Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 12:59

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
I totally understand peer support. What I do not understand is that my daughter should spend her time teaching kids who do not want to learn.
What something extra would I like her to learn?
I would like her to learn things she does not already know. That is one of the main things school is for.
Would you suggest it was a good idea for a child who could read and understand Harry Potter books to spend her day going through "Biff Chip and Kipper Level 4" and then teaching it to others, without EVER getting a chance to read things like that in school? That is her situation in both maths and literacy.[/quote]
With respect, you don’t understand it if you still think your daughter is spending her time teaching kids who do not want to learn - that’s not the purpose of peer support.

There’s a real danger in pushing kids along when they’re not ready. So education these days doesn’t focus on ‘learning things they don’t know’, it looks at building (widening, if you like) knowledge. That doesn’t mean giving them a trickier book to read or a worksheet of quantum physics to work their way through. It means looking at their existing knowledge and using it to build more skills.

So a skilled reader could easily get a lot of out reading a basic book - they could examine sentence structure, for example, or look at sounds or spelling. They could read it aloud and use different tones and inflections, they could examine illustrations. It’s not the case that the school don’t want kids to progress, it’s that they want them to progress properly.

thenovice · 17/09/2021 12:49

@Pumperthepumper
I totally understand peer support. What I do not understand is that my daughter should spend her time teaching kids who do not want to learn.
What something extra would I like her to learn?
I would like her to learn things she does not already know. That is one of the main things school is for.
Would you suggest it was a good idea for a child who could read and understand Harry Potter books to spend her day going through "Biff Chip and Kipper Level 4" and then teaching it to others, without EVER getting a chance to read things like that in school? That is her situation in both maths and literacy.

ancientgran · 17/09/2021 12:33

[quote Driftingblue]@LimitIsUp

Please know that those of us who got the “bright” label as children and those who have it applied to our own children fully understand that it only means a person is skilled in one very narrow way.

We still have to advocate for our kids because school can actually be really hard for kids like that. When we go in for testing they get labels like “asynchronous development” and “resulting in severe anxiety.”

The ability that just awes me is composing. For all we know, this hypothetical kid struggling with the math lesson could end up writing amazing music some day. It’s a skill I simply don’t possess and when I encounter someone who does, I feel dwarfed by the capacity of their brain.[/quote]
This is very true and I would say my DD didn't really benefit academically by helping another girl but she did benefit by become great friends with this girl who had other skills my DD didn't have at that time and that became the most significant friendship she had at primary school. Unfortunately the other girl moved away with her family at 11 so the friendship gradually reduced although 20 years on they still keep up to date with each other online.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 12:27

[quote Driftingblue]@LimitIsUp

Please know that those of us who got the “bright” label as children and those who have it applied to our own children fully understand that it only means a person is skilled in one very narrow way.

We still have to advocate for our kids because school can actually be really hard for kids like that. When we go in for testing they get labels like “asynchronous development” and “resulting in severe anxiety.”

The ability that just awes me is composing. For all we know, this hypothetical kid struggling with the math lesson could end up writing amazing music some day. It’s a skill I simply don’t possess and when I encounter someone who does, I feel dwarfed by the capacity of their brain.[/quote]
I think also though, everyone thinks their kid is the top dog. So people hear ‘team teaching’ and think it means ‘their teacher has decided my ten year old is so capable at maths they’ve drafted them in to actually teach the other children while the professional teacher sits with their feet on the desk drinking tea’ and nobody stops to think how unlikely that is.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 12:24

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
Yes she does understand the importance of it.
But that is not my point.
She is being made to do basic sums that bore her stiff and having done them, she has to explain them to other children who don't want to learn. She is a little kid. She is not the teacher, nor does she wish to be. She is in school to learn. But the school is failing her and others like her. She should be spending her time learning something extra.[/quote]
I think you’re misunderstanding the point of peer support, like many, many others on this thread

It’s not so your daughter can teach the other kids. It’s for her benefit: so she can reframe and reorganise concepts that she already knows. It’s a fantastic skill to learn, and it also builds into lots of other transferable skills like vocabulary, communication and so on. It’s her own learning she’s doing, not someone else’s.

What ‘something extra’ would you rather she did?

Driftingblue · 17/09/2021 12:23

@LimitIsUp

Please know that those of us who got the “bright” label as children and those who have it applied to our own children fully understand that it only means a person is skilled in one very narrow way.

We still have to advocate for our kids because school can actually be really hard for kids like that. When we go in for testing they get labels like “asynchronous development” and “resulting in severe anxiety.”

The ability that just awes me is composing. For all we know, this hypothetical kid struggling with the math lesson could end up writing amazing music some day. It’s a skill I simply don’t possess and when I encounter someone who does, I feel dwarfed by the capacity of their brain.

thenovice · 17/09/2021 12:20

@Pumperthepumper
Yes she does understand the importance of it.
But that is not my point.
She is being made to do basic sums that bore her stiff and having done them, she has to explain them to other children who don't want to learn. She is a little kid. She is not the teacher, nor does she wish to be. She is in school to learn. But the school is failing her and others like her. She should be spending her time learning something extra.

