Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Holskey · 15/09/2021 16:27

I'm a teacher. Getting students to teach each other is pretty much gold standard if done correctly. Your child's teacher isn't doing it correctly because:
it's always one way;
it's always the same child;
the students aren't engaged or on board;
and it's always the same, boring routine which is too general ("help Ben finish" is a crap instruction)

It's a lazy application of a very valuable and useful concept. And your child's teacher should ensure your ds knows he is not responsible for this other child's work or behaviour!

Marylou2 · 15/09/2021 16:25

Totally unacceptable. I remember having the same conversation re DD many years ago. Your child is there to learn. Not to teach.

HitchhikersGuide · 15/09/2021 16:24

It's surprisingly common. I was really peeved when my DD kept getting moved around the class to sit next to anyone who was struggling to help them. When I moaned to a friend, she said her daughter and another friend had said the same thing. I raised it with the teacher and she said it was good for the helper-child, to embed their learning, as well as for the struggling child, and that it's a very common method. I was still a bit annoyed to be honest because I did kind of think she was being used as a free TA!

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 16:22

And if they lack the ability and motivation (which is part of being intelligent) to self-extend then they really aren’t that bright

That is utter, utter horseshit and massively biased towards children from middle-class families who prioritise education and support good study habits in their children. Teaching is about realising potential in students, including those who may not be very motivated for a variety of reasons. Writing off children who can't (yet) self-motivate as 'not being that bright really' is outrageous. The OP's child is... what... 9 years old?

I really hope you're not a teacher.

NailsNeedDoing · 15/09/2021 16:20

It’s quite possible that your ds is completing the extension work and still has time left over at the end of the lesson.

A skill isn’t really consolidated until it can be explained properly to someone else, so there’s nothing wrong with more able children helping the less able ones, it’s good for them.

It should be explained to your ds that he’s not going to get in trouble if the other child won’t work, but other than that, this teacher is doing nothing wrong.

Peaplant20 · 15/09/2021 16:19

I believe there has been alot if research done which shows this is one of the reasons mixed ability classes are more beneficial than setting classes - it actually benefits both pupils in this scenario as your son is reinforcing his own learning too. Maybe look it up and see what you think. This is common practice in teaching and unfortunately one teacher and one TA isn’t enough to help a struggling student on every table in a class of 30. An extension task potentially wouldn’t get marked as the teacher wouldn’t have time and can’t mark it as a class exercise when only one or two students have done it and if your child was doing an extension task no one would be helping the other student who may then misbehave out of boredom which would later have a detrimental effect on your son and the other pupils in the class. There’s a whole host of reasons this is a good learning activity for your son and the other pupil, and as mentioned, can’t really be avoided in classes of 30 such is the state of our education system!

maddy68 · 15/09/2021 16:18

It's a common teaching strategy. You call it "helping". To the child so they feel important But both benefit. They lesser able one has a "peer" way of being taught which is different to the way the teacher has explained and also the more able one gets the knowledge embedded by exoaining it in a different way. Consolidating their understanding.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 16:16

Tell them this then. Tell them they should be working at home if they want to get on and tell the parents too. Many non teachers are simply not aware that their kids won't be stretched in school.

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 16:15

This question always bores me. If the child really is that bright they will self-extend.

Not really. Bright children and motivated children aren't the same thing. There are plenty of reasons why a child might not self-extend. It is part of a teacher's job to provide extension for brighter children.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 16:13

Why not stay home and learn off the internet if self extending is that obvious? I mean who needs teachers, right?😏

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 16:13

And if they lack the ability and motivation (which is part of being intelligent) to self-extend then they really aren’t that bright, they are in the middle, like the other people the teacher is aiming at.

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 16:11

@Whatwouldscullydo

However, helping kids who are not as quick to learn as him is beneficial because it will consolidate his own learning, it will move the whole class along quicker which benefits him, and because as people who choose to live in a society together we should be willing to share our knowledge with other people for the good of the group. Not everything is a 'how does this help me individually?' question

Teach to the middle then? So when do the brighter kids get to extend their knowledge?

This question always bores me. If the child really is that bright they will self-extend.
lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 16:00

I was used as an unpaid teaching assistant at school - I hated it. I didn't mind helping my friends, but the constant shouts of "MrsColon! MrsColon!" throughout class got really annoying.

I don't enjoy teaching, never have - that's why I didn't become a teacher!

I was used as teacher's assistant in that way (in a 'family grouping' i.e. mixed year group class in the 1970s). I did like it though, and wonder if it's partly why I became a teacher!

Peer learning is a tried and tested way of consolidating the learning of both children. It deepens the learning of the child doing the teaching, putting it in their long term memory. Lots of research done on it. His teacher is trained in pedagogy to at least a post-graduate level so it's quite safe to assume the same can be said of all strategies they use in the classroom. In the nicest possible way, I would focus on your job and let them focus on theirs.

I wouldn't assume that all of teachers' classroom strategies are based on post-graduate pedagogical theories tbh. It's more likely to be down to the frazzled teacher not being able to get round and help everyone who needs helping. Besides, the theory of peer learning is all very well, making a child in their very first term of a new school responsible for getting an unwilling classmate to do their work doesn't sound like it's going to consolidate much for anyone.

