Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
eeek88 · 15/09/2021 17:42

(I’m a teacher of this age group)
I think this is reasonable as long as it’s not all the time, and he’s not responsible for the other child’s productivity.

A lot of schools are now adopting a Mastery approach in maths where the aim is for the more able children to explore each topic deeply and widely rather than racing to the next thing as soon as they’ve grasped one topic at a superficial level. It makes a lot of sense because there really is no value in accelerating through the curriculum and trying to do difficult maths with weak foundations. (And I don’t care how clever you say your kid is, if they skim over the building blocks of this subject it WILL come back to haunt them later, though maybe not for some years.)

In theory Mastery is great but it’s not always easy or possible to find suitable extension activities, especially so early in the year when the teacher is still getting to know the kids and no doubt reluctant to overface them. The teacher may be quite new to the Mastery approach and still building up a collection of suitable resources. ‘Teach a peer’ should be one of several types of extension. It’s an easy one for the teacher to implement but some kids find it hard, especially at first. But I think it’s valuable used in moderation and will help your child’s mathematical understanding as well as build other very valuable life skills.

ancientgran · 15/09/2021 17:41

@Lweji

It might improve my explaining skills but not my maths skills.

Well... there you go.

School should be for more than learning maths, or subjects.
Your son is also learning how to deal with frustration, and difficult people. These can be valuable skills.

But, I'd make sure that he isn't made responsible for whatever the other child does, and that he doesn't feel that he will suffer any consequences for whatever the other child does, or doesn't.

Indeed. One of mine was partnered with a child who struggled with the work, another was partnered with a child who had a troubled background and was difficult (to say the least) at times (most days.) One is now a teacher and one is a mental health nurse working with troubled children. They found their vocation at primary school.
ancientgran · 15/09/2021 17:35

My DD was very bright and this used to happen, she became great friends with the girl she was helping. I suppose it was a bit different as she was happy to do it and got great pleasure from helping the other girl.

Bimblybomeyelash · 15/09/2021 17:33

I’m not necessarily a fan of ‘extension work’ when tasks are completed. If a child is completing their work more quickly, then they should be getting more challenging work to start off with, not just MORE work. So I’d question if your child is being stretched and challenged sufficiently if he is always finishing ahead of others.

Supersimkin2 · 15/09/2021 17:29

DS should be rewarded, not annoyed, for doing his work ok.

If the other child's dim/malingering/whatever DS can't fix him.

ILoveAutumnShowers · 15/09/2021 17:25

Schools do this all the time and you have to watch out for it and pull them up if it is affecting your DC.

I once had a situation where a child was really badly behaved and a massive bully and in the end, the school decided to put him in a class with 5 of his friends/ calming influences around him. The mother joyfully told me this herself. I marched in there the next morning and had my son taken off that list, and was then balled out by the mother when my son wasn't in his class.

My other DS has also come home saying he has been put sat next to a child who had problems in his last year and so has been moved to his form. He is sat next to him in every lesson and the boy refuses to participate in any joint work and my DS ends up doing everything. I've told him to go with it until half term and then tell the teacher it is someone else's turn to sit next to him as it is affecting his work.

We also know of someone whose behaviour is awful and some other poor kid we know has been put next to him in every lesson and he has to stay with him every break and lunchtime and because of the first boy's behaviour none of the other boys go near them. This has been going on for the whole of last year and this poor boy has not had the opportunity to make new friends. It is really, really unfair on him. I don't think his mum knows. If that was my DC, I'd go absolutely ballistic.

Schools do this all the time. They enrol DC in to appease/ babysit/ pacify others and they think nothing of the effect on the other children.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2021 17:23

I should think it is very demoralising for the poor 'helped' child to have a peer explain the task. A clear message that s/he isn't worth a professional's time and energyandthat s/he's falling behind classmates

I've been both children. In one hand I was ignored. They just stuck my name on the work in the group work as they couldn't he arsed ti explain it to me nor did they bother to listen.

I also had to stay I'm at break akd finish my work as I'd spent so long having to help another child I didn't get a change to finish my work as she was disturbing me every 30 seconds.

I'd live to know what I was supposed to have taken from the situation

AGreenerShadeofKale · 15/09/2021 17:19

Lweji in that case I again implore teachers to pass on that this is the pedagogic thinking.
Normal non teaching parents are bringing up their children to cooperate and trust the teacher's way. They are at a disadvantage in this environment.

amicissimma · 15/09/2021 17:07

I should think it is very demoralising for the poor 'helped' child to have a peer explain the task. A clear message that s/he isn't worth a professional's time and energy and that s/he's falling behind classmates.

