Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
HarrietsChariot · 15/09/2021 13:40

It's normal. The child teaching a) learns skills by teaching and b) reinforces their knowledge.

PeppermintMocha · 15/09/2021 13:40

yes only good when used very rarely. A really bright child who definitely understands isn't necessarily going to consolidate anything more by trying to persuade a reluctant pupil to do something. And might end up just telling him how to do it, which isn't what the other pupils needs either - they too need proper teaching and explaining of something that they don't understand.

I was always doing this as a child, and it changed my relationships with peers. I wasn't seen as an equal, somehow, but as an 'older sister' or something, a person that you went to for help or to ask questions, and that changed the types of social interactions I had. I was also one of the oldest, and significantly ahead and so interested often in different things anyway, not to mention very shy, and none of that did anything but reinforce my isolation.

On the other hand, teaching younger children or listening to reception children read, etc, was quite fun. I still ended up being treated as someone much older than my age, but it didn't matter so much in that context.

I was never really extended much in my own work, which was a shame. I ended up focusing on doing my work perfectly or getting perfect scores in it all, which led to very unhelpful and unhealthy perfectionist streaks. If I'd been challenged with harder work instead on occasion, it might have prevented some of that.

Macncheeseballs · 15/09/2021 13:35

Peer to peer teaching is meant to be very effective, can't say I'm a big fan of it though

CuddlyDudley · 15/09/2021 13:35

I can see it being frustrating for your child. I know DS5 has a subject that he flies through and is partnered with a child of lesser ability and he doesn't like it as he gets told to stop doing it and explain to his friend. But I've noticed he is explaining his work much better now as a result, obviously it depends on whether the other child wants to be helped and not have the work done for them. I would mention to teacher if you feel that it is affecting your son as you don't want him to feel he has to if he doesn't want to.

CharleyMarley · 15/09/2021 13:31

@Tiredforfive45

Helping others can be an extension task. It requires skills in showing and expressing your understanding and communicating that understanding to others.

Having said that, it should be one of a range of extension tasks and not happening every lesson.

100% this!

Good for your son on occasion. Not all the time!

FoxgloveSummers · 15/09/2021 13:30

"Your son is also learning how to deal with frustration, and difficult people. These can be valuable skills."

Well how marvellous for him, but if he's finding it annoying and worrisome (because he feels responsible for managing the behaviour of a reluctant peer) the obvious solution he'll come to is not finishing his own work, so he doesn't have to help. So the OP's son could end up not even completing his own tasks and falling behind, rather than deciding to continue working fast and well and being "punished" with having to help this boy.

If every time I finished a work project I was told to manage a poorly performing person on my own level who won't listen to me, I'd string it out too.

If they're adamant on this policy you could at least demand they swap who he sits with.

2bazookas · 15/09/2021 13:27

If both children are comfortable and receptive , that kind of peer support can be a positive learning aid for both.

However, that's obviously not the case here, and neither child should be put in such an unwelcome and negative scenario. I'd speak to the teacher ASAP.

Blendabrethin · 15/09/2021 13:20

Helping explain things to others will reinforce your sons learning. It will also help with his people skills. I actially think this is a lovely idea.

TheSandgroper · 15/09/2021 13:18

Collaborative learning.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 13:18

Similar here MrsColon, teaching is not for everyone.

MrsColon · 15/09/2021 13:15

I was used as an unpaid teaching assistant at school - I hated it. I didn't mind helping my friends, but the constant shouts of "MrsColon! MrsColon!" throughout class got really annoying.

I don't enjoy teaching, never have - that's why I didn't become a teacher!

WaitinginVain · 15/09/2021 13:14

You are definitely not being unreasonable.
Last year I complained about my previously top set DC apparently moving down in a subject. The response was to "buddy them up" with someone of a similar level so they could work together.
Several moves later, what actually happened was them being sat next to their best friend (lovely friend but much less academic) who they were expected to help.
DC couldn't concentrate, asked to be moved and was, for one day only. Continued to be distracted by requests for help, when actually struggling themselves, for the rest of the year.
Went right through the complaints process to be told the teacher was fantastic.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 13:13

Does such learning happen in these enforced interactions? I learned that stuff playing out tbh.

ZenNudist · 15/09/2021 13:12

I've just given a promotion to one of my team this morning and I highlighted their being a people person who explained things well to others. It could be doing your son more good than you know. Being able to communicate so others can understand, showing leadership etc

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 13:09

Should he be encouraged to complain and improve his assertiveness skills Lweji?😉

HollowTalk · 15/09/2021 13:07

It sounds as though the other child would be happy to let your child do his work for him - that's what often happens. Yes it's great for people to show someone else how to do something - it really helps drum it into their own mind, but this other pupil doesn't want to learn. That's a completely different scenario.

I agree your son should be given extension work.

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 13:05

(I'm a teacher). This is not on. Well, not as a regular thing anyway. If your ds is finishing his work early, he should be given an extension task to further his own learning, not be used as an unpaid child TA! It's fine to ask a child to help another with their work occasionally, but not the same children every time. And especially not if the helper child is being expected to navigate attitude or behaviour issues from the other child in order to be able to help.

Lweji · 15/09/2021 13:04

It might improve my explaining skills but not my maths skills.

Well... there you go.

School should be for more than learning maths, or subjects.
Your son is also learning how to deal with frustration, and difficult people. These can be valuable skills.

But, I'd make sure that he isn't made responsible for whatever the other child does, and that he doesn't feel that he will suffer any consequences for whatever the other child does, or doesn't.

HeronLanyon · 15/09/2021 13:02

As an occasional it’s an excellent learning aid to teach someone else. It often makes you think about the ‘right answer’ which you may already have arrived at in a different and mind stretching way.
So if it’s occasional I’d positively welcome it.
If it’s constant then I would question it.

NotAnotherPushyMum · 15/09/2021 13:00

Happens to my dd all the time and I really don’t like it. I’d prefer she had work which was at least a little bit challenging so that it takes her more than ten minutes of the lesson to complete it.

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:58

*isn’t being done with that in mind

OP posts:
Antinerak · 15/09/2021 12:57

It is very common for brighter pupils to help those who struggle, but it should be encouraged not forced. Your son should be given extension work or another task to do if he doesn't want to help the boy. Helping him could improve his own understanding of the work but shouldn't be necessary

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:57

Thanks. It is bothering him to be honest, because he thinks he will get into trouble if this other kid doesn’t do their work and he doesn’t understand why this kid won’t at least try. Apparently he throws his pencil down straightaway and says he needs help. I agree that having to verbalise his own thought process could benefit him, but i am pretty sure that the policy, if it is a policy, is being done with that in mind. I have asked for clarity and his teacher is going to call me back after school. I don’t want to make a fuss so early on whilst they are settling in but I also don’t want my son feeling negative about a new school.

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 15/09/2021 12:57

As long as it isn't impacting your son's own work or learning I think it's a good thing

Liverbird77 · 15/09/2021 12:54

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request