Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 18/09/2021 14:53

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
Do you mean focus on the ALLUSIONS rather than ILLUSIONS?
I suspect you are teaching infants rather than juniors?
At what stage do you think a child is ready to read Harry Potter, Anne of Green Gables, Black Beauty, Little House on the Prairie.....?[/quote]
I’ve just realised what that first question meant - I actually meant illustrations.

Pumperthepumper · 18/09/2021 14:52

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
Do you mean focus on the ALLUSIONS rather than ILLUSIONS?
I suspect you are teaching infants rather than juniors?
At what stage do you think a child is ready to read Harry Potter, Anne of Green Gables, Black Beauty, Little House on the Prairie.....?[/quote]
I don’t think there is a set stage that a child is ready to read any of those - whenever they feel ready and willing to. But that doesn’t mean they’ve got a great understanding or a fantastic reading ability, it just means they can read a story. It’s my job to make it wider than that.

thenovice · 18/09/2021 14:40

@Pumperthepumper
Do you mean focus on the ALLUSIONS rather than ILLUSIONS?
I suspect you are teaching infants rather than juniors?
At what stage do you think a child is ready to read Harry Potter, Anne of Green Gables, Black Beauty, Little House on the Prairie.....?

Pumperthepumper · 18/09/2021 09:46

[quote mathanxiety]@Pumperthepumper

It’s not the case that the school don’t want kids to progress, it’s that they want them to progress properly.

The problem is that class sizes are too big to allow a teacher to pay enough attention to anyone's progress, and the expectation that basic levels will be attained means that the students performing the worst will get what little attention there is to go round, while those students most likely to pass assessments without much input from a teacher will be ignored, or used to keep their peers focused.[/quote]
Again: I’ll never argue against smaller class sizes. Smaller classes with a range of abilities and interests are absolutely one way we could improve education.

But endlessly handing out extension tasks (worksheets) and just handing them the next level of book in a reading scheme because you’ve heard them read the previous one is, ironically, lazy, poor teaching.

Where’s the active learning? How are they processing knowledge in either of the above? How to we assess their skills in either of the above? Where’s the opportunity to consolidate knowledge in a worksheet?

We’re not just guessing with this stuff, we’re not thinking ‘ah I’ll give peer support a bash’, we know it works because the way we teach is based on decades of research, focused child-development tactics and constantly updating practice. It’s not guesswork.

I understand the term ‘skilled reader’ to mean someone who is confident in their own reading ability, someone who enjoys reading and someone who can form sounds, blend words and make sense of scribbles on a page, someone who can understand plot, character development and story arc.

So with a ‘skilled reader’ like the above, I’d be looking to broaden those existing skills. Which might involve giving them, say, We’re Going on a Bear Hunt’ to see if they can appreciate the story arc in a much more basic book. Or ignore the words and focus on the illusions and how we can ‘read’ a story from them. Or look at colour. Or look at drama.

I promise you, I’d be failing your skilled reader if I handed them them next Harry Potter book and got them to fill a worksheet in afterwards.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2021 05:34

@Pumperthepumper

It’s not the case that the school don’t want kids to progress, it’s that they want them to progress properly.

The problem is that class sizes are too big to allow a teacher to pay enough attention to anyone's progress, and the expectation that basic levels will be attained means that the students performing the worst will get what little attention there is to go round, while those students most likely to pass assessments without much input from a teacher will be ignored, or used to keep their peers focused.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2021 05:16

I've responded multiple times to your one liner posts, @Pumperthepumper.

You can see what I suggest instead as extension work, if that's what you are talking about.

If not, and this particular post is about skilled readers, then sustained silent reading should be done in the classroom daily, with a book of the child's choice. Teachers can keep track of what a child is reading by checking the level of reading material, and whether a child is challenging him or herself by progression to higher level material.

What do you understand by the term 'skilled reader'?

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 20:43

[quote mathanxiety]@Pumperthepumper, your thoughts on what a skilled reader could get out of a simple book are mind boggling.

What you are proposing is a sure way to kill any interest in reading a child might have.

Your suggestion is so far from what a skilled reader might need that I would like to know what you think the term 'skilled reader' means.[/quote]
What do you suggest instead?

mathanxiety · 17/09/2021 20:22

@Pumperthepumper, your thoughts on what a skilled reader could get out of a simple book are mind boggling.

What you are proposing is a sure way to kill any interest in reading a child might have.