ThePlantsitter · 15/09/2021 15:43

@PaperDolphin

Peer learning is a tried and tested way of consolidating the learning of both children. It deepens the learning of the child doing the teaching, putting it in their long term memory. Lots of research done on it. His teacher is trained in pedagogy to at least a post-graduate level so it's quite safe to assume the same can be said of all strategies they use in the classroom. In the nicest possible way, I would focus on your job and let them focus on theirs.
I do agree with this tbh.
Glssr195726113493 · 15/09/2021 14:43

This happened with my niece. She’s extremely bright and works fast. My brother found out that she was regularly being asked to miss play time to stay inside to ‘coach’ another pupil. She was 11-years-old. The teacher had dressed it up as some sort of honour so hadn’t really objected at first. She eventually mentioned it in passing at home as she hated missing her play time.

For want of a better phrase, shit ricocheted off the fan every which way when my brother and my SIL found out.

Whoever referred to them as ‘unpaid TAs’ is right. Awful.

Branleuse · 15/09/2021 14:43

i think usually this is quite a good set up as its the best way to establish the knowledge for your child to be able to explain it to another child. However if that child is unwilling and resistant then thats unfair

PaperDolphin · 15/09/2021 14:39

Peer learning is a tried and tested way of consolidating the learning of both children. It deepens the learning of the child doing the teaching, putting it in their long term memory. Lots of research done on it. His teacher is trained in pedagogy to at least a post-graduate level so it's quite safe to assume the same can be said of all strategies they use in the classroom. In the nicest possible way, I would focus on your job and let them focus on theirs.

ThePlantsitter · 15/09/2021 14:34

@Whatwouldscullydo

However, helping kids who are not as quick to learn as him is beneficial because it will consolidate his own learning, it will move the whole class along quicker which benefits him, and because as people who choose to live in a society together we should be willing to share our knowledge with other people for the good of the group. Not everything is a 'how does this help me individually?' question

Teach to the middle then? So when do the brighter kids get to extend their knowledge?

Getting kids to do this doesn't preclude giving them extension stuff as well does it?
HelstonaireMonty · 15/09/2021 14:04

I volunteer in a primary school and even with a teacher and a TA (or me) there are still children who don't get everything they need within a lesson. Sadly I feel this will now be worse because of the number of children who weren't able or didn't engage with at home learning during lockdown. Differentiation work is available and yes more able students should be given this work. This does sadly leave the less able children at a disadvantage.

All tables are mixed ability to allow for peer teaching, logistically it is hard to corral 4 or 5 pupils together for teaching, there isn't the room in the classroom and depending on the number of pupils needing this sort of intervention we are vying for space outside the classroom too. I often end up kneeling down between the chairs as the desks are for 6 children and have 6 children on them.

I can see this from both sides. I think the parent of the lower ability child would be upset that their child is being left to flounder. It is hard to try to get round all the children who need you. I tend to work with the lower ability as it is easier for me to keep them focused on the task at hand and help rather than expand and push the higher ability children.

However, the OP is right, this should be an occasional thing not an every day task for her son. If the child is not engaging with any work then clearly they need an adult, not a child, to help.

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 15/09/2021 14:04

I think it’s fine if the friend or other child just struggles and it’s not the same child helping and expected to help. That can be quite full on especially at 9. I have the child (10) who doesn’t engage etc and struggles with school however it is managed by school/teachers/sla etc not by other pupils. However they have all been very kind with my son which is lovely.

My older son is 11 so year above (p7) is very good at spelling and reading and his friend really struggles, my son isn’t great at maths and the same friend is very good so they help each other or other kids but it’s nothing forced and it’s a nice arrangement and he’s really helped my son and my son gets something out of helping his friends as he enjoys it. But in op sons position no, I wouldn’t want my child doing that in that situation, it should be a mutual arrangement where they work together or help each other but it shouldn’t be expected, it singles that other child out too, def speak to schopl op

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2021 14:02

However, helping kids who are not as quick to learn as him is beneficial because it will consolidate his own learning, it will move the whole class along quicker which benefits him, and because as people who choose to live in a society together we should be willing to share our knowledge with other people for the good of the group. Not everything is a 'how does this help me individually?' question

Teach to the middle then? So when do the brighter kids get to extend their knowledge?

ThePlantsitter · 15/09/2021 13:55

Having to manage the other kids behaviour is not on.

However, helping kids who are not as quick to learn as him is beneficial because it will consolidate his own learning, it will move the whole class along quicker which benefits him, and because as people who choose to live in a society together we should be willing to share our knowledge with other people for the good of the group. Not everything is a 'how does this help me individually?' question.

romdowa · 15/09/2021 13:54

If the other boy was willing to accept the help and attempt the work then maybe it might be OK but he isn't. Which sounds incredibly frustrating for your ds . It should be the school staffs job to encourage and assist reluctant learners, not the other children.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2021 13:50

Id email. People always try and justify this crap by saying it teaches them this that ajd the other. The assumption being that just because they understand it or finish the work or are we'll behaved and helpful that they have no other needs that mean this might actually be stressful and a source if worry for them. Wheres the incentive to really work hard and do your best when all it gets you in return is not extra investment to improve your education but merely the worry of the responsibility of teaching a child, that adults with University degrees who's entire job is to do just that haven't managed to do but somehow a 9 yr old canHmm

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 15/09/2021 13:43

There is a difference between ds helping explain something to another child and being made to feel responsible for that's child's learning. At the bare minimum the teacher needs to explain to ds that it's not his job/responsibility to make the child do his work. It also shouldn't happen all the time, certainly not every lesson.

Swipe left for the next trending thread