Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 11:01

@thenovice have you spoken to the school about it?

I’d say the counting methods aren’t for the other kids but for her to relearn concepts she already knows (the old ‘we’re not looking for answers’ thing again). So if she already knows 3 piles of 4 are twelve, she can also look at two piles of six, one pile of ten plus one pile of two, and so on.

thenovice · 17/09/2021 10:47

@Driftingblue

My absolute favorite teachers handled the curriculum problem by changing the assignment itself, not offering extra work for finishing quickly. For math that would be doing fewer of the basic problems before moving on to more challenging versions. (I think this was easier when everything was textbook based) For another subject it might be giving essay questions instead of a fill in the blank worksheet.
That would be great. I'm afraid all mine gets is basic White Rose sheets and Twinkle sheets. Their entire school day consists of nothing but scaffolded Twinkle or White Rose worksheets. She DETESTS them. She gets told off for getting the answers right by conventional mathematical methods, without going through all the tedium of counting counters and other methods designed to help people who haven't yet "got it".
Driftingblue · 17/09/2021 10:46

@LimitIsUp

I've also felt quite triggered / growing irritation when reading posts which refer to "brighter" kids helping the others. Can I just point out that having better literacy skills does not make a child brighter than the other. They are simply more able in one discrete area!
Fair enough if terms like bright or advanced aren’t appropriate. It is hard to select the best word in this situation. However, we did need some term to describe students who find the school curriculum easy. I’m happy to adapt my language if someone can suggest something acceptable that can relay the idea of children who happen to perform well in school academically.
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 10:44

@MoreAloneTime

I think when there has been a lot of negativity through unchecked behaviour between children it's inevitable. I can well imagine if a bright child who has been picked by someone is then put in a position to sneer at them for not being able to read well it's going to be a temptation to get back at them.

Maybe these things work in small classes where the teacher is able to be aware and responsive of any issues like bullying and exclusion. A real 30+ class not a chance.

I would never argue against smaller class sizes.

But actually, peer learning works best with a wide range of abilities, in a community-focused classroom with a bright and engaging teacher who explains properly what they’re doing and why. It has to be managed properly - the children shouldn’t resent each other, and there definitely should be no name calling.

A lot of posters talked about ‘just giving them the answer’ and the point I’m trying to make is, that’s not what peer support is for, it’s not about sharing answers. It’s about consolidating your own knowledge and building your own vocabulary and communication skills. So it works best if children know that’s what the aim is.

Driftingblue · 17/09/2021 10:33

My absolute favorite teachers handled the curriculum problem by changing the assignment itself, not offering extra work for finishing quickly. For math that would be doing fewer of the basic problems before moving on to more challenging versions. (I think this was easier when everything was textbook based) For another subject it might be giving essay questions instead of a fill in the blank worksheet.

MoreAloneTime · 17/09/2021 10:30

I think when there has been a lot of negativity through unchecked behaviour between children it's inevitable. I can well imagine if a bright child who has been picked by someone is then put in a position to sneer at them for not being able to read well it's going to be a temptation to get back at them.

Maybe these things work in small classes where the teacher is able to be aware and responsive of any issues like bullying and exclusion. A real 30+ class not a chance.

Coronawireless · 17/09/2021 10:26

@MoreAloneTime

Sorry for not being able to fall over with sympathy for kids who treated me like crap at school. For many of us it's just about survival and telling myself I'd never have to have anything to do with them once I left school helped me to cope.

I never minded helping out friends or even just the kids that were nice to me when it seemed appropriate. Being made to help someone who doesn't want your help not so much.

I don’t doubt you had to deal with unpleasantness but nastiness has nothing to do with how bright people are. Though the methods of unpleasantness are probably different. Eg a bright child sneering at a child who has trouble learning.
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 10:26

@LimitIsUp

I've also felt quite triggered / growing irritation when reading posts which refer to "brighter" kids helping the others. Can I just point out that having better literacy skills does not make a child brighter than the other. They are simply more able in one discrete area!
I pointed this out several times in the thread too! People have a weird idea of ‘higher ability’, I think, where they can’t see what that high ability looks like to different kids.
MoreAloneTime · 17/09/2021 10:23

Sorry for not being able to fall over with sympathy for kids who treated me like crap at school. For many of us it's just about survival and telling myself I'd never have to have anything to do with them once I left school helped me to cope.

I never minded helping out friends or even just the kids that were nice to me when it seemed appropriate. Being made to help someone who doesn't want your help not so much.

Coronawireless · 17/09/2021 10:18

Really, such attitudes contribute so much to a more horrible world for everyone - your own children included!!!

Coronawireless · 17/09/2021 10:18

But you carry on Jack, you’re all right!

Coronawireless · 17/09/2021 10:17

@MoreAloneTime

That's all well and good in the workplace but the chances of the OPs kid and Jaxxon being colleagues is pretty slim
What a disgusting dismissive attitude.
bedtimestories · 17/09/2021 10:14

My daughter helped other kids, teacher told me it would help her with further understanding of the work. It is in her nature to help

thenovice · 17/09/2021 10:04

In DS2's school the bottom line is they do nothing to stretch anyone who can do the set work. The school is only interested in pulling those below the required standard (mostly due to misbehaving) up to an acceptable standard. So that is what they use the able kids for. Mine just wants something to challenge her and the odd bit of praise would help too. As she sees it, the kids who behave badly and do nothing get a trumpet fanfare if they actually bother and complete a piece of work. She finishes everything and is told to help some of the misbehaving kids. But she gets no praise or thanks and she doesn't want to do it because they don't want to learn and she would rather be learning something more. The school has also started to use TAs with no formal education to teach on a regular basis (i.e. not just if a teacher is off sick).