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 12:10

The principle is apparently that students feel more comfortable sharing difficulties with other students, but I’m not sure that’s true. Maybe some do, but I think many kids would feel more comfortable airing their difficulties with a safe adult, for fear of teasing, ridicule, exposing their weaknesses etc.

MakeMathsFun · 17/09/2021 12:10

@Smartiepants79

Having to teach something to another person can actually be very helpful in improving your own understanding and clarifying your thought processes. Having to explain your thinking is a learning tool used in lots of areas. The only reason I’d have a serious problem with this is if it’s preventing my child from completing his own work or the other child is being horrible.
Exactly right. Peer-to-peer mentoring helps develop any learner's skills in a multitude of ways. It also empowers them to be better independent learners and problem solvers. If the other child is reluctant to engage every time, then I would ask the teacher to rotate the group every day, so that a different child is mentored by different peers each time. Also, if extension work can be added, your child could be mentored or paired up with another of similar ability to achieve it together.
LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 12:09

Thank you for being gracious

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 12:06

No worries, I don’t take offence on the internet, and I didn’t intend to trigger you further.

For me it highlights one of the problems with the practice that it labels individual students among their peers, which I don’t think is fair.

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:53

I'm clearly a bit thin skinned and over sensitive today. I'll get my coat

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:51

Sorry that was a bit rude Blush

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 11:51

Xpost - at least you accept it’s rather laborious Smile

Aiui, peer support is not used for dyslexia or any kind of SEN where it would be inappropriate. Well it’s not supposed to be, I suspect it is in practice. But in principle it’s not the same scenario.

All that is really referred to is the child is who is deemed more able in that subject by the teacher at that point. Like I said a child may be a whizz at maths but struggle with English comprehension or vice versa.

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:49

less able / more able in a subject

Its not hard

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:48

Well now you are revealing yourself to be less able

Just avoid the fucking word brighter, okay?

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 11:44

So every time we want to refer to the less able child we have to say rather than relying on the intelligence of the posters to know that many children are more or less able in some subjects than in others.

Perhaps instead of writing it out long hand we could do a MN shorthand: MACWILAIASS

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:41

I know that's a less punchy, short hand description, but the use of 'brighter' child helping another child feels personal to me. Dyslexic dd is smart and intelligent - she is excellent at analysis, problem solving, lateral thinking and is numerate, creative and emotionally intelligent - it therefore smarts a bit that people might describe those with better literacy skills as brighter than her - when actually they aren't necessarily (some will be, many won't be)

However, I do realise that nobody meant it to be belittling

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 11:33

@TatianaBis

what language would you prefer?
The language which I think is more appropriate is mentoring a child who is less able in a specific subject (i think you wrote that yourself in a preceding post)
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 11:24

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
I think she's gone a bit beyond 3 x 4 = 2 x 6.. She can find the expression for the nth term in a sequence, and use algebra for calculations. So being forced to do White Rose stuff is just torture.[/quote]
Yes, it was an example, I obviously don’t know what stage your daughter is at in numeracy.

So she can use algebra for calculations, does she know why that’s important? Does she understand the real-world connotations of that? Could she adapt her language around the nth term to explain it to someone who doesn’t understand it?

thenovice · 17/09/2021 11:22

And yes we have spoken to the school. Last time we did, it got her bullied by the teacher.

thenovice · 17/09/2021 11:21

@Pumperthepumper
I think she's gone a bit beyond 3 x 4 = 2 x 6.. She can find the expression for the nth term in a sequence, and use algebra for calculations. So being forced to do White Rose stuff is just torture.

Localocal · 17/09/2021 11:17

I am more worried about the effect this may have on the other child than the effect it is having on your son. Setting some children up as "learning mentors" and others as the recipients of their superior knowledge seems extremely divisive and demoralizing to the children who need help. I can't believe they would humiliate a child who already knows they are struggling like that. It's one step away from the dunce cap.

And, as others have said, while it might benefit your child to explain things sometimes, an explanation from another 9 yo is not going to help the other child as much as an explanation from an actual teacher. And it is definitely not your child's job to make sure his classmate understands fractions. I would definitely clarify to the teacher that this is not working for your son.

Putting them on tables where good work habits are unintentionally modelled by one child for the benefit of another is good. Giving them some work to do in teams to reinforce this is also good. (Though frustrating for the conscientious pupils carrying the load.). But putting labels on them and giving them responsibility for someone else's learning is bang out of order.

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 11:07

what language would you prefer?

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 11:07

It’s true ability in one area doesn’t make the child brighter. And some children can excel in some subjects and not in others - some can be ace in maths/science/tech but struggle more with language/literacy/comprehension; or excel at literacy/language but struggle with maths.

But when describing the able child asked to ‘mentor’ a less able child in that subject -