons. She is bright, but when it comes to reading work, comprehending what she has read, then working out an answer, it becomes too much. She has a negative opinion of herself as she always used to be one of the last to finish. An adult teacher or TA explaining wouldnt always help as she always feels they are an adult so they dont understand why she does t know it. This year, she has been tabled with a non friend who assists her. This makes her feel liked, doesnt focus on the fact that every other child has finished except her, as her helper is still working too (with her!) She understands things a bit better when explained in an age appropriate way by a peer.

Now SS8. Struggles with confidence. Excellent at lessons and quick to picm things up but struggles with social skills we didnt even know he had problems with. His face when he comes out of school telling us he helped a classmate get an answer right is priceless. Makes him feel wanted and helps bond with his peers as over the past 18 months his anger and fear of losing attachments has made him reactive and he ended up missing class due to this. The other kiddos now dont see him as the grumpy one.

If your LO isnt bothered, then embrace the chance for them to learn compassion and that not all children are as clever at the same things.

But her kid is bothered. OP says so in her second post.

And in the first post she makes it clear he isn't able to help the kid. So it isn't going to improve his confidence or make him feel wanted. Most likely the exact opposite.

Jennylinda79 · 16/09/2021 23:24

A fellow pupil should not be responsible for another pupil's learning outcomes. It sounds as if the other pupil needs more specialised support in class and the school needs to take more responsibility for the learning needs of this pupil. This is not a satisfactory situation for either pupil. Pressure on your son who needs extension work and lack of proper in class support for the other pupil.

bellie710 · 16/09/2021 23:10

@Dogmummastepmumma

Just 2 alternative opinions from a Mother of a child that needs the extra help and a child whk gives the extra help. SD10 has always had trouble in lessons. She is bright, but when it comes to reading work, comprehending what she has read, then working out an answer, it becomes too much. She has a negative opinion of herself as she always used to be one of the last to finish. An adult teacher or TA explaining wouldnt always help as she always feels they are an adult so they dont understand why she does t know it. This year, she has been tabled with a non friend who assists her. This makes her feel liked, doesnt focus on the fact that every other child has finished except her, as her helper is still working too (with her!) She understands things a bit better when explained in an age appropriate way by a peer.

Now SS8. Struggles with confidence. Excellent at lessons and quick to picm things up but struggles with social skills we didnt even know he had problems with. His face when he comes out of school telling us he helped a classmate get an answer right is priceless. Makes him feel wanted and helps bond with his peers as over the past 18 months his anger and fear of losing attachments has made him reactive and he ended up missing class due to this. The other kiddos now dont see him as the grumpy one.

If your LO isnt bothered, then embrace the chance for them to learn compassion and that not all children are as clever at the same things.

While this is all lovely for certain parents, when your kids are permanently bored at school because they finish a task in 15 minutes and spend 45 minutes helping the teacher then something is seriously wrong. Kids are there to be taught not to teach, I am all for helping out the kid next to you if they ask a question but from my experience of primary school which has been 11 years so far, the kids don't explain anything they just give them the answer so no one is winning.
Holskey · 16/09/2021 23:08

@Newbabynewhouse

See .. I'm mixed about this.. Im Training to be a teacher and there is a big emphasis on how children helping other children is beneficial in lots of different ways.. self esteem etc etc child struggling finds it easier to talk to another child etc.. but IMO I feel like schools may be pushing this so they don't have to pay for a TA ..
What? Are you just starting your teacher training? Schools don't push this because there's no money for a TA! It's supported by studies (like most teaching practices) and it's popular because Ofsted expect to see it.
Dogmummastepmumma · 16/09/2021 22:51

Just 2 alternative opinions from a Mother of a child that needs the extra help and a child whk gives the extra help.
SD10 has always had trouble in lessons. She is bright, but when it comes to reading work, comprehending what she has read, then working out an answer, it becomes too much. She has a negative opinion of herself as she always used to be one of the last to finish. An adult teacher or TA explaining wouldnt always help as she always feels they are an adult so they dont understand why she does t know it. This year, she has been tabled with a non friend who assists her. This makes her feel liked, doesnt focus on the fact that every other child has finished except her, as her helper is still working too (with her!) She understands things a bit better when explained in an age appropriate way by a peer.