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 09:23

I've also felt quite triggered / growing irritation when reading posts which refer to "brighter" kids helping the others. Can I just point out that having better literacy skills does not make a child brighter than the other. They are simply more able in one discrete area!

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 09:19

Or even MoreAlone

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 09:18

100% agree MarchAlone

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 09:17

@MoreAloneTime

That's all well and good in the workplace but the chances of the OPs kid and Jaxxon being colleagues is pretty slim
I guess it depends on where they live - the village I lived in a few years ago had one main (energy) employer, and it was common for families to stay put. A lot of the kids went to school with kids of their parents’ and often grandparents’ friends. Fairly rural Scotland. So it wouldn’t be a massive coincidence if classmates were working together as adults.

And regardless of Jaxxon, chances are he will end up working with people he’ll have to adjust his communication for.

babblemum · 17/09/2021 09:10

When my children were in primary school, they were told by their teacher it’s “ask 3 before me” so they had to ask round their class for help before bothering the teacher

MoreAloneTime · 17/09/2021 08:46

That's all well and good in the workplace but the chances of the OPs kid and Jaxxon being colleagues is pretty slim

jontyl · 17/09/2021 08:31

In life it is sensible that when climbing the ladder of success that you reach behind and give a hand to those behind you.

MoreAloneTime · 17/09/2021 08:10

@Newbabynewhouse

This see three before me rule would've probably made me get lower grades .. for the unpopular children with not many friends, it can be hard to get the confidence to ask for help from 3 peers... if the teacher doesn't want to know before they have asked 3 others, then can I see how some children may just sit and struggle
Agree. This policy would have had me sitting in silence feeling like I'd be told off for approaching the teacher at all. I can also imagine for a socially excluded child the other kids thinking it's a great laugh to refuse to help. This sort of bullying is very subtle and a teacher with 30+ kids may not notice.

I'm also very cynical about "teaching empathy" in general as its more often than not used as an excuse to justify putting children and young people in situations they aren't ready to cope with.

TheFairyCaravan · 17/09/2021 07:52

My children helped other children through primary school. I didn’t object to it and neither did they, tbh.

I can even remember going to a parents evening for DS2 when he was in Year 11 and the French teacher told me that she’d moved someone who was struggling a bit next to him because they bounced off DS2 and DS2 was always eager to help. DS2 and the person he was helping both got their predicted grades so it all worked out well in the end.

DS2 is such a lovely, kind person anyhow. When he had a Saturday job one of the people he worked with was having difficulty with his driving theory test because he couldn’t read very well. So DS2 used to stay back at the end of a shift, for many weeks, to help him until he passed.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 07:37

@mathanxiety

What extension activities would you want?

@Pumperthepumper, speaking from observation of what my own children were offered, and what they found stimulating:

Story prompts,
Drawing prompts,
Challenges - make words from another longer word,
Logic puzzles,
Verbal reasoning - analogy puzzles, comprehension of passages,
Maths - word problems, pattern problems,
Tangrams,
Writing /grammar/ comprehension exercises - read the passage and change the ending, find all the adjectives, all the verbs, identify subject and object, various clauses, 'correct the following sentences', 'make the following sentences clearer', 'correct the punctuation', identify characters' motives/tone,
Spatial reasoning,
Mechanical reasoning...

They had folders on their desks which they could open when finished with set work, and work on whatever they felt like, then hand it up along with the set work. Their teachers kept track of the sort of extra work they were gravitating to (for example, more maths than visual puzzles) and could reduce the favourite options and add more choices in areas they were avoiding.

The sort of work I saw in my DCs' folders is available online now. Back when my DCs were in elementary school, teachers had to to far more legwork to come up with the contents of the "Never Done Work' folder.

That seems like a lot of worksheets.
mathanxiety · 17/09/2021 06:07

What extension activities would you want?

@Pumperthepumper, speaking from observation of what my own children were offered, and what they found stimulating:

Story prompts,
Drawing prompts,
Challenges - make words from another longer word,
Logic puzzles,
Verbal reasoning - analogy puzzles, comprehension of passages,
Maths - word problems, pattern problems,
Tangrams,
Writing /grammar/ comprehension exercises - read the passage and change the ending, find all the adjectives, all the verbs, identify subject and object, various clauses, 'correct the following sentences', 'make the following sentences clearer', 'correct the punctuation', identify characters' motives/tone,
Spatial reasoning,
Mechanical reasoning...

They had folders on their desks which they could open when finished with set work, and work on whatever they felt like, then hand it up along with the set work. Their teachers kept track of the sort of extra work they were gravitating to (for example, more maths than visual puzzles) and could reduce the favourite options and add more choices in areas they were avoiding.

The sort of work I saw in my DCs' folders is available online now. Back when my DCs were in elementary school, teachers had to to far more legwork to come up with the contents of the "Never Done Work' folder.