Your suggestion is so far from what a skilled reader might need that I would like to know what you think the term 'skilled reader' means.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 18:10

@LostFrog

Gosh hi everyone, wasn’t expecting so many replies but thanks for all the different perspectives. The update is that I have spoken to the teacher to ask for clarity on what was expected and he took on board my concerns, he said that ds mustn’t feel responsible for others’ learning and that he would reiterate this to all his ‘learning mentors’ on Monday. He said that he wanted to help them feel confident by giving them some responsibility but on reflection realised that perhaps it was too much pressure especially at an early stage. He also called the whole practice ‘contentious’ which made me wonder whether he was a secret Mumsnetter and had been on here Wink

Anyway, hopefully a good outcome for ds.
Thank you everyone, hearing different opinions probably stopped me going off guns blazing but also gave me some great arguments to make. I almost sounded like I knew what I was talking about Grin

Ah that’s good news then OP! Hope it’s better for him now, good work Flowers
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 18:09

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
Such as, from the DoE:
In 2019 35% of pupils did not reach the expected standard in reading, writing and maths (combined). That's terrible.
I get it that you are a loyal defender of everything done in schools, but there is room for improvement and what is happening in some schools is NOT what you describe.
I am struggling to understand what stimulating sentence structure could be found in a Level 4 Biff, Chip and Kipper book for a child who enjoys Harry Potter. The way to get children keen on reading is to give them something to read that interests them. She is being turned off both literacy and maths because the level is so low. Of course helping another child is OK at times, but she should be given challenging work at her own level too. She is always asking to learn at home but frustrated by the lack of stimulation at school.[/quote]
That is terrible. What should we do about it?

thenovice · 17/09/2021 17:40

@Pumperthepumper
Such as, from the DoE:
In 2019 35% of pupils did not reach the expected standard in reading, writing and maths (combined). That's terrible.
I get it that you are a loyal defender of everything done in schools, but there is room for improvement and what is happening in some schools is NOT what you describe.
I am struggling to understand what stimulating sentence structure could be found in a Level 4 Biff, Chip and Kipper book for a child who enjoys Harry Potter. The way to get children keen on reading is to give them something to read that interests them. She is being turned off both literacy and maths because the level is so low. Of course helping another child is OK at times, but she should be given challenging work at her own level too. She is always asking to learn at home but frustrated by the lack of stimulation at school.

LostFrog · 17/09/2021 16:58

Gosh hi everyone, wasn’t expecting so many replies but thanks for all the different perspectives. The update is that I have spoken to the teacher to ask for clarity on what was expected and he took on board my concerns, he said that ds mustn’t feel responsible for others’ learning and that he would reiterate this to all his ‘learning mentors’ on Monday. He said that he wanted to help them feel confident by giving them some responsibility but on reflection realised that perhaps it was too much pressure especially at an early stage. He also called the whole practice ‘contentious’ which made me wonder whether he was a secret Mumsnetter and had been on here Wink

Anyway, hopefully a good outcome for ds.
Thank you everyone, hearing different opinions probably stopped me going off guns blazing but also gave me some great arguments to make. I almost sounded like I knew what I was talking about Grin

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 15:49

[quote thenovice]@Pumperthepumper
You say, "Education these days doesn’t focus on ‘learning things they don’t know’....."
Well that'll be why the standards are so appalling then.[/quote]
Which ones specifically?

thenovice · 17/09/2021 15:41

@Pumperthepumper
You say, "Education these days doesn’t focus on ‘learning things they don’t know’....."
Well that'll be why the standards are so appalling then.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 15:13

@opentherm

I do not agree with you. Of course, that is my opinion, and my opinion is just that, an opinion. You seem to think that your opinion should be accepted by everyone as an undeniable fact.
Ok, thanks for your feedback.
opentherm · 17/09/2021 15:03

I do not agree with you. Of course, that is my opinion, and my opinion is just that, an opinion. You seem to think that your opinion should be accepted by everyone as an undeniable fact.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 17/09/2021 15:00

Mind reader.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 14:58

@opentherm

They do not.
They do.
opentherm · 17/09/2021 14:52

They do not.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 14:51

@AGreenerShadeofKale

Everyone does not think their child is "the top dog."
Ah they do though. Every parent thinks their kid is the most important one in the class, of course they do.
AGreenerShadeofKale · 17/09/2021 14:50

Everyone does not think their child is "the top dog."

TatianaBis · 17/09/2021 14:41

Yes people still think their kid is being used as a teacher, the posters who did it themselves think they were used as teachers and the kids who are doing it feel like they’re being used as teachers. Do you a pattern?

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2021 14:36

@opentherm

With respect, you don’t understand it if you still think your daughter is spending her time teaching kids who do not want to learn - that’s not the purpose of peer support.

With respect, she probably does understand that, as do many others on this thread. We know what the purpose of peer support is, it's just that so often it isn't used for its true purpose. What should happen and what does happen, are two entirely different things.

I’m not sure that’s true though - people still think their kid is being used as a teacher. Even if it not being done properly, that’s not it. Teachers don’t think 10 year olds are capable of teaching.
opentherm · 17/09/2021 14:33

With respect, you don’t understand it if you still think your daughter is spending her time teaching kids who do not want to learn - that’s not the purpose of peer support.

With respect, she probably does understand that, as do many others on this thread. We know what the purpose of peer support is, it's just that so often it isn't used for its true purpose. What should happen and what does happen, are two entirely different things.

LimitIsUp · 17/09/2021 13:32

Thank you Driftingblue.

Yes I do acknowledge that you need to advocate for children who are academically very able in some subjects, and can appreciate that school can be frustrating if they are not challenged appropriately