Now SS8. Struggles with confidence. Excellent at lessons and quick to picm things up but struggles with social skills we didnt even know he had problems with. His face when he comes out of school telling us he helped a classmate get an answer right is priceless. Makes him feel wanted and helps bond with his peers as over the past 18 months his anger and fear of losing attachments has made him reactive and he ended up missing class due to this. The other kiddos now dont see him as the grumpy one.

If your LO isnt bothered, then embrace the chance for them to learn compassion and that not all children are as clever at the same things.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 22:01

@Newbabynewhouse

This see three before me rule would've probably made me get lower grades .. for the unpopular children with not many friends, it can be hard to get the confidence to ask for help from 3 peers... if the teacher doesn't want to know before they have asked 3 others, then can I see how some children may just sit and struggle
I think it would work best in a community classroom, it would take a lot of background setting to make it work properly.
Newbabynewhouse · 16/09/2021 21:59

This see three before me rule would've probably made me get lower grades .. for the unpopular children with not many friends, it can be hard to get the confidence to ask for help from 3 peers... if the teacher doesn't want to know before they have asked 3 others, then can I see how some children may just sit and struggle

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 21:59

@bellie710

There are many reasons not to like this rule.
  1. The teacher is relying on another child teaching your child Maths and hoping they know what they are doing.
  1. Most of the time the child tells them the answer without any explanation so the teacher assumes they know what they are doing.
  1. Any children who are clever instead of being given extra work or harder work to do they are doing nothing but helping other children, not being challenged at all!

I could go on, the school don't care everyone has complained tehy just ignore it, I am just glad my last child only has about anotgher 8 months in the school then she is gone!

That does sound very poorly done.
powershowerforanhour · 16/09/2021 21:57

Ah, I see. Poor management again.

THAT WOULD BE AN ECUMENICAL MATTER.

ostravagirl · 16/09/2021 21:55

@MissCruellaDeVil

Helping others is an extension task, to teach it you need to understand yourself. We call this "learning mentors" at my school. We are encouraged to set extension tasks for children where appropriate, and let them be learning mentors the rest of the time. Studies have shown it to be effective.
I absolutely see the benefits if used well. But if it bothers the child then surely the teacher should reconsider how much he/she uses it and how. I am not a teacher and I have a massive appreciation for their work but as in any other job some are better than others. So the question is whether this should be brought to the teacher's attention in case she just isn't aware that this bugs the child.
Newbabynewhouse · 16/09/2021 21:52

See .. I'm mixed about this.. Im Training to be a teacher and there is a big emphasis on how children helping other children is beneficial in lots of different ways.. self esteem etc etc child struggling finds it easier to talk to another child etc.. but IMO I feel like schools may be pushing this so they don't have to pay for a TA ..

Mollymoostoo · 16/09/2021 21:49

Some schools have a policy of C3 B4 Me. The idea is the child who is struggling will seek help from 3 sources before asking the teacher. This isn't what you are describing though and I would object to this not in the least because it is affecting your child but also where is the stretch and challenge if he isn't having extension tasks and the other child is being 'helped' by someone who has finished.

bellie710 · 16/09/2021 21:43

@bellie710

There are many reasons not to like this rule.
  1. The teacher is relying on another child teaching your child Maths and hoping they know what they are doing.
  1. Most of the time the child tells them the answer without any explanation so the teacher assumes they know what they are doing.
  1. Any children who are clever instead of being given extra work or harder work to do they are doing nothing but helping other children, not being challenged at all!

I could go on, the school don't care everyone has complained tehy just ignore it, I am just glad my last child only has about anotgher 8 months in the school then she is gone!

Sorry was in reply to @pumperthepumper
bellie710 · 16/09/2021 21:42

There are many reasons not to like this rule.