Horrible for both children.

RicStar · 15/09/2021 17:06

My kids school have mixed attainment teaching, which includes peer coaching. The tables are very carefully and cleverly arranged. Its unusual to get one child who is brilliant at everything, writing, imagination/ story craft, self confidence and social skills, reading, maths, art, music etc, although of course you get the occasional one, the school is really good at making sure the partnerships / groups work and they are mixed each half term. I think its fair to question what is happening but is not necessarily bad in our experience.

Droite · 15/09/2021 17:05

I seriously doubt whether it is sensible to assume that children have the skills to teach others adequately. When I was at school, I was fortunate enough to understand, say, what we were supposed to be doing in maths, but I very much doubt that I could have explained it adequately. I also had no understanding about why people would find something like reading difficult so I fear that if anything I would have undermined the confidence of other kids.

Yogsgirl · 15/09/2021 17:05

Teaching what you have learnt to someone else is one of the best ways to embed your own understanding of something!

OakPine · 15/09/2021 17:04

He's in school to learn the subject being taught. If he is finished early, he should be given extension work.

I would get your son to repeat "Ask the teacher.", "I'm not the teacher". And if he gets into trouble for that, then he needs to tell you so that you can clarify this with school.

user1471538283 · 15/09/2021 17:00

It is too much if it's all the time. He should be given stretching work instead and it certainly shouldnt stress him out.

My DS and the other bright ones helped one child each once a week with reading in the final year of primary. My DS and the little girl he helped gain value from it. It taught my DS patience and the little girls reading improved so much.

EmbarrassingAdmissions · 15/09/2021 16:58

I was used as an unpaid teaching assistant at school

Likewise. Let me say that it contributed to a gang beating that fractured my skull and ribs. It turns out that older boys didn't like a younger girl being allocated to help them.

Who knew. Hmm

Fincklebinckle · 15/09/2021 16:57

Would love to hear the teacher’s thought process here… because I think it’s poorly thought out.

Surely doing this every lesson is a drain on OPs son??

Daphnise · 15/09/2021 16:56

Sounds like lazy teaching requiring a child to do this regularly.

Teachers must use all their spare time thinking up ways to do even less!

Lweji · 15/09/2021 16:47

@AGreenerShadeofKale

Should he be encouraged to complain and improve his assertiveness skills Lweji?😉
Certainly. Grin
HollowTalk · 15/09/2021 16:46

@TheSandgroper

Collaborative learning.
How exactly is this happening here?
Sunndown · 15/09/2021 16:37

RTFT?

Polkadots2021 · 15/09/2021 16:35

@LostFrog

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

Oh wow, seriously? It's so important to help others and how lovely of your child to offer to help another student. First, explaining to others is a real skill - and takes more understanding of a topic than just answering questions about it, so it'll stretch your son, second, it teaches him to care about others. So third, this IS the extension activity.

Honestly I think there's such a stress on targets but we have to remember to raise kind helpful kids too, and that we're not just always to focus on ourselves. This kind of focus on helping others should be a regular thing for all kids.

Sunndown · 15/09/2021 16:34

It's a way of saving the school money, as they appear to need another TA in the class.
Unfortunately some schools believe that their job is teaching all children the basics, rather than stretching all children to achieve what they as individuals are capable of achieving.

Holskey · 15/09/2021 16:33

@lazylinguist

And if they lack the ability and motivation (which is part of being intelligent) to self-extend then they really aren’t that bright

That is utter, utter horseshit and massively biased towards children from middle-class families who prioritise education and support good study habits in their children. Teaching is about realising potential in students, including those who may not be very motivated for a variety of reasons. Writing off children who can't (yet) self-motivate as 'not being that bright really' is outrageous. The OP's child is... what... 9 years old?

I really hope you're not a teacher.

Can't be a teacher, surely. The confidence with which that ignorant argument was asserted is embarrassing. A teacher would know better.
lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 16:32

It's a lazy application of a very valuable and useful concept. And your child's teacher should ensure your ds knows he is not responsible for this other child's work or behaviour!

Yes, exactly this!

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2021 16:27

A skill isn’t really consolidated until it can be explained properly to someone else, so there’s nothing wrong with more able children helping the less able ones, it’s good for them

If teachers haven't managed to do that in a way all children can understand How's a 9 year old supoosed to?

Swipe left for the next trending thread