  1. The teacher is relying on another child teaching your child Maths and hoping they know what they are doing.
  1. Most of the time the child tells them the answer without any explanation so the teacher assumes they know what they are doing.
  1. Any children who are clever instead of being given extra work or harder work to do they are doing nothing but helping other children, not being challenged at all!

I could go on, the school don't care everyone has complained tehy just ignore it, I am just glad my last child only has about anotgher 8 months in the school then she is gone!

Gilly12345 · 16/09/2021 21:41

My Daughter had this situation at Secondary School in years 9/10/11 during GCSE Maths, the boy was quite happy to have her help and she enjoyed helping him, the Teacher did ask her to help with the boy involved and his aptitude and grade improved with her help.

Panjandrum123 · 16/09/2021 21:29

Both my DSs helped other pupils - one was asked to do so, the other just did it off his own bat because he’s that kind of kid. It worked for them but it wouldn’t necessarily work for every child and I would hope the teacher + TA take that into account. It certainly should be done as a matter of course.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 21:21

@NumberTheory I read it, thanks.

NumberTheory · 16/09/2021 21:18

Pumperthepumper
bellie710

Our school have a ridiculous 3 before me rule, you have to ask 3 children in the class first before you are allowed to ask the teacher!

It is so unfair on the clever kids in the class as they never get time to do their own work.

I quite like this! Why don’t you like it?

Did you just not read bellie's last sentence, where she told you why?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 21:10

@thenovice

Because the clever kids are continually interrupted by the one's who can't or don't want to do the work.
Ah, I see. Poor management again.
NumberTheory · 16/09/2021 21:10

[quote Pumperthepumper]@NumberTheory well, obviously he should be. He should be being told that calling someone stupid is not how we speak to each other. I don’t know what you mean about the deep end.[/quote]
If what the OP had described was a situation where her DS knew what was required of him, had been told how to tackle the challenge of helping a peer and got feedback from his peers and the teacher on what he was doing well and what he could work on, then I think most people would be telling the OP - this is a great way fro your DS to be stretched sometimes. But this isn't what the OP has described and she probably wouldn't have posted if that's what was happening.

What the OP has described is a situation where every lesson (which, even if it was well planned and supported, would not be appropriate) her DS, when he's finished his own work is supposed to turn around and help his neighbour, who is not interested. If there is any time spent providing her DS with the tools he needs to try and tackle this challenge or providing feedback for how well it's going then it isn't being done effectively as her DS has said he thinks he will get into trouble if this other kid doesn’t do their work and has said he doesn’t understand why this kid won’t at least try. Peer support can't be provided to kids who won't try.

There is nothing in the situation that OP has described that suggests that the hard work of making peer support a useful stretch activity where those skills are developed is being done and lots of things that suggests it is not

My comment about the deep end was in relation to the idea you seemed to be suggesting that being in a situation where he needs to exercise empathy, patience, etc. in order to succeed is enough to help him develop those skills. It isn't. Just as throwing someone into deep water is not enough to teach them to swim.

Headteacher415 · 16/09/2021 21:07

As a headteacher ... (a) common - yes , it's surprising how much you see this in schools. (b) reasonable - no, completely not. You send your child to school to learn, not to be an unpaid teaching assistant!

Pairing more/less able to complete a task together can be a valid strategy, but only if the more able is learning too, and the suggestion that this is when he's finished rules that one out.

DirtyDancing · 16/09/2021 21:06

What do I think..? Hum, well my DS has just opted to be a digital / tech ambassador. He chose the role & with it signed up to the responsibility. So I think the key thing is the school need to set out what is expected from both sides- and the boundaries. If the child is not receptive to your DS support then the teacher needs to step in. DS Should not be expected to help with poor behaviour, as part of this responsibility

MissCruellaDeVil · 16/09/2021 21:06

Helping others is an extension task, to teach it you need to understand yourself. We call this "learning mentors" at my school. We are encouraged to set extension tasks for children where appropriate, and let them be learning mentors the rest of the time. Studies have shown it to be effective.